Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

 

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SingaporeScene

    'Fare hikes to help transport workers'

    The former PAP Chairman points out that fare hikes will also ‘'help bus workers and operators.' (Yahoo! photo)The former PAP Chairman points out that fare hikes will also ‘'help bus workers and operators.' (Yahoo! photo)

    Public transport fare increases, while unpopular, are essential to finance pay increases for workers, said former Labour Ministry chief and Minister in the Prime Minister's Office Lim Boon Heng on Wednesday.

    Speaking at a delegates' conference of the Singapore Shell Employees' Union, the former PAP chairman noted that no increase would be unjust for the transport operators' workers.

    "You know raising bus fares is unpopular," he said. "But if we cannot raise bus fares, how will that impact your fellow workers? I am sure you will understand that it is not fair if they cannot get wage increases."

    "But their wage increase will be funded by fare increases, which adversely impact the public."

    Lim, who left the Cabinet after the General Election in May, also pointed out that if bus fares were never allowed to rise, transport operators might not have enough "to invest in new buses, and quality of service must drop," reported The Straits Times.

    By "new buses", Lim referred to buses of higher quality as well as those cateriing to the handicapped and elderly.

    He said that in the absence of productivity improvements, a 3 percent wage increase for workers meant that fares had to go up by 1.5 percent because labour costs make up half the total operating costs for buses.

    Previously, operators tried to hold off fare hikes through productivity improvements, he said. These included doing away with conductors so buses became one-man operations, and introducing double-decker and bendy buses so each driver served more passengers.

    "So productivity went up, fares were kept down, but bus drivers could get wage increases as wages of conductors no longer featured in the cost of operations," he said.

    But it will get harder to make similar high gains in productivity. For one, fuel costs make up 30 percent of operating costs. A further jump in oil prices, which is beyond the control of bus firms, will affect operating margins, he said.

    "But from the worker's perspective, when there are millions in profits, they want the employer to pay them better wages," Lim added.

    "To them, millions of dollars in profits is a lot of money, and the commuting public feels fare increases are not justified."

    SMRT posted net earnings of S$161.1 million for the financial year that ended this March, while SBS Transit had a net profit ofS$54.3 million for last year.

    Both companies had applied for fare increases earlier this month, sparking off a public transport debate.

     

    797 comments

    • HeadortailiWin  •  10 months ago
      Why use own people to hit back at own people tactics? It's a never ending argument one using WAGE INCREASE to make justification. There are many Singaporean still jobless and many have not have their pay increase for many years despite we have the highest GDP growth.

      Once again Ah Lim, your comment make adds no value. CPF cut for older workers also you said and did it. Now wage increase also you said. After all you are no longer a minister(without portfolio)or an NTUC chief. Why didn't you set minimum wages for Singaporean during your tenor? Why keep talking now?
      • Anthony 10 months ago
        i think he is still crying over the lost of his million salary.
      • GoRight 10 months ago
        Maybe, he is going to be the next SMRT CEO...!!!!
      • Ah Beng Kia 10 months ago
        Anthony , you dementia already.....all those ex PAP strpped down happily pocketing pension money now until mati...before that already pocket enough for his 5 generations then willing to step down...since still can continue with pension pay...$$ is enough to feed a battlion of pigs 3 meal daily with that obsence amount of money.
    • Hope  •  10 months ago
      This is the most retarded statement I have heard among many from the PAP group of elite ex and current Ministers - is this the only way to solve problems - so are you suggesting that everyone should be accepting price increase so salaries can increase with it - don't you realise this will spiral out of control !!!! Medical cost will have to increase because one of the idiots in PAP advocate for increase in salaries of nurses. PAP ex and current Ministers - please think before speaking like an idiot - problems are not solved solely with price increases !!!! If so, we do not need you - any idiot can do the job !!!!!! LKY - please review your team of elite idiots!!!
      • Frank view 10 months ago
        I do agree with your statement!

        It actually contradict to their argument on minimum wage policy!
      • Patriot Wong 10 months ago
        All our government knows is only to use money to solve problems. Other than that, their brains are dead.
      • S'porean Lim 10 months ago
        Hope, well said ! The PAP is really a elite group of heartless, arrogant idiots.
    • Agressor  •  10 months ago
      I think Lim Boon heng forget to mention below:

      1. Pay for dividends for Shareholders
      2. Pay for higher COE which goes to you know where
      3. Pay for higher ERP which goes to you know where too
      4. Pay for fines slap on the operators due to lack of service and security which is of no fault of commutors.
      5. Pay for the PTC who sit and do nothing (Notice the balloning size of Mr Ee)
      6. Pay for Transport Minister.

      So better nationalise the transport system and let the government take care of these "Transport Workers"
      • Baby Boomer 10 months ago
        Yes. And I couldn't help noticing how well fed Mr Lim looks! And also the lady helming SMRT seems to be "growing" in size and riches....at the expense of commuters....jeez!
    • BengTeck  •  10 months ago
      Lim Boon Heng,

      You are now no longer government servant, so keep your mouth shut>>> you did not do any thing good for the common citizens when you draw big fat salary from PAP>>> Now that you are out of the picture, keep your mouth shut and do not rub more salt on the wound. Average citizens have already suffered from all the hike of cost of living>>>>

      We could not see what you said made sense, please do not talk rubbish>>>>>
      • Patriot Wong 10 months ago
        LBM, did the two transport companies pay you to speak for them?
      • Extremely Frustrated 10 months ago
        Agreed with BT. I remembered LBH mentioned that by having Casino in Singapore it will create more jobs for Singaporean. Till today, how many jobs had given to us local Singaporean. So LBH you shut up... don't talk rots.
      • Patriot Wong 10 months ago
        The government is now shortage of talents. Even those old retirees have to come out to talk.
    • Please Lah  •  10 months ago
      I was beginning to wonder why they get this ex-PAP minister to issue statements on this instead of transport minister Lui. So even if Lui is "unavailable", don't we have a Minister of State for transport or a Deputy Minister of Transport?

      All these ministers where ar?? So put 1 LBH out here to test test water and if his ideas kena shot down, hopefully we all associate them with LBH and in so doing shield the rest from the fallout?

      Someone up there must be really thinking we Singaporeans are daft - LBH to us is still PAP. And right now, PAP do not have the answers!
      • Patriot Wong 10 months ago
        The stake is too high if a Minister talks wrongly, so getting an old retiree to talk is a better option for the government and he can also be a scapegoat if the public sentiment turns against the government.
      • Teh Hong 10 months ago
        More surprising thing is that ther are not many new talented PAP MP commenting on this as well. Where are the ones who declare to serve the people? To understand the people and to help the people? Why are they keeping quite? Why aren't they voicing their opinion?
      • boon 10 months ago
        Yes,that's correct.Pap always use such tactics.Discussions are good for more ppl to understand how our 'talented and exceptional' gov work and think.Just remember that they will never do anything that benefits the commoners without them taking the lion's share.
    • NETIZENS  •  10 months ago
      Mr Lim, are you also guaranteeing a pay rise for all of us so that we can pay for the increase in transport costs that will fund the pay rise for the employees ? If not, please shut up !
    • Ah Tiong  •  10 months ago
      The Transport Minister Lui Tuck Yew has explained how the system work. See his note on his facebook page. On paper, it is a very good system. In real life, it is getting worse. It is inevitable with policies that they decay because the environment which they were first crafted change. Also all policies have undesirable and unwanted side effects, which often accumulate over time. Worse, various policies interact with each other making problems very complex to tackle. Hopefully not, but sometimes you end up staring down at a Gordion Knot and that only way to resolve it is to bring Alexander's sword and brutally cut it.

      This is a reasonable formula (from the minister's facebook note) to guide transport fare change.

      (0.5 CPI + 0.5 WI -1.5%)

      In theory, if CPI or WPI is negative, transport fares could even go down when there is deflation and pay cuts. In real life, I don't remember it had ever happened. It is always up. Lucky if there was no hikes for a long time.

      In real life, with widening a income gap, for a growing number of people the CPI and WPI make less and less sense. So the formula need to be changed. E.g., the proportion of a person's income that goes into transportation is more meaningful.

      There is no point upgrading the transport system to make it look good and comfortable if people's pockets are hurting very badly. Similarly I noticed many upgraded HDB precincts are more beautiful that the inside of many homes. What for? These folks don't live or sleep outside their apartments!

      Politicians and policy makers no matter how smart they are, if they are disconnected from the ground cannot serve the people successfully. They use their academic and model-based thinking to substitute for common sense. Then they issue and rate their own report cards yearly. We will give them a more honest and fairer score at the next elections.
    • Badly Squeezed  •  10 months ago
      Lim Boon Heng is the most screwed up MP. My father who has now passed away had seen him in action or in-action since he entered politics. His argument is baseless, no details on COGS etc, he seems to be working for the public transport companies than on the people's side to seek better understanding of why it is justificable.

      Typical of government services, squeeze money from the Public, defence the proposition and say 'no' when ask to reconsider.
    • Oops..  •  10 months ago
      Is this all what a PAP MP are capable of ?? Talking rots and nonsense !!!

      PAP need to have a long hard look at your cabinet ministers !!!

      They are a bunch of half-cook, brainless, lazy, over-recycled and 'highly-dignified' goons !!!

      PAP, your grave is dug, now go lay in it !!!
    • Tan  •  10 months ago
      More profit from fare increase only go to the board of directors bonus! Are you sure will go to the workers salaries? My dad used to be SBS bus driver for 5 years, his salary from $1200 increase to $1300 after 5 years. Pay increase? You sure? Trying to fool a 3 years old kid?
    • Saykeng Tan  •  10 months ago
      Before the Transport Committee sees or decides on the fare increase, our Transport Minister,PM and now Lim BH have agreed in principle on the fare increase.If these great people have already agreed on the fare increase, then what is the Transport Committe for????
      This is why Singaporean are angry of. On one you say let the Tpt Ctte look into it on the other
      you great people starts to support it openly.
      Dont blame us for voting against PAP. We can wait for the next GE
    • yummy  •  10 months ago
      cant believe he give such a stupid reason for fees increase. How did he become a minister in the first place?
      The operators of trains / bus are apparently unhappy, which can be seen from the way they drive the bus / train or give announcements in the trains. And with so much profit in previous years, why do smrt/sbs transit start to think of using this increment to increase their workers pay now and not before?
    • Citizen  •  10 months ago
      Unbelievable. Having good returns and not satified. Public transport is the responsiblity of the Govt. and yet we have to carry the burden to ensure the main shareholders get more money.
    • Pro Singaporean  •  10 months ago
      What was the pay increase of the CEO and top executives last year? Was it only 3%?
    • Tan  •  10 months ago
      LBH , if you have nothing to do and please go to sleep with snake.
      To All the singaporean fellow , in fact , we are very rich but ask ourselves where is our money now unfortunately now what we have all are in the cpf , it is our money ???
      Now is the global economic crisis problem , the government still wnats to take this opportunity to kill us , really throwing stone into the well.
      Do you think , the transport services and qulaity will be better , all are bbbbsssss.
      LBH , have u ever take mrt during the evening time when passengers try to go bavk home , you will feel to vomit with the aircondition, it is so warm and stuff .
      i ever sit at the last corner seat where the air is totally still, no feel of any air ventilation and got sweating till to my home station.
      This is called qualty of service despite so many complaint make the SMRT. ...... Hopeless
    • Time for Change  •  10 months ago
      I'm sorry Mr Lim Boon Heng - your reasoning is very very shallow! Thank God you're no longer in government. You're saying that if the fare increase is not allowed then the workers will have no increments? What utter rubbish! Are you also saying that in the past few years when there was no fare increases the workers had no increments?
      We all know that the two transport companies have been making huge profits in the last three years. Now they want to increase the fares so that they can make more money?? If you're still able to make huge profits in the last 3 years it means that the fare is correctly charged. There is no justification for any fare increase. Period!
    • a s  •  10 months ago
      u are one of the shameless and sinful miw.
      $161 million profit not enough for transport workers?
      where does this money gone to?
    • Orlando Orlando  •  10 months ago
      I believe Mr. Lim Boon Heng is a 'has been' ...... 'A RETIRED FROM POLITICS' person.
      SO STAY RETIRED....!
    • sarah l  •  10 months ago
      It is true that the workers for the transport operators should get pay hikes, but it should be from the profits of the company, not extra increases from the common folk who do not have people fighting for their pay increases. The profits would help to fund healthy pay increases as well as the very necessary training such as driving safety and service quality, both of which are sorely lacking from their staff. Bus drivers still bully on the roads, they still drive recklessly. There is also the issue of over-crowding on buses, trains, etc. How will all of this be fixed? Certainly not with a fare hike if they are already reaping extremely high profits.
    • jaisam  •  10 months ago
      Tpt fares keep increasing but the services are getting bad to worst. Every morning taking Bus number 161 from punggol road to Woodland's interchange , got to stand in the full packed Bus till woodland's interchange and also not keeping up with the frequency of the time intervals. MR.LBH try to take the bus in the morning at 6 30 onwards then u talk about the fare hike . I assume that other services will also have similar problem . Brought up to the Bus company's feedback department several time but no improvements. Please can someone tell me what else can we do ?

    Featured Blog Posts

    Blog Authors / Profiles