Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

 

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SingaporeScene

    S’poreans outraged over PRC scholar’s ‘dog’ comment

    Sun has since apologised for the remarks he made about Singaporeans (Screengrab from Weibo)Sun has since apologised for the remarks he made about Singaporeans (Screengrab from Weibo)

    Singaporeans are up in arms over a foreign scholar's derogatory comment that "there are more dogs than humans in Singapore".

    The Ministry of Education (MOE) scholar in question, Sun Xu from China, was referring to his unpleasant experience with Singaporeans as he brushed against them.

    A rough translation of his Chinese blog post read: "It's so annoying to have gangster Singapore uncles stare at you when you bump into them. There are more dogs than humans here in Singapore."

    His comment has outraged Singaporeans, who questioned MOE policies. Some have even called for Sun's scholarship to be revoked.

    Singaporeans like Nanyang Technological University student Choy Chan Yuan feel that Sun's comment was "unjustified, rude and ignorant".

    Said the 24-year-old, "Why is our government paying him [Sun] to study here? How did he pass the selection process?"

    He added that the government should "reconsider their policies" when awarding scholarships to foreign students.

    Sun is currently studying at the National University of Singapore.

    NUS student Chng Kahhwee echoed Choy's sentiments. Said the 24-year-old, "His comment is an insult to the Singapore nation, especially the group which he had specifically mentioned."

    The year three economics student added that Sun should not have used "strong words" to express his anger, especially on social media.

    "Given that he is a scholar background with educational funding from Singapore, the least he can do is to respect Singaporeans," she added.

    However, others like NUS student Jay Tan feel that although Sun's comment was offensive, it did not warrant a revocation of his scholarship.

    Said the 24-year-old, "He shouldn't call us dogs. I agree that uncles in Singapore behave like that, it's normal behavior…But his [Sun] comment is too exaggerated."

    "Other scholars should use him as example not to make same kind of mistake. MOE shouldn't revoke his scholarship since it's not serious enough," he added.

    Sun came to study in Singapore in 2006 on a MOE scholarship for students from China. According to TREmeritus, the final year student in NUS is currently on attachment in Schlumberger, an international oilfield services company.

    There have even been calls from members of the public for MOE to revoke Sun's scholarship. In an online survey which asked respondents whether Sun's scholarship should be revoked, 96 per cent of those polled responded in the affirmative.

    When asked by Yahoo! Singapore, NUS Provost Professor Tan Eng Chye said, "The University does not condone the disrespectful comment made by our student on 18 February 2012. All NUS students are expected to behave in a manner that is respectful of the community they live in."

    He added that Sun has undergone counseling for the incident, and has removed the comment on his blog.

    Sun has since posted an apology on the blog. "I am very sorry for the statement that I had made on my blog on 18 February 2012, which I now realize was insensitive and inappropriate. Please accept my sincere apologies," he said.

    The provost also said that a board of discipline will be convened as Sun had "acted in a manner that is in breach of the NUS Code of Student Conduct, which reflects the University's expectations regarding standards of responsible behaviour in our students' academic and non-academic areas of university life".

     
    • BlackSheepShepherd  •  3 months ago
      In Hong Kong, they have a Prof. 孔慶東 who scolds them as dogs (And Singaporeans as 贱民。) .
      In Singapore, we have a undergraduate scholar 孙旭 who scolds us as dogs.

      In Hong Kong, a mob nearly started b'cos of this & the legislation gov't openly disapprove of this comment by someone from the sovereign country.

      In Singapore, we complaint on facebook, twitter, forums, & voted over 98% to revoke his scholarship. AND WE GET AN MP WHO ASKS US TO REFLECT ON OURSELVES!!!!!!
      YOUNG MAN!! YOU WAKE UP ALREADY!!!?? OR STILL IN LA-LA LAND!!!???
      • A Yahoo! User 3 months ago
        Bloody hell .... reading this really makes my heart boil. How can we tolerate any further when someone calls us dogs, take our jobs and university places? What the hell is govt doing? Can't wait for another 4 years man...
      • jrlow 3 months ago
        How come these assholes go round scolding people. They think the world belongs to them ?
      • Lost Soul 3 months ago
        i should pay him a visit ..try calling me that straight to my face...i'll gladly serve my sentence wholeheartedly..
    • Bill  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      I'm an uncle and at least I don't spit like what I saw the uncles and aunties does in Beijin and Tian Chin..aArrrghhh_Pui and instead of saying excuse me, they just push and shove their way thru. Moreover..in Kopetiam..they are the noisier, loud speaker and with ill table manners when dinning..drinking beers make them worst...sighhh!
      • Eddie 3 months ago
        recently I boarded a domestic flight in Kunming, oh boy, the PRC were running and pushing their way up. I could hardly see my own legs and I was swarmed by these rude, uncivilised dogs!!
      • Tan 3 months ago
        @Eddie, calling them uncivilised dog makes you no difference from him!
      • SING 3 months ago
        Not long ago, Wang Peng Fei, was expelled from East Asia Institute of Management for creating a video in which he made racist remarks about Singaporeans.

        Despite apologising on his blog on Sunday, Mr Wang also had his student visa cancelled and will not receive a refund for the year's course fees, which amount to $10,000, because the act violated a clause in his contract.

        Would NUS and MOE do the right thing? I believe there should be a clause in the scholarship contract upon which violation would require him to pay back in full the scholarship amount to MOE.
    • PingPong  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      Isn't he himself worse than a dog?
      At least if you rear a dog, it would be faithful and loyal to the ones who provide food and shelter.
      This one actually bites the hands that feed him!
      Our gahmen must be bl@@dy stewpig to have fed him for so long.
      • 叉叉 3 months ago
        Why and when will Pay and Pay own up to StewPIGpity??

        Listen for the sounds of silence from PAP and their dogs, case in point... the painting HKL!

        They continue to ignore the problems they've created. Instead, they're more preoccupied with blowing the whistle of Workers Plaza.
      • A Yahoo! User 3 months ago
        Whatever the case. THoose supid immigrants should go back to their dirty dustcovered streets and poverty stirken asshat countries. They dont deservere OUR singapore..
      • Joseph Lim 3 months ago
        That's our gahmen, to raise our so called reputations, economics or whatever, they are prepared pay and bring in foreigners and let them criticises us. That's what they always do.
    • Chopper  •  3 months ago
      Stop this nonsense about counseling for the student involved. He knowingly made that statement under no duress and of his own free will, and he should suffer the consequences for it. Counselling should only be administered if there are sufficient proof that he is suffering from any physical or psychological duress which results in him behaving inappropriately. I am not a scholar, but I understand one simple fact--Do not bite the hands that feed you.

      Dear NUS, this is a slap to your face for giving scholarships to these people who owes no loyalty to Singapore. What do they contribute? End of the day, it'll be "wham, bam, thank you mdm!"
      • Please Lah 3 months ago
        They deliberately left out the details - counselled by PRC professors and the board of discipline also made up of PRC professors.....

        Counsellor advice is: Can you please work on your presentation?? We are know Singaporeans are daft, that's why they took us in the first place...so please, don't kill the goose that lay the golden egg ok??!!
      • CHUANCHYE 3 months ago
        Counseling? Huh? NUS should dismissed him from the University! This is tertiary education and not lower education.
      • edwin 3 months ago
        Probably the scholarship was approved by an uncle as well....whom he call dog
    • Pepper Leaf  •  3 months ago
      Our local U is paying for many foreigners to study here instead of giving the place to local who is paying FULL fees. What a joke.
      • WTF 3 months ago
        thats Y singaporean like me HIDE in MSIA
      • CHUANCHYE 3 months ago
        He should be sent back home immediately! Disgusting PRC!
      • zerase 3 months ago
        MSIA nice to hide meh?
    • G-Man  •  3 months ago
      In my office we have 2 new recruits. 1 from vietnam and 1 from singapore. The colleague from Vietnam was provided a scholarship by the singapore government to study @ NUS. While the Singaporean colleague had to pay for his way through University in England. Work wise, the Vietnamese colleague work performance is way below expectations. I am shocked that she even had a scholarship from the Singapore government to study at NUS when she can't even comprehend simple instructions. As for the Singapore colleague, he is smart and bright and his performance is above average. Hence the question here is how is it that our government is handing out scholarships to these foreign students where some of them dont even stack up to expectations and while Singaporeanns students have to pay their way through school locally and overseas. Something is definately wrong with the system here@!
    • Average Singaporean  •  3 months ago
      Hi LHL, someone said nasty thing about your wife, and you sue. This piece of shit, opening call your countrymen dogs!!! What are you going to do? Give him more tax payers' money!?!?!? I tell you what, forget about the money your MOE already given him, just throw this stinking piece of crap back to where he came from and never let him set foot in our soil ever again!!

      His disgusting dickface already posted online . . . if you dont correct this mistake, someone else will !!
    • KenluckyL  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      Is the MOE and education minister here giving up hope on their own local students? If so please let the whole damn public know! Otherwise can you explain why these foreigners are given scholarships to come here to study! Why? Why these scholarships not given to local poor students? Why only give to foreigners and rich families?
    • catherine  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      @ Sun Xu, I am a Singapore Permanent Resident and studied in NUS.Unlike you, I paid school fees by myself. However, I always appreciate the opportunity of pursuing my Master degree from NUS and always am grateful to Singapore.Living and working here about 10 years, I encountered and dealt with many many people from different levels/background due to nature of my work.I can say that all people I have met and dealt with here are, needless to say, genuine humans.Bottom line is everybody has different personality and individuality.It is unfair and untrue when you draw a rough conclusion in line with your inconvenient encounters of some.You need to take time to some extend to deeply comprehend the custom, tradition,nature and mindset of general people of a nation. After 10 years in Singapore, I dare to say that I love Singapore and its people once I really get used to understand them.Perhaps, I am leaving Singapore within few days for personal reason.However, you know Sun Xu, I will always remember the gratitude I owe Singapore as I studied and worked here whereby making some income for family.When I leave, I will bring good conduct, good manners, good practices that I learned from Singaporeans and will reciprocate wherever I will be.Meanwhile I will leave behind the habits that I don't want to learn and mimic. This is my perspective on life. Hope you can learn from the recent lesson and will contribute your knowledge for Singapore and its people one day to pay your gratitude back as a scholar of Singapore.
    • Disclaimer  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      But why are WE paying $174,000 for each foreign scholar??
      Who decided this?
      Were enough citizens consulted in this "all-inclusive" method of govt??
    • boysaigon  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      if singaporeans were dogs, he should be a 狗养的, since his is paid by singaporeans to be here!
    • Pragmatic  •  3 months ago
      NUS should review his scholarship. We should not support ingrates on tax payers money. There would be many others that we can sponsor that would be more than appreciative.
    • Awesome  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      At least Singapore uncles won't cut out your kidneys and leave you to die on the streets. :( Goto your homeland, no guarantee hor??!!
    • Armorboot  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      I will have to agree with him, ever since the government open up the flood gate, there are more dogs in Singapore than before, much much more. Make no mistake, who let those dogs in? I have nothing against them, just remember one thing foreigners, when u are at a foreign country, you are the FOREIGNERS!!!!! Not the locals. Be humble & respect others and don't bring your bad habits here cause here ain't your home or home ground.
    • hearty  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      MOE should take his comments seriously and revoke his scholarship. This will deter foreign students from insulting Singaporeans. If Sun Xu can say this remarks means he did not respect our SINGAPORE. We must stand together against him. Majulah Singapura!!!
    • Cense  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      Singapore's Government are kind enough to provide places for dogs to enter... be appreciative when dog hse is provided to u.. RESPECT YOUR OWNER.
    • David  •  3 months ago
      I am a Singapore "uncle", who has to pay full fees for my son's U education. First, these #@&!! are given scholarships, which means one Singaporean deprived of a place in the Uni. Later, they are given jobs, which means one Singaporean will not have a job. Then, they are still allowed to call us dogs and other derogatory terms. I don't understand why we have to take this???
    • SGGuard  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      Quote: NUS Provost Professor Tan Eng Chye said, "The University does not condone the disrespectful comment made by our student on 18 February 2012. He added that Sun has undergone counseling for the incident, and has removed the comment on his blog.

      Halo Professor, your statement is like from a standard template used by a lot of commercial & govt organisations. Do you think counseling really work on ungrateful shit like him ?? You mean after counseling & his apology via his blog, thats it ?? So is ok to be professor doggy ???
    • Ling Ling  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      I got 4 kids with a monthly income of S$1,500.00. My eldest daughter is in NUS and her annual school fee is $6,600.00. For the last 3 years we struggle every penny to put her through NUS. Imagine how I feel our gov is throwing our $$$$$ to support a heartless PRC!!
      We eat maggie mee so that our children can have a proper education! WHY WHY !!
    • cool jazz shen  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      this ah tiong is trying to make headlines..if you go Hong kong, see what they will do to people like you. they called all PRC dogs or pigs coz they dont brush their teeth. Their breath stinks even if they rinse their mouth with acid

    Featured Blog Posts

    Blog Authors / Profiles