Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

 

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SingaporeScene

    President not a separate power centre: Tony Tan

    Candidates should run for the office that exists, not for the one they wish to have, says Dr Tony Tan. (Yahoo! photo)Candidates should run for the office that exists, not for the one they wish to have, says Dr Tony Tan. (Yahoo! …

    While the elected President can have influence, he "is not — and should not be — a separate power centre," believes presidential hopeful Dr Tony Tan.

    What the President can and should do is address the concerns of Singaporeans and take them into account when exercising his or her powers, said Dr Tan.

    "These concerns can also be raised formally or informally through appropriate channels. The choice of channels to pursue depends on the individual situation," he said.

    Outlining his understanding of the President's role in a statement on Wednesday, he added the President must also have "a heart for all Singaporeans" and know how to reflect their concerns effectively in the context of national and international affairs.

    "One can, of course, imagine very different roles for the President that would require a constitutional amendment. But the Presidential Election itself is the wrong forum for this," said Dr Tan.

    "Candidates should run for the office that exists, not for the one they wish to have."

    His comments come in the midst of an ongoing debate on the role of the highest office in Singapore, most recently stemming from Law Minister K Shanmugam's comments at an Institute of Policy Studies forum.

    He said the President "can speak on issues only as authorised by the Cabinet; and he must follow the advice of the Cabinet in the discharge of his duties".

    Dr Tan, who attended the IPS forum, said many have pressed him for his thoughts on the issue.

    Other Presidential hopefuls have also raised their views. Both Tan Kin Lian and Dr Tan Cheng Bock agreed the President should work within the boundaries of the Constitution.

    Tan Kian Lian disagreed, however, that the President could not speak without the Cabinet's approval. He urged the government to "adopt a more open approach towards the issues of the people" and engage the public on their concerns.

    Dr Tan Cheng Bock took issue with Minister Shanmugam's comments that the influence a President depends on who the President is. Dr Tan Cheng Bock urged for mutual respect between the government and the President.

     

    440 comments

    • Elected  •  9 months ago
      If he is not, vote him out. Let the vote do the talking. Simple.
      • Crazy 9 months ago
        Istana jaga. Must be crazy to vote him.
      • Pun 9 months ago
        He believed he is going to be a guard the Istana to enjoy his take home pay of $4+ millions fat fat reward for his loyalty to the godfather's dynasty, a watchdog instead of guarding the national reserves. How not to vote you out.. the puppy Presidency?
      • Tan ku 9 months ago
        Dr Tony Tan, tan ku ku.. wait long long.. the vote is not this Tan.
    • Michan  •  9 months ago
      Let see the numbers, Click the thumbs Up.

      Not Voting for Dr Tony Tan
      • Crazy 9 months ago
        If he becomes President, he may declare that all his descendants need not perform National Service
      • Michan 9 months ago
        Let show PAP the highest number ever in yahoo. and see what will they come out next..
      • Tip of the Arrow 9 months ago
        I am afraid even if we have 3,000 dumbs-ups for your post here, TJS still can't get elected to be our President.

        Anyway, just to follow the crowd, I'm all the way behind you 'Michan', through and out at the other end. CHEERS!!!
    • righteous Xie  •  9 months ago
      Only Fools will believe that this guy will serve S'porean. He serve PAPa only. He is a Yes Man.
      • Dio 9 months ago
        Agreed.....Puiiii.......
      • william 9 months ago
        TT is die hard PAP Puppet. Even before voted in he already surrender all his power to
        PAP. Then how is he going to tell voters that he have Singaporean at his heart??? Why must he be paid higher than PM salary??? Did he deserve millions of dollars salary??? That must be the most luxurious job in the world. No need to make any
        decision just waiting PAP instructions and hold dinner parties-- spending tax payers
        money and holiday fly 1st class hotel 1st class salary 1st class while man in the streets struggling to pay and pay. All of you are CONMAN and BLOOD SUCKERS.
      • Patriot Wong 9 months ago
        So, Singaporeans should know what to do as we are not fools.
    • Sun  •  9 months ago
      Whether to support PAP or not is not the main concern now but personally like yr well presented in words and sincere appearance which will touch many hearts in Singapore and overseas counterparts I personally feel. Take care, u will have my full support due to yr truly and trustful minds and heart for the people of Singapore. If u are selected, pls take care of truly Singaporeans not 'cos of me but for many other family members from babies to elderly parents including my family and related families like my little ones - niece and nephew :) Thanks, I will support u. And hope my message here will help u one way or another.
    • Sun  •  9 months ago
      Best wishes & good luck to u :)
    • gihh  •  9 months ago
      Why the President cannot be a separate power centre???????
      This is only an excuse to collude with the corrupted PAP.
      This NDP, when I hold my hand tide and place at my heart and say the Singapore pledge out loud………I remember late President Mr Ong Teng Chong.
      Tony Tan, You are definitely out!!!!!
    • marko  •  9 months ago
      Whether a newly elected, favourable or non-favourable among us....the biggest point?...The president has to do more than what our previous president did…get connected to the people and focus on important issues like the next 5th-6th generation of singapore..

      and pardon all dead-man walking criminal pleads…thats the number one issue which is never discuss in public..

      the new president has to do more and more than you know…all you people ever think is the opposite and not the role of the president real and formal duties and responsilbility..like the above dead-man walking issues..it could be your relatives or bro-in-law or cousin...

      think and not open your hole below your nose SINGAPOREANS!!! TSK TSK TSK!!
    • ZANZIBAR  •  9 months ago
      really waste a holiday to vote when the president has already been chosen...
    • ET  •  9 months ago
      HOW MUCH IS THE TOTAL CO$T TO TAXPAYER ??? FOR MOBILISING THE TRADE UNION,CLAN,RC,CC,& MANY MORE ORGANISATIONS, ETC ?$$$$$$??????????
    • hippo  •  9 months ago
      Tony Tan, you don't need to tell us what a puppet president can do or cannot do. We already know. Just tell us in simple English about your son's 12-yr deferment from National Service and how he did his ICT. You are right that Sporeans are savvy enough to know that you and your son are lying. Even present-day Defence Minister Ng Eng Hen dare not come out openly to clear your name.....and Mindef's statements so far only confirm that you are not fit to be a presidential candidate.
    • teddy bear  •  9 months ago
      Seriously this Election is not between the Opposition & the PAP.

      The elected President has the responsibility under the Constitution to safeguard the NATIONAL RESERVE AND to veto the government BUDGETS and KEY APPOINTMENTS TO PUBLIC OFFICE.

      Can we hand this responsibility to the former Deputy Prime Minister?
      Can we hand this responsibility to the former MP for the Government?

      That is TT & TCB they would simply agree to the Government request
      without studying it carfully. It is quite clear that they will not dare question the Government on any matter.

      This means appointing these two men to be the President of Singapore is not proper as they will not really check all the misuse of National Reserve or favouritism in key appointments by the Government. WILL THEY VETO the Government on this?

      These key duty of the President they will NOT be able to perform – so do we need to
      give them our vote? This for Singaporeans to think!!
      • Post65 9 months ago
        I'm kind of disagree with you that TCB would also simply agree to the Government request. TCB had spoken up against some government policies before (I have to give him the benefit of the doubt that he did so sincerely rather than to put up a weak opposition so as to create a facade showing the "superiority of the policies"). But as an MP, he was one against the rest. But as a president having veto power and the backing of the presidential advisory committee, things may be different.
      • teddy bear 9 months ago
        TCB has been a Government MP from 1980 to 2006 - that is 26 long years - he has served and worked closely in all their campaign - now standing for President does not suddenly make him a person who will go aganist his former bosses.

        His agenda as he says - is not to have another walkover at the Presidential Election. He is just a faithful party man.
    • 55 cents  •  9 months ago
      TT please swear by the bible you will tell the truth if you are elected. No ifs and buts.
    • SG  •  9 months ago
      TT u hv no intergrity! so my vote is for TAN JEE SAY. Think about it people , tan jee say was LHL former sec, he would know all his wanyang , i can LHL SHITTING in his pants if Tan jee say walks in as president. Lhl would hv to think very carefully befor implementing any fare hike!

      You go for Tony, well his sons and family memebrs would not even risk NS to safe you...!
    • Comments Addict  •  9 months ago
      TJS, TKL and TCB should be taking part in the General Election instead of the PE if they are really sincere about wanting to be a voice for the Singaporeans.

      But wait, wasn't TJS rejected by the voters in the last GE?
    • VisVis  •  9 months ago
      President not a separate power centre

      huh no seperate power then you will be a Yes Man n a dumb n deaf One ?

      or Being tied down my the outdated consitution that written by the ruling party that good for the party and not good for the citizens ?

      if there no Seperate of power how are the One Going to checks and balance ?
    • VisVis  •  9 months ago
      This Current One is a example for a outdated consitution that written by the Party that makes him dumb n deafs n no power as a EP so Citizens is really Feedup by this One that have no power to question or have a answer or goes to the Media to say.
    • PatRed  •  9 months ago
      Quote "What the President can and should do is address the concerns of Singaporeans and take them into account when exercising his or her powers, said Dr Tan"

      Me and my family added 4 votes. If you are interested, would you address in specific, in the newspaper as follows:.

      1. Do you know by now or so far, what are the concerns of S'porean and how you would take them into account when exercising your power as President?

      I would be thankful for your respond
    • VisVis  •  9 months ago
      The Consitution needed to be rewritten to include :

      1. Given the power to say about the aged to retire or suggest to ... and the interests rate in CPF.
      2. Given the power to say about CPF interest of all citizens to be higher then lower.
      3. Given to say about housing and land sales
      4. given the power to say about interest to pay in cpf for housing to be reduced to 1% and not above the ORD account as that can save in cpf then current policy there nothing earned in CPF . if one buy a house.
      5. To give timely report of account of current reserve n past reserve n investment to all citizens.
      6. to have a stop loss on investment if market turn bad .
    • Street Voices  •  9 months ago
      All Trade Union please don't boot lick for P.A.P. and Tony Tan. Please stand independent, keep yourself clear from this dirty show. Not all members in your union stand for Tony Tan, there are supports of other Tan's too.

      Vote ex-P.A.P. candidates out.
    • Desmond Tang  •  9 months ago
      Please do not listen to the media in singapore which are not fully true. Go to this website you will be enlightened http://www.temasekreview.com/

    Featured Blog Posts

    Blog Authors / Profiles