Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

 

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SingaporeScene

    Watch out Singapore as Malaysia’s ‘transforming’: hiring experts

    Singapore will witness "stiff competition" from Malaysia, said hiring expert.Singapore will witness "stiff competition" from Malaysia, said hiring expert.

    Singapore will witness "stiff competition" from Malaysia for businesses if the Economic Development Board does not up its game, said a hiring expert.

    Andrea Ross, managing director for professional recruitment consultancy Robert Walters for Singapore, Malaysia and Vietnam, said, "Singapore has to be more innovative, which the EDB has been doing very well in. But it has got to revamp it up moving forward."

    While Malaysia's infrastructure is not yet comparable to Singapore's, it will be in the near future and talents are open to migrating to the neighbouring country, she said during the presentation of the firm's annual global survey salary.

    Sally Raj, country manager of Robert Walters Malaysia, said that the Singapore neighbour is currently undergoing a "transformation" to beef up its infrastructure. This could potentially see more companies beefing up workforce in the country.

    That said, Joanne Chua, associate director of the firm's HR, supply chain and business support division, thinks that Singapore is "still very well-positioned as a market where talent is concerned."

    Singapore still has investments pouring in, Chua said, adding, "So are we seeing a dearth in the jobs market? Definitely not. Are we seeing a slowdown? Yes, definitely. That's because companies are more cautious in terms of hiring."

    The report highlighted that 2011 remained a generally conservative year for banks hiring, the firm said, as many firms "overhired" in the previous year. There, however, remained a strong demand for experienced professionals and support staff like sales and relationship managers, and credit analysts in small medium enterprises (SMEs) and corporate banking to generate revenue.

    There was also an estimated up to 40 per cent increase in contractual positions offered in Singapore especially within finance, human resources and business support staff.

    Singapore's economic outlook for the last year stood similar to that of Hong Kong's with dips in recruitment advertising activity — a similar seasonal decline in the last quarter of 2010.

    According to the report, this year will see hiring slog on as global economic concerns will continue to "weigh on candidate and client confidence".

    Andrea Ross, managing director for recruitment consultancy Robert Walters for Singapore, Malaysia and VietnamAndrea Ross, managing director for recruitment consultancy Robert Walters for Singapore, …

    Ross optimistically pointed out that there are a number of public sector projects such as transport infrastructure, hospitals, schools and universities which will result in increasing demand for professionals within construction and logistics.

    While Singapore has a strong talent pool, Ross warned that the next biggest challenge other than the rising inflation and housing prices is for firms to retain talent.

    On the same note, Chua said, "Are we hearing retrenchments in certain areas? Yes, we are, not because companies are downsizing but because they're offshoring certain functions to lower-cost markets."

    The consultancy firm said that the key operative for many organisations in 2012 is likely to be "cautious optimism". Assessing the global economic uncertainty will be a factor in headcount decisions.

    The report revealed that job influx is likely to be seen in professions such as engineering, HR, secretarial support, IT and sales and marketing roles for professionals across the fast-moving consumer goods, IT and telecommunications and industrial sectors as these areas are less immediately affected by the uncertainty phenomenon as compared to banking and financial sectors.

    Technical healthcare is predicted to see a growth in terms of constant labour demand.

    Addressing the concern that inflation will curb real income increments, Chua said she does expect "adjustments" that firms will most likely make based on their yearly reviews.

    Chua cautioned though the challenge for the government now remains managing that fine balance between the need to attract foreign investments into the local market and "providing jobs through our local talents" while being mindful that Singapore risk forcing foreign investors out if the country becomes a high cost centre.

    "I think they're [the government] tacking the issues right now."

    Related articles:

    1. 'Foreign talent allows S'pore to punch above its weight'
    2. 90 turn up for talk on 'Supporting Singaporeans First'
    3. Singapore to face a labour crunch?

     
    • sean  •  2 months ago
      if truly M'sia transforms S'pore will have a very hard time, more than 50% FT will want to go there to work including locals, this is purely political it will always be a disproportion
      • LAN HE TOH 2 months ago
        Sean if that happen, its a good sign for singapore, its time to for true singaporen to fight for thr mother land and trash out all the rubbish. cheers
      • Ahoy 2 months ago
        ""Prosper thy neighbour"" should be motto for ASEAN integration otherwise ASEAN is just a hypothetical dream
      • Please Lah 2 months ago
        Andrea convenniently fails to mention a few key points i.e.

        1. Malaysia Bumiputra policy - Malaysia may grow but up to a certain point for this to become such a stumbling block to many starting SMEs.

        2. Immigration policy - Ironically, while we Singaporeans seems to open our floodgates without any due consideration for overcrowding/competition for jobs, Malaysia has always been very stringent in approving PR application to safeguard their own people.

        Andrea, being from Robert Walters, seems to have vested interest in encouraging Singapore to continue to open up because by doing so, head-hunting companies can continue to expand their database of potential candidates - so I would take her opinion with a huge dose of salt.

        Malaysia has always been competing with Singapore - it is not something new. It is just that when the time comes, and the table gets turned, will we see the Malaysia governement welcoming Singaporeans to work and settle there as what our current PAP is doing? Don't be surprised they'll not be as open as we had been and don't get angry either, they could just be balancing the interest of their own people instead of GDP wholesale.

        As it is today, Malaysia has huge natural resources especially East Malaysia that is untapped. There is really not much motivation for their government to stress out the nation driving especially high GDP growth - what's more important is maitain unity and general contentment with Malaysians to ensure political survival. This has been the policy all the while and will be the policy for some time to come.
    • repairwork  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      I thought long ago we are no longer their match... just compare apple to apple... even Singaporean has to go in there for shopping and holiday... sure if they will to take care of the safety issue for the people... everyone will love Malaysia for work, biz and fun.. comparing with our stress in Singapore, high cost, lots of FT, small yet costly...
      • J.T 2 months ago
        Yes, I bet you only go there because it's cheap. It's like they always say, we're just like birds when we go to Malaysia, "Cheap! Cheap! Cheap!".
      • ihs 2 months ago
        J.T. dont you too ? Beside the cost Malaysia is much bigger than our tiny red dot island .... people are friendlier beautiful landscape ONLY downside is security !
      • David Snake 2 months ago
        I would go to Malaysia if it reforms.....
    • Leo  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      I guess "Robert Walters" will be moving to Malaysia soon??
    • Jeffrey  •  2 months ago
      I am looking at Penang, if any place which will develop rapidly, it will be Penang, where just taken over by OPPOSITION last election... heard that already change quite a lot..

      FYI, Penang just got into to the Top 10 most comfortable city to stay in ASIA, btw is an expat survey.
      • Nurul 2 months ago
        Yes Pinang is much more cleaner now. But the traffic jams are still there.
      • Jeffrey 2 months ago
        it take times... the opposition only took over 3 yrs ago :) pretty effective already
      • Steven 2 months ago
        Penagnite say PLEASE DON"T COME YOU FT
    • CubanCat  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      i bet Andrea is also refuelling her motorbike in johor baru and visits the market there for her groceries..
    • sammy  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      a malaysian now in singapore parliament was smart enough to see the future and told singaporeans to send their parent to malaysia .
    • Dolphin Tan  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      Some years ago they decided to built Tanjong Pelapas to compete with PSA, manage to snatch Maersk Line and Evergreen over, but in the end , all spit saliva, because slow loading /unloading, missing cargoes and so much problem. Next they say wanna built Financial hub to compete, in the end so many red tapes and investor all pulled out, now they claim Iskandar zone is sucessful, lets see how long can they last, Malaysia is rich, they can built all first class building, but the problem is they cannot maintain, probably due to corruption.

      Take a look at their parliament house, need to use umbrella during parliament sitting, before they can say competing with us, they need to tackle their own problems. Religion conflict already a big headache for them, the minority are not happy with their NEA policy. How to progress if the citizens are not united?

      Their bumi policy also frighten lots of investor, all business investment needs a tua pek kong to be shareholder, but that chap probably knows nuts about running a company. I think ang mo still dun understand malaysia well.
      • Jeffrey 2 months ago
        hahah well said, tht was why their opposition can win over 5 states
      • Dolphin Tan 2 months ago
        Whats the differences? With 5 states in the hands of opposition, there are not much changes in Malaysia policy, perhaps the only better state is Penang, under Lim Guan Eng, which you can see he is more aggresive, the rest are just the same, no action , not even talk.
      • Ling 2 months ago
        i do agree that Penang is better.
    • frank  •  Bandar Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  2 months ago
      EVERY MIDDLE CLASS FAMILY IS TRYING TO SEND THEIR CHILDREN AWAY FROM MALAYSIA...BECAUSE THERE IS NOT FUTURE FOR MALAYSIA
      • green lantern 2 months ago
        there will be good future for Malaysia when the Malaysians vote UMNO out.
      • Steven 2 months ago
        @Green Lantern Why don"t you mind your own business.You bark in Singapore for all I care.We Muslim in Malaysia don"t like mad dogs barking at us.so do your own barking at home.Pls don"t come over here and work we don"t need S"porean FT just like you don"t like FT.By the way you can come over to spent your Money here you are most welcome But not to work PLEASE. THANKS
      • Timothy 2 months ago
        @Steven this is Yahoo Singapore forum therefore please respect the statements of Green Lantern and Frank which is actually the truth.
    • lynn  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      Tolong, Malaysia solve the long running problems first.

      Their corruption problems - hello what government? what police force?

      Ethnic bias - citizens of a certain ethnic group is always selected / prioritized over the rest in schools, businesses, etc. How ironic when most of the time its the OTHER ethnic group who bring up/sustain the economy with their pure hard work and business savvy-ness.

      Mindset - certain ethnic group also super lazy, come on time go home on time. off work hours nothing at the office is their problem, no ownership to job or work. How will the population with a half-assed mindset push the country forward?

      Language and Religion - the country is generally Muslim, I cannot imagine how a country and its society can grow when the government cannot manage a balance between respecting religion and allowing freedom of speech & action. And almost everything from spoken language, all media and press is expressed in Malay language. How to move towards a prosperous future like this?
    • Linda Chiang  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      Hi Andrea, I'll take my chances in S'pore thank you very much. At least S'pore is a merit based society unlike Malaysia.
    • goh  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      haha i got so many colleagues in my Malaysia office dying to work in Singapore.
    • Stitch  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      This Ang Mo women is try to Pitch Singaporean and Malaysian against each other. Just another pieces of foreigh trash. We had so much in common and half of my family is living accross the causeway holding Malaysian citizenship.
    • Jason  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      firstly, msia have to solve their corruption issue.
      Otherwise, everything are just a dream.
    • 12345  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      Now I know which recruitment consultancy NOT to use.
    • Singapore Gaga  •  2 months ago
      All these consultancy firms are no better than anyone reading tea leaves. They consultants are paid by the businesses to generate fear and pressure the Singapore Govt to hire more foreigners. Lets put all these consultancy firms out of work by asking your elected Govt and MPs to ignore these good for nothing consultants.
    • SK  •  Shanghai, China  •  2 months ago
      I really do not bother much about what these headhunting companies wrote or reported. Many of these head hunters do not really know how to fill the positions with the fight guy. I do not mean all. At the end of the day, infrastructure is one thing and actual performance is another.

      And I am sure our Government will take measures that we will stay competitive . What happened in Singapore with influx of foreigners will happen too in Malaysia, unless they had the local people with the right talent. Shanghai , Beijing and many cities suffered the same fate. Foreign companies employed large amount of foreigners - German , Malaysian, Taiwanese, Japanese and see what happen to their cost of living. Already , Shanghai cost of living is not that much cheaper than Singapore in terms of purchasing power compare with their salary.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      i love malaysia .. at least i know for politics .. malaysia is going for a more democratic political system... not like singapore where the Lees likes to practise nepotism and pushing their own people with credits to take on high position. one good examples is lee hsien loong, his wife ho chin.. and the rest of Old Lee's family members :)
    • William T  •  2 months ago
      If Malaysia is smart, they'll make it attractive for all the SMEs in Singapore which are now being driven out of business by our newly introduced restrictive hiring policies and increased costs to move across the border to Johor. But I question their (Malaysia's) ability really capitalise of our mistakes because of their history of suka-suka rule changing, corruption and the other reasons already listed by other contributors.
    • Judah  •  Singapore, Singapore  •  2 months ago
      We are born naked, we know our G-d, we have the Torah, out faith and trust is in G-d and G-d takes us to places of refugee and serenity. These are the legacy of having faith in G-d alone nothing else. All that we aquired and learned and our fortunes goes with us. if you thing you could rule this Nation with your wealth greed, name , fame power like the Egyptians, be prepared as the Lrd G-d will say " Let My People Go". When Sons an daughters of this soil leaves the Nation, what nation do you hav ewith out people. You may open your doors to new people. But the neww people are merely " Singapore Dollar Citizens and Singapore Dollar PR's ".The natural home born Singaporean are no longer you child and we all feel rejected in our own homeland. So we Go else where !

      What is your life and achievements when you dont have people who love you but hate you .

      Truth are Truth.
    • Happy Asian  •  2 months ago
      Malaysian government willing to help students who are smart and poor (even if they are not), to continue with their studies overseas, and everything is being paid for. Why can't the Singapore government do the same....ohh wait. the government ONLY help foreigners first and NOT Singaporean.

      Even when the Malaysian government wants to introduce GST, they ask the citizens and they rejected it....the government stop, unlike Singapore, the government DO NOT LISTEN to us, they ONLY hear us.

      The housing there is cheaper compare to Singapore. So that they are able to assist their citizens...in Singapore, the government will tell you...IT CAN'T BE HELP or they will THREATEN you!!!

    Featured Blog Posts

    Blog Authors / Profiles