Farcical scenes in Japan-Korea judo quarter-final

The Olympic judo quarter-final between world champion Masashi Ebinuma and Cho Jun-Ho of South Korea descended into farce on Sunday after Cho was awarded victory, only for his Japanese rival to be declared the winner moments later.

The under-66kg fight remained level after a five-minute contest, plus an extra three minutes of golden score, meaning it went to a judges' decision.

All three judges on the mat awarded the bout to Cho, clad in blue, but the International Judo Federation's Refeering Commission then intervened.

Following frantic discussions on the sidelines, referees director Juan Carlos Barcos, who had been seen consulting federation president Marius Vizer, called the judges over and seemingly told them to change their minds.

The three judges then went back onto the mat and having originally all lifted blue flags denoting a Cho victory, this time thrust up three white ones instead.

Ebinuma was declared the winner and although he lost to eventual gold medallist Lasha Shavdatuashvili of Georgia in the semis, both he and Cho went on to take the two bronze medals.

When the original decision was made it brought protests from the crowd and Ebinuma felt that helped him.

"I thought I was going to lose but there was all this support in the spectator seats and that allowed me to get this medal," he said.

"But I'm feeling a bit bad for (Cho)."

Having matched Ebinuma's medal, the Korean let sleeping dogs lie.

"Initially I thought I had won but when it was reversed I was a little sad," he said.

"But I had my remaining fights to focus on and I hoped (Ebinuma) would get a good result because he beat me. We both won bronze so I'm happy."

Federation general secretary Jean-Luc Rouge told AFP the move was made as it was believed an Ebinuma attack had not been scored.

"The referees weren't told to change their minds, they were merely reminded about an incident (an attack by Ebinuma that could have scored) that should have influenced their decision," he said.

"It had escaped their minds but having reconsidered it they then gave their modified verdicts."

When put to him that the incident had been damaging for the federation, Rouge added: "It's better that the federation is damaged rather than judo."

The crowd, who were upset over the original decision and jeered loudly, became even more vocal following the farcical overturn and Cho was afforded a standing ovation as he left the mat.

Already, during the sudden death golden score period, the referees commission had overturned the award of a winning score for Ebinuma by the judges -- the incident the commission then reminded the judges to consider in their later decision.

For the first time at the Olympics, video replay technology is being used to review contentious scoring but the over-rule of a judges decision following a draw has never been done before.

The federation later put out a statement trying to clarify its ruling.

"The International Judo Federation (IJF) is strongly committed to equity and, as part of our sport judo, to the development of all the tools that in our competitions help the referees to make the right decisions, so that the best fighters win.

"In order to achieve this, a video system was set up and has proved successful.

"The referee and the two judges of the fight, after having received the details from the experts commission, decided to change their decision and give victory to the Japanese.

"The IJF states that this is the final and right decision."

Loading...
  • 50 things that successful people do 13 hours ago

    Do you want to be successful? Of course you do. Who doesn’t, right? Obviously, the path to success isn’t easy. If it were, you’d see far more successful people around. Through my work, I’ve had the … More »

  • Is being apple- or pear-shaped healthier? 17 hours ago

    Good health is determined not only by a healthy weight but also by a healthy waist size and body shape. Increasingly, doctors are using waist size and body shape, along with body weight, to predict … More »

  • What Does 1-Billion-Year-Old Water Taste Like? Wed, Jun 19, 2013

    It's summer, and as much as I love the sunshine, I am doing my best to stay hydrated. Besides central air conditioning, a cool glass of water is my seasonal BFF. A newly discovered water source is … More »

  • Haze in Singapore reaches all-time record high at 321 PSI

    Haze in Singapore reaches all-time record high at 321 PSI

    Haze in Singapore reaches all-time record high at 321 PSI

    The Pollutant Standards Index (PSI) hit an all-time high of 321 at 10pm on Wednesday, crossing into the "hazardous" range, according to data from the National Environment Agency (NEA).

  • PM Lee, ministers up pressure on Indonesia to tackle haze

    PM Lee, ministers up pressure on Indonesia to tackle haze

    PM Lee, ministers up pressure on Indonesia to tackle haze

    Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong and several Cabinet members have increased the pressure on Indonesia to take control of the haze situation.

  • COMMENT: A thin fine line

    COMMENT: A thin fine line

    COMMENT: A thin fine line

    COMMENT The concept of sub judice contempt for ongoing court cases is an important one; it is in place to ensure that proceedings can be as objective as possible, rather than swayed by the court of public opinion. Yet in … Continue reading →

Featured Blogs

  • Daniel Wong

    Do you want to be successful? Of course you do. Who doesn’t, right? Obviously, the path to success isn’t easy. If it were, you’d see far more successful people around. Through my work, I’ve had the privilege of interacting with … Continue reading → …

  • Health Xchange

    Good health is determined not only by a healthy weight but also by a healthy waist size and body shape. Increasingly, doctors are using waist size and body shape, along with body weight, to predict your risk for chronic health … Continue reading → …

  • It's summer, and as much as I love the sunshine, I am doing my best to stay hydrated. Besides central air conditioning, a cool glass of water is my seasonal BFF. A newly discovered water source is making me appreciate those glasses of water in a whole new way. A mile and a half below [...] …

  • COMMENT: A thin fine line
    COMMENT: A thin fine line

    COMMENT The concept of sub judice contempt for ongoing court cases is an important one; it is in place to ensure that proceedings can be as objective as possible, rather than swayed by the court of public opinion. Yet in … Continue reading → …

  • Sony was E3’s big winner in large part because of the company's decision to price the PlayStation 4 at $399, a full $100 cheaper than Microsoft’s upcoming Xbox One. But the man in charge of Xbox maintains Microsoft is offering … Continue reading → …