Which is Healthier: Black Carrot Cake or White Carrot Cake?

Black and white carrot cake are popular Singapore dishes.

By Natalie Black (guest contributor)

For most westerners moving to Singapore they are confused with “carrot cake” being sold at the local hawker stalls. For most Caucasians – carrot cake is a sweet baked cake with frosting that you have with your tea or coffee. It resembles nothing that comes out of a wok. In Singapore, carrot cake is very different.

“Chai tao kway”, more popularly known as carrot cake is actually fried cubes of radish cake made from white radish and steamed rice flour. It is stir-fried with garlic, eggs, preserved radish and seasonings. It comes in white and black versions. The only difference is that the “black” version is cooked with dark, sweet soy sauce giving it a different taste and appearance.

Nutrition information for one plate of White Carrot Cake

Energy: 466 calories
Protein: 11 g
Carbs: 51 g
Fat: 24 g

Nutrition information for one plate of Black Carrot Cake

Energy: 566 calories
Protein: 12 g
Carbs: 77 g
Fat: 24 g

That means that in two tablespoons of dark, sweet soy sauce added, there was 100 calories, 1g Protein, 26g carbs, 0g Fat. Just in sauce!

And the winner is…

White carrot cake.







Therefore the healthier option is to choose the white version. It’s still quite carbohydrate dominant with not a green vegetable in sight. The recommended portion size of carbohydrates is only a fist size portion. Therefore, this isn’t the healthiest, most balanced option you could choose for a meal.

If you choose to eat Carrot Cake, please remember to always follow my additional recommendations every time you eat: Eat slowly, put your utensils down between bites, and always stop when you feel 80% full because it’s better to waste it than to “waist” it.

Enjoy!

By guest contributor Natalie Black, an accredited Exercise Physiologist who blogs at The Health Guru. Via HealthMatters.sg, a Singapore Health and Fitness blog that aims to help you lose weight, keep fit, and live healthy. Click here to get our free guide “Eat Your Way to Health – Secrets of a Healthy Diet”.

Related Articles

4 Steps to Lose Weight by Changing Your Beverage Habits (at HealthMatters.sg)

5 Healthy Local Foods You Can Order For Your Next Meal (at HealthMatters.sg)

10 Tips to Not Be Annoying At the Gym (at HealthMatters.sg)

  • Best and worst sugar substitutes Fri, May 17, 2013

    Sugar has earned a bad reputation for being bad for your heart, your brain and your waistline. Because of this, there have been many attempts to market sugar substitutes. Some are useful, but some More »

  • Why go through a preventive double mastectomy? Fri, May 17, 2013

    Hollywood actress Angelina Jolie announced she has had both her breasts removed in February to reduce her high genetic risk of breast cancer. The surgery, called double mastectomy, brought down her More »

  • Top 8 lucrative routes for taxi drivers Fri, May 17, 2013

    For a taxi driver, a key survival skill is knowing where to find customers. As far as possible, a driver should know the routes at his or her fingertips. Hence, in this 6th instalment of Taxi Talks, More »

Loading...
  • Teo Ho Pin presses WP's Sylvia Lim for answers

    Teo Ho Pin presses WP's Sylvia Lim for answers

    Teo Ho Pin presses WP's Sylvia Lim for answers

    Worker's Party Chairman Sylvia Lim has challenged Dr Teo Ho Pin to make a report to the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) if he believes that the WP had mismanaged the Town Council.

  • Some Chinese tourists 'uncivilised': top official

    Some Chinese tourists 'uncivilised': top official

    Some Chinese tourists 'uncivilised': top official

    The dire manners and "uncivilised behaviour" of some Chinese tourists abroad are harming the country's image, said a top official who lamented their poor "quality and breeding", according to state-run media.

  • Former president Nathan urges more Singaporeans to volunteer

    Former president Nathan urges more Singaporeans to volunteer

    Former president Nathan urges more Singaporeans to volunteer

    “People need to feel compassion,” says former president of Singapore, S R Nathan. “Problems will always be there. You can always throw money but that will not be the solution," he said as he urged more Singaporeans to give of their time and effort as volunteers to help those in need.

Featured Blogs

  • Sugar has earned a bad reputation for being bad for your heart, your brain and your waistline. Because of this, there have been many attempts to market sugar substitutes. Some are useful, but some are even worse than the original … Continue reading →

  • Health Xchange

    Hollywood actress Angelina Jolie announced she has had both her breasts removed in February to reduce her high genetic risk of breast cancer. The surgery, called double mastectomy, brought down her risk from 87 per cent to about 5 per … Continue reading →

  • For a taxi driver, a key survival skill is knowing where to find customers. As far as possible, a driver should know the routes at his or her fingertips. Hence, in this 6th instalment of Taxi Talks, I would like … Continue reading →

  • For three decades he smiled and waved at Singaporeans from his spot on billboards, posters and brochures. He was dedicated to his task of making Singapore a kinder, more courteous place for everyone to live in, regardless of whether he … Continue reading →

  • Top five career moves for Singa the Lion
    Top five career moves for Singa the Lion

    There’s nothing quite like death to make a point. Even when it comes to telling Singaporeans how ungracious they are. Call it clever marketing or whatever, terminating (via resignation that is) “Singa the Lion” has certainly worked for its zookeepers … Continue reading →