YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Malaysia Islamic clerics forbid forex trading

    Malaysia's highest Islamic body has issued an edict forbidding foreign exchange trading by Muslim individuals, saying such speculation violates Islamic law.

    The National Fatwa Council ruled forex trading by money changers or between banks was allowable but trading by individuals "creates confusion" among the faithful, according to a report issued Wednesday by state news agency Bernama.

    Council chairman Abdul Shukor Husin warned "there are many doubts about it (forex trading) and it involves individuals using the Internet, with uncertain outcomes," Bernama reported.

    "A study by the committee found that such trading involved currency speculation, which contradicts Islamic law," he was quoted saying.

    A council official confirmed the ruling to AFP but gave no further details.

    Islam lays out a strict code of ethics for business that forbids speculation and usury.

    While Malaysia's brand of Islam is more moderate than in much of the Muslim world, some 60 percent of its 28 million people are Muslim and remain subject to Islamic law in civil affairs.

    In 2008, the National Fatwa Council banned yoga for Muslims, saying it could erode their faith.

    That triggered an uproar from moderate Muslims, prompting then prime minister Abdullah Ahmad Badawi to wade in, saying Muslims could do yoga as long as it had no Hindu spiritual elements.

    How do you feel about this article?

     

    65 comments

    • RAJAH  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      free thinker kata - tuhan tak wujud , semuanya natural datang sendiri , kalau kita tuhan cipta siapa cipta tuhan .
      Buddha kata - tuhan wujud dalam semua org , kita patut belajar cari sendiri mcm Budda gautama itu sendiri .
      Hindu dan Cina kata - tuhan wujud di bumi dengan rupa byk dewa & dewi .
      Muslim kata - satu tuhan sahaja dan Nabi Muhamad itu tuhan allah hantar kasi bumi .
      Kristian kata - Jesus itu tuhan punya anak , Mary jesus punya emak .

      semua agama kata ada syurga ada neraka . jadi buat baik saja .

      tapi problem sekarang mana satu baik , mana satu jahat pun semua org sudah pening .

      Hantam satu sama lain lagi byk dosa , karma .

      sorry muslim fren . kalau saya ada salah ckp .
      • ozi 3 months ago
        bro yr punya definasi salah lah.
        Tuhan x wujud= atheist
        Free thinker= yes may be ada and may be x de Tuhan
      • anon 3 months ago
        pun salah.
        agnostic = mungkin ada Tuhan, mungkin juga tak ada
        free thinker = mirip Buddhism. cari falsafah sendiri.
      • adam 3 months ago
        woi...mari bayar tax...gua ajar sama lu orng.lari mana.BAYAR taxxxx2000x12bulanx17j(org)mai korek duit.kerajaan untung lol'lektrk free air free.
    • Amino Acid  •  Moscow, Russia  •  3 months ago
      Most of the Forex traders are Muslim in M'sia. Some of them even pay "Zakat" for it.
      • John 3 months ago
        why malaysian muslim are such hypocrites??? ......they should convert to animalism...freaks
      • ozi 3 months ago
        Well they are good practising muslims obedient...and also Muslim by names only but practice non Islamic life...
      • ozi 3 months ago
        in islm concept is simple the end do es not justify the mean, you do haram thing and pay zakat??when u started with shit the output is also shit...
    • sabaman  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      haram apabila memperJUDIkan nyawa dengan bekerja di tempat bahaya. itu saham malaysia semuanya HARAM. Tapi klu pinjam 250J itu halal.
      • mohamad 3 months ago
        boleh tahan gak kebodohan ko ni
      • Cisss 3 months ago
        Confirm ko ni orang UMNO Mohamad... Menghalalkan 250j... Dalam duit tu, saya pun ada bayar tax juga, jadi saya MENGHARAMKAN SEGALA MAKAN MINUM yang dorang salahlaku dan salahguna, atas bahagian tax saya yg ada dalam tu.
    • YM  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      Jangan pergi pasar - sebab duit yang bertukar tangan dari setiap kedai tidak nampak datang dari kedai jual daging barang haram - orang ini pegang - orang itu pegang - kalau macam itu pegang duit pun haram - jangan keluar rumah - mungkin udara yang ada dipersekitaran pun mungkin haram untuk dihirup - sebab udara nye mungkin datang dari batuk orang yang makan daging haram - fikir fikir kanlah untuk hidup yang macam mane yang Tuan kehendaki - akai ada kah.
      • Azuddin Nik 3 months ago
        nampak sgt bodoh kau ni,,cover2 skt bodoh tu
      • wong 3 months ago
        Nak cover cam mana...apa dia kato tu betul juga....banyak wang kertas dan syiling memang dah diguna oleh penjual daging babi......bolehkah wang ni diharamkan....??
      • A Malaysian 3 months ago
        jika tak tau,jgn komen. Dalam islam, duit untuk urusan perdagangan tak ada soal haram halal.
    • soldier fortune  •  Lagos, Nigeria  •  3 months ago
      .....even trading in the stock market is HARAM.... such trading involves speculation, which contradicts Islamic law.....
      • adam 3 months ago
        jangan main forex.,,bayar tax x.:untung la x kena gaji prebet.kerajaan lak tu.kalu kena tax 2000setahun anda dapat percuma lektrik air.silap 555rm dapat balik
    • change  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      FOREX TRADING HARAM.. SWINDLE NFC ALLOCATION IS HALAL..
      GOOD KEEP IT UP...
      PM, PLEASE ADVICE NOT TO GIVE STATEMENT BEFORE CONSULTING GOVERMENT..
      PM, THIS ALSO YOU CANNOT DO HA?
      WHAT ELSE YOU CAN DO AND CONTROL?
      EXCERCISE YOUR RELIGION AT HOME AND FOLLOW MALAYSIAN LAW OUTSIDE THE HOUSE, THEN NO PROBLEM WILL ARISE.. WE CAN LIVE HAPPILY UNDER 1 MALAYSIA ..
      AGAMA BERLAINAN TAPI BANGSA MALAYSIA..
      PM THIS IS THE RIGHT SLOGAN..
    • Simon  •  3 months ago
      Now even Muslims cannot do forex trading. Does that mean more jobs for the non-malays?
    • Tim  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      That's a good one. Should see how many of them buy 4 digits.
    • Jason  •  Johor Baharu, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      Tell that to Dr. Mahathir and especially Bank Negara.
    • hardyyboyy  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      duit cukai dari arak, 4D, TOTO, kuda, casino genting mana pergi? Kalau haram mesti orang india dan cina saja dapat tapi tak. Jadi mana pergi duit haram itu?
    • Puaka Tanah  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      hidup pun haram...ada pelir haram,ada pukie haram...dalam neraka haram dalam syurga haram...apa tidak haram? Buang anak dalam tong sampah tidak haram...
    • diam  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      ramalan cuaca pun haram..sebab melibatkan ramalan..betui tak? maknanya nampaknya muslim akan ketingalan ke belakang alamatnya bye bye
    • ozi  •  3 months ago
      in short forex trading ni ada element judi,speculation itu je so haram abeh kesah..apa nak argue argue patut dah lama hgn di bagi buat...
    • Hawkeye  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      MMM....Who ever said that is not make sense, the people in side majlis fatwa islam malaysia is already nonsense, if they say that forex for individus is haram so the the bank do the forex also haram, i dont know why this people make such of this fatwa.....bussiness matter for someone i thing, everything is haram so what is halal for us for muslim, as far as i know forex bussiness is nothing concern on islamic economic b4........haram forex is a bad idea...
    • SURGA NERAKA  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      ORANG-ORANG BUKAN ISLAM BERTUAH KERANA TIDAK TERLIBAT. BANYANGKANLAH BERTAPA SUSAHNYA KEHIDUPAN BILA SIANG MALAM ADA SAHAJA YANG HALAL HARAMNYA. MEMANG BERTUAH ORANG-ORANG BUKAN ISLAM KERANA AGAMA MEREKA LEBIH PRAKTIKAL, MUDAH SERTA TIDAK MENEKAN SAMPAIKAN MENYULITKAN KEHIDUPAN SEHARIAN MEREKA.
    • redfaceindian  •  3 months ago
      Wait a minute......this means Bank Islam, Bank Muamalat is run by robots and not humans ? Banks can trade in forex but not individuals ? This is absurd beyond comprehension. How many Malays going to lose jobs ? Who is going to feed their family ? Is the National Fatwa Council trying to make Malaysia into a Taliban state ? These people must be told that religion and government administration does not mix. Malaysia is not a Islamic country. Their statement is surely going to confuse the Malays more about Islam. Bank Negara is under the Government, forex is under Bank Negara. Why do these people try to play God?
    • DevanK  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      And yet malays are the most active Forex traders in Malaysia because its 'easy money'. They probably came up with this BS law after some fatwa fool lost money in FX.
    • eagle  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      I am indian and my opinion.Diffrent people diffrent perception from their experiance, how many people make money and how many of then lose their entire savings so what the about article is all about gambling. There is no such thing as easy many as stupid Devan suggest, Risk is always there
    • hardyyboyy  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      this is what happends when one depands on government for everything till the brain is totally shut down but not on sex
    • SeriouslyFunny  •  Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia  •  3 months ago
      Funny. Why muslim individuals only? Not applicable to corporation run by muslims? MBB, CIMB, RHB, all Islamic banks..etc..etc...BNM too?

    Featured Blog Posts