Yahoo!. Now with Friends.

Discover news, videos and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    MM Lee on stepping down: It's the right thing to do

    MM Lee is stepping down as Minister Mentor. (AFP file photo)MM Lee is stepping down as Minister Mentor. (AFP file photo)Minister Mentor Lee Kuan Yew says his decision to step down from Cabinet is the "right thing to do"  and sends a clear message that there is a "break from the past."

    In an email to The Sunday Times, the 87-year-old founding father of Singapore said, "SM Goh and I believe this is the right thing to do, to give PM and his team the room to break from the past, and we want to make it clear that the PAP has never been averse to change."

    In what could be an oblique acknowledgment he and SM Goh may have cost the ruling People's Action Party some votes during the recent General Elections, MM Lee added, "It is vital to avoid a situation where people vote to have more opposition for opposition's sake."

    MM Lee attracted widespread criticism for his remarks that Aljunied GRC constituents would "repent" if they voted for the opposition, while SM Goh was involved in an ugly war of words with his previous staff member and Singapore Democratic Party member, Tan Jee Say. SM Goh also raised eyebrows when he appeared to defend then-Foreign Minister George Yeo, only to inadvertently put down some other Cabinet Ministers.

    MM Lee's email came hours after he and Senior Minister Goh Chok Tong issued a surprise 168-word statement on Saturday evening announcing that both senior politicians were leaving the Cabinet.

    In a joint-email statement to the media, the two leaders and former Prime Minister said they have considered the "new political situation" and it's time for a new generation to take the country forward.

    Here is their statement in full:

    We have studied the new political situation and thought how it can affect the future. We have made our contributions to the development of Singapore. The time has come for a younger generation to carry Singapore forward in a more difficult and complex situation. The Prime Minister and his team of younger leaders should have a fresh clean slate. A younger generation, besides having a non-corrupt and meritocratic government and a high standard of living, wants to be more engaged in the decisions which affect them. After a watershed general election, we have decided to leave the cabinet and have a completely younger team of ministers to connect to and engage with this young generation in shaping the future of our Singapore.

    But the younger team must always have in mind the interests of the older generation. This generation who has contributed to Singapore must be well-looked after.
    SM Goh Chok Tong will still remain as Marine Parade MP. (Getty file photo)SM Goh Chok Tong will still remain as Marine Parade MP. (Getty file photo)

    It will be the first time Lee will be out of government in 52 years -- he was first elected prime minister in 1959, when colonial ruler Britain granted self-rule to Singapore, and stepped down in 1990 in favour of Goh.

    Goh himself has spent 35 years in office, including 14 years as Prime Minister. He handed over the PM role to Lee's son, current Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, 59, in 2004.

    Both MM Lee and SM Goh will remain Members of Parliament for their respective constituencies of Tanjong Pagar and Marine Parade.

    SM Goh, 69, wrote on the MParader Facebook page in the wake of his statement and said, "I will now have more time to devote to our GRC. Team Marine Parade will build a consensus on creating our 4G Home."

    The announcement caught many by surprise.

    Political commentator Cherian George was surprised by the timing and the reasons behind the two ministers' announcement.

    "The signal from the election was addressed to the whole government, not to any particular generation of ministers," said the 46-year-old associate professor in journalism from National Technological University.

    "But it's a momentous move, and shows Mr Lee acting in what he thinks is in Singapore's interests," he added.

    The National Solidarity Party (NSP) also issued a public statement in response, lauding MM Lee as "the architect of modern Singapore", and credited SM Goh's leadership for Singapore's successful navigation through crises such as the Asian financial crisis and the SARS outbreak.

    "We welcome their decision to encourage new, younger voices in their leadership structure," the party said in their statement issued to the media and released to the public through their Facebook page.

    "But this renewal must not be limited to the People's Action Party; it must extend to our political culture with an inclusion of perspectives from outside the Party."

    Student Lim Yan Liang, 24, told Yahoo! Singapore he felt that the decision made by the two outgoing ministers seemed quite a populist one.

    "They're trying to contain the damage from the results of the election as much as possible by stepping down," he said, referring to the increased vote share that went to the opposition from the 7th May polls.

    "This is a step in the right direction," said retiree Steven Lye, 72. "It shows the government is willing to back up its talk with concrete action.

    "Singapore will miss them, and I am sure they appreciate their past services," he added.

    The surprise statement also sparked a flurry of reaction within the online community, with Facebook users posting a range of comments.

    A comment by Eugene Yuhin Wong on Yahoo Singapore's Facebook page said, "Our election was a total sham. If they announced it before elections, a certain GRC will be opposition area. Those two just put in eight MPs at one shot."

    Another user, Alamak Chua, wrote, "Their retirements are long overdue. Nowhere else in the world has such cabinet posts. They should have done that long ago to save our taxpayers' money on their (million-dollar) salaries and their overseas trips."

    However, Freddy How Yong Song wished the two outgoing Ministers well, saying, "It's good news the Cabinet needs new faces and the old should go away gracefully. I respect their decision and hope for the best in their near and far future."

    Others reacted with sadness.

    Gina Sg wrote, "I'm sad. Thank you MM Lee and SM Goh for their contribution to Singapore. Without their guidance , Singapore would not be what it is today. From an insignificant dot country to a country well known for it's stable financial infrastructure!"

    How do you feel about this article?

     

    1,548 comments

    • red hot boyz  •  9 months ago
      Calls are brewing from the People to ask Mah Bow Tan to step down!!!
    • Mirror Image  •  9 months ago
      I felt a sense of consolations in the last sentence of the joint statement.
      "But the younger team must always have in mind the interests of the older generation. This generation who has contributed to Singapore must be well-looked after."
      I am one of these older Singaporeans. Why is it that as one grow older in Singapore, he has to work harder than before ? My children are growing up and there comes extra worries of higher cost and my potential high medical cost in the future. Let's see what the younger generations have in mind. The old policies cannot be repeated as they do now work as evident from current situations.
    • nj  •  9 months ago
      whatever is done is done, they have contributed greatly to singapore. i just hope and pray that the younger and new ministers have the brains and insight to continue with what they have create and not cause singapore to go down instead of going up.
    • KHOO  •  9 months ago
      The government should have a very tight control over the so call foreign talents coming in. They should be heavily scrutinize before allowing them in. As for PR status there should be a cap of let say 5 years after which a decision has to be made.
    • All for Improvement  •  9 months ago
      We are all very grateful to the two of you for making Spore what it is today. It is indeed honorable for you to step down so graciously. Only "Great" men can do this!

      Now that GCT is not in the Caninet, I wonder how will TPL perform without GCT as her mentor and advisor. Will she too step down graciously? Just hoping!
    • chris  •  9 months ago
      Most people I know are hoping Mah Bow Tan step down, not so much LKY and GCT.
      Mah Bow Tan's policies are the real sg human-killers.
    • james  •  9 months ago
      To show appreciation to the older generation, the younger team should and must give more benefits to the older generation. Afterall, it is this group that contributed to the large reserves we now have. Give them some benefits to tide over their retirement years. I am very concerned that the large reserve will benefit the newly naturalised citizens in the future when the older generation slowly fades away in the next 10-20 years. And we must have a clear and consistent definition of the older generation - ie those from aged 55 and above. Now, polyclinics define elderly as 65 and above.
    • Crazy World  •  9 months ago
      Hmmm. One would expect MBT (screw up on housing), WKS (dangerous criminal escaped under his nose), VB (squandering money with a flimsy excuse because its taxpayers' money) to step down immediately because they are the ones that caused the most anger, resentment and frustrations and sufferings to the people of Singapore. Unfortunately, they seemed to be enjoying the ride at the expense of others. What a shame!

      Incidentally, I also wonder that Singapore is such a little dot, why do we need so many Ministers assisted by so many deputies with multi-layers of staff to enable him to be the mouthpiece to convey the policies to Singaporeans? Why is a ceremonial President who does even less thinking than the manual construction workers paid so highly, even higher than George Bush?

      Why a young and inexperienced candidate who can't even command a 5k salary in the private salary simply rides on the coat tails of a heavy weight minister and straightaway command a 15k salary despite her not being suitable for the job? Shouldn't she be listening to the public resentment and immediately step down? Why are so many PAP MPs holding 2 jobs with 2 very high salaries? They have only 24 hours a day. It's either doing one good job neglecting the other or under-performing in both jobs. Most Singaporeans have one job and they worked from 8 to 9 or even 10 pm with no overtime!

      When is PM Lee going to hear all these cries.
    • SL  •  9 months ago
      My child goes to PCF at Sengkang and the class consists of 7 Indian PRs and 8 Singaporeans. And i was surprised to hear from the PR kids mums that they r here since last 10 to15years, all with HDB flats, but no one has the intention to become a citizen. A couple of months back when i asked them if they would consider Singapore citizenship now that getting PR status is difficult, they said "No way, we haven't done it for past so many yrs, we would eventually sell our flats and move back to our native. Few of them were joking that being a citizen holds no benefits for them, they'd rather be PRs and move back eventually. One even said that citizens are 20$ cheaper." When i asked her what she meant by 20$ cheaper, she said "Have you taken a look at the PCF fees and childcare fees. Childcare fees are the same for PR working/non-working mum after the subsidies. While the PCF Kindergarten fees is only 20$ more for PRs. If citizens pay 160 for Nursery, the PRs pay 180 and fees for KG is 120$ for citizens and 180$ for PRs." This was a real shocker to me as i thought that PRs are supposed to fork out more, but seriously PCF should reconsider fee for Citizens or we would end up being 20$ cheaper always.
    • Allelujah!  •  9 months ago
      Mr Wong Kan Seng and Mr Mah Bow Tan, pls step down as well. The damages you've done to Singapore, not withstanding the contributions you've made for the past 20 years, should entail a punishment of some sort. But since you're serving and contributing the country as well, you shall be pardoned.
    • canla  •  9 months ago
      There need to be some MAJOR changes in Govt plans and policies to make sure that the average hardworking Singaporeans live in a DIGNIFIED way when retired.-

      Don't just tell us to tighten our belts or downgrade during retirement when inflation soars.- some of the wealth accumulated of the nation need to be used to help old folks and sandwiched generation.

      may be set up transparent "sink fund" for each generation (10-15 years cycle) - so hardworking generation will accumulate more and easy complacent generation will have less.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  9 months ago
      WHAT ABOUT THAT GOOD FOR NOTHING MBT??? ;(
    • Suffering Singaporean  •  9 months ago
      although this is long overdue their departure are designed to placate more voters who have deflect towards alternative voice and the real changes should be those that impact Singaporeans in real tangible terms.

      both actions by SM and MM though will be well received by the media and many Singaporeans but the real challenge will be in the undoing of policies that will create better lives for all Singaporeans regardless of race, language or religion. and by Singaporeans it means Singapore Singaporeans who have toiled with the government to bring Singapore where we are now.

      Now the real works begin for PM Lee unfettered and without excess baggage to carry - I Hope!

      In the Corporate World - as the saying goes Heads Will Roll -- with the latest news - there will be and should be more heads to go especially in those non-performing Ministers.

      well, people please help me in putting the list down as we also have more contribute in this aspect in the past - lets have an updated list

      next will be for the undoing of policies -- Singaporeans workers interest must be protected

      policies should be formulated with Singaporeans in mind first and we do not want to have any Singaporeans fall victim of employers and bosses who use or rather abuse their authority as in the case of the supporter of NSP who got the sack right after the election by the company that she works in -- this should never happen

      besides all workers should be protected and not be replaced by FTs

      unemployed Singaporeans should be given preference over FTs for jobs especially those with family responsibilities

      costs of living should be arrested and brought down through prudent measures and reduction in other areas of expenditures

      health care cost should be further reduced and do not allow Minister Khaw to shoo away Singaporeans to JB in their old age -- this should not happen.

      for the poor and needy - more help and care should be extended and do not allow Minister Vivian to be so condescending as to question where they like to have their meals in a demeaning tone whether it is at the foodcourt, hawker centre or restaurant -- we do not want our Ministers to be so aloof as not to recognized that the poor really needs all the help they can get.

      get going for the betterment of Singapore for Singaporeans and next allow conducive environment for people to start family and reverse the TFR

      there are alot the be done rather than making more of this sort of news to placate Singaporeans - we want to see real tangible actions that will impact better living conditions for us native Singaporeans.
    • Citizenfoo  •  9 months ago
      After knowing how retired ministers are given pension which is withdrawable at 55 while singaporeans have CPF caged up till 62 and being told religiously that we have to work hard, accept pay cuts when times are bad, and continue to work even after we received our CPF. This is a bad taste of hyprocrisy and a case of how self interest above nation. This is a sad relevation.
    • Lim  •  9 months ago
      MBT and WKS are the 2 that must get LOST to create a better Tomorrow....
    • Rigel  •  9 months ago
      Following this, should the government look into their SALARIES issue and the Ministers’ pension scheme? It's really a burden to Singaporeans, and it's DEFINITELY NOT JUSTIFIABLE. They should REDUCE their salaries and make good use of this sum to explore ways to help the middle & lower income groups.

      I'm speaking out of sincerity, hope the government will seriously look into these issues.
    • lum  •  9 months ago
      Well,after reading the news,i feel lots of Sadness for MM(sorry not for SM),without MM,we,Sinagoporean will not be what we have today,anyway,it good for him,have more rest and enjoy his Golden years to come.

      As for SM,you should retire(bring Miss Cuite-Ting Pei Ling along with you,she can be your personnal private secretary),dont waste tax payer money for her sitting in Parliment.

      3 more Joker,they are : MBT , KBW and WKS , A Million.......................please resign from your present post,if not,more ppl will be become Anti-PAP and join the opposition , which i am one of those.
    • Sandy  •  9 months ago
      SM Goh, you should have stepped down before the election. Tin Pei Ling only became an MP because people gave you face. Even then, your percentage was only 56%, and you rightly attributed part of the poor showing to TPL. Please do us a big favour before you step down - ask her to resign to save the PAP.
    • TALK ONLY ONLY ONLY  •  9 months ago
      When WKS was Minister for Home Affair incharge of Prison & Immigration, he let No.1 terroist Mas Salamat escaped to swin to JB and Ah How just walked acroos the causeway. Why didn't PM sake WKS resign from cabinet ? Not only WKS still remain as DPM, PM reappointed him as Coordinating Minister for NATIONAL SECURITY ????? It seems like a joke !!!!!!
      In recent election camgaign, he was asked why he did not resign as Minister,he still dared to ask people to look at his last 5 years track record and added "you see, PM still needs me in his cabinet."
      WKS is most arregant. If he stands beside GCT, he will think he is just as tall and may even try to look down on GCT.
      Therefore to make Singapore safe,PM should ask WKS to quit from cabinet as he will never resign .
    • John  •  9 months ago
      It is a welcoming news and I am sure our PM can manage without them.

      Another two ministers that we wish that they could step down are Mah BT and Wong KS. They are the disgraces of our country and our people.