YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SEA Games showing ‘at best satisfactory’: CDM

    REPORTING FROM JAKARTA

    Singapore’s athletes may have garnered a total of 160 medals from the SEA Games, 42 of which were gold, but to contingent Chef de Mission Tan Eng Liang, their combined performance was “at best, satisfactory” compared to how they fared at the 2009 Games in Laos.

    Speaking at a post-Games press conference held in Jakarta on Monday, Tan said that the boost in the number of gold medals won this year was largely thanks to six sports that were not offered two years ago that produced a combined 12 gold medals for Singapore.

    These sports were canoeing, which produced two golds; sailing and bowling, which took home four and three golds respectively; and water skiing, gymnastics and women’s water polo, which clinched one gold medal each.

    Deducting them from the total, however, would leave 30 gold medals, fewer than the 33 attained in Laos.

    “Therefore, if you ask me, as Chef de Mission, have we done well? My answer is, I’m sorry to say, it is at best satisfactory,” he said, also noting that eight sports out of the 36 that Singapore participated in at the Games held in Jakarta and Palembang performed worse than they did two years ago.

    Tan also offered his own “report card” for the various sports, summarised below:

    A+ (for outstanding achievement): Swimming

    A (more than 2 gold medals/gold medal in team sport): Table tennis, sailing, athletics, bowling, water polo

    B+ (credible improvement): canoeing

    B (at least one gold medal/medal in team sport): Water skiing, billiards, gymnastics, shooting, badminton, contract bridge, wushu, softball

    C (attained medals/no medals attained in team sport):
    Fencing, pencak silat, rowing, open water swimming, wrestling, karate, judo, boxing, cycling, synchronized swimming, roller sports, sport climbing, taekwondo, basketball, football

    D (no medals attained): Petanque, sepak takraw, weightlifting, archery, golf and traditional boat racing

    He highlighted the achievements of the swimmers, shuttler Fu Mingtian who set a historic gold performance in the women’s singles final, sprinter Gary Yeo and thrower Wong Lay Chi who both achieved personal bests alongside their silver medals in the 100m dash and shot put, respectively.

    He also lauded the results attained by Singapore's contract bridge players, who clinched one gold and two silver medals from hosts Indonesia, who being world-class bridge powerhouses were expected to sweep the golds on offer.

    Conversely, Tan brought up sports that underperformed such as shooting, fencing and pencak silat. Shooting, in particular, was “a real disappointment” given that the team had brought home six gold, five silver and five bronze medals at the Laos Games, as compared to one gold and one silver at this year’s meet, he added.

    Also present at the press conference were Singapore National Olympic Council president Chris Chan, who praised the performance of athletes who did not win medals, including shuttler Derek Wong, who defeated World number seven Vietnamese player Nguyen Tien Minh but did not make it to the medal rounds, and the men’s basketball team, which in his opinion played valiantly against the Indonesians before getting knocked out by the latter.

    “I, for one, never had such high regard for the men’s basketball team; I thought they played so well,” said Chan.

    He also commended the Young Lions’ performance at the Games football tournament despite being knocked out before the semifinal rounds.

    “This team is much better,” he said. “But they were in the ‘group of death’, and didn’t go for the win against Malaysia.

    “They’re definitely not an ‘F’ for me. This was a good team,” he added.

    Singapore Sports Council (SSC) CEO Lim Teck Yin added that Tan’s review allows the SSC to study each sport’s performance individually.

    “That way, every sport will be challenged to come back stronger,” said Lim. “Yes, a couple underperformed, and their athletes whom I met are very upset, but are determined to go back and examine what happened.”

    How do you feel about this article?

     

    192 comments

    • Kenny  •  6 months ago
      How many of the athletes are professional? If they are professional criticise all you want. But if they are on voluntary basis, then you should shut up. Looks and behaves like a tyrant.
      • Samuel Samuel 6 months ago
        Then tell me for those third world countries, how many full time spot people they have.Touch your heart bro.We are paying handsomely for the medal, do they have?
    • A Yahoo! User  •  6 months ago
      Is this how you inspire Team Singapore? ... do yourself a favour by watching "Invictus" the movie. See how Nelson Mandela inspired South Africa's Springboks rugby team, and healed the great divide between whites and blacks... His humility is so much greater than your comments... search it in youtube!
      • raw egg 6 months ago
        totally agree with you! These ministers need to master the art of motivation! That statement alone pisses me off.
      • tigerella 6 months ago
        Simple, just ask him to do it himself. Only know know to talk cock sing song.
    • 小 Lee 飛刀  •  6 months ago
      During early 1990s, Singapore could easily beat Vietnam by two or three goals. At present we got to struggle against them. Unlike Vietnam and Indonesia, soccer has become a dispensible exercise among our children, they rather playing E-games soccer in house than playing real one at the field. The standard of soccer will be thow behind further as the new generation not pay attention on playing it on the field.
      • Aftermath 6 months ago
        After spending so much money, our standard dropped?
        Where has all the money gone?
      • steve 6 months ago
        @小 Lee 飛刀

        I agree with you about children rather play football on computer games. I am from the UK and before I came to Singapore I worked in a secondary school and coached 2 of the football teams for U11's and U12's. During the trials to select both teams i was shocked by the poor standard, quite a number of the kids were trying all these fancy flicks and tricks with the ball, or attempting 50 yard passes instead of a simple short pass. At the end I asked them why they are trying to do all the fancy flicks n long passes and they said beacuse they can do it on the xbox or playstation. And that's were the probem lies, they spend too much time playing E Games.
        I grew up in the 70's & 80's in a football mad city, if you were a boy, as soon as you could walk you had a ball at your feet, 90% of the time you would walk to school kicking a ball, before going into class you would be playing football, break time play football, lunchtime playing football, get home forget about homework and go and play football on the nearest field. Normally there would only be about 4 or 5 of us, so we would play "3 and you're in", that is hv one person in goal and the remainder play against each other, the first to score 3 then goes in goal, we would play "volleys and headers", that is you had to alternate between scoring with a volley and a header, we would play one touch, one bounce, and all of this improved our game. At school if we never had a football we would use a tennis ball, an empty can or even a stone. At about 9 yrs of age you would start playing football for the school team and also play for a sunday league side.

        However, over the years especially with the introduction of playstation and Xbox etc, kids don't seem to be as passionate as my generation and those before. Young kids will be given some kind of electronic toy when they can walk, kids will walk to school either playing on a PSP or mobile phone, after school they will be bogged down by homework or will be on social media sites etc. When I was a kid, parents had to come and fetch you to bring you home, nowadays it seems parents try to do all they can to get the kids out of the house.

        I would take a guess that it is similar in Singapore.
      • noitulive 6 months ago
        Lets just put it this way folks. Which of the following activities can allow you some form of appreciation of the sport whilst achieving a common Singaporean's goals (career, capital, etc)?

        a. Play Xbox on and off whilst studying to work in a certain career path?

        b. Take up soccer as a real career path???

        Its not about the generation... indirectly, our better comforts in life have led us here today. I'm not saying its wrong to criticize... but its very simple. We have no challenges in Singapore... everything is pretty much provided. There aren't a lot of reasons for us to fight for survival. Heck, there aren't a lot of folks with the same appreciation of things as you do, heck even if you do find groups of people with the same appreciation, everyone's got a varying degree of commitment. ('cept for CARS, HOUSES, INVESTMENT, the common Singaporean stuff)

        And honestly, you might not succeed working towards a certain career, but hell, at least you get a normal job that pays you appropriately.

        I think we are ultimately unhappy about the progress in certain areas. But consider this... this country and its ready to purchase creature comforts were created by our own direct and indirect demands... Basically, we've got a shitty football team cause we want iPhone4 :D
    • Be fair  •  6 months ago
      I read somewhere that one cancer patient delayed chemo treatment to play for Singapore in the recent SEA. Here is a very patriotic Singaporean who put country and her team before her life just to participate in the game. In the end, we have the CDM Tan to comment that all Singapore results are just mediocre and performing 'at best satisfactory'. Are you not sad and angry to here remarks like this from someone who is entrusted by Singapore to take charge. I have yet to hear some good remarks from the CDM on the act of this patriotic Singaporean, but instead, some discouraging comments on the Singapore particpation. how disppointing!
    • scally  •  6 months ago
      Since when has playing cards been a sport - contract bridge? I read the other day about small nations that have produced great champions, olympic and world, that are smaller than us. You see athletes from poor African countries that continually win major titles, where are we going wrong? Take Jamaica, nearly the same size population as Singapore, I mean born and bred Singaporeans, not including the FT/FW, yet they have produced world record holders and champions consistently in athletics and sent a football team to the World Cup. They have also produced a world boxing champion. What are they doing right that we are doing wrong? It seems the mentality of people in charge is for us to only do well in regional competitions and compete against other Asian countries. Take last year we chose to send a small team to the Commonwealth Games so the majority of our athletes would be fresh for the ASEAN Games. But if we did send a strong team to the Commonwealth Games we would have been competing against Australia, the UK teams, the strong Caribbean and African athletes and got an insight into whats required to compete at the top level. But no we chose to stay in our comfort zone and compete against lesser competion, not including the dominant China team. We will never produce any worthy champions with the mentality that exists in the powers that be.
      • raw egg 6 months ago
        hahaha, yes i laughed when i heard that the bridge game was part of the SEA Games. No idea how that got in there,... what's sports about it?

        Agree with the rest of your comments. Maybe we didn't want to 'lose face' in the Commonwealth Games?
      • Localknight 6 months ago
        Playing cards is also sports? Maybe in the next Sea Games, Monopoly & Carrom will be included!
      • PAP 6 months ago
        It is high time CDM retired.
    • A Poster  •  6 months ago
      Sports is no longer about coming together for some fun and promoting physical fitness.

      Nowadays it's only about individual and national prestige.
    • .  •  6 months ago
      "As Chef de Mission, have we done well? My answer is, I’m sorry to say, it is at best satisfactory,”

      Wow, really encouraging words to our young sportsmen and women.. You do not deserve to be the Chef de Mission. Go be a chef in the nearest restaurant.

      A fine example of these pen pushing bureaucrats who only look at the results and not consider the feelings and dedication of the team.

      Shame on you, Tan Eng Liang.
    • Kit  •  6 months ago
      It's a shame that we have appointed Chef de Mission Tan for this event, apparently his only mission there is to ensure we get Gold Gold and more Gold....perhaps he should just plainly tell us we need to "buy in" more sure win FT instead of wasting our times sending locals who at best can only get a Silver or Bronze.....his comments and so call "report card" is a disgrace to himself as a CdM...or perhaps somebody should explain what CdM means....by the way, how much taxpayers are paying this CdM huh???? National Disgrace...he should be the first one to be sacked....wasting our money...poor guys try so hard (sorry, I'm only referring to the local breed) and just deserved a blunt execution from their Chief....THANKS!
    • Veera  •  6 months ago
      i feel satisfied that all singapore born participanst contiributed except for FT contibution not in my cards to applaud them, they are after all mercenaries of wealth,
      • KH 6 months ago
        I don't like the scheme either, but the FTs were brought over by the government to represent us. They are wearing the Singapore jerseys and fighting for our country, so let's please support them while they are doing so.
    • William  •  6 months ago
      Singapore used to have and still having this problem of renewalship.
      Take swimming for example, for the past few years, we always have Tao Li.
      Can we start to grow more talents instead of buying more?

      In Singapore, we should consider ourselves having a very good environment for sports.
      Its so different to Vietnam, Thailand, Phillipines or even Indonesia.
      We have good accomodation, good nutrition food, no worry for natural disaters, but our sportsman are just....like that.
      After years in track and field, we cannot break thru the barrier. This sport is the only sport that enable us to win many gold medals
      There are many events, single, team and both man and woman category.
      I suggest we should train our young up on this.
    • AH BENG  •  6 months ago
      TAN ENG LIANG LISTEN HERE, EVEN IF SINGAPORE WIN ALL THE MEDALS.
      CAN SPORTS MAKE A LIVING IN SINGAPORE.
      THE ANSWER IS NO, PLEASE WAKE UP.
    • curio6  •  6 months ago
      I agree with him whole-heartedly...look at Tao Li's timing - for a person who is supposed to be our hope for the Olympic and the amount of money spent on her, her performance is actually disappointing.
    • Seng  •  6 months ago
      so how much does taxpayer like us pay to buy those medals?

      how much did we pay and pay?
    • A Yahoo! User  •  6 months ago
      Very discouraging remarks from the CDM and the way the appraisal was put across + his judging by number of gold medals. "At best, satisfactory" is too harsh for all who have trained and tried their best.

      If we are to cultivate love of sports and local talents, we need to be more encouraging and nurturing! We should give moral support to our local athletes whether they are medalists or not. Some are facing world-ranking opponents and we cannot expect to win all, can we?
    • clement chua  •  6 months ago
      i find this is as redundant feedback. it does not boost anyone's morale, and merely puts our athletes down.

      firsly, winning is not everything. talking about medals should be only done before the event happened. whatever should have happen would have happened and there's no changing that. the athletes would have known where they have went wrong. its about the commitment and hardwork put into the event that shines through sports. that should be the only thing they should be commenting upon after the event and not the number of medals. who cares if you have plenty of medals if you do not commit and do well, and have the character and discipline to back it up with?

      secondly, i find it redundant to have men in suits to comment on the sportsmen and women. their two cents worth of talk like this wouldnt make them any better in their sport to earn them a medal, or any better an athlete in terms of character.

      this is not economics where the ultimate goal is for growth or profits. in sports, to me it is about the intangible rewards, the national unity it provides and develops among the people that is ever more important than the number of gold medals garnered.
    • Singha Master  •  6 months ago
      Need to improve further. That is what needs to be told. He is just one person and thinks he can grade it overall just b'cox he is Chef de Mission. The team needs to wind down and also celebrate as they have given their best. Boo Boo to Mr Tan.
    • Rock  •  6 months ago
      We have performed worst despite buying foreign talents and staffing with foreigners. Look at Malaysia and Indonesia football, all locals including coach and they did much better! Go local it seems is much better!
    • Simsci  •  6 months ago
      Satisfactory means nothing special to talk about. If the CDM is so critical about the performance of our sports personnel, please ensure only medal winners are send to such or any competitions. Don't send average competitors and expect a medal haul, then "execute" them with discouraging comments when they failed to deliver.
    • Wander  •  6 months ago
      In sport, winning may seem to be everything. However, medals are just comparables...they do not reveal the true spirit and strength of the people. If any nation had wanted it bad enough, they would have imported the athletes and up the stakes. Hopefully, we will not seek this shortcut just to prove a point. As a Singaporean, I'm just happy to see the joy in our people, knowing that they have given their very best, made sacrifices and displayed great courage. All our athletes should proudly wear their medals in their hearts for the love of sport. A country must always have a sporting culture...it shows a rounded, responsible and robust lifestyle, which in turn can spin off many attractive benefits for the economy and culture. Cheers to all who participated. They are all winners. A long journey begins with one small step and if we focus on the right angles; sports, medals, pride, strength and unity will all be in alignment.
    • Apple  •  6 months ago
      among 10 countries, we got 42 gold, yet none of the above 10 countries can get gold in the olympics....

    Featured Blog Posts