Singapore mother sues clinic over IVF mix-up: report

A Singapore mother is suing a clinic for alleged negligence after it mixed up her husband's sperm with that of a stranger during in vitro fertilisation, a report said Wednesday.

The ethnic Chinese woman first suspected that something was amiss when her baby, who was born in 2010, had markedly different skin tone and hair colour from her Caucasian husband, the Straits Times newspaper reported.

Thomson Fertility Centre, a Singapore clinic which carried out the IVF procedure, has admitted the error and said it is up now up to the courts to decide on the level of compensation.

The 36-year-old, who cannot be named because the baby girl is a minor, is suing the centre for unspecified damages on grounds that the mix-up has caused her personal trauma, the report said.

She is also suing the centre's parent company, Thomson Medical Group, and the two embryologists who were involved in her IVF.

According to the report, the woman's husband has refused to acknowledge the baby girl as his daughter in a move that has financial implications for the mother.

Her suspicions about a mix-up were confirmed after her paediatrician informed her that the baby's blood type was B while her and her husband's were groups O and A, a scientific impossibility if they were the two biological parents.

The baby remains in the couple's care but the Straits Times, citing court documents, reported that the two were "utterly devastated" by the incident.

Thomson Fertility Centre said in a statement emailed to AFP that it "acknowledged the unfortunate incident and accepted its responsibilities in the IVF matter".

"TFC will not deny the clinical error was made, but the real issue is what the reasonable quantum of compensation should be," it said.

"We will now leave it in the court's hands to decide what would be a fair outcome for all parties," the clinic added.

Thomson Medical Group was slapped with a Sg$20,000 ($15,786) fine last year for failing to ensure suitable practices were followed during IVF. It placed extra checks on its IVF procedures after the incident.

Loading...
  • Best and worst sugar substitutes Fri, May 17, 2013

    Sugar has earned a bad reputation for being bad for your heart, your brain and your waistline. Because of this, there have been many attempts to market sugar substitutes. Some are useful, but some More »

  • Why go through a preventive double mastectomy? Fri, May 17, 2013

    Hollywood actress Angelina Jolie announced she has had both her breasts removed in February to reduce her high genetic risk of breast cancer. The surgery, called double mastectomy, brought down her More »

  • Top 8 lucrative routes for taxi drivers Fri, May 17, 2013

    For a taxi driver, a key survival skill is knowing where to find customers. As far as possible, a driver should know the routes at his or her fingertips. Hence, in this 6th instalment of Taxi Talks, More »

  • Video of man hitting worker in office goes viral

    Video of man hitting worker in office goes viral

    Video of man hitting worker in office goes viral

    A clip of a man hitting an office worker – who appears to be an employee under his supervision - has gone viral in Singapore, sparking outrage and calls for the authorities to step in.

  • Teo Ho Pin presses WP's Sylvia Lim for answers

    Teo Ho Pin presses WP's Sylvia Lim for answers

    Teo Ho Pin presses WP's Sylvia Lim for answers

    Worker's Party Chairman Sylvia Lim has challenged Dr Teo Ho Pin to make a report to the Corrupt Practices Investigation Bureau (CPIB) if he believes that the WP had mismanaged the Town Council.

  • Some Chinese tourists 'uncivilised': top official

    Some Chinese tourists 'uncivilised': top official

    Some Chinese tourists 'uncivilised': top official

    The dire manners and "uncivilised behaviour" of some Chinese tourists abroad are harming the country's image, said a top official who lamented their poor "quality and breeding", according to state-run media.

Featured Blogs

  • Sugar has earned a bad reputation for being bad for your heart, your brain and your waistline. Because of this, there have been many attempts to market sugar substitutes. Some are useful, but some are even worse than the original … Continue reading →

  • Health Xchange

    Hollywood actress Angelina Jolie announced she has had both her breasts removed in February to reduce her high genetic risk of breast cancer. The surgery, called double mastectomy, brought down her risk from 87 per cent to about 5 per … Continue reading →

  • For a taxi driver, a key survival skill is knowing where to find customers. As far as possible, a driver should know the routes at his or her fingertips. Hence, in this 6th instalment of Taxi Talks, I would like … Continue reading →

  • For three decades he smiled and waved at Singaporeans from his spot on billboards, posters and brochures. He was dedicated to his task of making Singapore a kinder, more courteous place for everyone to live in, regardless of whether he … Continue reading →

  • Top five career moves for Singa the Lion
    Top five career moves for Singa the Lion

    There’s nothing quite like death to make a point. Even when it comes to telling Singaporeans how ungracious they are. Call it clever marketing or whatever, terminating (via resignation that is) “Singa the Lion” has certainly worked for its zookeepers … Continue reading →