YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Netizens on daring ads: why the fuss?

    UPDATED

    Singaporeans need to loosen up and be more open to creative advertisements, said the majority of Yahoo! Singapore readers, who were referring to ads that have been in the spotlight in the past week.

    One is an ad by Strip: Ministry of Waxing, featuring an open fur clutch captioned, "Unfurgiveable". The ad, offering a discounted price for a Brazilian wax, leaves no doubt about which part of the female anatomy it's referring to.

    The other ad that has made headlines recently is an Abercrombie & Fitch (A&F) ad, showing a male model's naked upper body with his hands pushing down his low-slung jeans.

    The Advertising Standards Authority of Singapore said it breached decency guidelines and the Media Development Authority has thrown its weight behind the regulatory watchdog.

    Straits Times reader Anand A Vathiya earlier wrote in to the newspaper's Forum page, where he questioned the "fuss" over fashion retailer A&F's ad.

    "Would ASAS care to assess a truly obscene poster advertising a local firm specializing in beauty and waxing?" he asked in a letter published on Saturday.

    
"The vulgar visual of the poster advertising Strip: Ministry of Waxing is plastered in malls and on lamp posts and as street buntings," he said, citing The Cathay building and Great World City as two places where the ad is displayed.

    Strip, established in Singapore in 2002, is part of a the Spa Esprit  Group founded by entrepreneur Cynthia Chua.

    Yahoo! Singapore's story on Saturday asking which of the two ads was more indecent drew over 200 comments.

    Most readers felt both ads were creative and got the job done in terms of attracting people's attention.

    Taurus said, "If one puts too many restrictions into advertising visuals, where is creativity? What is indecent or not here, is just a matter of perspective. Singapore is a cosmopolitan city, let's not expect the government agencies to be policing all the time."

    Calling for Singaporeans to be more "open-mind(ed)", Daniel Teo noted on Yahoo! Singapore's Facebook page that such ads are common in other countries.

    However, some readers felt otherwise.

    Boy Wonder said, "It may be 2011 but a thought must always be given about children who are sensitive to such images."

    Facebook poster Pauline Sook said advertising should be done with "responsibility and class, balanced with creativity". She added, "Playing on gender sexual objectivism to this extent is insensitive to women."

    How do you feel about this article?

     

    291 comments

    • Marrku San  •  7 months ago
      I wonder why a parents make noise about it. Why not ask their kids, what they looking at? LOL
      I did imagine, the kids might be saying simple things like "the guy never wear shirt." or "my dad also don't wear shirt in the house." LOL
      • Victor 7 months ago
        Hahaha, frankly I don't see anything wrong with either of the images, they are nowhere near obscene. I think its more of the notion of using sex to sell that people are uncomfortable with. But regarding that notion, I must say, people have been doing that for ages, why only kick up a fuss now?
    • Colin  •  7 months ago
      Double standards. Magazines that SPH put on stands are even more suggestive. It all right for kids to see that but this is not?
    • Reaping  •  7 months ago
      Hey we got better things to worried about than this ads, like the 40s to 50s got no job . . . hello you there!
    • jake  •  7 months ago
      Rule 34 - If it exists, there is porn of it. No exceptions.
    • I LOVE SINGAPORE  •  7 months ago
      LOL....cannot Tahan liow....what's happening to Singapore??
      See no evil, Speak no evil & Hear no evil......even it is fur open clutch bag.....hahaha
    • Chieftain  •  7 months ago
      There are worse & more vulgar ads than the one portayed by Acrombie ads. Its still not excusable but if anyone wants to go 'huff & puff' over this ad then stop 1st & looked around & u can see even more lurid & blatantly sexists ads esp. ones concerning women e.g. lingerie, undergarments, Jeans ads & etc. So all this faked outrage is the outcome of the collaborative silence of the majority of the public in tolerating these kinds of ads for years. ASAS ppl hv been sleeping on the job & so has society complicit in giving a nod a wink to these types of 'provocative' Ads. So who is really to blame??
    • Roy  •  7 months ago
      I guess the people from
    • Roy  •  7 months ago
      I guess the people from
    • EurasianGirl27  •  7 months ago
      I like the Abs ad....darn, it gets removed!!!!!:(
    • Chong  •  7 months ago
      Out of sight does not mean out of mind ..
    • hermitmount  •  7 months ago
      The adverts is not steamy enough. The adverts is like many eeries hairy caterpillars crawling all over our body.
    • Mohd  •  7 months ago
      Sometimes there reasons why Singaporean ppl complain..If someone see something which is uncomfortable..they have every reason to voice up..Same goes to parents with kids..if their kids does mistake..the parents have every right to discipline them..Same goes to the ads..Singaporeans has every rights to voice their opinion..
    • Andie  •  7 months ago
      OMG..the wallet ads is..so OMG. haha
    • Santi  •  7 months ago
      all in the name of money... and money is great...
    • Eric Li  •  7 months ago
      Singaporean conservative?? Serious?? I think only you yourself have the answer. Stop complaining for once. Really makes no sense to a country that allows prostitution and gets offended by the content.
    • lpsit1  •  7 months ago
      When in Rome do as the Romans do. Period.

      Sg is 1st an Asian society, then a global city. Do not hide behind the veil of creativity to display subtle vulgarity. And above all, it really has nothing to do with affecting kids, affecting women, or affecting those academia - but a lack of BASIC RESPECT for the Sg community at large by indulging in such designs knowing that they are meant for display (whether innuendoes or real) in public media/area.

      If u design something for your own viewing in your own home - no one would take offence....

      Remember the "bear sighted" video in some place in Sg some time back? That caused some panic yet some creative people escaped unscathed....

      Where's the social responsibility? Where's the conscience? Where's the discretion?

      ALL discarded in the name of creativity and making a living......

      May the force be with us all.....
      • lpsit1 7 months ago
        This will not be an isolated case - more would be coming from creative people trying to test the patience of the authority....at the expense of the Sg community...
      • lpsit1 7 months ago
        The key is discretion, discretion, and discretion......
      • lpsit1 7 months ago
        It seems some didnt see the subtleness of the advert - that's where the authority would come in to put a stop to it..... Some ads are simply distasteful and lack discretion
    • Mervyn  •  7 months ago
      On A&F Ad - if this ad is ban, den Sg should ban swimming trunks and bikinis...
      On the purse - OMG common...those who are saying this ad is dirty are those who are dirty minded. Children mind are still young and pure, I dun think they know it was referring to a pussy. It even take me a while to actually know what it is. These so call conservative people are only trying to hide their dirty mind.
      • ZAFT 7 months ago
        kinda agree with you.. those who try to look clean and decent are those who rots inside.
      • Love IS Truth 7 months ago
        Here here!
      • Dee 7 months ago
        yeah...those who find the Strip ad offensive must be keeping their bush well nourished! ;-)
    • RIZAL  •  7 months ago
      I dont like, I dont want. Kids.
      • X-man 7 months ago
        ejaculating into purses won't give you a descendant..
      • The Master 7 months ago
        @S Spore.
        Lol
    • mutucurry  •  7 months ago
      What is so offensive?
      It is all in the mind.
      Even a piece of bananas can be offensive to the dirty minded.
      • Heartlander 7 months ago
        Indeed imagination is more OBSCENE!!
      • Zorro007 7 months ago
        Talk rubbish. see if you can become a saint in front of a nude woman. The best policy is to avoid. Hard to fight temptations, unless you are a robot!.
      • X-man 7 months ago
        Yep..I can be a saint in front of a 100 yr old lady..
    • teddy  •  7 months ago
      A&F is fine.. Its just a guy's good abs. Yes the hands part spells cheekiness but it doesn't degrade woman!! but the waxing ad is worse.. even more suggestive and indecent!

    Featured Blog Posts