Largest review of abortion in U.S. finds it to be 'safe and effective'

In 2018, “abortion” is often thought of less as a medical procedure and more as a political battleground — one that drives news stories, fuels debates, and sways voters. Whether it’s Donald Trump endorsing the “pro-life” agenda on the National Mall, or Mississippi lawmakers banning abortion after 15 weeks, national conversations often center around the ethics of abortion, and rarely touch on the safety of the procedure.

This month, the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) set out to shift the narrative surrounding abortion, focusing the conversation on the safety of the medical procedure rather than the ethics behind it. In a 186-page joint report, 22 experts explored the existing data on not only the safety of medical abortions, but also the efficacy. Pro-abortion experts see their report as a momentous shifting of the abortion debate, one that makes sound scientific evidence a priority in the conversation. Meanwhile, antiabortion experts tell Yahoo Lifestyle that the study isn’t comprehensive enough to be taken seriously. 

Published by the National Academy of Sciences, the study’s goal was to peel back the layers on abortion data in America and make the information more accessible to the masses. To achieve this, doctors, scientists, and researchers pored through hundreds of randomized control trials, systematic reviews, and epidemiological studies of abortion since it was legalized in the U.S in 1973 through Roe v. Wade. The chief question they sought to answer was a simple one: Are abortions safe? The answer: an unequivocal yes.

Gynecological chair (Photo: Getty Images)

“Legal abortions in the United States — whether by medication, aspiration, [dilation and evacuation], or induction — are safe and effective,” the authors conclude. “Serious complications are rare and occur far less frequently than during childbirth.” On top of finding abortions safe, the authors found evidence that unnecessary delays increase the likelihood of harm.

“Safety and quality are optimized when the abortion is performed as early in pregnancy as possible,” the authors wrote. “Quality requires that care be respectful of individual patient preferences, needs, and values so that patient values guide all clinical decisions.”

To reach these conclusions, researchers used “six dimensions of health care quality” (taken from a 2001 report called Crossing the Quality Chasm: A New Health System for the 21st Century). These six points of reference are safety, effectiveness, patient-centeredness, timeliness, efficiency, and equity. Using this framework, they also studied the physical and mental health risks that are often associated with abortions.

Most of these risks — such as the idea that abortions can cause depression, lead to infertility, and raise a woman’s chance of breast cancer — are circulated by antiabortion activists. The researchers concluded these — and others — are unfounded. “Much of the published research on these topics does not meet scientific standards for rigorous, unbiased research,” the researchers wrote, adding a higher chance of preterm birth, anxiety, and posttraumatic stress disorder to the list of unproven claims. 

Beyond disputing the myths that exist surrounding abortion’s risks, what seemed most troubling to the researchers was that these claims are used to place restrictions on abortion access. “The quality of abortion care depends on where a woman lives. In many states, regulations have created barriers to safe, effective, patient-centered, timely, efficient, and equitable abortion services,” the authors wrote. “The regulations often prohibit qualified providers from providing services, misinform women of the risks of the procedures they are considering, overrule women’s and clinician’s medical decision making, or require medically unnecessary services and delays in care.”

Photo: Getty Images

The regulations they mention aren’t an anomaly — they’re the rule when it comes to abortion access in America. According to the Guttmacher Institute, 401 abortion restrictions have been adopted by states across the U.S. since 2011, 71 in the past year alone. Currently, 29 states are considered hostile or extremely hostile to abortion rights, meaning that 58 percent of U.S.-based women of reproductive age live in a state that hinders their ability to safely terminate their pregnancy.

Dr. Daniel Grossmana clinical and public health researcher on abortion and contraception from the University of California, San Francisco, hopes that will change — and that this study will be the first step. “I thought the study was incredibly rigorous and well done,” Grossman tells Yahoo Lifestyle. “It sought to answer important questions and did a good job of reviewing the literature fully and come up with very solid answers that are based on good evidence.”

Grossman, who is also the director of UCSF’s research group Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health, gained notoriety on the Internet for “schooling” an Arizona representative on Twitter who claimed it was “science” that fetuses could feel pain at 20 weeks. Grossman, who posted a thread that went viral, began it, “This isn’t science.”

Like Grossman tweeting to clarify myths online, he hopes the NASEM study will remind people that abortion is a medical issue first. “Restrictions force women to jump through hoops and make extra unnecessary visits and read information that’s inaccurate,” he says. “This report does a very good job at looking at this issue, which has become now so politicized, through a lens of health care. These debates have big impacts on patients, but the voices of doctors are rarely heard.”

Not everyone agrees that the study was well done, however. Dr. Donna Harrison, executive director of the American Association of Pro-Life Obstetricians and Gynecologists, suggests it’s missing important data. “The study is not a scientific study in that they have neglected to look at 150 studies over the last 50 years which have shown an association between abortion and preterm birth in subsequent pregnancies,” Harrison tells Yahoo Lifestyle, adding that she believes they left out studies on suicide, substance abuse, and major depression as well. 

Harrison also seems acutely concerned with a lack of attention to research showing an increase in breast cancer risk. I disagree with the obvious conclusion here and I think the evidence speaks for itself,” Harrison concludes. “Anyone who takes an honest look at what the research shows will see that abortion hurts women.” Studies prior to this one have discounted these claims.

Grossman begs to differ. “Abortion as currently practiced in the U.S. is very, very safe, and restrictions that limit access negatively impact the quality of care,” he tells Yahoo Lifestyle. “Even beyond that, they’re unnecessary. There is no health benefit that’s demonstrated to come from restrictions. If we treated this service more like health care, it would be a lot of better for everyone—both for women who are accessing it and the providers who are offering it.”

In response to Harrison’s comments, a spokesperson for the National Academy of Science sent the following: “The committee examined the scientific evidence on the safety and quality of abortion care in the U.S. We stand by our report.”

Read more from Yahoo Lifestyle:

Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter for nonstop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day.


  • U.S. regains crown as most competitive economy for first time since 2008 - WEF
    Finance
    Reuters

    U.S. regains crown as most competitive economy for first time since 2008 - WEF

    The U.S. economy sits atop of the World Economic Forum's annual global competitiveness survey for the first time since the 2007-2009 financial crisis, benefiting from a new ranking methodology this year, the Swiss body said on Tuesday. In its closely-watched annual Global Competitiveness Report,

  • Trump says does not want to move away from Saudi Arabia amid Khashoggi case
    News
    Reuters

    Trump says does not want to move away from Saudi Arabia amid Khashoggi case

    U.S. President Donald Trump on Wednesday said he does not want to walk away from Saudi Arabia despite concerns about Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi and said he hopes Saudi's royal leaders were not involved in his disappearance. In an interview with Fox Business Network, Trump, a Republican, pushed

  • Glitzy 'Science Oscars' to make stars of researchers
    News
    AFP News

    Glitzy 'Science Oscars' to make stars of researchers

    Nine scientists were recognized Wednesday with a "Breakthrough Prize," a $3 million Silicon Valley-funded award meant to confer Oscars-style glamour and prestige on the basic sciences. The prizes in physics, life sciences and mathematics went to six men and three women, including four researchers

  • Brazil presidential candidates slug it out on Twitter
    News
    AFP News

    Brazil presidential candidates slug it out on Twitter

    Brazil's two candidates vying for the presidency, far-right Jair Bolsonaro and leftist Fernando Haddad, have taken to Twitter to trade campaign blows in the absence so far of any televised debate ahead of an October 28 run-off election. In the exchange late Tuesday, Haddad tried to taunt Bolsonaro

  • US envoy says Idlib deal 'freezes' Syria conflict
    News
    AFP News

    US envoy says Idlib deal 'freezes' Syria conflict

    A Russian-Turkish deal for a buffer zone around Syria's last rebel stronghold was a "major step" that has "frozen" the country's devastating seven-year war, a US envoy said Wednesday. James Jeffrey, Washington's special representative on Syria, spoke a day after regime

  • French leftist leader under fire for shoving officer during raid
    News
    AFP News

    French leftist leader under fire for shoving officer during raid

    French prosecutors on Wednesday announced they were investigating leftist firebrand Jean-Luc Melenchon after he shoved a prosecutor and an officer in a fit of rage over police raids on his home and party headquarters. The leader of the France Unbowed party has drawn a torrent of criticism over Tuesday

  • Greek foreign minister quits in Macedonia name row
    News
    Reuters

    Greek foreign minister quits in Macedonia name row

    Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras accepted the resignation of his foreign minister on Wednesday, Greece's first major political casualty in a crusade to end a decades-old name dispute with Macedonia. Tsipras has said he will do whatever is required to ensure an agreement reached in June to rename the

  • Israel strikes Gaza after first rocket fire in weeks
    News
    AFP News

    Israel strikes Gaza after first rocket fire in weeks

    Israeli warplanes struck the Gaza Strip on Wednesday after the first rocket fire from the Palestinian territory in weeks hit an Israeli city, in a blow to efforts to avert a new war. Gaza's Islamist rulers Hamas disavowed the rocket fire, saying they rejected "all irresponsible attempts"

  • Ben Sasse Reacts To Trump's 'Horseface' Comment: 'That's Not The Way Men Act'
    News
    HuffPost

    Ben Sasse Reacts To Trump's 'Horseface' Comment: 'That's Not The Way Men Act'

    Sen. Ben Sasse (R-Neb.) said Tuesday that President Donald Trump should not

  • Trump pulling out of treaty that cut rates for foreign postal deliveries to U.S.
    News
    Reuters

    Trump pulling out of treaty that cut rates for foreign postal deliveries to U.S.

    The United States will begin withdrawing from the Universal Postal Union, a United Nations treaty that lowered rates for foreign postal deliveries in the United States, senior White House officials said on Wednesday. The White House said the treaty enables foreign postal services to take advantage of

  • Police Release Video Of Florida City Official Fatally Shooting Suspected Shoplifter
    News
    HuffPost

    Police Release Video Of Florida City Official Fatally Shooting Suspected Shoplifter

    A Florida police department decided to make video footage public showing a

  • Lack of power, phones hampering rescue efforts after Hurricane Michael
    News
    Reuters

    Lack of power, phones hampering rescue efforts after Hurricane Michael

    A lack of power and phone service in the areas of Florida flattened by Hurricane Michael last week was hindering efforts on Wednesday to distribute food and water and to contact residents not heard from since the storm plowed through the state's Panhandle. Florida officials have not said how many

  • Palestinian rocket attack on Israeli city draws Gaza air strikes
    News
    Reuters

    Palestinian rocket attack on Israeli city draws Gaza air strikes

    A rocket fired from the Gaza Strip hit a house in the largest city in southern Israel early on Wednesday, prompting Israeli air strikes that killed a militant in the Palestinian enclave. Egypt, which sent a delegation to Gaza on Tuesday for the latest round of talks on a long-term ceasefire, postponed

  • How To Talk To Your Kids About Porn
    Lifestyle
    HuffPost

    How To Talk To Your Kids About Porn

    The idea of talking to your child about pornography may feel terrifying,

  • Melania Trump's plane lands safely after mechanical issue
    News
    Reuters

    Melania Trump's plane lands safely after mechanical issue

    "Everything is fine and everyone is safe," said the first lady's spokeswoman, Stephanie Grisham. The plane was en route to Philadelphia, where Trump was scheduled to visit Thomas Jefferson University Hospital and meet with families affected by prenatal opioid use as part of her "Be

  • Greek PM urges Macedonia to ratify name deal after losing foreign minister
    News
    AFP News

    Greek PM urges Macedonia to ratify name deal after losing foreign minister

    Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras on Wednesday urged Macedonian lawmakers to ratify the two countries' landmark name deal after a cabinet spat in Athens prompted the shock resignation of his foreign minister. "I want to encourage them to move forward with determination and bravery, because

  • Iranian security staff unconscious when kidnapped to Pakistan: Guards chief
    News
    Reuters

    Iranian security staff unconscious when kidnapped to Pakistan: Guards chief

    A group of Iranian security personnel kidnapped on the border with Pakistan this week were unconscious at the time, the commander of Iran's elite Revolutionary Guards said, following reports that they had eaten drugged food. Iran's Fars News agency also quoted Major General Mohammad Ali Jafari

  • Barack Obama Brutally Shuts Down People's Lame Excuses For Not Voting
    News
    HuffPost

    Barack Obama Brutally Shuts Down People's Lame Excuses For Not Voting

    Barack Obama is done with people's lame excuses for not voting in the upcoming

  • China propaganda chief warns Hong Kong media over 'interference': reports
    News
    AFP News

    China propaganda chief warns Hong Kong media over 'interference': reports

    China's propaganda chief has reportedly warned Hong Kong's senior media executives not to allow the city's newsrooms to "become a base for interfering with mainland politics" as Beijing ramps up pressure on challenges to its authority. Concerns about press freedom in Hong Kong

  • Clashes as Hindu hardliners block women from Indian temple
    News
    AFP News

    Clashes as Hindu hardliners block women from Indian temple

    Clashes erupted on Wednesday as Hindu hardliners prevented women visiting one of India's most sacred temples, with baton-waving police charging stone-throwing protesters. The situation remained tense after nightfall, with police reinforcing the 500 officers already present ahead of likely another

  • Spanish drug lord arrested after music video cameo: police
    News
    AFP News

    Spanish drug lord arrested after music video cameo: police

    One of Spain's most-wanted drug traffickers was arrested on Wednesday after seeming to taunt police by appearing in a music video, a police spokesman told AFP. Francisco Tejon, leader of the "Los Castanas" clan, was "arrested today at La Linea de la Concepcion," a southern city

  • UN Syria envoy to step down next month
    News
    AFP News

    UN Syria envoy to step down next month

    The United Nations envoy for Syria announced on Wednesday he will step down at the end of November after more than four years in the key post, setting back UN efforts to end the seven-year war in Syria. "I will myself be moving on as of the last week of November," Staffan de Mistura told the

  • 279 White Helmets leave Jordan to resettle in West
    News
    AFP News

    279 White Helmets leave Jordan to resettle in West

    Jordan said Wednesday a group of 279 Syrian rescue workers has left the kingdom for resettlement in Western countries three months after they were evacuated from Israel. The kingdom announced on July 22 it had received 422 White Helmet rescuers and their relatives after they were evacuated from Syria

  • Jamal Khashoggi Tortured In Front Of Top Saudi Diplomat: Reports
    News
    HuffPost

    Jamal Khashoggi Tortured In Front Of Top Saudi Diplomat: Reports

    Jamal Khashoggi, the Washington Post columnist who has not been seen publicly

  • Norway apologises to mistreated war-time 'German girls'
    News
    AFP News

    Norway apologises to mistreated war-time 'German girls'

    Norway's government on Wednesday officially apologised to Norwegian women targeted for reprisals by authorities for having intimate relations with German soldiers during the country's war-time occupation. Between 30,000 to 50,000 Norwegians, labelled "German girls", had intimate relations