‘Blame SMRT’s corporate culture, LTA’s lack of regular checks'

(AFP file photo)(AFP file photo)

It is becoming clearer by the day that the way the transport chaos was handled has exposed major cracks in SMRT's company culture and the regulator's inability to act on these loopholes early in the game.

Both are national embarrassments and need immediate attention.

The outpouring of anger by Singaporeans and the swift political reaction that followed the disruptions, with even the Prime Minister returning from leave to announce the formation of a Committee of Inquiry, reflect the awakening that the country is experiencing.

But if the post-chaos focus is mired in technical jargon like collector shoes, steel support brackets and claws, then the lessons will not be learnt.

The scrutiny that follows should also ask these two questions: Why SMRT's management failed to get its act together during and, more importantly, after the two major disruptions? Why was the Land Transport Authority not rigorous enough in detecting the defects in a company culture that go beyond the disruptions on Friday and Saturday?

It was the Shame on Sunday that is more worrying and has long-term implications for Singapore Inc.

The corporation knew that its trains would start running on the North-South Line only after the compulsory checks ordered by the LTA were over by about 10am on Sunday. Yet, it was found wanting in providing an efficient shuttle bus service on that day. The buses were late (unpardonable), some drivers were clueless about how to get to their destinations (again, unpardonable), signages were only in English in some stations (unpardonable, for sure).

The saddest story to emerge from that episode was that of a senior citizen. The Straits Times reported that truck driver Chan Chun Meng, 68, was at the Ang Mo Kio station at 5am to catch the bus to his workplace in Tanjong Pagar, but had to wait one and a half hours to get his transport. He reached his office late and lamented that his daily rated pay of $78 was cut by $10.

It is this inability to realise that you have an emergency on your hands and get it fixed quickly that needs urgent attention by the SMRT board and LTA. This inability seems to have seeped into its corporate culture. Take, for instance, the two security blunders that happened within two years. A concerned organisation would have taken the first breach at its Changi depot very seriously, instituted  a zero-error system and instilled it down the ranks. Obviously, that didn't happen because another similar incident took place, this time at the Bishan depot.

And now, four months later, you have two major rail breakdowns.

Look not just at the top

The populist and sensational thing to do is to call for SMRT's CEO, Saw Phaik Hwa, to resign. I say, look deeper into why these things are happening. The company's operating model needs a re-examination. Is it possible for a company to please two masters at the same: Shareholders and commuters? Saw's stellar track record in opening up a new and major source of revenue from retail outlets in MRT stations is commendable. But did she take her eye off the ball when it came to the other part of  her job, running an efficient and reliable public transport organisation?

The way the events of the past two years have unfolded, the answer must be a yes. Thus, the time has come to look into how the train operator's twin roles can be managed by two different bosses -- one to go to back to the basics of running a public transport company and the other to make money that will pay for the running of the system.

As for the LTA, it had failed to spot the signs, as early as two years ago with the first security breach and more recently with the second failing. That, together with the pressure on the train system brought about by overcrowding and increased frequency of train timings, should have alerted the regulator to insist on thorough and regular checks.

Such health checks were eventually forced on the operator after the event and they unearthed danger signs in three areas: 21 dislodged brackets that keep the third rail in place to provide power to the trains, damaged collector shoes in 13 trains; 34 damaged protective covers in the third rail.

To find so many faults, although not fatal, is like opening a can of worms. Obviously, there was something wrong with the maintenance framework at SMRT which the regulator could have identified if it had carried out its part of the deal.

These failings, together with the mistakes of the past three years -- terrorist Mas Selamat's escape, the floods at Orchard Road and the supply squeeze on HDB housing  -- show a malaise creeping into a country that has matured too fast. A bold examination of the root causes of these incidents is needed quickly to stop further cracks from appearing in a system built up assiduously by the Merdeka Generation.

The PM has his plate full.

P N Balji has more than 35 years experience as a journalist. He is now a media consultant.

  • First-Ever HDB Smart Homes Go On Sale Tomorrow From An Unbelievable $28,000
    First-Ever HDB Smart Homes Go On Sale Tomorrow From An Unbelievable $28,000

    This article originally appeared on Vulcan Post.  Smart homes still have a ring of the futuristic about them, but the future is here: Singapore’s first-ever batch of next-generation homes by the Housing Development Board (HDB) will be up for sale tomorrow (May 27). These 1,400 homes in Punggol Northshore don’t just boast the best of The post First-Ever HDB Smart Homes Go On Sale Tomorrow From An Unbelievable $28,000 appeared first on Vulcan Post.

  • Malaysia welcomes Japan’s bid for HSR project

    TOKYO: Japan’s bid to develop the Malaysia-Singapore High Speed Rail Project (HSR) has been welcomed by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak. In an interview with Japanese-based media, Nikkie Asian Review, Najib said he welcomed the bid by the Japanese government and believed companies can put in a competitive bid. "Japanese shinkansen and rail technology is very competitive," said Najib who is on a 3-day visit to Japan. He added the funding, operation system technology and rolling stock will be key factors in deciding who wins the project. Bidding companies will need to include long-term financing assistance as well as the technology capability to build and operate the project. "It has to be a total package," said Najib On May 5, Najib, during his official visit to Singapore said leaders of both countries had agreed to re-assess the initial target of a 2020 deadline to complete the project that will connect both countries, given its complexity and scale. Najib said the development of the project will take five years, while the tender and design processes will take a year each, thus it would push the initial target of 2020 further. Malaysia reckons the project will be a "game-changer" in developing rural towns along the route. With shorter traveling time, it may cut the cost of doing business, especially for Singapore-based companies, by attracting workers from Malaysia. Both countries are finalising a feasibility study on the project, estimated at 40 billion Ringgit (US$11 billion). The development of HSR will also see Malaysia playing a major role in Asean and boost regional integration Najib also welcomed Japanese and foreign companies to invest in Malaysia and is ready to offer incentives to smoothen the investment. Malaysia is ready to custom-made incentives for companies that invest in automation and high-technology projects that create jobs for the locals in designated economic development zones in Malaysia. "I would prefer companies to tell us directly if there is any request they have in mind," he said. Malaysia is also supportive of Japan's pledge to offer RM397 billion ($110 billion) to fund infrastructure projects in Asia over the next five years, as these projects will sustain growth and development of the local economies, he added. On the territorial disputes in the South China Sea, Najib said the bloc will "foster discussions" with China to resolve the issues peacefully. "We hope the countries that have their interest with respect to the South China Sea will not raise tensions do anything that will lead to instability," he added.

  • Najib takes Shinkansen bullet train to Sendai

    TOKYO: Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak today had a first-hand experience of Shinkansen, Japan’s renowned bullet train that travels 320km per hour. Accompanied by his wife Datin Seri Rosmah Mansor, Najib boarded the Hayabusa 15 Shinkansen train at 10.40am (9.40 Malaysian time) to travel to Sendai city, about 325km from here. The journey took 96 minutes, compared to more than four hours by road. Also present were Transport Minister Datuk Seri Liow Tiong Lai, Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Datuk Seri Idris Jala, Chief Secretary to the Government Tan Sri Ali Hamsa and Ambassador to Japan Datuk Ahmad Izlan Idris. Earlier, Najib and the Malaysian delegation were briefed on the Shinkansen rail service and development around the Tokyo Station by East Japan Railway Company officials, led by its Chief Executive Officer, Tetsuro Tomita. Tetsuro told the Premier that the train he would be travelling to Sendai is using the latest technology. “This is the latest train with the latest technology, it runs 320km per hour. This is the operating speed and safe speed,” he said. Yesterday, Japanese Premier Shinzo Abe said the country wanted to see the Shinkansen technology used in the planned high speed rail project between Kuala Lumpur and Singapore. “I hope to see Shinkansen running on Malaysian land,” he told a joint-press conference with Najib after their bilateral meeting at the Prime Minister’s Office. In his response, Najib said he believed that Japan would submit a highly-competitive bid when the time came. Introduced in 1964, the Shinkansen line now spans 2,400 kilometres and runs across Japan. Early this month, Najib and his Singapore counterpart Lee Hsien Loong reaffirmed that both countries were fully committed to the success of the high speed rail that is expected to reduce the travel time between Kuala Lumpur and Singapore to just 90 minutes compared to more than three hours by road now. Besides Japan, several other countries like China, France, South Korea and Germany have shown interest to participate in the project. It was reported here that Japan was also lobbying at introducing the Shinkansen in the high speed rail project between Bangkok and Chiang Mai in Thailand, and Jakarta and Bandung in Indonesia. – BERNAMA AR MIS 26/05/2015 10-48ST

Featured Blog Posts