A viral blog that attacked Australia’s failure to stop the months-long bush fires and implied Chinese firefighters were braver and more patriotic has stirred a vigorous online debate.
The WeChat post contrasted the situation in Australia with China’s largest-ever wildfire, which lasted just under a month in 1987, and quickly racked up more than 23 million views after it was published.
The piece attracted more than 100,000 likes and multiple patriotic comments praising the country’s firefighters, but was criticised by high-profile media commentators for insensitivity and using nationalism to generate cheap viral clicks.
Friday’s article, titled “If it weren’t for the Australian bush fires, I would’ve never known that China was so powerful 33 years ago”, also suggested that Australian firefighters were lazy and unpatriotic for taking rest days, and claimed that “human rights and democracy” were responsible for the continuing fires.
“That’s right, Australia has the world’s best firefighting technology. But putting out fires depends not only on technology, but also on how much you love the people who live on this land,” wrote Yong Bo on the little-known WeChat blog Youth Courtyard.
“In Australia, everyone thinks that these bush fires have nothing to do with themselves.
“Because of so-called ‘human rights and democracy’, the Australian government and firefighters are taking holidays and celebrating Christmas while their country burns to a crisp and the fires kill everything in their path.”
The blogger also criticised the New Year’s Eve fireworks display in Sydney and Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison’s Christmas holiday to Hawaii while the devastating bush fires raged on.
Thousands of Australians have protested against what they see as the government’s inadequate response to the country’s worst ever fires, which have so far killed 27 people, an estimated one billion animals and destroyed more than 10 million hectares of land in the past four months.
In contrast, Yong praised how Chinese firefighters handled the 1987 Daxinganling wildfire in the northeastern province of Heilongjiang, which lasted just under a month.
At the time, the Chinese government sent nearly 60,000 under-equipped firefighters to tackle the blaze, which is commemorated as a national tragedy that killed 211 people and displaced more than 50,000 victims.
A groundbreaking China Youth Daily investigation that same year concluded that the fire was “principally a man-made disaster”, while top officials in Beijing blamed it on the failure of government bureaucracy.
But systemic failings in China’s firefighting services, such as a nationwide lack of full-time career firefighters and dozens of firefighter deaths each year, continue.
In April last year 30 mostly young and inexperienced first responders died while tackling a remote forest fire in Sichuan in April last year.
Multiple comments on the Youth Courtyard blog post praising Chinese firefighters’ heroism attracted more than 100,000 likes by Monday.
However, high-profile media commentators criticised the article as an attempt to stir up patriotism for cheap viral hits, as well as for its insensitivity to two countries’ natural disasters.
Fang Kecheng, a communications professor at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, wrote a WeChat blog post on Sunday that complained: “The article, which has not an ounce of respect for history, simplified the painful lessons of the Daxing wildfire into a heroic narrative about the firefighters’ great sacrifice, and turned a huge natural disaster that prompted nationwide reflection into evidence of ‘how great China was 33 years ago’.”
Fang also pointed out that the outlet that published the article had previously been censored by WeChat last May for publishing an inaccurate report.
Similar “self-media” WeChat blogs have been criticised for their clickbait content and rampant misinformation.
“I never could’ve imagined that 33 years later, this national tragedy would be dug out by a millennial ‘self-media’ writer who wrote some thousand-word thinkpiece claiming that this is some great victory for China,” wrote another Weibo blogger with nearly a million followers.
One Weibo user quoted Yang Lang, the editor responsible for the China Youth Daily investigation, who said at the time: “Everyone very clearly recognises that a calamity is a calamity. To turn a it into a song of triumph is to further heap calamity upon calamity.”
Sign up now for our 50% early bird offer from SCMP Research: China AI Report. The all new SCMP China AI Report gives you exclusive first-hand insights and analysis into the latest industry developments, and actionable and objective intelligence about China AI that you should be equipped with.
More from South China Morning Post:
- Australian fires have devastated koala population. Could they be introduced in New Zealand to prevent extinction?
- Australia’s Scott Morrison regrets handling of bush fire crisis, proposes high-level inquiry
- Australia bush fires: Scott Hend is a man on a mission at Hong Kong Open as each birdie and eagle helps stricken animals; Club vows to match each dollar
- Australian Open: bush fire smoke delays unlikely, say confident organisers
- Australia’s bush fires are unprecedented – what’s the link to climate change?
This article Chinese blogger fans flames of controversy by blaming ‘lazy and unpatriotic’ Australians for bush fires first appeared on South China Morning Post