Court rules Apple must pay California workers during bag checks

California's Supreme Court called out Apple for hypocrisy in its characterization of the iPhone as unnecessary for its own employees

The California Supreme Court ruled on Thursday that Apple must pay employees for time spent waiting for their bags and personal electronic devices to be searched when they leave work.

The decision means that the tech giant will have to pay millions of dollars to more than 12,000 hourly workers at California retail stores who fall under the mandatory bag-search policy.

According to court documents, Apple employees are required to clock out before submitting to an exit search which can take from five to 20 minutes.

On the busiest days, employees say the wait time can be as long as 45 minutes. Those who refuse to have their belongings searched are subject to discipline, including termination.

A lower court had previously sided with Apple, ruling that time spent by employees waiting for the exit searches cannot be considered "hours worked" under California law.

The plaintiffs escalated the case to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals which asked the Supreme Court to address the state law issue.

The state's high court in its decision issued on Thursday rejected Apple's argument that its employees could easily avoid a search by choosing not to bring a bag or iPhone to work.

Quoting from a US Supreme Court decision, it noted that cell phones are "now such a pervasive and insistent part of daily life that the proverbial visitor from Mars might conclude they were an important feature of human anatomy."

"The irony and inconsistency of Apple's argument must be noted," the court added.

"Its characterization of the iPhone as unnecessary for its own employees is directly at odds with its description of the iPhone as an 'integrated and integral' part of the lives of everyone else."

Apple representatives could not immediately be reached for comment on the ruling.

The Apple case is the third the state high court has considered in recent years as related to minimum wage and time during which workers are under employers' control.

In 2018, the court ruled that Starbucks has to pay for off-the-clock work -- such as going through the checklist for closing the store -- that can last a few seconds or minutes past someone's shift.

  • WHO tells world to brace for 'potential pandemic' as virus spreads
    News
    AFP News

    WHO tells world to brace for 'potential pandemic' as virus spreads

    The World Health Organization warned countries on Monday to be ready for a "potential pandemic" as new deaths and infections in Europe, the Middle East and Asia triggered more drastic efforts to contain the new coronavirus. The number of fatalities in China -- where the virus emerged late

  • Lesotho PM in court over murder of estranged wife
    News
    AFP News

    Lesotho PM in court over murder of estranged wife

    Lesotho Prime Minister Thomas Thabane appeared in court on Monday over the murder of his estranged wife, after failing to turn up for a hearing last week. The latest twist in a saga that has gripped the southern African kingdom came after a weekend in which the 80-year-old premier was said to be receiving

  • Iran denies virus coverup after claim of 50 deaths
    News
    AFP News

    Iran denies virus coverup after claim of 50 deaths

    Iran's government vowed Monday to be transparent after being accused of covering up the deadliest coronavirus outbreak outside China, dismissing a lawmaker's claim the toll could be as high as 50. The authorities in Iran have come under mounting public pressure since it took days for them to

  • 'Several injured' as car rams Germany carnival procession
    News
    AFP News

    'Several injured' as car rams Germany carnival procession

    Several people were injured Monday when a car drove into a carnival procession in central Germany, police said, adding that the driver had been arrested. Pictures from the scene showed police officers and rescue vehicles next to a silver Mercedes hatchback with its doors open, having apparently come

  • Turmoil in Malaysia as PM Mahathir resigns
    News
    AFP News

    Turmoil in Malaysia as PM Mahathir resigns

    Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad resigned Monday in a shock move as his alliance that came to power less than two years ago unravelled, but he was reappointed as interim leader by the king. It came after months of rising tensions in his "Pact of Hope" coalition, which toppled a corruption-mired

  • WHO warns coronavirus may be 'around for months'
    News
    AFP News

    WHO warns coronavirus may be 'around for months'

    The World Health Organization warned Monday that the new coronavirus might be around for months but said the measures China implemented have prevented the infections of hundreds of thousands of people. Bruce Aylward, leader of a joint WHO-China mission of experts, said the world can learn from the nation

  • NASA Mathematician Katherine Johnson Dies At Age 101
    huffpost
    HuffPost

    NASA Mathematician Katherine Johnson Dies At Age 101

    Her calculations helped the first American orbit the Earth and inspired the movie “Hidden Figures."

  • Car drives into German carnival parade, ten injured - police
    News
    Reuters

    Car drives into German carnival parade, ten injured - police

    Ten people were injured on Monday after a car ploughed into a carnival parade in the western German town of Volkmarsen, police said, adding that the driver had been arrested. German news website HNA cited witnesses as saying the driver appeared to have deliberately targeted children and had driven &

  • Praise, cheering crowds for Trump in India love fest
    News
    AFP News

    Praise, cheering crowds for Trump in India love fest

    Emerging in a stadium to the appropriate strains of the Village People's "Macho Man" as 100,000 people cheered on, US President Donald Trump looked like he was at a campaign rally in America's Midwest. Five months after being feted by 50,000 people at a mass rally in Houston, Trump

  • Bus passengers from Italy blocked in France in coronavirus scare
    News
    AFP News

    Bus passengers from Italy blocked in France in coronavirus scare

    A bus that arrived in the French city of Lyon from Milan in Italy was sealed off for several hours Monday after the driver showed symptoms of possible coronavirus infection, security sources said. Health authorities isolated the bus in Lyon Perrache station early Monday and ordered the passengers to

  • Stocks, oil prices tumble as gold soars on pandemic fears
    News
    AFP News

    Stocks, oil prices tumble as gold soars on pandemic fears

    World stock markets and oil prices tumbled Monday on growing fears of a coronavirus pandemic, with Milan and Seoul off the most as new cases spiked, while gold hit a seven-year peak on safe-haven buying, dealers said. In afternoon trading, Milan's stock market was more than five percent lower following

  • EU condemns anti-Semitic Belgian parade
    News
    AFP News

    EU condemns anti-Semitic Belgian parade

    The European Commission on Monday slammed a Belgian street parade for featuring anti-Semitic floats that it said were "incompatible" with EU values. The Aalst carnival, a centuries-old event in central Belgium long known for mocking public figures, has in recent years been accused of parading

  • U.S. Supreme Court rejects Apple appeal in patent fight with VirnetX
    Finance
    Reuters

    U.S. Supreme Court rejects Apple appeal in patent fight with VirnetX

    The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear Apple Inc's bid to avoid paying about $440 million in damages for using patent licensing firm VirnetX Inc's internet security technology without permission in features such as FaceTime video calling. The justices rejected Apple's appeal in

  • U.S. Supreme Court to hear religious fight over same-sex foster care
    News

    U.S. Supreme Court to hear religious fight over same-sex foster care

    The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday agreed to hear a major religious rights dispute involving the city of Philadelphia's refusal to place children for foster care with a Catholic agency that bars same-sex couples from serving as foster parents. The justices will take up an appeal by Catholic Social

  • Samos villagers up in arms over new refugee camp plan
    News
    AFP News

    Samos villagers up in arms over new refugee camp plan

    For many of those who live on the Greek Aegean island of Samos it is absolutely clear -- they want no more refugees, no new camps and to be left alone as they were before the migrant crisis broke in 2015. "We, the people who live here, we oppose this idea of a camp," says an angry Nikos Ftinogiannis

  • China shutdowns to impact economy: White House economist
    News
    AFP News

    China shutdowns to impact economy: White House economist

    The disruption caused by the virus outbreak in China will have an effect on the US economy, but the magnitude of the hit remains uncertain, a White House economist said Monday. With the death toll worldwide reaching 2,600, the official cautioned that other illnesses such as influenza are responsible

  • Merkel's crisis-hit CDU launches leadership race
    News
    AFP News

    Merkel's crisis-hit CDU launches leadership race

    Germany's centre-right CDU said Monday it would choose a new leader at a special congress on April 25, as the crisis-racked party hopes to halt a slide in the polls and end speculation about who could succeed veteran Chancellor Angela Merkel. Merkel's Christian Democratic Union has been in turmoil

  • Policeman killed in Delhi clash ahead of Trump arrival
    News
    AFP News

    Policeman killed in Delhi clash ahead of Trump arrival

    A policeman was killed in New Delhi Monday in violent clashes over a contentious citizenship law, hours before US President Donald Trump was due in the Indian capital as part of a two-day visit. Protests have broken out across India since the law that critics say discriminates against Muslims came into

  • Automobili Pininfarina celebrates 90 years with launch of all-electric, hand-crafted GT
    News
    AFP Relax

    Automobili Pininfarina celebrates 90 years with launch of all-electric, hand-crafted GT

    In honor of the brand's 90th anniversary, Automobili Pininfarina will debut the Battista Anniversario at this year's Geneva Motor Show, an all-electric GT of which only five units will be made. Automobili Pininfarina announced on Monday that the world premiere of the Battista Anniversario all-electric

  • New study finds high intake of fruit, veg, and fiber-rich foods can reduce the risk of ischemic stroke
    News
    AFP Relax

    New study finds high intake of fruit, veg, and fiber-rich foods can reduce the risk of ischemic stroke

    New large-scale European research has found that different foods are linked to a higher or lower risk of different types of stroke. Led by researchers at the University of Oxford, UK, along with researchers from across Europe, the new study looked at data gathered from 418,329 men and women from nine

  • Intel unveils new data center processor, 5G chip
    News
    Reuters

    Intel unveils new data center processor, 5G chip

    Demand from cloud computing companies have boosted sales of server chips, leading to strong results from Intel and its rival AMD Corp. Intel's Xeon chips have dominated the market for server chips, but AMD has been gaining ground since its re-entry into the business three years ago with rival EPYC

  • Canadian police move in to clear indigenous blockade of Ontario rail line
    News
    Reuters

    Canadian police move in to clear indigenous blockade of Ontario rail line

    Police moved in on Monday morning to clear a rail blockade by an indigenous group in eastern Canada that had been stopping freight and passenger traffic for more than two weeks on one of the country's busiest lines. Canadian National Railway Co obtained an injunction against those preventing rail

  • Italy's coronavirus 'red zone' gets used to life under quarantine
    News

    Italy's coronavirus 'red zone' gets used to life under quarantine

    At the edge of the northern Italian town of Casalpusterlungo, residents are slowly getting used to the isolation measures descending around towns like theirs, the centres of Italy's outbreak of the new coronavirus. Here the frontline of the fight against the virus is an unassuming roundabout in

  • French court delays fraud trial for ex-premier Fillon
    News
    AFP News

    French court delays fraud trial for ex-premier Fillon

    French former prime minister Francois Fillon and his wife Penelope appeared in court on Monday over claims they embezzled over one million euros in an alleged fake-jobs fraud. Investigators suspect that Fillon, 65, hired his Welsh-born wife Penelope as his parliamentary assistant between 1998 and 2013

  • Huawei launches Mate XS foldable smartphone with better screen
    News
    Reuters

    Huawei launches Mate XS foldable smartphone with better screen

    The Mate XS has the same size display as its predecessor but comes with an improved gull-wing hinge mechanism and stronger wraparound screen, while boasting faster download speeds and longer battery life than the rival Samsung Galaxy Fold, Huawei's top salesman Richard Yu told a launch presentation