Hong Kong is eighth safest city in world overall, but ranks badly when it comes to personal and environmental security

·3-min read

Hong Kong is the eighth safest city in the world but does badly when it comes to personal and environmental security, according to a new set of rankings released by The Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU).

The Safe Cities Index, which grades the world’s metropolitan areas on a variety of factors, placed Hong Kong 20th in its previous rankings in 2019, which were compiled before the anti-government protests that year.

In its fourth set of rankings based on urban safety, the EIU put Copenhagen top of the list, ahead of Toronto and Singapore. Beijing, which was 31st two years ago, slipped to 36th, while Taipei was 24th.

Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answers with SCMP Knowledge, our new platform of curated content with explainers, FAQs, analyses and infographics brought to you by our award-winning team.

For the first time, 60 cities across five continents were assessed for environmental security, alongside the usual categories of digital security, infrastructure, health and personal security.

A general view of Nyhavn, the old harbour in Copenhagen. Photo: Getty Images
A general view of Nyhavn, the old harbour in Copenhagen. Photo: Getty Images

According to the report, which was released last week, the coronavirus pandemic has changed the whole concept of urban safety.

“Agencies responsible for personal security need to address a large, lockdown-driven shift in crime patterns; and the priority that urban residents and officials assign to environmental security has risen markedly as Covid-19 serves as a stark warning of unexpected crises,” it said.

The elevation of Copenhagen from eighth to first did not represent “a tectonic shift”, the report said, but was more a “reordering among cities that have always come close to the top”.

In the past, the top three spots have been held, in the same order each year, by Tokyo, Singapore and Osaka. This time around, Sydney was ranked fourth, with Tokyo rounding out the top five.

Hong Kong set the benchmark for infrastructure and ranked third in health security, but dropped significantly in personal security to 21st from the third spot in 2019. It ranked 21st in digital security and 27th in environmental security.

Safe cities: Seoul is 8th, Singapore is 2nd, and protest-hit Hong Kong?

The report said the experience of Covid-19 showed the need for a more holistic approach to health security and its closer integration into urban resilience planning.

“It has led us to think about the kind of cities we want to live in, a reconsideration that, in turn, has led us to reassess longer term dangers in the way of achieving safe, sustainable, liveable cities as well as opportunities for getting there,” the report said.

Dr Jaideep Gupte, a fellow at the Institute of Development Studies in Britain, warned against the risk of hastily made policy decisions during the pandemic, saying such calls could threaten people’s sense of safety and security.

“Many decisions, taken in the heat of the moment of the pandemic, which bend or burden data privacy relationships or raise broader legal and ethical worries, [risk] getting hard-wired into the longer term status quo,” he wrote in the report.

More from South China Morning Post:

This article Hong Kong is eighth safest city in world overall, but ranks badly when it comes to personal and environmental security first appeared on South China Morning Post

For the latest news from the South China Morning Post download our mobile app. Copyright 2021.

Our goal is to create a safe and engaging place for users to connect over interests and passions. In order to improve our community experience, we are temporarily suspending article commenting