Judge Orders Trump Administration To Turn Over DACA Emails

TheTrump administrationmust turn over all emails and memos used to make its decision to phase outDeferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, the 2012 program created to protectundocumented youthsfrom deportation, a federal judge ruled Tuesday. 

If the communications between the White House and the departments of Justice and Homeland Security are made public, it could offer a window into the political machinations behind the Trump administration’s abrupt call to torpedo DACA.

The order is part of an ongoing lawsuit brought by several parties in the Northern District of California in an effort to overturn the Trump administration’s decision last month to rescind the program.

The Trump administration left DACA in place for months, even after scrapping rules that conflicted with the president’s immigration priorities in February and aftercanceling an Obama administration program in June that would have shielded the undocumented parents of U.S. citizens from deportation. That program, known by its acronym, DAPA, was never implemented due to a legal challenge led by the state of Texas.

But U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions announced Sept. 5 that the White House would end the DACA program, arguing that a looming legal threat, again led by the state of Texas, would likely result in the courts declaring the program unconstitutional. Immigrant rights groups and many prominent Democrats criticized that logic, noting that the program had hummed along for five years without legal challenge.

Trump’s about-face on DACA was widely viewed as a triumph of immigration hard-liners in his administration, including Sessions, who viewed the program as unconstitutional.

Lawyers representing the administration have already supplied the court with a series of documents explaining their rationale for nixing DACA.

But U.S. District Judge William Alsup noted that lawyers representing the federal government in oral arguments had acknowledged they rescinded DACA with input from the White House. “Despite this, defendants have failed to provide even a single document from any White House officials or staff,” the decision reads.  

The documents supplied by the Trump administration also failed to include any communications with subordinates of Acting Homeland Security Secretary Elaine Duke, who might have helped shape the decision to end DACA. “It strains credulity to suggest that the Acting Secretary of DHS decided to rescind a program covering 800,000 enrollees without consulting one advisor or subordinate within DHS,” the ruling says.

Alsup ordered the Trump administration to also provide similar documents that informed Kelly’s decision to leave the DACA program intact in February, when he canceled the Obama administration’s deportation priorities.

The Trump administration has been ordered to hand the documents over to the court by Oct. 27.

Five lawsuits challenging the Trump administration’s decision to kill DACA filed in the Northern District of California were consolidated into one. That lawsuit includes the one filed by a coalition of states led by California Attorney General Xavier Becerra (D) and another filed by Janet Napolitano, the secretary of homeland security in the Obama administration.

Separate lawsuits challenging the end of DACA were also filed in New York.

The lawsuits typically argue that the White House violated the Administrative Procedure Act when it canceled the program, resulting in a due process violation. 

This article originally appeared on HuffPost.

  • Donald Trump And Ted Cruz Seal Alliance In Texas After 'Little Difficulties'
    News
    HuffPost

    Donald Trump And Ted Cruz Seal Alliance In Texas After 'Little Difficulties'

    President Donald Trump and Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) were all smiles during a

  • NATO to show military muscle in massive Norway exercises
    News
    AFP News

    NATO to show military muscle in massive Norway exercises

    Some 50,000 troops will kick off NATO's biggest military exercises since the Cold War on Thursday in Norway, a massive show of force that has already rankled neighbouring Russia. Trident Juncture 18, which runs until November 7, is aimed at training the Alliance to mobilise quickly to defend an

  • News
    Malay Mail

    Umno gone? Zahid insists party still right there

    KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 23 — Umno president Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi responded to Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s sounding of the death knell for his party yesterday by insisting the Malay nationalist...

  • Refugee offer could strengthen embattled Australian PM's grip on power
    News
    Reuters

    Refugee offer could strengthen embattled Australian PM's grip on power

    Australian opposition lawmakers have offered a deal to resettle 150 refugees from a Pacific detention camp, which if accepted by embattled Prime Minister Scott Morrison could strengthen his tenuous grip on power. Morrison's government is on the verge of losing its majority, after a devastating by-election

  • Relook PKR voter roll, Selangor MB says after clashes over discrepancy
    News
    Malay Mail

    Relook PKR voter roll, Selangor MB says after clashes over discrepancy

    SHAH ALAM, Oct 23 ― Selangor Mentri Besar Amirudin Shari today called for the revision of the existing PKR electoral roll after scuffles within the party last weekend following claims of phantom...

  • Zahid says Indonesia quake was divine retribution for LGBT activities
    News
    Malay Mail

    Zahid says Indonesia quake was divine retribution for LGBT activities

    KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 23 ― Opposition leader Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi expressed concerns about efforts needed to stem lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) activities in the country,...

  • Trump to cut Central America aid as migrant caravan rolls on
    News
    AFP News

    Trump to cut Central America aid as migrant caravan rolls on

    President Donald Trump said Monday the United States will start cutting aid to three Central American countries as a caravan of thousands of mostly Honduran migrants rolled on toward the US border. The United Nations said more than 7,000 people were now heading toward the United States, as more migrants

  • Lawmaker Ted Hui pleads not guilty to three charges over phone-snatching incident in Hong Kong Legislative Council
    News
    South China Morning Post

    Lawmaker Ted Hui pleads not guilty to three charges over phone-snatching incident in Hong Kong Legislative Council

    Hong Kong opposition lawmaker Ted Hui Chi-fung denied on Tuesday all three charges he faced over a phone-snatching incident in the legislature in April. Hui, 36, pleaded not guilty on his first court appearance to charges of common assault, obstructing a public officer in the performance of a public

  • Rise, fall and suspense: bitcoin's wild first decade
    News
    AFP News

    Rise, fall and suspense: bitcoin's wild first decade

    From its birth in an anonymous, academic style paper to one of the world's most volatile and closely watched financial instruments, bitcoin has lived through a tumultuous first 10 years. Here is a look back at some of the trials and tribulations of the world's most popular virtual currency as

  • Hundreds of migrant children held in U.S. tent city for months: filings
    News
    Reuters

    Hundreds of migrant children held in U.S. tent city for months: filings

    More than 500 children have been housed in tents near Tornillo, Texas since August, and 46 have been held there since June, according to a Friday court filing in Los Angeles federal court by civil rights organizations and advocacy groups representing migrant children. The filing opposes a government

  • China's Xi opens Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau bridge
    News
    Reuters

    China's Xi opens Hong Kong-Zhuhai-Macau bridge

    Chinese President Xi Jinping on Tuesday opened a new bridge connecting Hong Kong, Macau and the Chinese city of Zhuhai, one of the world's longest bridges, across the mouth of south China's Pearl River. The bridge is made up of nearly 35-km (22-mile) bridge sections and a 6.7 km (4-mile) tunnel

  • Cryptocurrency bitcoin marks 10 years
    News
    AFP News

    Cryptocurrency bitcoin marks 10 years

    Ten years on, the world's first cryptocurrency is at the forefront of a complex financial system viewed warily by markets and investors. From its first evocation amid a global financial crisis, in a white paper written by Satoshi Nakamoto, an unknown pseudonym, bitcoin conveyed a political vision

  • Japan PM heads to China looking for economic common ground
    News
    AFP News

    Japan PM heads to China looking for economic common ground

    Japan's Prime Minister Shinzo Abe makes a rare trip to China this week hoping improved relations will lead to new economic partnerships, as the two countries come under US pressure on trade. The incident prompted anti-Japanese riots in China, and kicked off a frosty spell that has only gradually

  • Growing concern over Pahang hill land cleared for Musang King durian farms
    News
    Malay Mail

    Growing concern over Pahang hill land cleared for Musang King durian farms

    KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 23 — Residents near Fraser’s Hill in Pahang are said to be upset after spotting land there being cleared and its foliage burnt, to grow Musang King durians, purportedly to...

  • Form special committee on hill slope projects, Gerakan tells Penang
    News
    Malay Mail

    Form special committee on hill slope projects, Gerakan tells Penang

    GEORGE TOWN, Oct 23 ― The Penang state government should set up a special committee to review all developments on hill slopes, Penang Gerakan chairman Oh Tong Keong said. He said the recent fatal...

  • Selangor’s Amirudin urges fellow MBs, CMs to raise minimum age to wed
    News
    Malay Mail

    Selangor’s Amirudin urges fellow MBs, CMs to raise minimum age to wed

    SHAH ALAM, Oct 23 ― Selangor Mentri Besar Amirudin Shari pressed other state government leaders today to follow his administration in adopting Putrajaya’s directive to standardise the minimum...

  • Asian markets resume downward spiral as geopolitical fears set in
    News
    AFP News

    Asian markets resume downward spiral as geopolitical fears set in

    Asian markets mostly fell Tuesday as geopolitical risks pile up, from US tensions with Russia and Saudi Arabia, to trade issues and Italy's budget stand-off with the European Union. Shanghai and Hong Kong saw deep losses, having soared over the previous two trading days after China's top brass

  • Mexico's next president vows security for banks in Santander meeting
    News
    Reuters

    Mexico's next president vows security for banks in Santander meeting

    Mexican President-elect Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador on Monday told the chair of Banco Santander, Spain's biggest bank, that his government will create a safe environment for banks, aimed at encouraging foreign investment. "The domestic banks, the foreign banks, will have security during our

  • Minister: RCI, tribunal on EC ex-officials unnecessary
    News
    Malay Mail

    Minister: RCI, tribunal on EC ex-officials unnecessary

    KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 23 ― Putrajaya does not see the need to convene a royal inquiry of tribunal to explore alleged misdeeds by former officials of the Election Commission before the general election,...

  • Foreign parents fight in vain for custody in Japan
    News
    AFP News

    Foreign parents fight in vain for custody in Japan

    Emmanuel, Stephane, Henrik and James come from very different backgrounds, but they share the same painful experience of battling Japan's legal system -- in vain -- for access to their children after divorce. Once married to Japanese women, they say they were prevented from contact with their children

  • Amazon and Super Micro back Tim Cook and call for Bloomberg to withdraw China chip hack story
    News
    South China Morning Post

    Amazon and Super Micro back Tim Cook and call for Bloomberg to withdraw China chip hack story

    Pressure is rising on Bloomberg over an investigative news report that claimed Chinese spies used microchips to infiltrate several major US tech companies, after executives at two other technology firms named in the report backed Apple’s CEO Tim Cook in calling for a retraction. The executives’ remarks

  • U.S. top court blocks questioning of Ross in census suit
    News
    Reuters

    U.S. top court blocks questioning of Ross in census suit

    The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday blocked a judge's order forcing Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross to give a deposition in a lawsuit by 18 states challenging a planned question in the 2020 census that would ask respondents whether they are U.S. citizens. The justices issued a stay of the Sept. 21 order

  • Queen Of Irony Melania Trump To Host Film Screening For Bullying Prevention Month
    News
    HuffPost

    Queen Of Irony Melania Trump To Host Film Screening For Bullying Prevention Month

    First lady Melania Trump is once again boldly staring irony in the face by

  • Taiwan driver granted bail after 18 killed in train crash
    News
    Reuters

    Taiwan driver granted bail after 18 killed in train crash

    The driver of a train that derailed in Taiwan killing 18 people and injuring 187, was granted bail on Tuesday after being detained in connection with the island's worst rail disaster in decades. The driver, You Zhen-zhong, 48, was granted bail of T$500,000 ($16,167) after he was detained for investigation

  • Explosive Found Near Home Of George Soros
    News
    HuffPost

    Explosive Found Near Home Of George Soros

    Law enforcement officials responded to an incident at the home of liberal