Keir Starmer accuses Boris Johnson of losing control of Covid crisis
Keir Starmer has accused Boris Johnson of “pretending there isn’t a problem” with the test-and-trace system, as he claimed the prime minister had lost control of the coronavirus crisis.
In a clash focused entirely on the government’s response to Covid, the Labour leader posed a series of sometimes detailed queries on the testing system. Johnson generally ignored these, instead accusing Starmer of trying to “create political opportunity” out of the pandemic.
One of the more confusing exchanges during prime minister’s questions came when Starmer quizzed Johnson on his insistence in the Commons on Tuesday that the performance of test and trace had no bearing on the coronavirus rate, contrasting this with Johnson’s previous insistence that the system would be “a real game-changer”.
(September 1, 2020) Boris Johnson
“Not only are we getting the pandemic under control, with deaths down and hospital admissions way, way down, but we will continue to tackle it, with local lockdowns and with our superlative test-and-trace system.”
(September 9, 2020) Boris Johnson
“NHS Test and Trace is doing a heroic job, and today most people get an in-person test result within 24 hours, and the median journey is under 10 miles if someone has to take a journey to get one … [To Keir Starmer] We make the tough calls – all he does is sit on the sidelines and carp.”
(September 9, 2020) Boris Johnson
[On the ‘moonshot’ proposal for mass, near-instant testing:] “We are hopeful this approach will be widespread by the spring and, if everything comes together, it may be possible even for challenging sectors like theatres to have life much closer to normal before Christmas.”
(September 16, 2020) Boris Johnson
“We don’t have enough testing capacity now because, in an ideal world, I would like to test absolutely everybody that wants a test immediately … Yes, there’s a long way to go, and we will work night and day to ensure that we get there.”
(September 17, 2020) Matt Hancock
“Of course there is a challenge in testing … We have sent tests to all schools to make sure that they have tests available. But of course I also recognise the challenges in getting hold of tests … Tests are available, even though it is a challenge to get hold of them.”
“Yesterday the prime minister said the complete opposite. Standing there he said testing and tracing has very little or nothing to do with the spread or transmission of the disease. Both positions cannot be right. Which one is it, prime minister?” Starmer asked.
Johnson’s reply appeared to argue that in saying test and trace had no impact on Covid infections, he was talking only about the “obvious fact of biology and epidemiology” that it is transmitted by human or aerosol contact.
Starmer again asked about the apparent contradiction, prompting the prime minister to accuse him of not listening.
The Labour leader responded: “I listened to the answer that the prime minister gave to the question. That’s why I asked him the question. Because yesterday he said the complete opposite of what he said today.”
Overall, the exchanges followed the recent pattern of prime minister’s questions, with Johnson avoiding direct answers to instead accuse Starmer of seeking to inflame tensions.
The Labour leader castigated Johnson over the lack of available tests, especially for families with school-aged children, and accused him of being in denial: “Pretending there isn’t a problem is part of the problem, prime minister.”
He asked the Johnson if the reason for the difficulty of some people in getting tests was “we haven’t got enough capacity, because nobody could have expected the rise in demand – that’s the Dido Harding defence – or is it, we’ve got all the capacity we need, it’s just that people are being unreasonable in asking for tests? That’s the Matt Hancock defence. So which is it?”
Johnson replied by accusing Starmer of making “unseemly and unjustified” attacks on Harding, the head of NHS test and trace.
While saying he did not “deny the anxiety of those who want tests, which I readily accept”, Johnson called for a “spirit of togetherness”.
Related: Growing numbers of NHS nurses quit within three years, study finds
Starmer angrily rejected this: “The prime minister knows my complaint is not with the NHS, it’s with the government. My wife works for the NHS. My mother worked for the NHS. My sister works for the NHS. So I’m not going to take lectures from the prime minister on supporting the NHS.”
In another exchange, Starmer asked Johnson about the numbers of pupils forced to miss school because they were awaiting a Covid test, with the prime minister replying by talking about the very low risk from the virus faced by children.
Starmer said: “That’s such a poor defence. The point isn’t whether the children have got Covid, it’s that they’ve got Covid symptoms and they’re off school.”
He added: “If the prime minister doesn’t see that he’s really out of touch with families and what they’re going through with schooling, day in and day out, in the last few weeks.
“The reality is that losing control of testing is a major reason why the prime minister is losing control of this virus.”
