Lawyer quits as judge for UM's Moot competition over protest crackdown, VC's racism

Azril Annuar
Lawyer Farez Jinnah has withdrawn as a judge in Universiti Malaya's 2019 Tun Suffian Moot Competition. — Picture by Saw Siow Feng

KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 18 ― A lawyer said he withdrew as a judge in Universiti Malaya's 2019 Tun Suffian Moot Competition to object to the university’s response to a graduate’s protest as well as vice-chancellor Datuk Abdul Rahim Hashim alleged racist remarks.

In a Facebook post, Farez Jinnah said he had accepted the invitation to judge the moot competition before this “debacle” began but must now rescind this.

“I cannot in good conscience participate as a returning judge in view of the recent adverse news of the University’s management and handling of its students in the wake of comments made by the University’s Vice-Chancellor at the recently concluded Malay Congress, which advertised the University as being a co-organiser of that event.

“Without getting into the veracity of the Vice-Chancellor’s statement or the validity of the grievance by the students affected, I am surprised that the University is unable to view this episode as an exercise of fundamental liberties, in this instance, the freedom of expression.

“There is also that the students are not allowed to challenge or question critically, the original source of the grievance that would be the comments of the Vice-Chancellor. It is said that University is a place where bad ideas go to die,” said Farez.

He condemned the university's officials led by Abdul Rahim as elitist for claiming that students must address their grievances at a “proper forum”, saying such a mindset ran counter to the values of an open environment academia.

The lawyer said he viewed Abdul Rahim's remarks at the Malay Congress as exclusionary with to the benefit of one racial interest and predicated on a fiction.

“There is a Federal Constitution, which all Malaysians derive their rights and liberties from.

“There is no such thing as a ‘social contract’, which is a casual but dangerous euphemism designed to propagate ideas contrary to the values and freedoms afforded by the Federal Constitution,” he said.

Furthermore, Farez said the student body has every right to question Abdul Rahim's statements, before saying the latter should have the courage and intellect to defend these easily against a student’s challenge.

He also lambasted the management for behaving like bullies for depriving student activist Wong Yan Ke's graduation scroll.

“To deprive the affected students of the privilege of receiving their graduation scrolls, is not only petty, it reeks of unmitigated overreaction, at best and at worst, bullying.

“That the University’s administrators cannot understand this, is to my mind horrifyingly reflective of the state of our public universities.

“To add insult to injury, there has been no open or vigorous discussions made over the statements of the Vice-Chancellor, which exacerbates the impression that the University is punishing the affected students without context or determination of the Vice-Chancellor’s statement.

“Thus it raises the view, in my opinion, that there is an element of unreasonableness and irrationality,” said Farez who firmly said that he stands in solidarity with the affected students.

Related Articles UM protest grad to get his scroll, degree not withheld No law allows university to withhold, revoke protester’s degree, insists UM Law Society VC’s Malay congress speech defied Malaysian unity, says UM Law Society

  • North Korea says no need to sit down with U.S. for talks
    News
    Reuters

    North Korea says no need to sit down with U.S. for talks

    North Korea does not feel the need to have talks with the United States, which would be nothing more than "a political tool" for Washington, a senior North Korean diplomat said on Saturday, ahead of a U.S. envoy's visit to South Korea. Vice Foreign Minister Choe Son Hui said negotiations would not work out between Washington and Pyongyang and there will be no change in North Korea's policy. "We do not feel any need to sit face to face with the U.S., as it does not consider the DPRK-U.S. dialogue as nothing more than a tool for grappling its political crisis," Choe said in a statement carried by state-run KCNA news agency.

  • Hong Kong officials disappointed at Canada's move to suspend extradition pact
    News
    Reuters

    Hong Kong officials disappointed at Canada's move to suspend extradition pact

    Senior officials in Hong Kong said on Saturday they were "very disappointed" at Canada's decision to suspend its extradition treaty with the Chinese-ruled city and again slammed Washington for "interfering" in its affairs. Beijing imposed a new national security law this week on the former British colony, despite protests from Hong Kong residents and Western nations, setting China's freest city and a major financial hub on a more authoritarian track. "The Canadian government needs to explain to the rule of law, and explain to the world, why it allows fugitives not to bear their legal responsibilities," Hong Kong's security chief, John Lee, told a radio programme on Saturday.

  • Two feared dead, 13 missing as heavy rain lashes western Japan
    News
    AFP News

    Two feared dead, 13 missing as heavy rain lashes western Japan

    At least two people were feared dead and 13 others went missing in western Japan Saturday as record heavy rain triggered massive floods and landslides, forcing authorities to issue evacuation orders for more than 76,000 residents. The nation's weather agency downgraded rain warnings by one notch from the highest emergency level in Kumamoto and Kagoshima on Kyushu island, but Prime Minister Shinzo Abe urged local people to be "on maximum alert". Two people were found "in cardio-respiratory arrest" and another was missing in landslides in Kumamoto, said Naosaka Miyahara, a disaster management official for the prefecture, using a term often used in Japan before a doctor certifies death.

  • Donald Trump Jr's girlfriend coronavirus positive
    Politics
    AFP News

    Donald Trump Jr's girlfriend coronavirus positive

    The girlfriend of President Donald Trump's eldest son has tested positive for coronavirus, US media reported Friday. Kimberly Guilfoyle, a former Fox News television personality who is dating Donald Trump Jr, had traveled to South Dakota to see the US president’s Fourth of July speech and celebration fireworks at Mount Rushmore. In a statement to the newspaper, Sergio Gor, chief of staff to the Trump campaign's finance committee, said: "She's doing well, and will be retested to ensure the diagnosis is correct since she's asymptomatic."

  • As US struggles with virus, Trump heads to Rushmore for fireworks
    News
    AFP News

    As US struggles with virus, Trump heads to Rushmore for fireworks

    President Donald Trump bemoaned protests demanding racial justice as "violent mayhem" Friday, but said little about an alarming resurgence of coronavirus cases as he attended a crowded, fireworks-studded Independence Day celebration beneath majestic Mount Rushmore. Trump, under fire for his response to America's spiraling coronavirus caseload four months before the presidential election, spoke on the eve of the July 4th celebrations before thousands of closely-packed people -- many of whom chanted "Four more years;" few of whom were wearing masks. In the shadow of four notable predecessors -- George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Theodore Roosevelt and Abraham Lincoln, whose likenesses are carved into a granite cliff in South Dakota's Black Hills -- the president called on supporters to defend America's "integrity".

  • Fears for 'Super Saturday' as pubs reopen in England
    News
    AFP News

    Fears for 'Super Saturday' as pubs reopen in England

    Pubs in England reopen on Saturday for the first time since late March, bringing cheer to drinkers and the industry but fears of public disorder and fresh coronavirus cases. - Prime Minister Boris Johnson has called for the public to use common sense.

  • U.S. sends carriers to South China Sea during Chinese drills
    News
    Reuters

    U.S. sends carriers to South China Sea during Chinese drills

    China and the United States have accused each other of stoking tension in the strategic waterway at a time of strained relations over everything from the new coronavirus to trade to Hong Kong. The USS Nimitz and USS Ronald Reagan were carrying out operations and exercises in the South China Sea "to support a free and open Indo-Pacific," the navy said in a statement. It did not say exactly where the exercises were being conducted in the South China Sea, which extends for some 1,500 km (900 miles) and 90% of which is claimed by China despite the protests of its neighbours.

  • Mexico logs 6,740 new coronavirus cases, passes Italy's total
    News
    Reuters

    Mexico logs 6,740 new coronavirus cases, passes Italy's total

    Mexico on Friday reported 6,740 new coronavirus infections, taking the country's total to 245,251 cases, more than Italy and the ninth-highest tally worldwide, according to a Reuters count. Mexico's health ministry also reported 654 more fatalities, bringing the total to 29,843 deaths, just a few behind France which currently has the fifth-highest death toll. Friday's new cases were just one less than the record number reported on Thursday in Mexico.

  • Pubs, restaurants and hairdressers reopen as England's lockdown eases
    Entertainment
    Reuters

    Pubs, restaurants and hairdressers reopen as England's lockdown eases

    England takes its biggest steps yet towards resumption of normal life on Saturday as people are finally allowed to drink in a pub, get a haircut or have a meal in a restaurant for the first time in over three months. Prime Minister Boris Johnson said everybody had to behave responsibly and maintain social distancing to support businesses and not risk a second wave of the coronavirus.

  • Bolivia digs mass graves as cemeteries fill with coronavirus victims
    News
    Reuters

    Bolivia digs mass graves as cemeteries fill with coronavirus victims

    Local authorities are digging mass graves at cemeteries across Bolivia to receive a new wave of victims from COVID-19, unnerving Bolivians as the outbreak rips across the Andean nation. Bolivia has registered 35,500 cases of the virus and 1,200 deaths. Raquel Loaiza, a representative of the region´s funeral homes, said residents dying of natural causes had been buried but those who died of COVID-19 were in limbo.

  • Alleged Jeffrey Epstein accomplice being held at 'well-run' jail - local lawyers
    News
    Reuters

    Alleged Jeffrey Epstein accomplice being held at 'well-run' jail - local lawyers

    A source familiar with Maxwell's case said she is being held at the Merrimack County Jail, a medium-security facility 20 miles from the luxurious home where she was arrested Thursday. Federal prosecutors in Manhattan have accused Maxwell, 58, of luring underage girls so that Epstein could sexually abuse them. Epstein was awaiting trial on federal charges of trafficking minors between 2002 and 2005 when he was found hanged in a New York City jail in August.

  • Canada's Trudeau faces third ethics probe over charity grant program
    News
    Reuters

    Canada's Trudeau faces third ethics probe over charity grant program

    Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is facing his third conflict of interest probe, after Canada's ethics commissioner on Friday launched an inquiry into a government contract awarded to a charity that Trudeau has family ties to. Ethics commissioner Mario Dion's office said it will look into whether in picking WE Charity Canada to administer a C$900 million ($664.5 million) student grant program Trudeau broke rules that prohibit politicians from making, or participating in, decisions that further their personal interests.

  • Colorado police officers fired after photos mocking death of Black man surface
    News
    Reuters

    Colorado police officers fired after photos mocking death of Black man surface

    Three Colorado police officers were fired and a fourth resigned after they shared photographs they took of themselves re-enacting a chokehold officers used to subdue a Black man who later died, authorities said on Friday. Vanessa Wilson, interim chief of police in the Denver suburb of Aurora, called the officers' actions surrounding the death of Elijah McClain, who was unarmed, "reprehensible." The officers who were terminated were named as Jason Rosenblatt, Erica Marrero and Kyle Dittrich.

  • Portugal fumes at exclusion from UK safe travel list
    News
    Reuters

    Portugal fumes at exclusion from UK safe travel list

    Portugal's tourism sector reacted with fury and disbelief at Britain's decision to maintain a quarantine regime for travellers coming from Portugal despite having a higher number of coronavirus cases and deaths. Portugal was left off a list of more than 50 countries that Britain considers safe enough for travel without coronavirus-related restrictions, meaning holidaymakers returning from Portugal would have to quarantine for 14 days. Over a dozen countries have imposed restrictions on travel from Portugal as a doggedly high toll of several hundred new cases per day concentrated on the outskirts of Lisbon in the past month has worried authorities.

  • Five ways Hong Kong has changed under China's security law
    News
    AFP News

    Five ways Hong Kong has changed under China's security law

    Beijing's new national security law for Hong Kong is the most radical shift in how the semi-autonomous city is run since it was handed back to China by Britain in 1997. China's authoritarian leaders say the powers will restore stability after a year of pro-democracy protests and will not stifle freedoms. - Legal firewall toppled - A key pillar of Hong Kong's success has been an independent judiciary, insulated from mainland China's party-controlled courts and their conviction rates of around 99 percent.

  • China plans reforms to organ donation rules
    News
    AFP News

    China plans reforms to organ donation rules

    China is planning changes in its organ donation rules to tackle a shortage of donors and curb illicit harvesting after it stopped taking tissue from executed prisoners five years ago. The draft rules published Wednesday by the National Health Commission allow people to donate the organs of relatives who have died. China has been grappling with a massive dearth of donors after it ended the controversial practice of harvesting organs from executed prisoners in 2015.

  • Polish president accuses German-owned tabloid of election meddling
    News
    Reuters

    Polish president accuses German-owned tabloid of election meddling

    Polish President Andrzej Duda suggested on Friday that Germany was trying to meddle in the presidential election after a German-owned tabloid newspaper reported on a pardon that he granted to a man who had served his sentence in a paedophilia case. Duda, a conservative who faces a neck-and-neck race against a centrist opponent in a presidential runoff election on July 12, was angered by reporting by the Polish tabloid Fakt. "Does Axel Springer, a company of German descent that owns the Fakt newspaper, want to influence the Polish presidential election?" Duda, an ally of the ruling Law and Justice party (PiS), said during a campaign rally in the western town of Boleslawiec.

  • Berlin drops derogatory name for metro station after protests
    News
    Reuters

    Berlin drops derogatory name for metro station after protests

    Berlin's public transport company BVG said it would rename a city centre metro station that has become notorious for bearing a name based on a derogatory word for Black people. The announcement comes amid a worldwide reckoning with buried legacies of racism and colonial crimes underpinning many western societies that was sparked by the death in the United States of George Floyd, a Black man, at the hands of a police officer. Berlin's BVG said that the "Mohrenstrasse" metro station - literally Moor Street, using the medieval term for people from North Africa, would be renamed after another nearby street, the Glinkastrasse, named after 19th century Russian composer Mikhail Ivanovich Glinka.

  • Putin mocks U.S. embassy for flying rainbow flag
    News
    Reuters

    Putin mocks U.S. embassy for flying rainbow flag

    President Vladimir Putin on Friday mocked the U.S. embassy in Moscow for flying a rainbow flag to celebrate LGBT rights, suggesting it reflected the sexual orientation of its staff. Putin said the U.S. embassy's move to raise the LGBT pride flag "revealed something about the people that work there".

  • From gyms to village cricket - England sees more easing ahead
    Lifestyle
    Reuters

    From gyms to village cricket - England sees more easing ahead

    British Prime Minister Boris Johnson said he would set out how sectors of the economy which remain in a coronavirus lockdown - such as indoor gyms, swimming pools and nail bars - would be allowed to reopen. Johnson said his government would also set out how amateur cricket matches - a traditional feature of the English summertime - can start up again. England's Chief Medical Officer, Chris Whitty, provided a glimpse of what the new guidelines would look like."Providing people don't do things that are clearly not sensible, ranging from hugging the bowler if they've just bowled someone for a duck through to spitting on the ball, it should be possible," he said.

  • Mainland China reports three new coronavirus cases
    News
    Reuters

    Mainland China reports three new coronavirus cases

    China on Saturday reported three new coronavirus cases in the mainland for July 3, compared with five cases a day earlier, the health authority said. Two of the new infections were imported cases, the National Health Commission said in a statement, while the capital Beijing reported one new case. China also reported four new asymptomatic patients, the same as a day earlier.

  • COVID-19 close to overwhelming Houston's vast healthcare complex
    Health
    AFP News

    COVID-19 close to overwhelming Houston's vast healthcare complex

    Despite its claim to host the world's largest concentration of hospitals and research labs, the city of Houston is dangerously close to being overwhelmed by the explosion of coronavirus cases sweeping across Texas. Since the Memorial Day weekend in late May and major anti-racism protests in June, "it is an unbelievable trajectory," as if the flood gates had opened, said Faisal Masud, director of critical care at Houston Methodist Hospital. Masud has been on the front lines of the battle against COVID-19 since it reached Houston.

  • Bolsonaro fans applaud his maverick virus response
    News
    AFP News

    Bolsonaro fans applaud his maverick virus response

    As the number of dead from coronavirus shot up in Brazil, the popularity of far right President Jair Bolsonaro has remained unchanged. For his supporters, the president has done nothing wrong despite more than 63,000 deaths and 1.5 million infections. Local epidemiologists and the World Health Organization have expressed concern about the president's approach in a country that is second only to the United States in terms of total cases and deaths from the virus.

  • US heads into Independence Day besieged by virus, Europe reopens
    Health
    AFP News

    US heads into Independence Day besieged by virus, Europe reopens

    Another record number of coronavirus cases overshadowed the start of America's Independence Day weekend Friday as the surge in infections prompted Britain to blacklist travelers from the US, intensifying its isolation. With beaches closed from coast to coast and officials urging Americans to stay home, the somber mood heading into what is usually a weekend of barbecues and sunshine underscored the struggle to extinguish COVID-19 at the epicenter of the global pandemic. "It is an unbelievable trajectory," said Faisal Masud, director of critical care at Houston Methodist Hospital in Texas, which officials say is dangerously close to being overwhelmed.

  • Sea turtles find protection from Senegal fishermen
    News
    AFP News

    Sea turtles find protection from Senegal fishermen

    In a classic case of "poacher turning gamekeeper", the fishermen of Senegal have joined forces to protect one of the ocean's most endangered species -- the sea turtle. Three species can be found on the Senegal coast in west Africa. The most populous is the green turtle and they are joined by the loggerhead and leatherhead which can weigh over 600 kilogrammes.