Pulitzer Prize picture highlights ethics debate

It is a picture of pure horror that is difficult to look at. But Agence France-Presse photographer Massoud Hossaini's gut-wrenching image of an Afghan girl crying in fear after a suicide bomber's attack last December was widely disseminated and on Monday won the Pulitzer Prize for breaking news photography.

Some newspapers used cropped versions of the picture at the time to remove the more disturbing images of blood and bodies, including one of a small child.

But The New York Times and others published the photograph intact on the front page the day after the attack.

Online news outlet MSNBC declined to run the picture at the time, saying "the dead bodies of children would be too disturbing to our readers," but published it Monday in a report on the Pulitzer with a warning of "graphic images which some viewers may find disturbing."

Journalists have long debated the use of graphic and violent images which can offend readers and sometimes inflict more trauma on victims and their families, says Jane Kirtley, director of the Silha Center for the Study of Media Ethics and Law at the University of Minnesota.

But Kirtley says images such as these tell an important story and should not be suppressed.

"My own view is that it is absolutely ethical to take and publish photographs like this. It is part of telling the full story. It is not something the public should be shielded from," she told AFP.

In the past, Kirtley said, many newspaper editors would avoid "a picture like this on the front page where people will be consuming it with their morning juice."

But the Internet has changed those considerations because of the proliferation of bloggers and citizen journalists, since "anyone with a camera and access to the Internet can publish these images."

Kirtley said editors can soften the impact of painful images by moving them from the front page to an inside page, or in the case of online news, to require users to click through a warning to see the image.

AFP's Hossaini said that he, too, was traumatized by the events of that day.

"The first and second night I had trouble sleeping. Whenever I was closing my eyes I was going to the scene, asking myself what else could I have done for those people, why didn't I help anybody?" he said.

By winning the award, he said he felt he had given the victims of the Afghan war a voice.

"I know that whoever sees this photo will think about the photographer but I hope they don't forget the pain Afghanistan's people have in their life," he commented.

"This is kind of the good part for me, that I can right now reflect the pain of the Afghan people to the world, tell the world what's going on in Afghanistan."

Susan Moeller, director of the International Center for Media and the Public Agenda at the University of Maryland and author of a book on war photography, said it is important for the media to explain the context of such images.

"I think there needs to be some kind of conversation... about why an image is appropriate, whether it is an image of gore, whether it is an image of exploitation," she said.

Moeller used the image in her class for a discussion on the appropriate selection of pictures, and found that students who had lived through violence in Asia or other areas or who had been in the military "were the most in favor of seeing the photo in its most explicit terms."

Those who wanted the picture to be used were those "who had the most personal connection to the events or to the meaning of the photo," Moeller said, while many others who had no experience in war suggested that it might be too disturbing for readers.

"This is all the more reason why such photos need to be understood as teaching moments," she said. "They are not just representative of the events they depict. That's their primary power."

Moeller said the same debates have been taking place over many decades.

"Everyone thinks things are so much worse and that the Internet has made coverage more aggressive... It has not, but it has made the images more accessible to more people," she said.

"There have been graphic images since photography was invented in the 1840s."

  • How a mom stole a car in under 60 seconds 6 hours ago
    How a mom stole a car in under 60 seconds

    “I didn't steal your car but I think my mom may have. It's a long story. I'll explain, but your car is safe and sound," read the flier posted in Red Hook, Brooklyn. It’s a strange tale that began when Cheyrl Thorpe was asked by her daughter Nekisia Davis to dog sit her Pomeranian at her apartment, according to New York Magazine.

  • All-new 2015 Subaru Outback reestablishes higher ground 8 hours ago
    All-new 2015 Subaru Outback reestablishes higher ground

    Much of Subaru’s modern day success in America can be attributed to one car: the Outback. Born in 1994 as a response to the growing popularity of SUVs, the Outback established a winning formula of combining a high-riding suspension, butch body cladding and big round fog lights to its comfortable, no-nonsense Legacy wagon. It is the kind of unique product that only a quirky company like Subaru could build, and was one that kept Subaru from slipping into ubiquity even as traditional SUVs and crossovers have taken over the world.

  • Custom faux-tique electric tram aims to replace New York's horses over the neigh-sayers 9 hours ago
    Custom faux-tique electric tram aims to replace New York's horses over the neigh-sayers

    For the record, it's the year 2014. I mention that in case someone reading this story about a push to replace horses with motorized carriages thinks they've stumbled onto some archival piece by accident. It's been more than 100 years since the first vehicles began to trundle around Manhattan, but the last remaining vestiges of horse-powered transport in the city could be nigh — if the backers of a massive electric wagon get their way.

  • Singaporeans slam NEA's $120 licence requirement for tissue sellers
    Singaporeans slam NEA's $120 licence requirement for tissue sellers

    Singaporeans on social media reacted angrily to news that tissue sellers at hawker centres and street corners are being required to pay for an annual licence.

  • ‘Huge’ Hindu, Buddhist statues against Islam, ex-judge says
    ‘Huge’ Hindu, Buddhist statues against Islam, ex-judge says

    KUALA LUMPUR, April 16 — The “huge” statues at a Hindu temple in Batu Caves and Buddhist temple in Penang are an affront to Islam as the religion forbids idolatry, a retired Court of Appeals judge...

  • Heartbreaking texts from students on sinking S. Korea ferry
    Heartbreaking texts from students on sinking S. Korea ferry

    Heart-wrenching messages of fear, love and despair, sent by high school students from a sinking South Korean ferry, added extra emotional weight Thursday to a tragedy that has stunned the nation. Nearly 300 people -- most of them students on a high school trip to a holiday island -- are still missing after the ferry capsized and sank on Wednesday morning. Mom, I love you," student Shin Young-Jin said in a text to his mother that was widely circulated in the South Korean media.