As the world mourns the death of famed physicist Stephen Hawking, many are calling out tributes that contain “ableist” language and what one disability rights blogger described as “inspiration porn.”
Among the social media posts honoring the A Brief History of Time author, who died March 13 at 76, are references to his use of a wheelchair and ALS diagnosis. Several tributes and obituaries have praised Hawking for “overcoming” his disease, while others claimed that death has “freed” him from his wheelchair.
But those comments perpetuate demeaning stereotypes, advocates and members of the public, including model and deaf activist Nyle DiMarco and actress and YA author Melinda Salisbury, argued.
If I see one more tweet about Stephen Hawking being 'free' of his chair, I'm going to puke. He wasn't caged by it. And to get that 'freedom' as you call it, he died. Imagine how the people around using wheelchairs feel when they see you commenting in such a fashion.
— Melinda Salisbury (@MESalisbury) March 14, 2018
A testament that disability is not “inability” and that people with disabilities can achieve anything they set their minds to.
— Nyle DiMarco (@NyleDiMarco) March 14, 2018
The odds weren't against a disabled person achieving what Stephen Hawking did.
They were against ANYONE achieving what Stephen Hawking did.
We really need to stop referring to disability and success/achievement as if they're somehow diametrically opposed. https://t.co/dRdZyS6Yis
— Diana Crow (@CatalyticRxn) March 14, 2018
If some of you talk about me the way you are talking about Stephen Hawking when I die I shall come back to haunt you all, please stop with the ableist ‘he overcame his disability’ talk he did everything *with* his disability, not *despite* it
— Shona (@shonalouiseblog) March 14, 2018
I mean, he did pretty amazing stuff but it wasn't amazing because he had ALS and used a wheelchair and AAC. Those are just things.
The amazing stuff Stephen Hawking did was amazing because he thought and said amazing things.
— Eb (@EbThen) March 14, 2018
Stephen Hawking was brilliant WITH a disability, NOT “IN SPITE” of it.
— Crutches&Spice♿️ | Creator of #DisTheOscars (@Imani_Barbarin) March 14, 2018
Whatever you say about Stephen Hawking, don’t ever say he was “wheelchair bound.” His chair and his adaptive speech device freed him to travel and share and teach the whole world.
— jess banks (@ProfBanks) March 14, 2018
Shona Louise, an activist and disability rights, beauty, and lifestyle blogger, was among those tweeting her objection to how Hawking’s disability has been portrayed. She explained to Yahoo Lifestyle why it’s important to be sensitive when addressing Hawking’s health.
“Since the death of Stephen Hawking was announced, tributes and tweets have poured in and similar themes keep coming up again and again,” Louise said. “I’m seeing illustrations of him walking away from his wheelchair, countless tweets about how he overcame his disability during his lifetime, and just as many saying that he achieved what he did ‘despite’ his disability. All of these are ableist responses.
“Equally, I see people saying he was inspiring because he was disabled, an example of inspiration porn,” she continued. “Disabled people don’t exist to inspire abled people. Be inspired by his incredible mind and work, be inspired by his humor and his activism, but don’t say he’s inspiring simply because he’s disabled. Hawking achieved everything he did with his disability, not despite it. He never overcame his disability like some have suggested; he simply lived with it and worked with it, finding different ways to do things.
“I’ve also seen many people say that they don’t see his disability, which isn’t helpful either,” Louise, who blogs about her experience with Marfan syndrome, added. “When you erase someone’s disability, you are erasing their identity; you are erasing the discrimination they face. Stating that you don’t see disability does not help to break down stigma like some people seem to think. People’s ableist reactions to his death show just how deeply ingrained ableism is within society.”
Have fun out there among the stars. pic.twitter.com/S285MTwGtp
— Barack Obama (@BarackObama) March 14, 2018
There’s nothing wrong with celebrating Hawking’s life and incredible work — but it’s possible to do that without fixating on his disability.
“Stephen Hawking transcended the boundaries between being disabled or nondisabled, and that was the measure of him,” Philip J. Connolly, policy and development manager for the advocacy group Disability Rights U.K., said to Yahoo Lifestyle.
“He taught us all to identify with universal values. Now is not the time for labels but redefining what it is to be human: infinite wisdom, infinite curiosity, etc. in an infinite universe.”
Read more from Yahoo Lifestyle:
- A fatal disease is striking dentists, and no one knows exactly why
- Paris Jackson defends smoking pot on social media: ‘It’s an incredible medical tool’
- Are magic mushrooms the next medical marijuana?