Trump's video game meeting may not lead to any further action

David Lumb
Trump's video game meeting may not lead to any further action

Early this week, Trump at last announced that he would meet with leaders of the video game industry. Not to discuss the rising frustration with loot boxes, but to rehash the exhausted and research-debunked notion that playing games causes people to become more violent. Predictably, Trump invited zero scientists or respected researchers to the summit, instead stacking it with outspoken video game critics and a trio of Republican lawmakers. And surprising nobody, the hour-long meeting produced very few actionable results.

Trump opened the meeting with a highlight reel of clips from the last decade of gaming, ranging from goofy to excessively bloody violence. Some attendees didn't expect any significant resolution, Glixel reported, and saw the meeting as an opening foray into a larger conversation...on gun violence in America. Critics of the industry called for regulations that would make it difficult for youths to buy violent games, and some asked Trump to widen the discussion to include violent movies and TV shows. But beyond sharing opinions during the closed-door summit, there was no commitment from attendees or the White House on concrete action.

Instead, it seemed a stage to reframe the post-Parkland debate around video games' influence on school shootings. Which, again, is zero: Only one-eighth of the 41 school shooters surveyed by the US Secret Service in a 2004 review were interested in violent video games (twice as many liked violent movies or books, which was still only a quarter of that sample). More studies disproving the faulty link between violence and games can be found in Engadget's long write-up on the topic here. Yet, the unsupported-by-science narrative prevailed at the summit:

"Today's meeting was an opportunity to learn and hear from different sides about concerns and possible solutions to violence in schools," Congresswoman Vicky Hartzler (R-MO) said in a prepared statement following the meeting, according to Glixel. According to reports (no press were allowed), Trump went around the table listening to various concerns from critics of the industry and opinions from video game company CEOs. The pro-industry Entertainment Software Association (ESA), also in attendance, released a statement after the meeting defending video games and politely denouncing the meeting's premise:

"We welcomed the opportunity today to meet with the President and other elected officials at the White House. We discussed the numerous scientific studies establishing that there is no connection between video games and violence, First Amendment protection of video games, and how our industry's rating system effectively helps parents make informed entertainment choices. We appreciate the President's receptive and comprehensive approach to this discussion."

This meeting rehashed the moral panic around video games that plagued the industry after the Columbine shootings in 1999 and, before that, in Congressional hearings back in 1994. That was when the ESA formed the Entertainment Software Ratings Board (ESRB) to disclose objectionable material on game packaging, which forestalled Congressional calls for the government to regulate the video game industry.

Melissa Henson of the Parents Television Council said that yesterday's summit was "respectful but contentious," she told The Washington Post, and that her side of the debate emphasized that the "steady diet of media violence is having a corrosive effect on our culture." Similarly, president of the Media Research Council Brent Bozell told Trump that the vidoe game industry should have much tougher regulation, and that violent games "needed to be given the same kind of thought as tobacco and liquor," he remarked to The Washington Post.


The Washington Post, Glixel

  • This article originally appeared on Engadget.
  • Greece, Macedonia sign historic deal to end name row
    News
    AFP News

    Greece, Macedonia sign historic deal to end name row

    Greece and Macedonia on Sunday signed a historic preliminary agreement to rename the small Balkan nation the Republic of North Macedonia, ending a row that has poisoned relations between the two neighbours since 1991. "This is a brave, historic and necessary step for our peoples," said Greek

  • Jailed Kurdish leader makes first TV appeal ahead of Turkey vote
    News
    AFP News

    Jailed Kurdish leader makes first TV appeal ahead of Turkey vote

    Turkey's leading Kurdish politician Selahattin Demirtas on Sunday appeared on state television from his prison cell to denounce the government's "repressive regime", ahead of the presidential election next weekend. Demirtas, a former co-leader of the People's Democratic Party (

  • Jailed Kurdish presidential candidate appears on TV from jail
    News
    AFP News

    Jailed Kurdish presidential candidate appears on TV from jail

    Turkey's leading Kurdish politician Selahattin Demirtas on Sunday appeared on state television from his prison cell to denounce the government's "repressive regime", ahead of the presidential election next weekend. Demirtas, a former co-leader of the People's Democratic Party (

  • Aquarius migrants step ashore in Spain after week-long ordeal
    News
    AFP News

    Aquarius migrants step ashore in Spain after week-long ordeal

    The 630 migrants whose rescue sparked a major migration row in Europe arrived in the Spanish port of Valencia on Sunday after a turbulent week that saw Italy and Malta turn them away. The Aquarius, which has been at the centre of the crisis, sailed into Valencia harbour about 10:30 am (0830 GMT) with

  • Indonesian Woman Swallowed Whole By 23-Foot Python
    Lifestyle
    HuffPost

    Indonesian Woman Swallowed Whole By 23-Foot Python

    A missing Indonesian woman has been found dead inside the belly of a 23-foot-

  • Portugal app empowers disabled to win better access to buildings
    Tech
    Reuters

    Portugal app empowers disabled to win better access to buildings

    By Catarina Demony LISBON (Reuters) - Fed up with the obstacle course of Lisbon's narrow footways and stairs in doorways, wheelchair user Ricardo Teixeira has taken matters into his own hands, giving disabled people the chance to fight back and instantly report violations via a phone app. Developed

  • Afghan Taliban say Eid ceasefire proved 'wide national support'
    News
    Reuters

    Afghan Taliban say Eid ceasefire proved 'wide national support'

    The Afghan Taliban said their three-day Eid ceasefire, which ends on Sunday, proved the unity of their movement and its "wide national support" as the presidential palace extended its own ceasefire with the militants by 10 days. Taliban fighters headed into cities across Afghanistan over the

  • Woman yelling 'Allahu akbar' slashes two with blade in France
    News
    AFP News

    Woman yelling 'Allahu akbar' slashes two with blade in France

    Two people were hurt in a town in southern France on Sunday when a woman shouting "Allahu akbar" (God is greatest) attacked them in a supermarket with a boxcutter knife, prosecutors said. A customer was struck in the chest during the late-morning assault in La Seyne-sur-Mer, outside the Mediterranean

  • Skopje sees Greece-Macedonia accord as 'breakthrough' for Balkans
    News
    AFP News

    Skopje sees Greece-Macedonia accord as 'breakthrough' for Balkans

    An historic deal between Greece and Macedonia to rename the small Balkan state the Republic of North Macedonia is crucial for the whole volatile region, Skopje's foreign minister said on Sunday. "We have made history today to open up our future," Macedonian Foreign Minister Nikola Dimitrov

  • FARC peace deal at risk as right closes in on Colombia presidency
    News
    AFP News

    FARC peace deal at risk as right closes in on Colombia presidency

    Voters in Colombia went to the polls Sunday to choose a new president in an election that has turned into a referendum on a landmark 2016 peace deal with FARC rebels, which conservative front-runner Ivan Duque wants to overhaul. Offering a starkly different choice to voters is Duque's opponent,

  • Erdogan in major Istanbul rally ahead of Turkey vote
    News
    AFP News

    Erdogan in major Istanbul rally ahead of Turkey vote

    Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Sunday was cheered on by tens of thousands of supporters at a rally in Istanbul ahead of next weekend's election, after facing tough opposition in the campaign. Erdogan and his Justice and Development Party (AKP) which he co-founded in 2001 are seeking a

  • In Uganda, football fever causes betting flutter
    News
    AFP News

    In Uganda, football fever causes betting flutter

    On a pot-holed street by Uganda's sprawling central jail, young men stream into a luminous betting shop that stands out from the surrounding dingy grocery stores lit by paraffin lamps. Inside, dozens of men clasp handfuls of betting slips as they huddle around a flat-screen television blasting out

  • Woman yelling 'Allahu akbar' slashes two with blade in France
    News
    AFP News

    Woman yelling 'Allahu akbar' slashes two with blade in France

    Two people were hurt in a town in southern France on Sunday when a veiled woman shouting "Allahu akbar" (God is greatest) attacked them in a supermarket with a boxcutter knife, prosecutors said. A customer was struck in the chest during the late-morning assault in La Seyne-sur-Mer, outside

  • Guatemala volcano search called off with nearly 200 unaccounted for
    News
    AFP News

    Guatemala volcano search called off with nearly 200 unaccounted for

    Authorities on Sunday called off a search for the nearly 200 people missing since Guatemala's Fuego volcano erupted earlier this month, devastating the surrounding countryside. Officials have confirmed the deaths of 110 people as a result of the volcanic eruption on June 3, but another 197 people

  • Stonewall Inn Owners: 'This Is The Gay Church. This Is Where It All Began.'
    Lifestyle
    HuffPost

    Stonewall Inn Owners: 'This Is The Gay Church. This Is Where It All Began.'

    Just over 10 years ago, it looked like The Stonewall Inn was going out of

  • Liberty customers have not suffered financial losses due to cyber attack: CEO
    Tech
    Reuters

    Liberty customers have not suffered financial losses due to cyber attack: CEO

    The Chief Executive of South African insurer Liberty Holdings said its customers did not appear to have suffered any financial losses after the company reported earlier on Sunday that it had become the victim of a cyber attack. The company had said an external party claimed to have seized data from

  • Boat caught in Europe's migration spat brings hundreds to Spain
    News
    Reuters

    Boat caught in Europe's migration spat brings hundreds to Spain

    Rescued migrants turned away by Italy and Malta arrived at the Spanish port of Valencia on Sunday, ending a gruelling Mediterranean odyssey that became symbolic of Europe's failure to agree on immigration. Spain swooped to help 629 mainly sub-Saharan Africans on board the ship Aquarius last week

  • Taliban say ceasefire will not be extended, as suicide attack kills 18
    News
    AFP News

    Taliban say ceasefire will not be extended, as suicide attack kills 18

    A suicide attack in restive eastern Afghanistan on Sunday killed at least 18 people in a crowd celebrating the Eid holiday, the second assault in as many days to mar an unprecedented ceasefire. There was no immediate claim of responsibility for the suicide attack in Jalalabad city, outside the office

  • Three still in hospital after taxi hits crowd near Kremlin
    News
    AFP News

    Three still in hospital after taxi hits crowd near Kremlin

    Three people were recovering in hospital on Sunday after a taxi ploughed into pedestrians just steps from Moscow's Red Square during the World Cup in Russia. More than 600,000 foreign tourists are expected to descend on Russia during the June 14 to July 15 showpiece. Moscow police underscored their

  • Guatemala ends victim searches at volcano where 110 died
    News
    Reuters

    Guatemala ends victim searches at volcano where 110 died

    Guatemala on Sunday ended its victim search efforts in the zone that suffered most deaths and injuries from the Fuego volcano eruption, its disaster agency said. At least 110 people died and 197 are still missing after violent eruptions that began two weeks ago, according to disaster agency CONRED.

  • The bigger Cryptocurrencies get, the worse they perform: BIS
    Tech
    Reuters

    The bigger Cryptocurrencies get, the worse they perform: BIS

    Cryptocurrencies are not scalable and are more likely to suffer a breakdown in trust and efficiency the greater the number of people using them, the Bank of International Settlements (BIS)said on Sunday in its latest warning about the rise of virtual currencies. For any form of money to work across

  • Saudi-led coalition conducts air strikes on Yemen's Hodeidah airport
    News
    Reuters

    Saudi-led coalition conducts air strikes on Yemen's Hodeidah airport

    Houthi forces fought to keep control of the airport in Yemen's main port city of Hodeidah on Sunday as Saudi-led coalition air strikes struck the compound, in an offensive that could be a turning point in the three-year conflict. Losing Hodeidah would deal a serious blow to the Iran-aligned Houthis

  • BIS wants tighter rules for funds offering credit, fintech
    Tech
    Reuters

    BIS wants tighter rules for funds offering credit, fintech

    By Huw Jones LONDON (Reuters) - Regulations introduced after the financial crisis a decade ago to smooth out banking booms and busts should be extended to funds that provide credit, or shadow banks, and fintech firms, the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) said on Sunday. The introduction of

  • Greece, Macedonia sign pact to change ex-Yugoslav republic's name
    News
    Reuters

    Greece, Macedonia sign pact to change ex-Yugoslav republic's name

    PRESPES, Greece/BITOLA, Macedonia (Reuters) - Greece and Macedonia set aside three decades of dispute on Sunday as they agreed on a new name for the former Yugoslav republic, paving the way for its possible admission to the European Union and NATO. The foreign ministers of the two countries signed an

  • Trey Gowdy Threatens DOJ, FBI Officials Over Clinton Probe Documents
    News
    HuffPost

    Trey Gowdy Threatens DOJ, FBI Officials Over Clinton Probe Documents

    House oversight committee Chairman Trey Gowdy (R-S.C.) threatened on Sunday to