VIEW: Bilateral investment treaties costing billions

Kuala Lumpur (The Star/ANN) - More countries are realising how they are at the losing end of a biased arbitration system that is loaded against them in investment cases that can cost them billions of dollars.

IT must be the world's most problematic and outrageous judicial system. Its decisions can cost a country billions of dollars.

It is riddled with conflicts of interest involving judges, lawyers and the proponents of the case.

Yet its hearings and decisions are shrouded in secrecy and even the very existence of the cases are often not public information.

This is the arbitration system at the heart of international investment agreements.

Many countries, including Malaysia, are signatories to these agreements.

There are around 3,000 bilateral investment treaties (BITs) signed by pairs of governments. And there are also bilateral free trade agreements which have an investment chapter that is similar in content with the BITs.

Under these treaties, foreign companies can sue governments if they introduce policies that these companies deem will affect their future incomes.

The treaties define "expropriation" to include depriving investors of future profits due to new regulations.

Thus, a tobacco firm has sued Australia and Uruguay for requiring cigarette boxes to have plain packaging.

When Ecuador cancelled a contract with an American oil company for violating the terms of the contract, the company took a case and was awarded US$2.4 billion. .

Another company sued Germany for two recent policies requiring tighter regulations on coal-fired power plants to reduce carbon emissions and to phase out nuclear power following the Fukushima nuclear disaster in Japan.

Indonesia is being sued for $2 billion by a British mining company after the government revoked a licence that it found was faulty.

Public interest groups have criticised the BITs for preventing or discouraging governments from introducing health, environmental and pro-development policies.

A small group of lawyers, working either for investors or as arbitrators, and who are based in Europe and North America, have been benefitting from the boom in litigation linked to investment agreements, and they also encourage big companies to sue governments, according to a recent report by two European groups, Transnational Institute and Corporate Europe Observatory.

In disputes relating to most BITs and FTAs, the arbitration is conducted by the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) at the World Bank in Washington.

The report "Profiting From Injustice" revealed that:

> Only 15 arbitrators, nearly all from Europe, the US or Canada, have decided 55 per cent of all known investment-treaty disputes. This small group sit on the same panels, act as both arbitrators and counsels and call on each other as witnesses;

> Many arbitrators show a clear bias towards investors. Several prominent arbitrators have been members of the board of major multinational companies, including those who filed cases against developing countries;

> A few law firms have been encouraging investors to sue governments as a weapon to weaken or prevent laws on public health or the environment. These investment lawyers are the new "ambulance chasers" and have fuelled an increase in cases from 38 in 1996 to 450 known cases in 2011;

> Countries have to pay exorbitant legal and arbitration costs averaging over $8 million per dispute and exceeding $30 million in some cases. The Philippines spent $58 defending two cases against a German firm:

> Lobbying by arbitration law firms and arbitrators succeeded in stopping reform of investment agreements in the EU and US in the last four years; and

> Fairness and independence of investment arbitration is an illusion.

Frustrated with the BITs and its arbitration, a growing number of governments have retreated from the system.

Recently, India started a review of its existing BITs and suspended all BIT negotiations to protect itself from frivolous litigation.

In 2011, Australia announced it would not include investor-state disputes in its future trade agreements.

In South Africa, the Cabinet decided to stop negotiating new BITs and to re-negotiate existing ones.

Bolivia, Ecuador and Venezuela terminated several treaties and have withdrawn from ICSID.

Officials of many developing countries admit that they signed the BITs without realising the full implications.

One problem is a "survival clause" in many BITs: even if a country withdraws, or if a treaty expires, the provisions will remain in force for 10 or 15 years.

In any case, awareness of the problems in the agreements and the unfairness of its arbitration system are growing, and calls for reform are being made by more countries.


  • 2015 Dodge Charger goes under the knife 1 hour 15 minutes ago
    2015 Dodge Charger goes under the knife

    Over the past decade, Chrysler's rear-wheel-drive sedans have managed to survive a bankruptcy and three different corporate overlords. Thanks to the original stoutness of the Mercedes-assisted chassis, and the periodic updates that keep them from seeming like 21st-century versions of the Ford Crown Victoria, the Chrysler 300 and Dodge Charger combo still draw in fans. Today, Dodge revealed yet another redesign for the 2015 Charger — and for an old car, it's quite the change.

  • Thursday #sgroundup: Singaporeans slam NEA's $120 licence requirement for tissue sellers 1 hour 15 minutes ago
    Thursday #sgroundup: Singaporeans slam NEA's $120 licence requirement for tissue sellers

    Here are the top trending stories of today in case you missed them:

  • 2015 Nissan Murano aims for the style-forward crowd 15 hours ago
    2015 Nissan Murano aims for the style-forward crowd

    Nissan says its 2015 Murano crossover, only the second major revamp of the car since it debuted in 2003, draws its design cues from the “age of future space flight.” That’s probably taking it a little far, but the new Murano, based off the 2013 Resonance concept vehicle, is an exceptionally lovely machine, all fluid, curved metal on the outside, and flowing, soft-touch materials on the inside. Certain kinds of comfort and charms that were unheard-of outside of premium vehicles five years ago have definitely trickled down, and reached a kind of design apotheosis with this car.

  • ‘Huge’ Hindu, Buddhist statues against Islam, ex-judge says
    ‘Huge’ Hindu, Buddhist statues against Islam, ex-judge says

    KUALA LUMPUR, April 16 — The “huge” statues at a Hindu temple in Batu Caves and Buddhist temple in Penang are an affront to Islam as the religion forbids idolatry, a retired Court of Appeals judge...

  • Over 280 missing after South Korean ferry capsizes
    Over 280 missing after South Korean ferry capsizes

    By Narae Kim JINDO South Korea (Reuters) - More than 280 people, many of them students from the same high school, were missing after a ferry capsized off South Korea on Wednesday, in what could be the country's biggest maritime disaster in over 20 years. It was not immediately clear why the Sewol ferry listed heavily on to its side and capsized in apparently calm conditions off South Korea's southwest coast, but some survivors spoke of a loud noise prior to the disaster.

  • StarHub 4G users to be charged from June as promo ends
    StarHub 4G users to be charged from June as promo ends

    Are you on the 4G or LTE mobile data network under StarHub? If so, you’ll have to start paying for the service.