Why Forever 21 will probably disappear forever

Brian Sozzi
Editor-at-Large

Forever 21 has been eaten alive by the new monsters in retail today, digital shopping and ginormous discount stores finally offering hot fashion at their always good prices.

An inability to evolve internally has also hampered Forever 21.

One of the formerly go-to destinations for disposable fashion filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection on Sunday to restructure its business. Forever 21 said the bankruptcy filing will allow it to close some international locations and focus on its core business, according to Reuters, which reported the company will also close 178 U.S. stores.

The company — founded in 1984 — sells its cheap wares at more than 800 stores in the U.S., Europe, Asia, and Latin America. (Though Reuters reports that it will shutter most stores in Asia and Europe.)

To hear Forever 21 is knocking on death’s door isn’t a shocker. In fact, one has to wonder what in the world took so long.

For starters, Forever 21 has become increasingly irrelevant in malls throughout the country. Whereas mall apparel rivals such as Abercrombie & Fitch (ANFhave invested in product quality to entice shoppers, Forever 21 has stayed true to its cheaply made, cheaply priced merchandise roots. Whereas Zara has upped its fashion game (and its prices), Forever 21 hasn’t kept pace, according to experts Yahoo Finance has chatted up.

Credit: David Foster/Yahoo FInance

And to add insult to injury, national apparel chains have focused on closing unproductive stores and downsizing others to drive healthier profits.

Forever 21 has been slow to even do that. And as a result, there really isn’t any reason for the chain to exist — too many better options out yonder for consumers. Too many other better positioned retailers from a fundamental perspective.

“First off they lost their way on fashion — used to be really quick in copying higher end brands. They became over assorted — less impactful on fashion, while quality declined,” said longtime retail analyst Janet Kloppenburg at JJK Research Associates. “Also the store footprint just kept getting larger and they have some huge 20,000-square-foot stores.”

So there is that entire mess.

Declining retail stores

Then there are the structural issues in retail that are no doubt pounding Forever 21 into the ground.

First, there remain too many retail stores in America amid the shift to online shopping. Unproductive retail chains must — and will — be weeded out as people reduce trips to physical shops.

The shakeout in retail is likely to be massive. Investment bank UBS estimated earlier this year that as online retail sales penetration rises to 25% from 16% currently, about 75,000 retail stores will close shop by 2026. That amounts to 7% or so of the 1,044,754 retail locations UBS says exist.

UBS believes 21,000 clothing stores out of the 82,000 in existence will have to close.

If you are near a Forever 21 — which has failed to evolve — this tsunami of store closings is likely to show up at your doorstep.

The rise of Walmart and Target

Meanwhile, the fact is discount stores such as Walmart (WMT) and Target (TGT) have gotten way better at giving shoppers what they want in apparel. The products are usually on trend and at great prices. Remember, the very existence of mall-based specialty apparel shops like Forever 21 came to be because discounters and department stores couldn’t sell good merchandise at fair prices.

No more. Plus, it’s the discounters with their large supply chains that are able to handle the rising worker wages in overseas markets and increased costs from tariffs. Fast-fashion’s business model has long been predicated on low prices because of low costs.

That is going away.

“The strength you are seeing in the retail sector is at Target, Walmart, TJ Maxx. Really the retailers that are standalones like Forever 21 and small, mall-driven retailers, those are the ones struggling because mall traffic continues to erode. The discounters have larger businesses and could offset higher costs,” said Nick Giacoumakis, strategist at New England Investment & Retirement Group.

The writing on the wall for Forever 21 has long been clear. You just had to connect the dots.

This story was originally published on Aug. 29, 2019 and updated with news of the bankruptcy filing on Sept. 30.

Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance

Yahoo Finance's live morning show.

Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, SmartNews, LinkedIn, YouTube, and reddit.

  • U.S. blocking G20 mention of climate change in draft communique - sources
    News
    Reuters

    U.S. blocking G20 mention of climate change in draft communique - sources

    The United States is against mentioning climate change in the communique of the world's financial leaders, G20 diplomats said, after a new draft of the joint statement showed the G20 are considering including it as a risk factor to growth. Finance ministers and central bankers of the world's

  • Russia-linked disinformation campaign fueling coronavirus alarm, US says
    News
    AFP News

    Russia-linked disinformation campaign fueling coronavirus alarm, US says

    Thousands of Russian-linked social media accounts have launched a coordinated effort to spread alarm about the new coronavirus, disrupting global efforts to fight the epidemic, US officials say. The disinformation campaign promotes unfounded conspiracy theories that the United States is behind the COVID

  • S.Korea reports surge in virus cases, including Samsung employee
    News
    AFP News

    S.Korea reports surge in virus cases, including Samsung employee

    South Korea is facing a "grave" situation from the coronavirus outbreak, Prime Minister Chung Sye-kyun said Saturday as the country reported 229 new cases in the sharpest spike in infections yet. Many of new cases involved patients being treated in hospital for mental health issues but also

  • Togo goes to polls as president seeks likely fourth term
    News
    AFP News

    Togo goes to polls as president seeks likely fourth term

    Togo went to the polls Saturday in an election widely expected to see President Faure Gnassingbe claim a fourth term in power and extend his family's half-century domination of the West African nation. The incumbent, 53, has led the country of eight million people since 2005 following the death

  • Latest on coronavirus spreading in China and beyond
    News
    Reuters

    Latest on coronavirus spreading in China and beyond

    **China has reported a total of 75,569 cases of the virus known as COVID-19, including 2,239 deaths. **Mainland China had 397 new confirmed cases on Friday, down from 889 a day earlier, but only 31 cases were outside of the virus epicentre of Hubei province, the lowest number since the National Health

  • S.Sudan rebel leader Machar sworn in as vice president
    News
    AFP News

    S.Sudan rebel leader Machar sworn in as vice president

    South Sudan rebel leader Riek Machar was sworn in as first vice president on Saturday, formally rejoining the government in the latest bid to bring peace to a nation ravaged by war. President Salva Kiir hailed the "official ending of war" and said peace was now "irreversible" as

  • Explainer: Nevada caucuses present new test to Democrats after chaotic Iowa contest
    News
    Reuters

    Explainer: Nevada caucuses present new test to Democrats after chaotic Iowa contest

    Nevada Democrats will host hundreds of caucuses on Saturday, the third contest in the state-by-state presidential nominating process, almost three weeks after the Iowa caucuses caused mayhem when a technical meltdown delayed results. After the contests in the states of Iowa and New Hampshire, where

  • Coronavirus: HK$800 million reusable mask plan flounders as materials, factory space prove difficult to source in Hong Kong
    News
    South China Morning Post

    Coronavirus: HK$800 million reusable mask plan flounders as materials, factory space prove difficult to source in Hong Kong

    A day after government attempts to boost local mask production were revealed to be flailing, Hong Kong’s technology chief conceded a plan to produce reusable versions was faring no better, citing the struggle to source raw materials or clean factory space.Speaking on a Saturday radio programme, Secretary

  • G20 ministers weigh coronavirus risks at Saudi meeting
    News
    AFP News

    G20 ministers weigh coronavirus risks at Saudi meeting

    Finance ministers and central bank governors from G20 nations weighed the potential impact of the coronavirus epidemic on the world economy as they met in Riyadh Saturday for a two-day gathering. At the meeting in Saudi Arabia, the first Arab nation to hold the G20 presidency, financial leaders from

  • Back to blue: UK passports revert to old colour from next month
    News

    Back to blue: UK passports revert to old colour from next month

    Reverting to the dark blue of pre-EU days has been a point of pride for many Britons who voted to leave the bloc in a 2016 referendum - even though the new passport will be made by a Franco-Dutch firm. Britain formally left the EU at the end of January and introduction of the new passport will be phased

  • Afghans mark start of week-long partial truce amid isolated attacks
    News
    AFP News

    Afghans mark start of week-long partial truce amid isolated attacks

    A week-long, partial truce appeared to be largely holding across Afghanistan on Saturday, with jubilant civilians celebrating in the streets to mark a potentially historic turning point in the war, even as isolated attacks threatened to undermine the process. The Taliban, US and Afghan forces have all

  • Pope moves slain Salvadoran priest, icon for poor, closer to sainthood
    News
    Reuters

    Pope moves slain Salvadoran priest, icon for poor, closer to sainthood

    A Jesuit priest who was murdered at the threshold of the Salvadoran civil war and who in death became a icon for human rights in rural Latin America was moved a step closer to sainthood by Pope Francis on Saturday. The Vatican said the pope had approved a decree recognising that Rutilio Grande and two

  • Sanders puts Democratic front-runner status on the line in Nevada's caucuses
    News
    Reuters

    Sanders puts Democratic front-runner status on the line in Nevada's caucuses

    Bernie Sanders faces a test of his front-runner status in the Democratic White House race on Saturday in Nevada, where voters will consider an unsettled field of candidates as they search for a challenger to take on President Donald Trump. Sanders, a self-identified democratic socialist senator from

  • Virus ship crew's families fear for kin as Philippines evacuation postponed
    News
    AFP News

    Virus ship crew's families fear for kin as Philippines evacuation postponed

    Families of hundreds of Filipino crew members still stuck on board the coronavirus-stricken Diamond Princess cruise ship are increasingly worried for their relatives' health, as the Philippines postponed on Saturday a scheduled trip to bring them home. The vessel, moored off the Japanese coast in

  • Iran reports fifth coronavirus death, most outside Far East
    News
    AFP News

    Iran reports fifth coronavirus death, most outside Far East

    Iran on Saturday reported one more death among 10 new cases of coronavirus, bringing the total number of deaths in the Islamic republic to five -- the highest of any country outside the Far East. The COVID-19 outbreak in Iran first surfaced on Wednesday, when authorities said it claimed the lives of

  • Lesotho PM granted medical leave from wife murder case - police
    News
    Reuters

    Lesotho PM granted medical leave from wife murder case - police

    Lesotho's 80-year-old prime minister has been granted sick leave until Feb. 27 when he will be have to appear in court on charges of murdering his wife, the country's deputy police commissioner said on Saturday. Thomas Thabane was due to be charged on Friday, but he failed to appear in court

  • Kazakhstan detains around 200 opposition protesters in largest city
    News
    AFP News

    Kazakhstan detains around 200 opposition protesters in largest city

    Police in Kazakhstan detained around 200 people Saturday as two opposition groups called for anti-government demonstrations in the oil-rich Central Asian country. An AFP correspondent saw police detain around 30 activists from the unregistered Democratic Party as they attempted to hold a protest in

  • WHO coronavirus team at ground zero in Wuhan to work out next containment step
    News
    South China Morning Post

    WHO coronavirus team at ground zero in Wuhan to work out next containment step

    A team of public health experts from the World Health Organisation (WHO) has arrived in the central Chinese city of Wuhan – ground zero of the coronavirus outbreak – to determine the next step in containing the epidemic.In a brief statement on Saturday, China’s National Health Commission said some Chinese

  • China virus cases drop as foreign fears rise
    News
    AFP News

    China virus cases drop as foreign fears rise

    Fears mounted Saturday over the growing spread of infections outside China from the new coronavirus outbreak, as the World Health Organization warned of a shrinking window to stem the spread of the deadly disease. The warning came as Europe saw its first deaths from the COVID-19 strain, which has now

  • North China city of Harbin puts four districts on lockdown in bid to contain coronavirus
    News
    South China Morning Post

    North China city of Harbin puts four districts on lockdown in bid to contain coronavirus

    Authorities in one of China’s most northerly cities, which also serves as a major regional transport and trading hub, have placed four districts under total lockdown in a bid to contain the spread of the Covid-19 coronavirus.The municipal government in Harbin, capital of Heilongjiang province, which

  • Hundreds join protest against ban of opposition party in Thailand
    News
    Reuters

    Hundreds join protest against ban of opposition party in Thailand

    Hundreds of students and supporters held a protest in Bangkok on Saturday against a court decision dissolving Thailand's second largest opposition party, less than a year after an election that ended direct military rule. The Constitutional Court on Friday disbanded the upstart Future Forward Party

  • Egyptian court acquits Mubarak's sons of illicit share trading
    News
    Reuters

    Egyptian court acquits Mubarak's sons of illicit share trading

    The two sons of former Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak were acquitted on Saturday of illicit share trading during the sale of a bank four years before the 2011 uprising that ended their father's 30-year autocratic rule. Alaa and Gamal Mubarak and seven others had faced charges of illegally profiting

  • Coronavirus: Hongkonger returned from Diamond Princess cruise ship tests positive
    News
    South China Morning Post

    Coronavirus: Hongkonger returned from Diamond Princess cruise ship tests positive

    A man under quarantine in Hong Kong after being evacuated from the Diamond Princess cruise ship tested preliminarily positive for the coronavirus on Saturday, according to medical sources.The 68-year-old had been quarantined on Chun Yeung Estate, Fo Tan, and tested positive after being sent to Queen

  • Kazakhstan detains dozens of anti-government protesters
    News
    Reuters

    Kazakhstan detains dozens of anti-government protesters

    Kazakh police detained dozens of opposition supporters who staged public protests against the government of the Central Asian nation on Saturday. Demonstrations have intensified since the resignation of President Nursultan Nazarbayev last March after almost three decades in power. Nazarbayev nominated

  • South Sudan set to swear in former rebel leader as first vice president
    News
    Reuters

    South Sudan set to swear in former rebel leader as first vice president

    South Sudan's President Salva Kiir is due to swear in former rebel leader Riek Machar as his first vice president on Saturday after the two men agreed to form a unity government, a move that could definitively end years of fighting in the country. Riek and Machar had repeatedly pushed back deadlines