World Cup Touchline: 32 March friendly takeaways

Every four years, on a groggy Wednesday or Thursday morning in March, the world comes to a realization: The World Cup is right around the corner. In 2018, that realization has hit.

The 2018 World Cup is months away, of course. But the next time national teams take to fields around the globe, previews will have already been written. Matchups will have been overanalyzed. Excitement will have built.

The buildup to a World Cup is, out of necessity, stop-start. That was precisely the idea behind this column, World Cup Touchline. The goal has been to bridge the narrative gap. To tell the story of qualification. To examine World Cup fandom for grieving U.S. supporters. To turn the page from the PyoengChang Winter Olympics to Russia.

But there is no bridging the preparation gap for managers. There are no clandestine training sessions. The last of the March friendlies concluded late Tuesday night, and suddenly, the next step of the process is World Cup camp. Russia is within reach.

That’s why those friendlies are so important, and so telling. And that is why I watched far too many of them. I caught 21 of the 32 teams in all, plus highlights of the others. I scrutinized lineups. I studied formations. I took note of squad selections, and researched the context in which they were made. And I came away with the following 32 observations:


Is there room for all three of Paul Pogba, Antoine Griezmann and Thomas Lemar in France’s starting lineup at the World Cup? (Getty)

1. The lineup that seemed set in stone, the Brazilian 11 that rolled through South America’s qualifying gauntlet, is suddenly no longer so. Thiago Silva started both friendlies against Russia and Germany over Marquinhos. And Tite is tinkering in midfield. Philippe Coutinho slide inside to take Renato Augusto’s central place against Russia. He then moved back out wide against Germany, with Fernandinho alongside Paulinho in the middle. The logical sans-Neymar move would have been to draft Willian and Coutinho on opposite wings. Tite, apparently, craves a bit of optionality.

2. The adjustments are neither inherently good nor bad. Viewed negatively, they’re uncertainty. But viewed positively, they’re flexibility. Tite can adapt his personnel to a given opponent. The balance seemed suitable on both occasions. In a 3-0 victory over Russia, Brazil had little trouble recouping possession in midfield despite the attack-minded change. In a 1-0 defeat of Germany, its chance-creation was sufficient despite the lack of central creativity.

3. No team has more strengths and fewer looming questions than Spain. La Roja, in a 1-1 draw with Germany and 6-1 thrashing of Argentina, really only had one weakness: an occasional emptiness at the base of midfield. But the deficiency is easily explained by Sergio Busquets’ absence. When Busquets returns, 10 of 11 places appear to be claimed, and Spain appears to be as prepared for Russia as anybody.

4. Those 10 starting Spaniards, barring injury, should be David De Gea in goal; Dani Carvajal, Sergio Ramos, Gerard Pique and Jordi Alba across the back; Busquets, Andres Iniesta and Thiago in midfield – with Koke the one potential interloper; and Isco and David Silva wide. That leaves only the striker position unfilled. Rodrigo and Diego Costa both placed themselves among the candidates to fill it with one start and one goal apiece in the friendlies. Neither made an irrefutable case for himself, but both made strong ones. Alvaro Morata is still in the mix as well.

5. German manager Joachim Low answered one of our questions for him. The flirtation with a back three seems to have been scrapped. But a few of his own questions remain unanswered. Neither Sami Khedira nor Ilkay Gundogan, nor the injured Emre Can, seized a role next to Toni Kroos in Low’s 4-2-3-1. And Julian Draxler started ahead of Leroy Sane on the left with the rest of the first team against Spain. Both those spots in the 11 appear to be unclaimed.

6. The rest of the Germany 11? Either Marc-Andre Ter Stegen or Manuel Neuer in goal, depending on Neuer’s health; Joshua Kimmich, Mats Hummels, Jerome Boateng and Jonas Hector across the back; Kroos in midfield; Thomas Muller on the right; Mesut Ozil in a central playmaking role; and Timo Werner up top.

7. Of the favorites, France remains the undisputed king of uncertainty. Didier Deschamps was one of several managers to experiment with two distinct formations. The first was a 4-2-2-2 against Colombia. The second was a 4-3-3 against Russia. And only four players started in both of them: Hugo Lloris, Samuel Umtiti, N’Golo Kante and Kylian Mbappe.

8. France’s 4-2-2-2 looked more coherent and fluid up front. Antoine Griezmann started alongside Olivier Giroud, and that strike partnership has proven itself to be more than functional. Behind them, the midfield was skewed. Mbappe played as a true winger, mostly off the right. Thomas Lemar was his nominal equivalent on the left, but tended to drop deeper with France in possession to get on the ball. In fact, that’s how the first goal came about:

9. There are two main issues with France’s 4-2-2-2. One is the overlapping run that created the goal. The formation depends on and encourages fullbacks to get forward. But attacking fullbacks require absolute security in possession. Kante and Blaise Matuidi, for all their strengths, don’t offer that. The problem was stripped bare when Kante gave away possession cheaply in the second half. Lucas Digne was caught cheating up the pitch. James Rodriguez snuck into the space he had vacated, and set up Radamel Falcao for the equalizer.

10. The obvious solution? Put a deep-lying playmaker next to Kante. The second issue? That player would be Paul Pogba, and his performances for both club and country have shown he’s not suited for a midfield two. It’s almost as if the midfield three that Deschamps went to against Russia was to accommodate Pogba. And the balance, with Adrien Rabiot also beside Kante, was better. But France’s attacking talent – specifically Griezmann – fits better in the 4-2-2-2. Griezmann and Mbappe both seem like must-starts, and both are better with partners. So the question for Deschamps essentially becomes, Whose strengths do you play to? Griezmann’s? Or Pogba’s? Whom do you need more?

11. England manager Gareth Southgate is all in on a 3-5-2, and seems to know precisely who he wants and what he wants from them in midfield. He wants one No. 6 and two No. 8s. And he wants those 8s – Jesse Lingard and Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain against both Holland and Italy – to press; to support the two forwards; and even to run in behind on occasion. He has the personnel to fulfill those responsibilities, and he even has a potential tweak – Dele Alli in for Oxlade-Chamberlain – against lesser opponents. (Harry Kane and Raheem Sterling are the probable front two.) Both England showings were promising.

12. Southgate’s biggest curveball was playing Kyle Walker as the right-sided center back in the three. The boss likely considered his squad’s strengths and weaknesses – depth at fullback, uncertainty at center back – and decided re-allocating resources from the area of strength to the one of weakness would be beneficial. It doesn’t maximize Walker’s skill set, but it looks like an option. The other two starters are likely John Stones in the middle and either Joe Gomez or Harry Maguire on the left.

13. Why, though, didn’t we see Eric Dier trialed as England’s third center back? He’d be the obvious candidate. He’s played there for Tottenham. And there doesn’t look like there’ll be room for both him and Jordan Henderson in midfield.

14. Jordan Pickford and Jack Butland each got 90 minutes in net. The four-man goalkeeper competition seems to have been whittled down to two. Farewell, Joe Hart.

15. Belgium, for better or worse, is going to be the most entertaining team in Russia. Because Belgium looks very Roberto Martinez-y. It looks like 2015 Everton with unlimited turbo boosts. Martinez played Romelu Lukaku, Dries Mertens and Eden Hazard as a front three in a 4-0 victory over Saudi Arabia. He played Kevin De Bruyne behind them. He continues to deploy Yannick Carrasco, an out-and-out winger, as one of his wing backs. The result is very little defined defensive structure. Even the overmatched Saudis were able to maintain some possession and make far to frequent jaunts into the final third. But at the other end? Holy s—. Belgium was terrifying every time it went forward.

16. Lionel Messi didn’t play a single minute for Argentina against Italy or Spain. Everything the Argentines did in those two games – the good and the bad – is therefore inconsequential. It doesn’t matter who started in attack. It doesn’t matter that the Albiceleste capitulated in the second half against Spain. There’s no utility in analyzing any of this. Jorge Sampaoli’s stumping task isn’t to install his system and figure out which players fit into it; it’s to fit his system and those players to Messi. We know nothing more about Argentina today than we did a week ago.

Lionel Messi did not look like he was enjoying Argentina’s 6-1 loss to Spain. (Getty)

17. The changing of the Uruguay guard is finally, (almost) definitely happening! After what seemed like seven years of 2010 World Cup retreads in midfield behind Luis Suarez and Edinson Cavani, it appears Oscar Tabarez really is going to stick with his kids. He started all four of Matias Vecino (26), Rodrigo Bentancur (20), Nahitan Nandez (22) and Giorgian de Arrascaeta (23) in a 2-0 victory over the Czech Republic. He started three of the four (de Arrascaeta excluded) in a 1-0 win over Wales. Uruguay will be exciting beyond its two big-name stars, and seems to be in great shape heading to Russia.

18. Several managers are still experimenting. Still piloting different systems. One of them, of course, is Mexico’s Juan Carlos Osorio. Osorio, true to form, rolled out an 11 and a formation that not a single fan could have predicted two weeks ago. It was a 3-3-1-3 – not a novel concept for Osorio, but a departure from the alignments that carried Mexico through qualifying. Diego Reyes played in front of the back three. Andres Guardado and Miguel Layun were wide in midfield. Osorio was missing some of his attacking pieces in the 3-0 win over Iceland, and reviews were mixed despite the scoreline. But you could see how the puzzle might eventually come together, with Chicharito flanked by Hirving Lozano and Tecatito Corona/Carlos Vela, and Hector Herrera ahead of Reyes in midfield.

19. The biggest worry for Mexico? Injuries. Ugh. Nestor Araujo, who figured to start at center back, was stretchered off in the first half against Croatia. Reyes replaced him, but had to withdraw at halftime with an injury of his own. And his replacement, Carlos Salcedo, also sustained an injury. Araujo’s and Salcedo’s knocks appear to be serious. If they are, both would be big blows to El Tri.

20. Colombia toyed with two different shapes. Carlos Bacca and Radamel Falcao started together against Australia with James Rodriguez underneath. Against France, though, it was the standard 4-2-3-1, with Bacca left out. The 4-3-1-2 could be an option against inferior opponents.

21. In the France game, James was in the middle of the three in the 4-2-3-1, as expected. But he drifted all over the field. With Juan Cuadrado injured (his World Cup status is touch-and-go) and Edwin Cardona suspended (he’ll be back), James was Colombia’s only real creative force. The three goals against France came from a fluke, a high press and a penalty. And the goals didn’t come against Australia at all. Despite the famous result in Paris, there are still attacking concerns for Los Cafeteros.

22. Portugal was another team to try two different systems. Andre Silva partnered Cristiano Ronaldo in a come-from-behind 2-1 win over Egypt. Ronaldo played up front alone in a 3-0 loss to the Netherlands. Needless to say, the 4-4-2 from the first game looked much better. It allows Ronaldo to drift to either wing, relieving him of any positional responsibility.

Cristiano Ronaldo and Portugal did not look good against the Netherlands. (Getty)

23. The Portuguese defense is a real worry. Alarm bells might not be going off just yet, because Pepe and Next Big Thing Ruben Dias both missed out due to injury. But the bells are readying themselves. Pepe is 35 anyway. Dias has never been capped. Neither Bruno Alves nor Jose Fonte nor Rolando – who started both friendlies – looks capable of holding down the fort. And there simply aren’t any other options.

24. Poland, like Portugal, tried both its systems, a 4-4-2 and a 4-2-3-1. Unlike Portugal, the 4-2-3-1 looked better – to the tune of a 2-0 halftime lead over South Korea, at which point Robert Lewandowski was substituted. We never got to see Lewandowski and Arkadiusz Milik together, though.

25. Peru used two slightly different alignments, and looked awesome in both. Both were sub-optimal due to Paolo Guerrero’s absence, but it hardly mattered. Two-goal wins over Croatia and Iceland re-affirmed the legitimacy of an impressive qualifying run.

26. South Korea tried two different formations. Both were, uh … not great! One lost to Northern Ireland, the other to Poland. Whereas some underdogs lack talent but make up for it with a defined and refined tactical approach, the Koreans leave a lot to be desired in both areas.

27. Senegal, after riding a 4-3-3 to qualification, rolled out a new-look, three-at-the-back system. It didn’t yield results, but wasn’t weaponized with a first-choice 11 just yet. Something to watch in May.

28. Panama, similarly, strayed from the formation that got it to its first ever World Cup. It went to a 5-4-1 of sorts. And, well, it got smashed by an understrength Switzerland squad, 6-0. Oof.

29. It only lost to Denmark 1-0, though! And held its own with 11 men until Blas Perez got a red card! And – wait … that’s not really something to celebrate, is it?

30. Breaking news: Egypt is going to be very reliant on Mo Salah. (I know, shocking.) It was outplayed by Portugal, but held a 90th-minute lead against the run of play thanks to a Salah strike. And then without the Liverpool forward, it lost to Greece.

31. Japan was without a few big names – some due to injury, some by choice – and looked like a team caught in between two generations of players at the worst possible time. Friendly results don’t matter, but a draw against Mali and a loss to Ukraine don’t exactly foretell of future success.

32. Saudi Arabia was built to qualify for a World Cup against the odds. It decidedly was not built to even tread water once it gets to Russia. It’s essentially an all-star team from the Saudi domestic league, with 18 of 28 players in the March squad coming from last season’s top two clubs – clubs accustomed to playing with the ball, on the front foot. The roster is full of small, technical players. That roster can carry you through a weak Asian qualifying circuit. But it offered very little resistance against Belgium in a friendly, and could be completely overwhelmed in Russia.

– – – – – – –

Henry Bushnell covers global soccer, and occasionally other ball games, for Yahoo Sports. Have a tip? Question? Comment? Email him at or follow him on Twitter @HenryBushnell.

  • Israeli forces wound dozens of Palestinians at Gaza border protest

    Israeli forces wound dozens of Palestinians at Gaza border protest

    GAZA (Reuters) - Israeli soldiers shot and wounded 77 Palestinians during protests near the Gaza border on Friday, the Gaza Health Ministry said.

  • Russia to send more military trainers, equipment to Central African Republic

    Russia to send more military trainers, equipment to Central African Republic

    Russia said on Friday it planned to send additional military equipment to Central African Republic (CAR) and deploy 60 more instructors to train the country's armed forces, escalating its most significant military foray in Africa in decades. Russia donated hundreds of weapons and sent 175 trainers

  • EU signs Singapore trade deal, urges China to open up

    EU signs Singapore trade deal, urges China to open up

    The European Union signed a free-trade deal with Singapore at a summit with Asian leaders on Friday and pressed China to allow greater foreign investment in its economy, but ran into familiar resistance from Beijing over state subsidies. At a biennial Asia-Europe Meeting bringing together leaders representing

  • Top EU court tells Poland to stop Supreme Court overhaul, reinstate judges

    Top EU court tells Poland to stop Supreme Court overhaul, reinstate judges

    The European Union's top court ordered Poland on Friday to suspend a law forcing some of country's Supreme Court judges into early retirement, and reinstate those who have already been dismissed. The injunction, issued by the European Court of Justice, marks a new phase in an investigation by

  • Comoros authorities sign pact to end standoff on island

    Comoros authorities sign pact to end standoff on island

    Five days of clashes between protesters and police in Comoros' Anjouan island have subsided after the national government, local authorities and the Anjouan capital Mutsamudu signed an accord aimed at ending the violence, officials said on Friday. Anjouan has been shaken by clashes pitting security

  • Romania’s tug of war over rule of law nears the line

    Romania’s tug of war over rule of law nears the line

    A power struggle between Romania's government and judiciary is reaching a tipping point that risks driving a new wedge between the European Union and its eastern members over democratic standards. Justice Minister Tudorel Toader has said he will soon decide the future of the prosecutor general,

  • US, S. Korea suspend additional military exercise: Pentagon
    AFP News

    US, S. Korea suspend additional military exercise: Pentagon

    US Defense Secretary Jim Mattis and his South Korean counterpart Jeong Kyeong-doo have canceled the "Vigilant Ace" military exercise that was slated for December, a Pentagon spokeswoman said Friday. The two officials agreed to suspend the drill to "give the diplomatic process" with

  • EU, Cambodia talks fail to end trade sanction threat - Mogherini

    EU, Cambodia talks fail to end trade sanction threat - Mogherini

    BRUSSELS (Reuters) - Cambodia failed on Friday to reassure the European Union it will address democratic and human right issues that have put its trade preferences with the bloc at risk, EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini said after a summit with Asian leaders.

  • EU top court orders Poland to suspend Supreme Court retirements
    AFP News

    EU top court orders Poland to suspend Supreme Court retirements

    The European Union's top court on Friday ordered Poland to "immediately suspend" its decision to lower the retirement age of its Supreme Court judges, which it said threatens judicial independence. The decision is the latest salvo in a bitter battle over sweeping judicial changes introduced

  • China's Cosco to pump more money into Piraeus development
    AFP News

    China's Cosco to pump more money into Piraeus development

    Chinese shipping giant Cosco on Friday said it has ambitious plans for the Greek port of Piraeus, including boosting already-bustling container and car piers and a five-star hotel expansion. "We do our best to improve the infrastructure to give a good image of our port," Piraeus port authority

  • Crimea mourns victims of mass shooting

    Crimea mourns victims of mass shooting

    Hundreds of residents in the Crimean port city of Kerch commemorated on Friday the victims of a college mass shooting in which an armed teenager killed 20 people, mostly his fellow pupils, and injured dozens more. The suspected attacker was found dead from a self-inflicted gunshot wound after Wednesday

  • Germany orders recall of 73,000 Opel diesels
    AFP Relax

    Germany orders recall of 73,000 Opel diesels

    Germany's KBA transport authority said Friday it had ordered carmaker Opel to recall 73,000 diesel vehicles worldwide that were configured to fool regulatory emissions tests. The authority "ordered an obligatory recall on October 17" for Opel Insignia, Cascada and Zafira diesels meeting

  • Turkey widens Khashoggi search, quizzes consulate staff
    AFP News

    Turkey widens Khashoggi search, quizzes consulate staff

    Turkey on Friday widened the investigation into the disappearance of journalist Jamal Khashoggi after his visit to the Saudi consulate, searching a forest in the city and interviewing the mission's staff. Ankara denied giving any audio recording to US officials from the investigation about Khashoggi

  • New moon: China to launch lunar lighting in outer space
    AFP Relax

    New moon: China to launch lunar lighting in outer space

    China is planning to launch its own 'artificial moon' by 2020 to replace streetlamps and lower electricity costs in urban areas, state media reported Friday. Chengdu, a city in southwestern Sichuan province, is developing "illumination satellites" which will shine in tandem with the

  • Comoros opposition sign government deal after clashes
    AFP News

    Comoros opposition sign government deal after clashes

    The Comoros government and main opposition on Friday signed a deal that could end the latest bout of instability to rock the Indian Ocean nation after violence flared on Anjouan island. Security forces and rebels opposed to President Azali Assoumani have fought in the narrow streets of the medina quarter

  • U.S. general says he may not have been target of Kandahar attack

    U.S. general says he may not have been target of Kandahar attack

    KABUL/PESHAWAR, Pakistan (Reuters) - The top U.S. general in Afghanistan said on Friday he did not believe he was the target of an attack that killed the powerful police chief of Kandahar, and Afghan officials said the gunman may have deliberately avoided hitting him. The gunman assassinated the police

  • Penang landslide: We told you so, experts tell state gov't
    New Straits Times

    Penang landslide: We told you so, experts tell state gov't

    GEORGE TOWN: “How many more innocent lives must we lose before serious measures are taken by the state to prevent hillslope tragedies?” This was the immediate response of Sahabat Alam Malaysia (Sam) honorary secretary R. Meenakshi following a landslide at the Bukit Kukus paired-road project site this

  • If you whisper, so will Alexa
    AFP Relax

    If you whisper, so will Alexa

    As announced at the September hardware event, Alexa is gaining the ability to whisper, and Amazon has just  confirmed to Engadget that the feature is already available to US users. When you've just spent hours trying to get your baby to fall asleep and finally manage it, the last thing you need

  • Cautious Turkey treads warily in Khashoggi case
    AFP News

    Cautious Turkey treads warily in Khashoggi case

    Turkey is seeking to strike a fine balance in the controversy over the disappearance of Saudi journalist Jamal Khashoggi, aware the aftermath could boost its economy and diplomatic hand but prove highly damaging if the case is mishandled. The probe strikes at the heart of one of Turkey's most sensitive

  • Tanzanian police say driver identified in billionaire kidnapping
    AFP News

    Tanzanian police say driver identified in billionaire kidnapping

    Tanzanian police said Friday they had identified the driver of a vehicle used in the kidnapping of Tanzanian billionaire Mohammed Dewji, who was snatched over a week ago. Dewji, 43, who is considered Africa's youngest billionaire, was seized by gunmen as he entered a hotel gym in Tanzania's

  • The Funniest Tweets From Parents This Week (Oct. 13-19)

    The Funniest Tweets From Parents This Week (Oct. 13-19)

    Kids may say the darndest things, but parents tweet about them in the funniest

  • Grandmother dies hours after being mowed down by bus in Johor
    Malay Mail

    Grandmother dies hours after being mowed down by bus in Johor

    JOHOR BARU, Oct 19 — The 80-year-old grandmother, who was run over by an express bus at the Larkin Sentral Public Transportation Terminal here today, has died from her injuries. The victim,...

  • Giorgio says Armani to stay independent
    AFP Relax

    Giorgio says Armani to stay independent

    Italian fashion house Armani will stay independent, its founder and designer Giorgio Armani in an interview published Friday on business website Milano Finanza. "I have always believed that economic independence was the fundamental principle to work in full freedom," said Armani. The 84-year-old

  • EU top court orders Poland to suspend Supreme Court retirements
    AFP News

    EU top court orders Poland to suspend Supreme Court retirements

    The European Union's top court on Friday ordered Poland to "immediately suspend" its decision to lower the retirement age of its Supreme Court judges, which it said threatens judicial independence. The European Commission, the bloc's executive arm, last month took Poland's rightwing

  • Russia and Uzbekistan launch work on nuclear power plant

    Russia and Uzbekistan launch work on nuclear power plant

    Russia and Uzbekistan began preliminary work on Friday on the first Uzbek nuclear power plant, a project Moscow estimates will cost $11 billion. The plant, to be largely financed by a soft loan from Russia, will allow Uzbekistan to use more of its natural gas for other purposes such as chemicals production