Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

 

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SingaporeScene

    Minister's 'town hall' visit to condo disappoints

    MICA Minister, Lui Tuck Yew, is also MP for Tanjong Pagar GRC. (AFP file photo)MICA Minister, Lui Tuck Yew, is also MP for Tanjong Pagar GRC. (AFP file photo)

    THE MR MIYAGI COLUMN

    I received a letter on Friday, 15 April 2011, from our condominium management. I thought it was probably about them fogging the place again and reminding us to close our windows.

    The last time they fogged without telling us, some of us chucked a fit and said they should always tell us when something's going down.

    It wasn't about fogging that the letter was trying to tell the residents of our small condo, but the impending visit of one of our Members of Parliament (MPs), the Minister for Information, Communications and the Arts, Rear Admiral Lui Tuck Yew.

    The letter said there would be a "simple tea reception" served while Minister Lui was to speak and listen to the residents from 7:30pm on Saturday, so that he could "get to know the residents better and to seek their views and suggestions on local and national issues".

    My wife and I were really excited. The only visit by government agents and officials we ever had were regular ones by the anti-mosquito-breeding squad of the National Environmental Agency (NEA), and that was only because we had informed them two years earlier that our son suffered a bout of dengue.

    Also, this was, after all, the Minister who said we did not need Freedom of Information legislation, because "the government already puts up a lot of information on its websites".

    This was the Minister whose subordinate body, the National Arts Council, cut local theatre company Wild Rice's annual grant in 2010 by $20,000, because it "promoted alternative lifestyles, were critical of government policies and satirised political leaders". The move is now known in theatre circles as "Gahmen say Tuck Yew to the Arts".

    This was the Minister who labelled the discontent and negative opinions regarding Tin Pei Ling's candidacy as "noise".

    We had to meet him.

    We didn't harbour any unrealistic hopes, of course. Our condo consists of three blocks of three-storey walk-up apartments, and we were never holding out for lifts or covered walkways (though the owners are waiting for the elusive en-bloc offer).

    My wife and I spent a few hours thinking of what national and local issues to talk to our Minister about. This was our chance to tell him our troubles, even though we could always just pick up our phones or computers to email him.

    The idea of a town hall-like meeting excited me, even if for our condo, the town hall was going to be the al-fresco (read: damn hot) common area by the poolside. What would people say? What did our neighbours worry about? Would anyone heckle the Minister and ask him about his pay, we wondered.

    We planned our evening to finish dinner by 7pm, bring the dog down for his pee and poo, and then spruce up a bit (wipe crumbs and other food debris off our son's face) and take a nice walk down to the poolside to meet with Minister Lui.

    Hopes dashed

    Like many best-laid plans, this was dashed when the Minister and some of his entourage arrived at 7:10 and milled along the driveway to the open car park. They were chatting among themselves, presumably wondering where to begin because our condo's security guard had already gone home for the day, and wasn't able to tell the parliamentarian's people which block was which. They had, to my disappointment, opted for a door-stop visit instead of a townhall-like meeting.

    (In case you're wondering, our condo's "security guard" "works" from 7am to 5pm on weekdays and 8am to 4pm on weekends)

    I intercepted the group on our stairwell as I brought Mac, our nervous adopted Jack Russell Terrier, to water the plants. I said "hi" assertively, causing a few of what must have been about eight people to scramble through their clipboards, before I volunteered which unit my wife, son, dog, cat and I lived in.

    The Minister was then guided to where I was, and he introduced himself as the MP for our area before I politely said I had to bring my dog for his own walkabout before he peed all over the PAP entourage.

    The Minister said, "If he has to go, he has to go!"

    I was relieved that Mac didn't do what some of our friends are familiar with -- this dog will pee on you just to show how much he loves / hates / is scared by / is in love with you -- and came back in a few minutes, in time to see how much progress the Minister had made in our block. No one else seemed to be at home, so I managed to squeeze in some  conversation with the Minister.

    In less than a minute, he asked me how many times a day I needed to walk Mac, I said twice, then he told me he once had a dog, a white samoyed, which died at age 6 and a half, and that it was very unusual. Then he asked what concerns I had living within this compound, and I said something to the effect of us having "some municipal issues (the dengue problem) which we have taken into our own hands (calling NEA)".

    And that was that.

    It was all over in a flash. I wasn't sure if he meant 6.5 dog or human years, or whether it was unusual because it died at 6.5 years or that it was an unusual dog, or that it was his opinion that the white samoyed, as a breed, was unusual. I didn't even get the dog's name.

    By 7:39pm the Minister and his entourage had done their doorstop round and left our compound, walking down the quiet street towards the neighbouring houses and apartments. I'm sure if no one from our condo had spoken about the need for brighter street lights in our area, he'd have figured it out.

    Pressed in my hand was a name card from the Minister, complete with a photo of him, and the address and timing of "MP Meet-the-People Session" at the local branch office. I didn't even remember him handing me the card. It will have pride of place on my fridge door, alongside other contractors' calling cards. I might mistake it for an electrician's though, what with the logo and all.

    Can't fault them for trying to make a fist of it. It's your turn, opposition candidates. Come visit our condo, because I think we still have food from the "tea-reception" they planned.

    Benjamin "Mr Miyagi" Lee writes across all media except where it can be construed as graffiti. More of him on twitter @miyagi and http://miyagi.sg

    Follow Yahoo! News on Twitter and become a fan on Facebook.

    This article is published by Yahoo! Southeast Asia Pte. Ltd., 60 Anson Road #13-01 Mapletree Anson, Singapore, 079914.

     

    420 comments

    • Allelujah!  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Please all of you, I urge you, do stay united, do stay true to your words. Not just online venting only. Not just NATO only. PAP MPs are going to unleash an onslaught of threatens and dangling carrots all over the place..all the way till 7 May. I am not sure how many people here really mean it. By the time 7 May comes, are you all going to still vote for Oppositions or succumb to PAP's threats and tempts YET AGAIN.

      They are going to threaten your housing. They are going to threaten your jobs. They are going to threaten your family and future in Singapore. But do you really think that Singapore's future is going to suffer if opposition MPs are voted in?

      I think all of us must have faith! We are survivors! Not weakling that only depend on our PAP government always! When you want transformation, you need revolution!

      How can MM ask us not to rock the boat when things are going on smoothly?? Is he encouraging us to just guai guai be a good citizen and be a YES-man??

      STAY STRONG! DON'T SURRENDER TO PAP'S THREAT!
      • S'porean Lim 1 year 1 month ago
        I am a patriot, & I will do what is best for Singapore : ) Count on me Singapore : ) No amount of fear mongering is going to change my vote : )
      • Augustine 1 year 1 month ago
        Yessssssssssss, stay stronggggggggggg
      • siaozabo 1 year 1 month ago
        my dear, it is easy to say what you said... however, even if these 500 commentors and netizens are gonna vote for the opposition, it is still not enough! there are 2 million voters right now!!! let us say, the netizens here ask their parents to vote for the opposition, that is still only 1500!!! still not enough!!! although we are anticipating the opposition to win one or two GRCs, personally, i am still skeptical... don't be surprised that the results are different from what we are anticipating... PAP still won...
    • hob  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Maybe I can just share how a different country does it, with examples of 2 leaders in that country who are much more senior than our minister for MICA.

      Qiu He is the Party Secretary for Kunming, capital city of Yunnan province. When he was first appointed to the post of the vice mayor of Suqian City, a poor backward area of the wealthy Jiangsu province in 1996, the first thing he did was to walk the ground of the 5 million strong city (sounds familiar?). Incognito, without an entourage. On foot from his county office. Without the massive cleanup effort preceding his visit, he saw the true picture of the city he had to look after - piles of garbage lying around. Kind of like East Coast Parkway or the void decks of some HDB blocks after a long weekend isn't it?

      When Hu Jintao, president of China, visited the same county years later - because he insisted on visiting the poorest county in Jiangsu and not the showcase cities - he did so with NO entourage and only a few close aides, despite concerns about security. He went to a sports shop and grocery shop to ask about prices, and visited another 2 more shops, staying almost an hour in the last one, to talk to the residents of the county. And to end it off, he took a road tour of the county IN A VAN, instead of heading straight back to the hotel.

      Now this is what I call learning about the ground first-hand. In a country as vast as China, the president visits the people, instead of asking the people to look for him at some specially arranged session. These 2 individuals are what I call leaders, who govern a population and land mass greater than ours, and still do not make a ham-fisted job of it.

      I don't think they earn as much as our minister though. I wonder why? And oh, by the way, they don't have elections every 5 years in China like we do.
      • KenluckyL 1 year 1 month ago
        In China, their leaders are well respected because they really serves the people and wanted the best for their country. Here, the leaders serves for the sole objective of higher pay, for the country, uuurrmmm, "skeptical" is the one word I would use for our new leaders. Do you think they really bother to look into every aspect of the happenings around here? That's why they created this thing call the RC and NC to let these volunteers (many negative people term them as bootlickers) do the job instead.
      • WandaGirl 1 year 1 month ago
        Because they're communist country, the ppl don't get to vote for the leaders at the higher levels. But within each province or village, the ppl do get to vote yearly still. This was told to me by a Chinese national.
      • ESAD 1 year 1 month ago
        This can NEVER happen here, coz they think they are the ELITE & we are untouchable, might as well introduce caste system!
    • Solvent  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Am not letting this guy win in my area this time.. eleven years never see him,, so many issues but he never bothered.. now he comes to beg for votes.. i also cannot be bothered.. i do not know who the opposition is in my area but somehow i am already liking them cause i dont like this coconut.. very rude face actually.
      • nigel 1 year 1 month ago
        hahahaa, well said! Last min then go around show face and pretend pretend...@#$%!
    • 马沙老大  •  1 year 1 month ago
      I live in a HDB where the transport minister is our MP... guess what, we have serious car parking problem at our block and he is unable to solve it.

      If the transport minister can't even solve his own residents' car parking problem, how he can solve the country's transportation problem???
      • j.wee 1 year 1 month ago
        Easy. Just sweep it underneath the carpet.
      • Fair Comments 1 year 1 month ago
        Raymond Lim just played his WAYANG & collect his big paycheck every month. That's how he solves problems.
      • Jiat Lat 1 year 1 month ago
        He is very quiet now, he knows that once he opens his mouth his ministry will be attacked, problem like COE, ERP, crowded trains and buses, transport price increased etc etc.
    • MYFoot  •  1 year 1 month ago
      I am a 70 year old man and I have seen and been through David Marshall, Lim Yew Hock and PAP Governments. PAP was the best of the worst at that time. The heroes like Toh Chin Chye, Rajaratnam, Hon Swee Sen, Goh Keng Swee who really cared for Singapore and Singaporeans have either kicked the bucket or had been kicked out by the tyrant. The PAP has lost its direction after genX ministers with their fat incomes came up with their bright ideas on redefining progress which favors their elite class leaving only the crumbs for us poor average Singaporeans calling them growth package. As a senior citizens we find ourselves being left so far behind that we now have to wash toilets, clear tables at hawker centers to survive. You genX Singaporeans should make sure that 50 years from now you do not end up like us senior citizens of today. We were just as excited when we were voting for the first time, but we only realized how bad our choice was decades later. So vote wisely to have fair representation in Parliament for your voices to be heard and taken seriously. It is about time to contain the arrogance of the genX ministers. Good Luck.
      • slumberland 1 year 1 month ago
        I share your sentiments absolutely. I am in my late 70s and I know the frustration you have when EVERTHING goes UP and we with whatever savings we had, see our small well getting lower and lower. Who cares about us? The goverrnent? Think again. When a minister gets over a million a year, what is a price increase of 50 to 100 per cent for the basics in life matter? Its affordable, they say. Dont blame the GenX. They have nothing to do with it. Its the guys we put in parliament.
      • objective 1 year 1 month ago
        I am glad you uncles admit your mistakes and it is really high time to contain their arrogance.thanks
      • Lason 1 year 1 month ago
        Uncles, please share with all you friends and people you meet. Ask them to vote for oppositions. We don't want to continue suffering like this. Together we will see a better tomorrow and for our kids' future.
    • Anson Be  •  1 year 1 month ago
      this is the PAP style
      Just before Election: PAP's Servant of the people:
      After Election: PAP's Servant: the people.
      so as servants, u pay GST, affordable HDB, ERP...
      So remember is this what you want?
    • COI  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Thanks, Mr. Miyagi. Your article is SO rip roaring funny! I sure hope the Admiral gets a copy of this from one of his clipboard minions.

      If it is not too late, please nominate Mac as an independent candidate. For sure myself and all whom I know will stand (far, lest he loves / hates / is scared by / is in love) behind him with our votes!

      HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
    • ComeAndGo  •  1 year 1 month ago
      My experiences with PAP MPs visits was they come late and leave early. Previously I was involved in some performances for CCs and festive seasons events where the MP for that constituency is the VIP. I notived they always turned up late, sat through some 20 minutes or so and left unannounced where the whole event could be more than an hour.

      Are they really that busy? Don't they set time aside for the community they serving in events under their constituency? I was naived to expect them to sit through or mingle with the performers or audience. The only thing the MPs did are to address everyone on stage with a few minutes talk, that's all.

      Now I have come to terms and don't expect too much. It seems they are servants during GE but once voted, they behaved like kings.
    • all  •  1 year 1 month ago
      I stayed in Tajong Pagar GRC for 11 years and I have yet to see a MP coming over to enquire about our well-being. Maybe when they need our votes ...
    • Raman V  •  1 year 1 month ago
      It is not surprising for PAP Ministers and MPs to behave like that becos that is their hallmark and style which has been there ever since they came to power. They live in ivory towers and to them elections are PAP family matters. They will blast whatever comes to their mind thinking that they are the only ones who know-all and the rest of Singaporeans are ignorant and illiterate.

      The PAP Ministers and MPs are always far and out of touch with the people. It is the media that makes them look as if they are near. They live in their own cliques srrounded by security men.

      As long as the PAP will be in power without sizeable opposition, this is going to carry on. Once in five years they will come to the people. Then they will forget you for the next 5 years.

      It is their trademark to criticise the opposition candidates and hit them below the belt and to act as if they are angels. They will pick on opposition's personal weaknesses and character as if they are all perfect. But when anyone criticises their candidates, they will give us a sermon and advise that we should not interfere into their candidates personality and should only talk on policies and issues.

      So it is high time that Singaporeans resolve to elect at least 20 qualified and suitable opposition candidates to ahve an alternative voice in the parliament and to represent us effectively.

      If we do not start with this election since so many credible, qualified and sincere opposition candidates are contesting to choose from, we are never going to make it. If we do not help ourselves, no body, even God cannot help us.

      Please think seriously what will happen if there are approx 20 opposition MPs and what are the likely damages? NONE WHATSOEVER. On the contrary, we can sow the seed for an effective two party system and prepare the opposition to be on standby to step in when the time comes. The opposition MPs will be able to have an on-the-job training and hand-on to become effective MPs just like the PAP MPs. Over a period of time, the opposition MPs can be better than the PAP MPs since they have the people at heart and which is why they take very big risks to contest elections under the opposition. As understood, the PAP MPs hardly take any risks becos in most cases they enter the parliament thru the backdoors of GRCs without any credentials and experience with the help of the Ministers. For PAP candidates, it is better job, better pay and better status in society.

      SO, SINGAPOREANS PLEASE WAKE UP AFTER ALMOST 5 DECADES AND LET US START THE BALL ROLLING TO PUT IN MORE AND SIZEABLE ABLE OPPOSITION MPs INTO PARLIAMENT.
    • Disappointed Me  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Fellow Singapoeans,

      I've only realised this morning that I've overlooked the summon to attend to Subordinate Court hearing against me schedule a week ago. No valid excuse but the notice was served to me end December last year and I've been jobless since Aug and were desperated and penniless. I've only managed to find a job end Mar this year thru recommendation from a friend.

      Very worried and panicky, I went to my Bishan Constituency office this afternoon and realised that the meet-the-people (MTP) sessons are cancelled till 10 May. But on its notice board, a separate Notice informing residents that *As for April 2008, Free Legal advice is available every 2nd of 4th Tuesday of every month. Registration starts at 07.30pm".

      Feeling more relieved, I reached the Bishan Constituency office at Block 213 Bishan St22 at 07:30pm thinking that I'll be given helped.

      The small office was packed with 6-7 people and I was very sure everyone of them saw me standing right in front of the door. Only after 5min, one of the staff asked me my purpose and replied me that no MTP no legal advice.

      Then Mr. Zainudin Nordin, Mayor of Central Singapore District and MP for Bishan-Toa Payoh GRC walked out of his office with his bag. I was so glad to see him thinking that he's my saviour.

      But Mr. Zainudin told me the same thing "no MTP, no legal advice." I then brought him to his noitce board and shown him what were displaced there.

      To my biggest surprise!!! He turned around and walked toward the multi-storey car park without saying a word.

      I waited in the constituency office for another 10 min before another staff asked me my purpose but also gave me the same answer.

      Disappointed, I left the office knowing very well who can serve the people better....
      MR ZAINUDIN NORDIN, MAYOR OF CENTRAL SINGAPORE DISTRICT AND MP FOR BISHAN-TOA PAYOH GRC ral
    • Anson Be  •  1 year 1 month ago
      well, at least he patronised you...see another report where he brush off the citizen totally...so much for people's servant...
      time to reject PAP'sSingapore and vote for Singaporean'sSinagapore.Vote for alternative parties.
      Make PAP an opposition party when it first started.
    • karen  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Ha.....during the election period, you will encounter the same scenario for the MP visiting your condo (once and only once) and asking the same question without action taken . This monkey show will repeat for the subsequent election. There is nothing new.
    • Asia Direction  •  1 year 1 month ago
      I advocated and always told my employees that if you don't look after your customers some one will. So, whoever voted into office please look after your voters otherwise some one will.
      Have a nice day ahead!
    • DRAGON  •  1 year 1 month ago
      this is the PAP style of visiting . Very 5 years I will recieve the same saying that our MP will visit you and you can tell him your concern. i Remenber one year when my MP came to my house so that i can talk to him on the issue i am concerning about. His so cal asistants quickly shake my hand and say thank and move on to otehr places. From then on i never accept any visit of and MP to my house again.
    • Zull  •  1 year 1 month ago
      I wonder...... all this chat..... is it for real...... every 5 years there is an election. As the day draws nearer, everyone talks about it and everyone hates PAP so so much. I talk to the taxi driver, bus driver, the cleaner that sweeps your block everyday, the uncle at the coffee shop(working there or having a cup of coffee)and even the people at the market, they all hate PAP so much and YET EVERY ELECTION they WON!!!!!!!! Amaze me.............

      Is it NATO like someone said, is it something is going on behind close doors or is it kaylong.....
    • david  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Look who is talking. Went he was introduce as a new PAP candidate he said he wanted to
      help the POOR cause of his poor up bringing.
      Look at him today too busy counting his millions and thinking how to make billions
      have forgeton the poor.
      Lui Tuch Yee What have you done for the less fortunite
    • Local Ah Neh  •  1 year 1 month ago
      CHANGE??????? YES WE CAN.
      HOW?
      BY VOTING OPPOSITION
    • 4Justice  •  1 year 1 month ago
      hey we already know their leadership style very well. they appear only when there are oppositions contesting their wards every 5 years. no contest no show. the pappy dogs and their hypocrisy. We seen through them ages ago but there are still some die hard lackeys who are afraid to upset the apple cart. These are the cowards who are afraid of change and they are the real losers in the world.
    • Sg Ge  •  1 year 1 month ago
      PAP should visit Florida (Hougang) and Simsvile condo. Its like Bollywood.

      And my friend's condo at Aston Mansions (Lor 42 Geylang), mostly China men or PRC.

      Although the value of the house went up but I cannot call my house a home anymore.

      Going home is like going to some backward city in China or India. Really sad.

    Featured Blog Posts

    Blog Authors / Profiles