Alan Cumming Teases the 'Group Turns and Piles' on 'Cutesy Bachelor' Peter Weber on “The Traitors” (Exclusive)

The host of the Peacock competition tells PEOPLE the pilot "has done incredibly well, but he's also forgotten, I think, that this show is called 'The Traitors'"

Peter Weber has played a strong game so far on The Traitors season 2, leading the banishments of Traitors Dan Gheesling and Parvati Shallow while zeroing in on third and final (for now) Traitor Phaedra Parks.

But the leader of the Most Faithful of the Faithful, as he's come to be known among the cast, might have a tough road ahead according to host Alan Cumming.

“Peter's trajectory in the show is fascinating because it shows this whole theory that gamers from shows like Survivor and Big Brother and everything are going to be much more predisposed to be good in the show; that's clearly not true,” Cumming, 59, tells PEOPLE in this week’s issue. “Peter being the cutesy Bachelor has kind of worked it all out and was really kind of strategizing in a really amazing way.”

Related: The Traitors Season 2: Who Has Been Banished, Who Has Been Murdered So Far?

The former Bachelor, 32, turned down an invite to become a Traitor after the banishment of Gheesling, 40. Weber explained on Nick Viall’s The Viall Files podcast that he didn't accept the offer because he “was feeling so good about where we [the Faithfuls] were at in the game” and didn’t want to “put a wrench in it at that moment." The pilot also didn’t think he “was going to be able to keep the suspicion off” if he changed his gameplay up at that point in the competition and believes he would’ve “felt like absolute s---” turning on the other Faithfuls in the end, like Cirie Fields did in season 1 to win the game.

Related: The Traitors Promises 'Chaos' and 'Diabolical Twists' in Season 2 Trailer: 'Hold on to Your Kilts, Dearies'

On last week’s episode, Weber joined Trishelle Cannatella in pivoting from going after Shallow, 41, to targeting Parks, 50. He even tried to strike up a deal to work with the Survivor winner. But ultimately, the rest of the group wanted to get rid of Shallow — and found Weber’s change of heart suspicious.

Related: Survivor's Parvati Shallow Was 'Jazzed' to Have 'More Than Just 1 Old Pair of Underwear' on The Traitors

Accordingly, Cumming speculates that Weber now has a target on his back.

“One of the things about this show is it reminds me a bit of Lord of the Flies, the whole group turns and piles on someone. And maybe that's going to happen to Peter,” the Tony Award winner tells PEOPLE. “I think he has done incredibly well, but he's also forgotten I think that this show is called The Traitors."

Still, Cumming acknowledges the unpredictability of the game. “As soon as you think, ‘Oh, that's happened,’ then something else happens and it's just so fascinating,” he says. “And people just disappear in the night.”

For more on Alan Cumming, pick up the latest issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands Friday, or subscribe here.

Cumming also squashed any hopes Traitors fans have of a showmance between Parks and Chris “CT” Tamburello. “I think there's as much chance of a romance between CT and Phaedra as there's between me and CT or me and Phaedra, actually,” the Scottish actor says. “But they're a funny little odd couple and they're very affectionate.” 

Related: Chris 'CT' Tamburello and His Challenge Costars Appreciated Being 'with People Our Age’ on The Traitors

Along with getting to try out bold, tartan-heavy fashion looks, Cumming likes hosting The Traitors because it mirrors his love of live performance in some ways.

“In a way, the contestants are my audience,” he says. “I make an entrance or I have an effect and want to say something dramatic, and I feel that it's working because of their reaction.”

Though Cumming says he would pick live performance “if I had a gun to my head and I had to choose” between TV, movies and theater, he enjoys doing it all right now.

“I've gone back and forth between all sorts of mediums and genres all my career. And I think it's one of the things that I enjoy most is this sort of eclecticism of that and the fact that each time you come to a new thing, you come to it fresh and excited to do it because you've been doing something else for a while,” he continues. “Each thing helps me be more interested in the other.”

Related: Alan Cumming on Owning His Bisexuality and the 'Blessing' of Not Having Kids in His First Marriage (Exclusive)

Cumming’s stayed interested in The Traitors, as he’ll be back as host for the reality show’s upcoming third season. Just don’t slide into his DMs trying to get on the show.

“There are proper channels to go through in these things,” the four-time Emmy nominee says. “When people try to contact me through DMs, I sort of think, I don't have to answer you because this is not the proper channels. I get it, I'm the host of the show. On my Instagram, I stopped looking because there was just so many random people. And I think, That's not my job.“

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

New episodes of The Traitors drop Thursdays at 9 p.m. ET on Peacock.

For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!

Read the original article on People.