WP’s margin of victory ‘devastating’ for PAP: analysts

A sombre Dr Koh and DPM Teo at the PAP post election press conference

Political observers say the Workers Party’s win in Punggol East has dealt a huge blow to the PAP and indicates rapidly growing resentment on the ground.

Describing PAP’s loss as "devastating" for the party, associate professor Bridget Welsh said that it showed a "massive downturn in support".

“It is not just about demographics but a national erosion of support sustained over the last four elections. The trends indicate that the PAP is in deep trouble – it’s efforts to win over the electorate are not working,” said Welsh, who is from Singapore Management University’s Political Science faculty.

“This is more than a wake-up call, it’s a fire alarm.”

In the end, Workers' Party candidate Lee Li Lian finished with 16,038 votes against PAP's Dr Koh Poh Koon’s 12,856 to become the first female opposition member to win a single member constituency since 1965.

[VIDEO: PAP responds to loss in Punggol East]

Former Nominated Member of Parliament Siew Kum Hong was also surprised at the nearly 11 per cent winning margin, saying that it sent out a clear message that the ground was shifting – and not in favour of the PAP.

“The size of the margin emphasises how unhappy voters continue to be. It’s clear that voters continue to be angry about issues like housing prices, public transport, COE prices, and the AIM issue,” he said.

He admitted that he had thought it would be too close to call but "the size of the swing was a surprise”, considering that WP's Lee Li Lian managed only 41 per cent of votes when she contested the same ward at the 2011 General Elections. 

Eugene Tan, assistant law professor at Singapore Management University, said the "stunning" margin of victory would have surprised the WP itself.

"A 13% increase in votes for the WP in a mere 20 months does suggest that all is not well for the PAP,"  said the current NMP.

'Demographics helped swing votes'

The demographics of Punggol East voters, mostly young families with children, drew crucial votes to the Worker’s Party, said the analysts.

“The fact that the electorate in this constituency is young only highlights the serious gaps the party faces in connecting with the electorate in future. The policy tinkering and elitist materialist approach is not working,” said Welsh.

Tan said many Punggol East residents are also part of the post-independence generation and therefore "less enamoured of the PAP".

"The message of a strong opposition as a safety net appealed strongly. And then there is the by-election effect in which voters were less constrained in their choices because the outcome would not result in any change of government," he added.

On the other hand, Singapore Democratic Alliance Desmond Lim's and and Reform Party K Jeyaretnam's poor vote shares, at 168 and 353 votes respectively, was "not a surprising result" for Siew.

“I think the fact that SDA and RP also contested didn’t make a difference,” he said.

What now?

All three analysts also said PAP will have to have a good, hard think about the policies they have lined up since their poor showing at the General Election in 2011.

“They still have up to three years until the next GE, so there is definitely enough time for them to make a difference. The question is whether they have learnt the right lessons from GE2011 and this by-election,” said Siew, who added that key issues like public housing and transport would have to be tackled and solid policies introduced.

Tan said the PAP had much to do to stem the "political bleeding" and that the ruling party had to find a way to "excite" the voters vis-a-vis their vision and policies for the country.

"How to stop the PAP's political vulnerability from being seen as normal is a key matter that it needs to deal with. Once electoral defeats of the PAP become normalised and are seen as no big deal, then the PAP's political longevity will be severely challenged," cautioned Tan.

WP, on the other hand, will need to step up to make sure that they give their voters what they promises – a louder and alternative voice in Parliament. With Lee joining their ranks, WP will now have a total of nine  representatives -- six from Aljunied and Hougang, one from Punggol East and two NCMPs.

It also "shortened the runway" for the WP to grow to contest in every seat in future elections, said Tan.

“They will have to be more active on issues, and this boost will likely give WP more confidence to set the agenda and engage issues,” said Welsh.

Watch the Workers' Party respond to their historic win:


















































WP responds to surprise Punggol East victoryWP leaders and MP-elect Lee Li Lian respond to the surprise sweeping victory she attained at the 26 January polls in the Punggol East by-election.



Related stories:

Workers' Party takes Punggol East
Devastating loss for PAP: analysts
PICS: WP takes Punggol East
Singapore ruling party hit by fresh poll loss







  • Asian markets head down with Fed rates set to rise more
    News
    AFP News

    Asian markets head down with Fed rates set to rise more

    Asian markets resumed their downtrend on Thursday as investors contemplated more interest rate hikes by the Federal Reserve, while Washington added to China-US frictions and Brexit negotiators struggle to find common ground. The broad rally across world markets in the middle of the week that was fuelled

  • Putin looks for reset with first visit to new Uzbek leader
    News
    AFP News

    Putin looks for reset with first visit to new Uzbek leader

    Russian President Vladimir Putin starts his first state visit to Uzbekistan under new leadership on Thursday as the Kremlin attempts to recalibrate a once thorny relationship with billions of dollars in business deals. The last time Putin jetted off to ex-Soviet Central Asia's most populous republic

  • Did you earn those titles? Kadir Jasin asks Pakatan’s new ‘Datuks’
    News
    Malay Mail

    Did you earn those titles? Kadir Jasin asks Pakatan’s new ‘Datuks’

    KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 18 — Pakatan Harapan (PH) leaders should hold themselves to a higher standard by making sure any state award carrying honorary titles they accept is based on merit, the media and...

  • Peru in danger of losing its national cinchona tree
    News
    AFP News

    Peru in danger of losing its national cinchona tree

    Pre-Columbian people used its bark as a medicine while South American liberator Simon Bolivar adopted it in Peru's coat of arms, but the cinchona tree is facing a battle for survival as vast swathes of forest are chopped down to make way for plantations. "Peru has 20 of the world's 29 cinchona

  • Turkish investigators leave Saudi consulate in Istanbul: witness
    News
    Reuters

    Turkish investigators leave Saudi consulate in Istanbul: witness

    ANKARA (Reuters) - Turkish crime scene investigators left the Saudi consulate in Istanbul after searching the premises and consular vehicles as part of an investigation into missing journalist Jamal Khashoggi, a Reuters witness said on Thursday.

  • Trump reluctant to abandon Riyadh over missing journalist, wants evidence
    News
    Reuters

    Trump reluctant to abandon Riyadh over missing journalist, wants evidence

    ANKARA/WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. President Donald Trump said on Wednesday he did not want to abandon ally Saudi Arabia over the disappearance of a Saudi journalist and has asked for audio recordings Turkish sources say indicate he was killed by Saudi agents. Trump said he was waiting for a full report

  • Canada becomes first major economy to legalize recreational cannabis
    News
    AFP News

    Canada becomes first major economy to legalize recreational cannabis

    Canada on Wednesday became the world's first major economy to fully legalize cannabis, sparking celebrations as the nation embarked on the controversial experiment in drug policy. Throughout the country huge lines outside pot shops snaked around city blocks, cannabis flew off store shelves and government

  • Stephen Colbert Exposes The Ridiculous Truth Behind Donald Trump's Latest 'Science' Boast
    News
    HuffPost

    Stephen Colbert Exposes The Ridiculous Truth Behind Donald Trump's Latest 'Science' Boast

    > TONIGHT: The president Trump-splains climate change. #LSSC

  • Trump denies covering for Saudis on journalist, says truth out soon
    News
    AFP News

    Trump denies covering for Saudis on journalist, says truth out soon

    President Donald Trump on Wednesday denied covering up for ally Saudi Arabia in the suspected murder of a critical journalist and said that he expects to learn the truth about Jamal Khashoggi's fate within days. Trump's comments followed the publication in pro-government Turkish media of allegations

  • Trains crash in Tanjung Malim; ETS and KTM Komuter services disrupted
    News
    New Straits Times

    Trains crash in Tanjung Malim; ETS and KTM Komuter services disrupted

    The cargo train was damaged in the accident at Tanjung Malim station this morning. KTM, in a statement via its Facebook page, said the accident caused about 10 to 15 minutes delay for the north-bound ETS while there was a 20 to 30 minutes delay for the Komuter on Tanjung Malim-Kepong route.

  • Asia-Pacific finance ministers fret over US-China spat
    News
    AFP News

    Asia-Pacific finance ministers fret over US-China spat

    The trade spat between the world's two largest economies -- China and the United States -- is imperilling the entire Asia-Pacific, regional finance ministers have warned. In a statement, finance ministers meeting in Port Moresby said risks to the global economy had increased thanks to "heightened

  • Honduran migrants defy Trump to continue long march north
    News
    AFP News

    Honduran migrants defy Trump to continue long march north

    Thousands of Honduran migrants marched north Wednesday in a bold attempt to reach the United States, defying threats from US President Donald Trump to stop aid to countries that let them pass. Trump -- who took aim at Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador on Tuesday -- kept up his attacks on the march

  • Power, phone outages hamper hurricane recovery one week after storm
    News
    Reuters

    Power, phone outages hamper hurricane recovery one week after storm

    A week after Hurricane Michael battered Florida's Gulf Coast with record fury, the full extent of devastation and loss of life remained unclear on Wednesday, as disruptions to phone, power and transportation systems hindered the disaster recovery. At least 30 people were killed, according to local

  • News
    Reuters

    McConnell says Senate Republicans might revisit Obamacare repeal

    In a forecast of 2019 policy goals tempered by uncertainty about who would win the congressional elections, McConnell blamed social programs, such as Social Security and Medicare, for the fast-rising national debt. On Nov. 6, Americans will vote for candidates for the Senate and the House of Representatives

  • Rosmah to meet cops again next Thursday?
    News
    Malay Mail

    Rosmah to meet cops again next Thursday?

    KUALA LUMPUR, Oct 18 — The wife of former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak has been served a police notice to present herself at the Bukit Aman Commercial Crimes Investigations Department’s...

  • Military men on the threshold of taking power again in Brazil
    News
    AFP News

    Military men on the threshold of taking power again in Brazil

    More than three decades after the end of military dictatorship, army men look to be on the threshold of returning to power in Brazil, this time through elections in a crime-ridden country whose official motto is "Order and Progress." The comfortable favorite in an October 28 presidential run-off

  • Trump touts push to rescind government regulations
    News
    Reuters

    Trump touts push to rescind government regulations

    U.S. President Donald Trump on Wednesday praised White House efforts to remove regulations that he sees as an impediment to economic growth, saying the administration had reduced regulatory costs by $23 billion in the year ending Sept. 30. The White House said it had eliminated regulatory costs totaling

  • At least one dead, dozens hurt as thousands protest graft in Haiti
    News
    Reuters

    At least one dead, dozens hurt as thousands protest graft in Haiti

    PORT-AU-PRINCE (Reuters) - At least one person was killed and dozens injured as thousands of protesters took to the streets in Haiti on Wednesday over a corruption scandal and some marchers called for the resignation of President Jovenel Moise. A report by Haiti's Senate accused former government

  • Facebook tentatively concludes spammers were behind recent data breach: WSJ
    Tech
    Reuters

    Facebook tentatively concludes spammers were behind recent data breach: WSJ

    Facebook Inc has tentatively concluded that spammers looking to make money, and not a nation-state, were behind the largest-ever data theft at the social media company, the Wall Street Journal reported on Wednesday. The people behind the attack were a group of Facebook and Instagram spammers that present

  • White House Counsel Don McGahn Has Officially Left The Trump Administration
    News
    HuffPost

    White House Counsel Don McGahn Has Officially Left The Trump Administration

    White House Counsel Don McGahn officially left the Trump administration on

  • China not manipulating currency but lacks transparency, US says
    News
    AFP News

    China not manipulating currency but lacks transparency, US says

    Washington on Wednesday again declined to call China a currency manipulator but said the yuan's fall and Beijing's exchange practices were of "particular concern." In putting Beijing and five other US trading partners on notice, the US Treasury once more refrained from escalating a

  • Trump to nominate former Air Force general as top Asia diplomat
    News
    Reuters

    Trump to nominate former Air Force general as top Asia diplomat

    U.S. President Donald Trump plans to nominate former Air Force General David Stilwell to be the State Department's top diplomat for East Asia, a post that has remained unfilled for more than a year despite major challenges in the region. A White House statement on Wednesday said Trump had announced

  • How changes to Schengen Area entry policy will affect Hongkongers
    News
    South China Morning Post

    How changes to Schengen Area entry policy will affect Hongkongers

    Travel to Europe is about to get more complicated for Hongkongers. From 2021, holders of Hong Kong passports will no longer be able to simply hop on a plane and arrive in most European countries with nothing more than a passport, owing to a policy change that will put an end to nearly two decades of

  • Two ex-Deutsche Bank traders convicted in Libor scandal
    News
    AFP News

    Two ex-Deutsche Bank traders convicted in Libor scandal

    Two former Deutsche Bank traders were convicted of fraud on Wednesday for their roles in manipulating a benchmark interest rate, the US Justice Department announced. The convictions of Michael Connolly, 53, of New Jersey, and Gavin Campbell Black, 48, of London, follow the bank's 2015 settlement

  • Scientists spot six near-extinct vaquita porpoises
    News
    AFP News

    Scientists spot six near-extinct vaquita porpoises

    The near-extinct vaquita marina, the world's smallest porpoise, has not yet disappeared from its habitat off the coast of Mexico, a research team said Wednesday after spotting six of them. The vaquita has been nearly wiped out by illegal fishing in its native habitat, the Gulf of California, and