Childminder branded ‘monster’ as she is jailed for shaking nine-month-old baby to death

Tara Cobham
·5-min read
Childminder branded ‘monster’ as she is jailed for shaking nine-month-old baby to death

A childminder who violently shook a baby boy in her care so hard he died has been jailed, as his family branded her a “monster” and “pure evil”.

Karen Foster, 62, left Harlow Collinge with unsurvivable brain injuries after he had been dropped off at her home by his mother Gemma Collinge, a court heard.

After paramedics were called and Harlow rushed away by ambulance Foster hugged his mother at the hospital and claimed the youngster had begun choking and she had slapped him on the back.

But she later tried to blame Ms Collinge for the injuries.

Harlow – who had been described as a “healthy and happy boy” prior to the traumatic injuries he suffered on 1 March 2022 – died days later in his parents’ arms having suffered massive brain injuries.

Foster was sentenced to 12 years and seven months imprisonment at Preston Crown Court on Thursday for his manslaughter.

Harlow had been described as a ‘healthy and happy boy’ prior to the traumatic injuries he suffered on 1 March 2022 (PA Media)
Harlow had been described as a ‘healthy and happy boy’ prior to the traumatic injuries he suffered on 1 March 2022 (PA Media)

Harlow’s mother, father Allen Frangleton, older siblings and wider family, sat in the public gallery, weeping as Foster’s case was heard and their victim impact statements were read out on their behalf.

Harlow’s mother Gemma Collinge said: “The actions she has taken over the past few years make me sick. It is pure evil and twisted to put a whole family through what she did. This monster Karen Foster deserves nothing. I hope her actions haunt her … It is now too late, there is no forgiveness.”

She called Foster’s lies and attempts to comfort her in hospital “despicable”.

The judge similarly highlighted the defendant’s lies when he passed her sentence.

Mr Justice Cotter KC also said: “In my judgement, you have high culpability – you shook a baby so hard as to cause devastating injury.”

Describing Harlow as previously “happy and healthy”, he concluded that Foster shook him “so violently as to cause him a devastating brain injury. His death was caused in the course of an assault.”

He added that Foster, despite ill health and pain in her hip, chose to carry on looking after more children than she should have under Ofsted rules, and this contributed to her “loss of temper”, with Harlow “on the receiving end”.

Ms Collinge similarly described Harlow as a previously “happy, smiling baby, whose giggle was infectious”, adding: “Right from the day he was born, I fell in love with him.”

Speaking of how the family were now in a “living nightmare”, Ms Collinge said: “I miss my boy more than life itself – the last two years have been hell, I am struggling to cope.”

She also spoke of the “guilt” she felt, having made arrangements to move him to a nursery six weeks after first using Foster as a childminder, due to her own concerns about the number of children being looked after.

Relatives of the baby shouted, “Scumbag b****! I hate you!” as Foster, herself a mother-of-two and grandmother, was led away from the dock after being sentenced.

She had been accused of murder but pleaded guilty to manslaughter just before her trial started last week, for the first time admitting “forceful shaking” of Harlow causing his death, after he had toppled over out of his high chair, began crying and she shook him in frustration.

Foster was a registered childminder with nine years’ experience who had been breaking Ofsted rules on the numbers and ages of children she should be caring for, to make more money from parents, the court heard.

Earlier Anne Whyte KC, prosecuting, said when Foster first registered in 2014, she did not say she was married and lived with her husband or that she sometimes sought help with childminding from other unregistered individuals, or that her health was poor.

In fact, she made two benefit claims for Personal Independence Payments in 2018 and 2022, claiming she felt constantly drowsy and tired, that sometimes she could barely move, or safely carry out daily living activities.

On 1 March 2022, Foster was looking after two children aged four, and two children under 12 months including Harlow – breaking the rules of her registration with Ofsted, as she was only allowed to care for one child under 12 months old.

Later that day she called 999 and told the operator that Harlow was not breathing, the court was told, and went on to inform a paramedic he had suddenly collapsed at her home in Hapton, Burnley, Lancashire.

As he was rushed to the Royal Blackburn Hospital, Foster told medics that Harlow’s mother had said the youngster had been unwell recently.

But Ms Whyte said the truth began to emerge as scans were taken of the boy, showing significant injuries to his brain, associated with the shaking of a baby, with bleeding on both sides and swelling.

Harlow died four days later.

Outside court on Thursday, Detective Superintendent Allen Davies, of Lancashire Police, said: “Before this reprehensible assault committed by Karen Foster, Harlow Collinge was a healthy and happy baby boy who had his whole life ahead of him.

“That life was so cruelly and unfathomably snatched away by a woman who Harlow’s parents had put their trust in to keep their little boy safe.

“Having inflicted such a devastating and catastrophic injury on Harlow, Foster spun a web of lies which she continued to repeat to medical professionals, the police and Harlow’s parents about how he came to be so gravely unwell.

“Her purpose was to try and protect herself rather than be honest about the child she had a duty of care to keep safe.

“My thoughts remain with Harlow’s family who have behaved with dignity while dealing with such an unimaginable and unexpected loss.

“They have endured every parent’s worst nightmare and have shown great strength and bravery.”

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • We gave up city life and moved to Bali. It was a lot more challenging than we expected.

    Coming from big cities, the couple was used to efficiency and getting things done quickly. That's not what they found in Bali.

  • Love Actually's Thomas Brodie-Sangster marries Elon Musk's ex-wife Talulah Riley

    Thomas Brodie-Sangster has married Talulah Riley in a picturesque village in Hertfordshire.

  • Priyanka Chopra Shares Adorable Footage of Daughter Malti While Filming in Australia Without Nick Jonas: 'Miss You'

    The actress posted a video montage of Malti spending time with loved ones on Instagram on Saturday

  • Elon Musk quietly welcomed another child into the world

    Elon Musk has quietly welcomed his third child with Shivon Zilis into the world.

  • ‘Love Actually’ star Thomas Brodie-Sangster, 34, marries actor Talulah Riley in romantic ceremony

    Actors were all smiles as they were pictured leaving Hertfordshire church on Saturday

  • Elon Musk's ex-wife Talulah Riley marries Thomas Brodie-Sangster in romantic country wedding

    Elon Musk's ex-wife Talulah Riley has tied the knot with Love Actually and The Maze Runner star, Thomas Brodie-Sangster.

  • People Are Calling Out The "Wedding Trends" That Will Be Outdated In A Few Years, And It's Spot-On

    "I'm actually surprised the cursive 'bridesmaid' font hasn't died off yet. I hate that font."

  • Heidi Klum and Her Husband Show Off Their Coordinating Leopard Looks: 'Love Is When He Matches Your Bikini Print'

    The model and the musician proved that their couples' style is perfectly in sync in the Instagram clip

  • There Might Actually Be Some Science Behind Eldest Daughter Syndrome

    Your oldest sister will feel so validated by this.

  • Husband Sparks Outrage for Refusing to Cancel Guys' Trip to Help Wife Move into Their New Home

    The man has an annual guys' trip planned during the same timeframe when he and his wife are set to close on a new house together

  • Princess Beatrice and Edoardo Mapelli Mozzi are proud parents as Sienna takes on flower girl role at wedding

    Princess Beatrice was pictured dancing at her friend Marissa Montgomery's wedding in Chelsea, London, alongside guests, which included Rebel Wilson

  • 'We are not trash': Horrors suffered by Canada's Indigenous women

    A mountain of windswept garbage. Beneath it, bodies. For years, the remains discarded by a serial killer have languished in a landfill -- the latest chapter in a long history of violence against Canada's Indigenous women.Morgan Harris and Marcedes Myran were raped, killed, dismembered and thrown out with the trash in Winnipeg, Manitoba. Police believe their remains are buried deep inside the Prairie Green landfill. The partial remains of another victim, Rebecca Contois, were found in two places -- a garbage bin in the city and in a separate landfill. The body of a fourth, unidentified woman in her 20s -- dubbed Buffalo Woman -- is still missing.Their murderer, Jeremy Skibicki, now 37 and linked to white supremacists, confessed in 2022 and has been tried. A verdict is expected next month. But their relatives have been unable to lay them to rest, as the excavations to find their remains have not yet begun. Indigenous women are disproportionately targeted by violence in Canada, and often poorly protected by authorities accused of paying little attention to their plight. Instead, they are thrown "into the trash," says Elle Harris, the 19-year-old daughter of Morgan Harris.A member of the Long Plain nation, Elle is dressed in a traditional skirt, her hair twisted into a long braid.She says her mother had a difficult life, spending years homeless after losing custody of her five children due to a drug addiction."My mom was taken just like that, just like nothing. And I wish I could see her one more time, to talk to her again," she tells AFP.Instead, she and her family are keeping vigil near the Prairie Green landfill, where they have set up teepees, a sacred fire, red dresses and a banner demanding empathy: "What if it was your daughter?"For months -- through the wind-blasted Winnipeg winter -- they have taken turns staying in the makeshift camp, seeking, says Elle, "to prove that we are something, we are not trash, we can't just be thrown into the garbage."It has also formed part of their campaign to pressure authorities to excavate the site, which has remained in use since Skibicki's confession, with new truckloads of debris regularly arriving to be piled on top of what is already there. The go-ahead for the digging was finally given at the end of 2023, shortly after Winnipeg elected Canada's first Indigenous provincial leader, Wab Kinew.But the searchers must sift through tons of garbage and construction rubble, and such an operation involves considerable risks due to the presence of toxic materials such as asbestos, according to independent experts. Ultimately, it could take years and cost tens of millions of dollars.Morgan Harris' family has vowed to maintain their vigil until her remains are recovered.- 'Devastating history' -Skibicki targeted Indigenous women he met in homeless shelters, prosecutors told his trial, which began in late April. A judge is expected to issue a verdict on July 11. At the time of his arrest, the then-Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations Marc Miller said the case was part of "a legacy of a devastating history" of Canada's treatment of Indigenous women "that has reverberations today.""No one can stand in front of you with confidence to say that this won't happen again and I think that's kind of shameful," he said.Indigenous women are wildly overrepresented among the victims of femicide in Canada.They represent about one-fifth of all the women killed in gender-related homicides in the country -- even though they are just five percent of the female population, according to official figures documenting an 11-year period up to 2021.In that year in particular, the rate of gender-related homicide of Indigenous victims was more than triple that of such killings of girls and women overall, the report said."Canada is looked at as a country that upholds rights," said Hilda Anderson-Pyrz, an activist who has championed Indigenous women for years. But when "we're being disposed of like garbage in landfills, that clearly says something is very wrong in this country."In 2019, a national commission went so far as to describe the thousands of murders and disappearances of First Nations women over the years as a "genocide."Isolated, marginalized, and heavily impacted by intergenerational trauma, they face disproportionate violence due to "state actions and inactions rooted in colonialism and colonial ideologies, built on the presumption of superiority," the commission concluded.It is a conclusion shared by some of the families of Skibicki's victims.The young children of Marcedes Myran do not understand why she is in a landfill, admits their great-grandmother Donna Bartlett, who is raising them in her small, cluttered house in an outlying neighborhood of Winnipeg.Marcedes was a kind, happy girl who loved to play jokes, the 66-year-old recalls. She laments authorities' reluctance to search the landfill."If (the women) were white, they would have done it right away," she says.- 'Highway of Tears' -Further west, in British Columbia, is a stretch of road hundreds of miles long known as the "Highway of Tears" -- a stark monument, activists say, to the many ways Canada has failed Indigenous women.Here, nature is spectacular -- the snow-capped mountains, the immense trees, the meandering Skeena River, waterfalls and abundant wildlife such as foxes, bears and eagles.But on the side of the highway is an incongruous sight: red dresses nailed to posts symbolizing vanished women, faded photos of young girls with dazzling smiles, messages promising rewards for any clues to where they have gone.Since the 1960s, as many as 50 women -- and a few men -- have vanished along this 450-mile (725-kilometer) highway linking Prince Rupert, on the Pacific Coast near Alaska, to Prince George.All are believed to have been young and Indigenous. Many vanished while hitchhiking or walking home along Highway 16. No community in the region was spared.Tamara Chipman, who was a member of the Wet'suwet'en First Nation, was heading to Prince Rupert to see friends when she was last seen hitchhiking on September 21, 2005. She was 22, the mother of a little boy.Her aunt, Gladys Radek, described a feisty young woman who "loved fast boats and fishing and also life," in a region marked by social disintegration and drugs.In these isolated and impoverished communities, connected only by this single highway flanked by deep forests, without proper telephone networks or public transportation, many young people are forced to hitchhike to get around. They often encounter temporary workers who have come for jobs at local mines: mainly well-paid, single men. The case of Chipman, like the majority of disappearances on the route, has never been explained.- Neglected -When Lana Derrick went missing in the area 25 years ago, "we had some challenges in the beginning getting support from the RCMP to take the case seriously," says her cousin Wanda Good, referring to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police.It is an observation made by many of the families -- that efforts to find women stigmatized as drug addicts, prostitutes or alcoholics can be middling at best. In several cases the families say they have organized the first searches themselves -- both for their missing loved ones, and for any witnesses.The head of the RCMP admitted to the national commission in 2018 that, for too many Indigenous families, "the RCMP was not the police service that it needed to be during this terrible time of your life."Studies show a deep-rooted distrust between police and Indigenous people. It dates back to decades when police were used as the armed wing of Canadian governments, as they imposed a policy of forced assimilation on the country's First Peoples.At the RCMP's British Columbia headquarters on the outskirts of Vancouver, Constable Wayne Clary, a veteran homicide investigator, tries to explain the tragedy of the Highway of Tears."The northern areas are very, very isolated. Some of the activities that these women engage in, and not just Indigenous, but other women, they make themselves available for men who prey on women," he says.He rejects accusations of botched investigations, but acknowledges: "In the past, communication may not have been there." - 'Never stop looking' -Clary is part of the E-Pana unit, created in 2005 -- more than 30 years after the disappearances began -- to "determine if a serial killer, or killers, is responsible."Eighteen women are on the unit's list -- 13 homicides and five disappearances spanning from 1969 to 2006. No connection has been established between the cases so far. The investigations remain open, but new homicides are not handled by the special unit. The last -- that of Chelsey Quaw, a 29-year-old Indigenous woman reported missing after leaving home from Saik'uz First Nation -- dates back to last November.In recent years, there has been progress, notes Good: the police listen more to families, and new relay antennas have been installed for mobile communications on the road. "We are moving forward, but at a very, very slow, snail's pace," she says. But it is a collective tragedy which the country refuses to confront, believes Radek, 69.Speaking slowly and gravely, her voice at times rising in anger, she describes how she began traveling the country "to tell the stories of all these women with broken destinies, to be the voice of these families, because they were silenced."Her dilapidated van is covered with photos of the missing. When she passes through local villages along the Highway of Tears, residents often stop her to talk. Her fight now takes her outside of Canada to conferences and demonstrations seeking to raise awareness of the women's plight."I'll never stop looking," she says.tib/amc/st

  • The Japanese Line of Succession, Explained

    There are only three people currently eligible to follow Emperor Nahurito on the Chrysanthemum Throne

  • Parents Of 6 Kids Drown In Rip Current During Florida Vacation

    Two of the couple's teens tried to save their parents, "but it became too dangerous and they were forced to swim ashore," according to local authorities.

  • Naomi Watts and Liev Schreiber Dine Out with Son Sasha, 16: 'So Proud'

    The actress and her ex spent time with their son in photos posted on Instagram on June 22

  • Emma Bunton shares sweet footage of long-haired children Tate, 13, and Beau, 16

    Spice Girls star Emma Bunton enjoyed an evening at Taylor Swift at London's Wembley Arena concert with her children Tate and Beau alongside Holly Willoughby, Salma Hayek, Nichola Coughlan and more

  • Deaths from Indian toxic alcohol rise to more than 50

    The death toll from a batch of toxic illegal alcohol in India has risen to 53, media reported Sunday, as more victims in hospital succumbed to the poisonous brew.Other Indian media on Sunday put the toll as high as 55, but there was no immediate official confirmation.

  • Cast Members Speak Out After ‘The Real World’ Star Dies by Suicide at 52

    Cast members of a reality show who featured in MTV’s The Real World are speaking out after the family of one of its stars, Sarah Becker, confirmed to TMZ on Sunday that Becker died at 52.An unidentified member of the family confirmed to the outlet that Becker died last week at her home in Illinois. The family member added that she died by suicide. Becker, who starred in the fifth season of The Real World, based in Miami in 1996, had recently moved to Illinois from California to take care of ill

  • Woman accused of trying to drown 3-year-old Palestinian-American girl in swimming pool

    A woman reportedly approached a mother, who was wearing a hijab, to question her about where she was from before attempting to grab the kids

  • Aristocratic roots of Peter Phillips’ NHS nurse girlfriend revealed

    Peter Phillips looked proud as punch as he posed with Harriet Sperling, his new girlfriend, at Royal Ascot on Friday.