Edmonton's plan to stop sprawl faces pushback from developers over housing affordability

CBC
·4-min read

Developers are pushing back against a city recommendation that would halt any planning and development on the outskirts of Edmonton to limit sprawl.

An urban planning committee Tuesday heard mixed feedback about the city's substantial completion approach, which prioritizes finishing infrastructure and amenities development before focusing on new areas.

Administration suggests halting any planning in annexed lands from Beaumont and Leduc, until 2029.

Adil Kodian, executive vice-president of Rohit Homes, warned that this strategy could affect housing affordability.

"By creating artificial curbs to bringing on new supply of housing, we end up creating a situation where not enough houses are being produced for the population growth that is coming," he told CBC's Edmonton AM Wednesday.

"We're already in the middle of a housing crisis and it does not look like the growth in population in Edmonton is going to stem anytime soon."

Edmonton metro's population reached 1.56 million in 2023.

A City of Edmonton map outlines the developing areas to be completed before future growth areas, if council agrees to new substantial completion standard.
A City of Edmonton map outlines the developing areas to be completed before future growth areas, if council agrees to new substantial completion standard. (City of Edmonton)

Out of the city's 295 residential neighborhoods, 91 are considered developing areas, such as Ellerslie, west Henday, far northeast and southwest, that still need infrastructure development and amenities.

City administration wants to focus on the developing areas before moving on to lands annexed in 2019.

Kalen Anderson, CEO of Building Industry and Land Development Edmonton Metro, said the whole reason the city annexed the land in the first place was to accommodate a growing population and for development.

"We already knew we were running out of land to accommodate dense and diverse neighbourhoods," Anderson said.

Developers like Brad Armstrong, vice-president of community development for Qualico Communities, said planning and development takes multiple years and halting planning causes them to lose years of work needed to begin building homes.

"This is a big concern because of the length of time that it takes to assemble the land and then to go through the entire planning process," he said.

Climate, community considerations

Supporters of the city's approach believe it will attract young professionals and help meet the city's climate goals.

Dolly Cepeda Montufar emphasized the desire of young people like herself, for community-centric developments over single-family homes.

"If I'm walking for half an hour and all I see is houses, I don't want to live there," she said.

However, she said her immigrant parents chose Terwillegar in southwest Edmonton in 2009 for affordability — despite not having developed amenities or a strong sense of community.

Jacob Komar, co-chair of the city's Energy Transition and Climate Resilience Committee, stressed the importance of substantial completion in the entire city to meet the city's climate goals as urban areas contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions.

LISTEN | Developer concerned about city's proposal to halt planning of annexed lands:

He said urban sprawl increases car dependency and associated pollution, more land consumption and destruction of natural carbon sinks.

"Building efficient, dense urban developments is the best levers we have for reducing GHG emissions," he said.

As for Kodian, he said limiting development could increase commute times as people might choose to live outside the city.

"Aren't we just incentivizing the customer to drive another 10 minutes and go live in Beaumont?" he asked.

Coun. Tim Cartmell of ward Pihêsiwin, which includes the annexed lands, does not support the motion.

"I completely agree that we want to maximize the utility of the infrastructure we already have … but we absolutely need to plan," he said.

"We are seeing now that the pace of growth is far faster than we anticipated a few years ago. I see no problem at all with planning ahead."

The cost of sprawl

In response to concerns about affordability, Karen Burgess, communications advisor for the city, said the city is working toward maintaining Edmonton's overall affordability relative to other Canadian cities.

One of the ways to do this is by reducing barriers and costs to building new housing and increasing non-market affordable housing options, she said.

Burgess said that while developers only pay for construction of new infrastructure, the city has to pay for operating, maintaining and renewing it, which can be expensive.

In the report the city stressed that this cost would then be borne by taxpayers.

City council will consider the motion on July 3.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • World's smallest elephant in danger of dying out

    Only an estimated 1,000 individuals remain in the wild but conservationists remain optimistic.

  • Beat them or eat them: What should we do about invasive species in the ocean?

    Should we beat them, or eat them? In this episode of Ocean Calls, we’re embarking on a journey to unravel the mysteries of invasive species in EU waters. They unsettle the delicate balance of marine ecosystems, so what can we do about them?

  • Trump Did Say 1 True Thing At The Presidential Debate

    The former president spoke about one simple, "immaculate" truth about his first term in the White House.

  • Bornean elephant assessed as endangered in new threatened species list

    An update to the IUCN Red List of threatened species also warns of a threat to lizards from invasive snakes and impacts of illegal cactus trade.

  • 2 giant pandas set off from China to the US - for first time in over 20 years

    For the first time in more than 20 years, giant pandas are travelling from China to the United States. The five-year-old male Yun Chuan and nearly four-year-old female Xin Bao are expected to arrive at the San Diego Zoo in California later this week after setting off from China on Wednesday. The pair will travel 7,000 miles, accompanied by caretakers who will help them adjust to their new environment. Do you have questions about the biggest topics and trends from around the world? Get the answer

  • The world’s biggest capital cities are heating up – and Asia tops the charts

    The world’s largest capital cities are seeing more extremely hot days than ever, according to a new study, which says the dangerous trend is being driven by scorching temperatures across Asia as the climate crisis worsens.

  • Climber Rappels Next to 'Raging Waterfall' That Developed During Flash Flood

    A “raging waterfall” cascading down the Morning Glory Arch was not enough to deter an experienced outdoorsman on June 21, with jaw-dropping visuals showing him rappelling down after a flash flood hit the area.Video by 16-year-old Spencer Grover shows Tyler Erickson rappelling from a sandstone cliff outside Moab, Utah, within touching distance of a muddy waterfall that “spontaneously developed”, Spencer’s father, Michael Grover, told Storyful.Speaking to Storyful, Erickson said that although the canyoneering adventure “unexpectedly turned into a test of resilience and preparedness,” at no point were he and his group in serious danger.“We were well prepared, equipped with headlamps, sufficient food, and water,” Erickson said.“Despite the situation, the temperature remained a comfortable 70 degrees, and no one was at risk of hypothermia. The storm was described by search and rescue as a once-in-150-years event, catching even experienced guides off guard.”Erickson said that the unexpected flash flood brought close to four inches of rain in just 20 minutes. He highlighted “the importance of preparedness and staying calm in unexpected situations”, but said the experience, while challenging, was also “an unforgettable and humbling adventure”.“It was a testament to the resilience and teamwork of our group, and a reminder that nature can be unpredictable,” he said.Separately, a group of 20 people had to be rescued during the same extreme conditions, local media said Credit: Spencer Grover via Storyful

  • Deaths mount as Pakistan swelters in heatwave

    Soaring temperatures in Pakistan have led more people to head to hospitals seeking help.

  • Female capybara goes to Florida as part of a breeding program for the large South American rodents

    A female capybara has arrived at a Florida zoo as part of a breeding program to bolster the population of the large South American rodents. Iyari, a 10-month-old capybara, went to the Palm Beach Zoo & Conservation Society in May from the San Diego Zoo Wildlife Alliance.

  • Bornean elephants endangered due to human activity

    STORY: Elephants living on the South Asian island of Borneo have become endangered.And human activities such as agriculture, mining, and logging are to blame.That’s according to a recent assessment by wildlife experts.The International Union for Conservation of Nature says there are around 1,000 Bornean elephants left in the wild.Craig Hilton-Taylor heads the IUCN Red List Unit, which assesses animal species' risk of extinction. "A thousand individuals, of which only 400 are mature. Those are the breeding individuals. It's a small population, and it could easily disappear if we just let development happen without any conservation actions.”The IUCN says the number of Bornean elephants has decreased over the last 75 years - initially due to extensive logging.The animals have since entered human-dominated areas, searching for food.That in turn can cause them to destroy crops and face retribution killing.Malaysian and Indonesian authorities are working on conservation action plans to help the species cope with human development.The plans will require extensive coordination with corporations, private landowners and conservationists.

  • Last woolly mammoths were inbred, but that’s not why they became extinct

    The last woolly mammoths were inbred, scientists have discovered, but this is not the reason they became extinct.

  • Garbage dumps may be ‘burping’ toxic ‘forever chemicals’: Study

    As many municipal landfills belch out gas from decomposing organic matter, they are also releasing toxic “forever chemicals” into the air, a new study has found. Scientists measured unexpectedly high levels of airborne per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) at three dumps they surveyed — demonstrating the ability of these persistent contaminants to escape into the…

  • Panda express: First pair to enter the United States in 21 years arrive in California

    San Diego’s newest giant pandas landed in California on Thursday, according to Chinese state media – marking the first time Beijing has granted new panda loans to the United States in two decades.

  • Sembcorp secures long-term power purchase agreements with GSK subsidiaries

    The agreements have tenures of up to 10 years and will commence Jan 1, 2025.

  • New drone footage shows 97% of coral is dead in northern Great Barrier Reef

    Bleaching event, which follows a similar one last summer, is fifth in eight years after parts of reef subjected to extreme heat stress

  • Damage to protected chalk stream left unchecked by Natural England for 11 years

    Damage to a protected chalk stream has gone unchecked by Natural England for more than a decade, according to new analysis.

  • Sime Darby Property Continues to See High Demand for the City of Elmina with 98% Overall Take-up for Elmina Ridge 1

    The overwhelming response reaffirms the strong demand for exclusivity and sustainable living in the award-winning township of the City of Elmina.

  • How the Midwest Floods Nearly Took Out a Century-Old Dam

    The warning from the county government was grim. The Rapidan Dam, a feature of the southern Minnesota landscape for more than a century, was “in imminent failure condition.” “We do not know if it will totally fail or if it will remain in place,” officials said Monday as dead trees and other debris piled up at the dam and floods overwhelmed the Upper Midwest. At one point, a support structure alongside the dam partly failed and gushing waters carved out a nearby cliff. Video footage showed a near

  • Factbox-Companies forging a rare earths industry in the EU

    In the rare earths sector, the EU will struggle to meet most of its ambitious goals in new legislation designed to boost domestic output of critical minerals and reduce dependence on China. Below are some key companies working on rare earths, with production figures in metric tons per year. Neodymium and praseodymium (referred to in the industry by their joint elemental abbreviation, NdPr) are key rare earths needed to make permanent magnets.

  • Temasek co-leads US$65 mil Series A+ round in ‘plastic-eating enzyme’ creator Samsara Eco

    Founded in 2020, the company has pioneered the ability to recycle materials like nylon 6/6 and polyester.