John Swinney criticised for not supporting Michael Matheson's Holyrood ban over £11,000 iPad bill

Sky News
·4-min read

Scotland's first minister has been accused of demeaning himself and "defending the indefensible" after announcing he will not be supporting a parliamentary committee's recommendation to ban Michael Matheson from Holyrood for 27 sitting days.

Former health secretary Mr Matheson is facing the suspension over a near £11,000 iPad data roaming bill.

He was sanctioned by the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee on Thursday, which also included a recommendation for the Falkirk West MSP to lose his salary for 54 days.

The decision will now go before MSPs for approval, but John Swinney has stated he will not be supporting the sanction, claiming the process had been "prejudiced" due to public comments made by a member of the committee and could bring the Scottish parliament into "disrepute".

At First Minister's Questions on Thursday, Mr Swinney described Mr Matheson as "a friend and a colleague".

He said Mr Matheson had "paid the roaming costs in question" with "no cost to the public purse", however the first minister failed to acknowledge his colleague was forced to U-turn after an initial bill to taxpayers hit the headlines and sparked a public outcry.

It was eventually revealed his teenage sons had racked up the eye-watering costs after using Mr Matheson's iPad as a Wi-Fi hotspot to watch football during a family holiday to Morocco around Christmas 2022.

Mr Swinney said he had "significant concern" over the parliamentary committee's findings.

He said: "I believe this process has been prejudiced."

The first minister referred to comments made by Tory MSP Annie Wells, a member of the committee, saying: "Annie Wells said that Michael Matheson's, and I quote, 'desperate efforts to justify his outrageous expenses claim have been riddled with lies, cover-ups and the need for us all to suspend our disbelief'."

Fellow Tory MSP Stephen Kerr stepped down from the committee earlier this year, admitting he could not be objective in the case, and was replaced by colleague Oliver Mundell.

Mr Swinney said that if a constituent had come to him facing disciplinary action at work when their employer had made similar comments about them, he would "come down on that employer like a tonne of bricks".

He added: "That is the situation that Michael Matheson if facing here, and that is why I will not be supporting the sanction."

The first minister said he would not support calls for Mr Matheson to resign.

He said his colleague had "suffered significant reputational damage" and his family had been impacted "as a consequence of losing office and the difficulties that have been created here".

Mr Swinney added: "This parliament needs to consider seriously the reputational issues that will arise from presiding over an unfair process."

Read more from Sky News:
Swinney admits election will be a 'challenge' for SNP
Election is going to be a record-breaking battle for No 10

'Incredible and indefensible'

Scottish Tory leader Douglas Ross said Mr Swinney was "defending the indefensible".

Mr Ross accused Mr Matheson of "deceit and abuse of trust" as he revealed his party will seek to push him to resign in a vote next week.

He added: "This is incredible and indefensible by the first minister.

"He told us, when asking for our support to make him first minister, he would be first minister for all of Scotland. What Scotland is seeing is he's a first minister that backs his pals."

'He has demeaned himself'

Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar described Mr Swinney's comments as "utterly unbelievable and embarrassing".

He added: "He has demeaned himself and the office of first minister.

"Two weeks in and the pretence of a new kind of government is gone. Party first, country second."

Speaking to journalists following FMQs, Mr Matheson said he acknowledged the recommendations made by the committee.

He added: "I think it's pretty clear though that the process has become highly politicised, which has compromised the process and the fairness of the process.

"I also think the sanctions they've imposed are excessive and they are unfair."

Mr Matheson said it is now for parliament to decide on the next steps for the report, and said he would "abide" by whatever decision it takes.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Biden ‘seriously considering’ leaving election race

    Joe Biden has for the first time said that he is considering ending his presidential campaign, according to reports.

  • New Poll Finds 1 Democrat Absolutely Trouncing Trump

    Just one problem: This person doesn't seem interested in running, should the opportunity arise.

  • Malaysia's Najib loses legal bid to serve sentence under house arrest

    KUALA LUMPUR (Reuters) -A Malaysian court dismissed jailed former Prime Minister Najib Razak's legal bid to obtain a document that he said would allow him to serve his remaining prison sentence under house arrest. In a judicial review application filed on April 1, Najib said an "addendum order" issued by the former king had accompanied a pardons board's decision in February to halve his 12-year jail sentence for graft in the multibillion-dollar 1MDB scandal. Najib had sought for the court to compel the government to reply to or confirm the existence of the royal order, which he said would entitle him to serve the remainder of his term under house arrest, and to execute the order if it existed.

  • Ukraine to be told it is too corrupt to join Nato

    Ukraine will be told it is currently too corrupt to join Nato, in a major blow to Volodymyr Zelensky.

  • House Democrat is proposing a constitutional amendment to reverse Supreme Court's immunity decision

    A leading House Democrat is preparing a constitutional amendment in response to the Supreme Court's landmark immunity ruling, seeking to reverse the decision “and ensure that no president is above the law.” Rep. Joseph Morelle of New York, the top Democrat on the House Administration Committee, sent a letter to colleagues informing them of his intent to file the resolution, which would kickstart what's traditionally a cumbersome amendment process. "This amendment will do what SCOTUS failed to do — prioritize our democracy,” Morelle said in a statement to AP.

  • Trump Caught on Video Claiming ‘Broken-Down’ Biden Has Quit: ‘It’s Kamala’

    Donald Trump delivered a brutal assessment of Joe Biden’s performance against him in last week’s presidential debate, calling the president a “broken-down pile of crap” teetering on the verge of “quitting the race” in a video provided by a source to The Daily Beast.“He just quit, you know—he’s quitting the race,” Trump says, sitting in a golf cart. “I got him out of the—and that means we have Kamala.”Later in the clip, he fawns over Chinese President Xi Jinping, calling him “a fierce man, very t

  • A growing club led by Xi and Putin to counter the US is adding a staunchly pro-Russia member

    A club of Eurasian countries spearheaded by China and Russia to advance their leaders’ vision of an alternative world order is set to expand again this week – this time adding a staunch Russian ally that has openly supported Moscow’s war on Ukraine.

  • Philippines says US mid-range missile system to be pulled out

    A US mid-range missile system deployed in the Philippines for annual joint military exercises -- to the annoyance of China -- will be pulled out of the country, a Philippine Army spokesman said Thursday.The US Army said in April it had deployed the Mid-Range Capability missile system which can fire the Standard Missile 6 (SM-6) and the Tomahawk Land Attack Missile in the northern Philippines.

  • Philippine military chief warns his forces will fight back if assaulted again in disputed sea

    Philippine forces will defend themselves with “the same level of force” if they come under assault again from China’s coast guard in the disputed South China Sea, where Chinese personnel armed with machetes and spears injured Filipino navy personnel and damaged two of their boats in a chaotic faceoff last month, the Philippine military chief said Thursday. Armed Forces of the Philippines chief Gen. Romeo Brawner Jr. asked China to pay 60 million pesos ($1 million) in damages for the two navy boats and return seven rifles which he said were seized by Chinese coast guard personnel during the June17 confrontation at Second Thomas Shoal.

  • Russian air strike ‘destroys five Ukrainian fighter jets’ at airbase

    A Russian missile attack destroyed five warplanes at a Ukrainian airbase primed to receive F-16 fighter jets from Kyiv’s Nato allies.

  • US deports 116 Chinese migrants in first 'large' flight in 5 years

    The Department of Homeland Security said Tuesday that it sent 116 Chinese migrants from the United States back home in the first “large charter flight” in five years. The flight, which happened over the weekend, comes as Chinese immigration has become the subject of intense political debate in the upcoming U.S. presidential election. "We will continue to enforce our immigration laws and remove individuals without a legal basis to remain in the United States,” Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas said in a statement.

  • Singapore to cane Japanese hairdresser for rape

    The 38-year-old man is the first Japanese national to receive this punishment in Singapore.

  • Have the Houthis sunk a British warship? Here’s what actually happened

    Yesterday afternoon the Iranian-backed militia in Yemen, the Houthis, claimed they had targeted four ships which they deemed to belong to the US/UK/Israel “trio evil”. According to the rapidly becoming famous Houthi spokesman Yahya Sare’e – the Comical Ali of the 2020s – “the British landing ship Anvil Point” was targeted and “the hit was accurate and direct. The ship was targeted by a number of cruise missiles.”

  • Who could replace Joe Biden as Democratic nominee? Here are six possibilities

    After his catastrophic debate against Trump and reports that some Democrats are calling for Biden to step aside, here’s who could run against Trump instead

  • Leaked polling memo ‘shook Democrats in their boots,’ says former Obama adviser

    Former Obama adviser Dan Pfeiffer said that a leaked polling memo “shook Democrats in their boots” in a Wednesday Substack post. The polling memo from Open Labs, leaked to Puck News, showed how President Biden’s support was sliding following his panic-inducing debate performance Thursday. The Open Labs memo noted the “largest single-week drop” in Biden’s…

  • Russia missed probably its best opportunity to steamroll Ukraine, war analyst argues

    The war expert Mick Ryan said Russia had failed to act decisively in the Ukraine war, missing a chance to strike a decisive blow.

  • Diddy sued by porn star who says he sex trafficked her at his famous ‘white parties’

    Adria English alleges in a lawsuit that she was paid to have sex with guests at Diddy’s annual Labor Day ‘white party’

  • Investigation reveals house of horrors on boat after dad arrested on child porn charges

    Police said they uncovered a world of sickening abuse on Eric Cadogan’s houseboat

  • Crocodile kills girl, 12, who was ‘cooling off’ in water

    The body of a 12-year-old girl has been found in remote northern Australia, two days after she was attacked by a crocodile.

  • Are UFOs Real? What the Pentagon Has Learned

    "The most common misconception is that [UFOs] are all the same thing and they're all extraterrestrial, and neither of those are true," said one government expert