More than 80% of airline passengers in favour of mandatory seatbelts on flights, poll finds

Simon Calder
·3-min read
Danger zone: Interior of Singapore Airlines flight SQ321 after its emergency landing at Bangkok (Reuters)
Danger zone: Interior of Singapore Airlines flight SQ321 after its emergency landing at Bangkok (Reuters)

As the world’s airlines gather in Dubai for their annual get-together, seatbelt wearing will be high on the agenda.

On 21 May, one passenger died and many were injured when a Singapore Airlines flight from London Heathrow to Singapore encountered extreme turbulence over the Bay of Bengal.

A preliminary investigation found passengers and crew endured a drop of 178 feet in just 4.6 seconds – representing a downward speed averaging 26mph. They also suffered violent changes in vertical acceleration.

The passenger who died, 73-year-old Geoff Kitchen from Somerset, suffered a fatal heart attack.

In a social media poll carried out in the wake of the event, participants voted five to one in favour of keeping seat belts fastened at almost all times.

The poll was conducted on Twitter/X and asked: “Should wearing a seat belt at all times on planes (except when using the washroom) be mandatory?”

More than 4,500 self-selecting people responded, with 84.1 per cent voting in favour and only 15.9 per cent against.

Snap poll: The response on mandatory seatbelt wearing (X)
Snap poll: The response on mandatory seatbelt wearing (X)

Among those in favour was Isabella May who wrote: “Definitely best to wear it. I once experienced clear air turbulence flying from The Gambia to London Gatwick.

“Although nowhere near as severe, it was sudden and scary. There’s simply no time to prevent injuries!”

Another respondent, Justin, wrote: “We drive for hours and it is not an inconvenience. It would not be difficult for the FAs [flight attendants] to have a screen showing who did not have their seat belts on.

He added: “If safety is really an issue why are people who have had too much alcohol allowed on a plane.”

But Kristen Covo opposed the idea, writing: “I don’t think it should be mandatory. Flight attendants have enough to worry about to also have to check in on passengers wearing seatbelts.

“In saying that I always keep my seat belt on. And pilots always caution you that you should. So just keep your seatbelt fastened!”

Matt Joy concurred: “If you make it mandatory people will complain. Most safety announcements already include a recommendation for people to keep their belt on when seated.

The International Air Transport Association (Iata), says: “Turbulence is a major safety concern. Each year, a significant number of people are injured by turbulence, while not wearing seatbelts.”

It also says the phenomenon “is increasing”.

Iata already tells passengers: “You must keep your seatbelt fastened whenever your are instructed to do so, and even simply when you are seated, to avoid injury in case turbulence is encountered without warning.”

But as the organisation’s conference got under way in Dubai, The Times reported Sir Tim Clark, the president of Emirates, saying: “We’ve had our own fair share of issues. Not as bad as Singapore Airlines, but let’s be quite honest, it’s a real race and the whole industry is now upping in the game with regard to making sure that passengers are strapped in. We are looking at all the protocols.”

Iata has a campaign called “Turbulence Aware” that is aimed at increasing the number of reports of turbulence to allow pilots to be given a better picture of likely trouble spots.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Barges swept down raging river crash into bridge in Philippines

    A dramatic scene in Metro Manila, Philippines on Wednesday afternoon as several barges crashed into a bridge after being swept downstream by the raging Marikina River. Shocking footage captured the flat-bed vessels slamming into the bridge, with some getting stuck underneath and even sinking. Typhoon Gaemi has brought more intense monsoon rains to the region.

  • 4 Car Brands That Cost Twice as Much To Maintain as the Average Vehicle

    According to Consumer Affairs, "the average car costs around $900 per year to repair and maintain." But some vehicles cost their owners twice that much money or more to keep up and running every year....

  • I Have Driven Over 250 Car Models: These Are the 3 Best and Worst for Your Money

    With so many models and options on the market, choosing the right car for your money isn't easy. The wrong choice leaves you trapped in a money pit, draining your finances with repair costs, poor gas...

  • 'Sabotage' hits French trains hours before Olympics

    Arson attacks scrambled France's high-speed rail network for tens of thousands of passengers on Friday, after what officials called premeditated acts of "sabotage" just hours before the Paris Olympics opened.- Olympics under heavy security - France's intelligence services were scrambling to determine the perpetrators of the sabotage, a security source told AFP. The source added that the arson method used resembled past attacks by extreme-left actors.

  • Pilot recovering after fatal Nepal plane crash

    The pilot and sole survivor of a plane crash in Nepal's capital was recovering in hospital after a miraculous escape from an accident that killed 18 others, aviation officials said Thursday. Gyanendra Bhul of the Civil Aviation Authority told AFP that the pilot remained in hospital but his condition was improving.

  • Thailand car production drops sharply in June, local sales fall

    Car production in Thailand fell 20.11% in June from a year earlier due to tighter financing rules and high consumer debt, and full-year production is now expected to be lower than in 2023, the Federation of Thai Industries (FTI) said on Thursday. In the January-June period, car production contracted 17.39% from a year earlier to 761,240 units, the federation said. "Stricter measures for credit approval from financial institutions, coupled with household debt that was nearing 90% of GDP, led to a higher rejection rate for auto loans," Surapong Paisitpattanapong, spokesman of the FTI's automotive industry division, told a news briefing.

  • Inside Forest's London cycle workshop: How firm keeps the wheels turning on 10,000 e-bikes

    Behind-the-scenes look at challenge of meeting soaring demand from Londoners wanting to hire e-bikes

  • AP Explains: French train lines hit by 'malicious acts' disrupting traffic ahead of Olympics

    High-speed trains around France were hit by several “malicious acts”, heavily disrupting traffic on the day of the high-risk opening ceremony of the Paris Olympics. The AP's Angela Charlton explains.

  • This Bonkers New All-Electric Sports Car Is Poised to Break the Porsche Taycan’s Track Record

    Xiaomi plans to make a run at the record with the SU7 Ultra this fall.

  • 'Sabotage' on French rail network before Olympics: What we know

    Arson attacks scrambled France's high-speed rail network for tens of thousands of passengers on Friday, after what officials called premeditated acts of "sabotage" just hours before the Paris Olympics opened.Friday's attacks were launched as the French capital was under heavy security ahead of the Games opening ceremony, with 300,000 spectators and an audience of VIPs expected at the event.- What was targeted?Fires that affected France's Atlantic, northern and eastern lines led to cancellations and delays at a time of particularly heavy traffic for summer holiday travel."Early this morning, coordinated and prepared acts of sabotage were perpetrated against installations of SNCF," the national rail operator, Prime Minister Gabriel Attal said.SNCF chief executive Jean-Pierre Farandou said the attackers had started fires in "conduits carrying multiple (fibre-optic) cables" that relay "safety information for drivers" or control the motors for points that change rails.- Who is affected?Around 800,000 passengers are expected to be affected over the weekend as the damage is heavy and labour-intensive to repair.France's rail network was expected to be busy this weekend, not only due to the Olympics but also as people return from or leave for their summer holidays."There are huge and serious consequences for the rail network," added Attal.Passenger services chief Christophe Fanichet said there were delays of 90 minutes to two hours on services between Paris and France's north and east."We ask people please not to come to the station, because if you haven't heard from us, your train won't be running," Fanichet told reporters.One major branch of the network, the line to France's southeast, was spared.High-speed rail operator Eurostar said around one in four services across its network linking France, the UK, Belgium, the Netherlands and Germany would be cancelled, including trains from Paris to London.Others would be slower as they will run on regular lines not designed for high-speed trains.- What happens now?Farandou of SNCF said: "There's a huge number of bundled cables. We have to repair them one by one, it's a manual operation" requiring "hundreds of workers".But by early afternoon Friday, Transport Minister Patrice Vergriete said that some departures were going ahead, with "one in three" trains operating from Paris's Montparnasse station, terminus of the line towards Bordeaux and the Atlantic coast.He too urged people not to come to the station without confirmation of their trip.At Montparnasse, passengers were waiting for information, with display boards showing delays of more than two hours."Normal traffic is expected to resume on Monday, July 29," read one of the signs in the departure hall.Paris's RATP transport network was also operating under "increased vigilance" following the railway attacks, its chief executive Jean Castex said as he visited a control station. - Who are the culprits?SNCF CEO Farandou said railway workers doing night maintenance in central France had spotted unauthorised people, who fled when the workers called in police.France's intelligence services were scrambling to determine the perpetrators of the sabotage, a security source told AFP. The arson method used resembled past attacks by extreme-left actors, the source added.In September, arson attacks on conduits holding railway cables caused travel chaos in northern Germany, with a claim of responsibility posted to an extreme-left website.- What legal action is being taken?Paris prosecutor Laure Beccuau said in a statement her office had opened a probe into a suspected bid to undermine "fundamental national interests".The investigation will also look at suspected damage inflicted by an organised gang and attacks on an automated data processing system.Her statement described the acts of sabotage as "deliberate damage caused to sites of SNCF on the night of July 25-26, 2024."burs-tgb-sjw/jj

  • Ulez scrappage scheme that sends cars to Ukraine should be extended across the UK, ambassador says

    The Ulez scrappage scheme that sends used cars to Ukraine should be extended across the UK, the country’s ambassador has said.

  • How Ferdinand Porsche Built an Automotive Legend

    Porsche didn’t just start the sports-car company that bears his name—he is inextricably associated with the history of the automobile.

  • Ford loses $50,000 on every electric car

    Ford loses nearly $50,000 (£38,700) on every electric car it sells, results from the company show, as traditional manufacturers struggle with the switch away from petrol.

  • Arsonists attack French high-speed rail system hours before opening ceremonies of the Paris Olympics

    Arsonists attacked France's high-speed rail network early Friday, setting fires that paralyzed train travel to Paris for some 800,000 people across Europe, including athletes heading to the opening ceremony of the Olympic Games. Targeting remote locations far from the capital, the apparently coordinated attacks sought to cut off rail routes into the city from all directions. Paris Mayor Anne Hidalgo said the damage would not affect the ceremony in which 7,000 Olympic athletes were due to sail down the Seine past iconic Parisian monuments such as Notre-Dame Cathedral, the Louvre Museum and the Musee d’Orsay.

  • These 6 Affordable Cars Should Last Throughout Your Entire Retirement

    If you're planning to retire this year or within the next five years, chances are you'll be reviewing whether you should keep your current vehicle or invest in a new car. The car you buy needs to be...

  • Toyota to build EV battery plant for Lexus cars, Nikkei reports

    TOKYO (Reuters) -Japan's Toyota Motor plans to build a battery plant for electric vehicles in the southwestern prefecture of Fukuoka and supply its batteries to a factory that makes luxury Lexus brand cars, the Nikkei business daily reported on Friday. The world's top-selling automaker would seek to make the island of Kyushu where Fukuoka is located a central part of its supply chain for battery-powered vehicles and an export base for Asia, the newspaper said. A Toyota spokesperson said the company was aware of the report, but that it was not something it had announced.

  • The 10 Greatest All-Electric Hypercars Right Now

    From the McMurtry Spéirling, which covers zero to 60 mph in 1.4 seconds, to the 2,011 hp Lotus Evija X, these EV outliers are otherworldly.

  • 'They were a family unit': Friends, relatives mourn 6 killed as they drove home from vacation

    Two women and four children were killed in a fatal car accident in Arizona as they were traveling back home to Southern California.

  • Eurostar Olympic chaos as vandals target high-speed rail tracks – trains cancelled on first day of Games

    ‘Coordinated acts of malice in France’ are causing cancellations on day of maximum demand – with airspace closure cutting off flight options

  • Eurostar trains cancelled and diverted after ‘acts of malice’ before Olympics

    The rail operator, which runs services from London St Pancras, confirmed on Friday its trains would be delayed.