NASA sued by family whose house was struck by space junk

Vishwam Sankaran
·2-min read
NASA sued by family whose house was struck by space junk

A Florida family is suing NASA after their house was damaged by debris that fell from the International Space Station.

In March, a mystery object weighing about 700g (1.6lbs) crashed into a home in Naples, Florida.

The object ripped through the house’s ceiling and tore up its flooring while the home owner Alejandro Otero’s son was living there.

NASA later confirmed that the strange object was from a metal support to a pallet packed with over two tons of batteries, released from the ISS in 2021.

The space agency planned to release batteries from the ISS after installing new lithium-ion batteries as part of an upgrade.

However, instead of fully burning up on entering the atmosphere, part of the old installation had remained intact, the space agency said.

Now the American family claiming $80,000 from NASA for the damages caused.

“The damages for the Otero family members include non-insured Property Damage loss, Business Interruption damages, Emotional/Mental anguish damages, and the costs for assistance from third parties required in the process,” according to law firm Cranfill Sumner which said NASA has six months to respond to the claim.

The problems posed by space junk to people on Earth have increased in recent years with the increase in space traffic.

Scientists have previously warned that as the density of space debris in low Earth orbit increases, it could cause a cascade of catastrophic collisions that could cause damage both in orbit and on the planet’s surface.

Deorbit of a 2.9 ton battery pallet from the International Space Station. Radar shows falling debris in the Gulf of Mexico extending towards Naples, FL. (NASA)
Deorbit of a 2.9 ton battery pallet from the International Space Station. Radar shows falling debris in the Gulf of Mexico extending towards Naples, FL. (NASA)

“My clients are seeking adequate compensation to account for the stress and impact that this event had on their lives. They are grateful that no one sustained physical injuries from this incident, but a ‘near miss’ situation such as this could have been catastrophic,” lawyer Mica Nguyen Worthy said.

“If the debris had hit a few feet in another direction, there could have been serious injury or a fatality,” she said.

The law firm hopes the case will set a precedent for the future of space debris claims in both the public and private sectors.

“If NASA were to take the position that the Oteros’ claims should be paid in full, it would send a strong signal to both other governments and private industries that such victims should be compensated regardless of fault,” Ms Worthy said.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Astronauts Sheltered in Escape Vehicles as Debris Menaced Space Station

    Shelter in Place Astronauts on board the International Space Station were forced to shelter inside their respective spacecraft after reports indicated pieces of a broken-up satellite were headed their way. The remains of the derelict spacecraft called Resurs-P 1, a Russian commercial Earth observation satellite that launched in June 2013, were spotted by space junk […]

  • China Finds Something Strange in Sample Retrieved From Moon

    Lunar Graphene Chinese scientists have made an unusual discovery while analyzing the sample Chang'e-5 collected from the Moon's surface in December 2020. They found naturally occurring "few-layer graphene" for the first time, as state-run news agency Global Times reports, which could have major implications for our plans to make use of local resources once on […]

  • China calls on scientists of all nations to study lunar samples, but notes obstacle with the US

    China's space officials said Thursday they welcomed scientists from around the world to apply to study the lunar rock samples that the Chang'e 6 probe brought back to Earth in a historic mission, but noted there were limits to that cooperation, specifically with the United States. Officials said at a televised news conference in Beijing meant to introduce the mission's achievements that any cooperation with the U.S. would be hinged on removing an American law that bans direct bilateral cooperation with NASA. "The source of the obstacle in US-China aerospace cooperation is still in the Wolf Amendment,” said Bian Zhigang, vice chair of the China National Space Administration.

  • Surprising asteroid sample reveals Bennu may have originated from an ocean world

    A sample from asteroid Bennu contains organic compounds usually found at midocean ridges on Earth, suggesting Bennu may have been part of an ancient ocean world.

  • Musk's SpaceX hired to destroy ISS space station

    The California-based company will build a "tugboat" to execute the end-of-life disposal of the ISS.

  • A weird sea creature was anatomically unlike anything ever seen — flipping it around led to a revelation

    Researchers have long puzzled over the peculiar innards of an ancient sea creature. A new study says scientists were looking at the Pikaia fossil the wrong way.

  • NASA picks SpaceX to carry ISS to oceanic resting place after 2030

    NASA awarded on Tuesday SpaceX an $843 million contract to build the vessel that will bring the International Space Station out of its longtime orbit of Earth when its operating lifespan ends in 2030. NASA on Tuesday said it had picked SpaceX to build a vessel to carry the International Space Station back through Earth's atmosphere and on to a final resting place in the Pacific Ocean after it is retired in 2030.Elon Musk's company has been awarded a contract with a potential value of $843 millio

  • Why two NASA astronauts are stuck in space and how they might get down

    Two astronauts are stuck in space because Boeing's Starliner can't make the journey back to Earth. Barry "Butch" Wilmore and Sunita "Suni" Williams blasted off on 5 June in Starliner's first mission to orbit carrying astronauts. After docking onto the International Space Station (ISS), the NASA astronauts were supposed to stay in orbit for eight days.

  • ‘Remarkably preserved’ 500-million-year-old sea creature discovered

    New findings have allowed scientists to document features in the extinct animal never seen before.

  • Astronauts stuck aboard ISS as Starliner issues delay return

    STORY: Problems with Boeing’s Starliner capsule have upended the original plans for the return of two astronauts to Earth, leaving them aboard the International Space Station as teams look at last-minute fixes. :: June 5, 2024Since its liftoff on June 5 the capsule has had five helium leaks, five maneuvering thrusters go dead and a propellant valve fail to close completely.The current problems center on Starliner’s expendable propulsion system, which is needed to back away from the ISS and position it to dive through Earth’s atmosphere. Starliner can stay docked at the ISS for up to 45 days, according to comments by NASA’s commercial crew manager Steve Stich. He said recent test-firings of the thrusters gave mission teams confidence in a safe return, though tests and reviews are ongoing. A source who spoke on the condition of anonymity said internally, NASA’s latest targeted return date is July 6. That would mean the mission, originally planned for eight days, would instead last a month. Even with the propulsion issues NASA has said Starliner would still be capable of returning the astronauts to Earth if absolutely necessary – that is, if the capsule must serve as an escape pod.If Starliner is deemed incapable of safely returning Barry "Butch" Wilmore and Sunita "Suni" Williams, one option would be sending them home aboard SpaceX's Crew Dragon.NASA and Boeing officials, as well as engineers familiar with the program, told Reuters nothing about Starliner’s current problems indicates that this would be needed.This is Starliner's first mission to orbit carrying astronauts - the final test needed before NASA can certify it as the U.S. space agency's second ride to the ISS.

  • Beat them or eat them: What should we do about invasive species in the ocean?

    Should we beat them, or eat them? In this episode of Ocean Calls, we’re embarking on a journey to unravel the mysteries of invasive species in EU waters. They unsettle the delicate balance of marine ecosystems, so what can we do about them?

  • NASA Astronauts Again Postpone Return To Earth After Boeing Spacecraft Issues

    There's now no return date set for Boeing's Starliner transportation vessel, after it experienced issues with its thrusters and helium systems.

  • Last woolly mammoths were inbred, but that’s not why they became extinct

    The last woolly mammoths were inbred, scientists have discovered, but this is not the reason they became extinct.

  • Decades after the famed Kyrenia shipwreck’s discovery, researchers have a new estimate of when it sank

    The timeline of a Hellenistic Kyrenia shipwreck stumped researchers for decades. But thanks to a cache of ancient almonds, a new study may have a better estimate.

  • Large asteroid to pass between Earth and the moon on Saturday

    Earth is surrounded by rocky bodies and bits of debris from when the solar system formed roughly 4.5 billion years ago. On Saturday, one of those leftover rocks will whiz past Earth.The asteroid is called 2024 MK and, at its closest, it will pass roughly 290,000 km from Earth. While we have plenty of small asteroids that are scattered within Earth's orbit, this one is sizeable, ranging anywhere from 120 metres to 260 metres in diameter. But there's another interesting — and somewhat disquieting

  • WATCH: NASA enhances weather observation with GOES-U satellite launch

    NASA launched the GOES-U weather satellite on a Falcon Heavy rocket from Kennedy Space Center.View on euronews

  • Sunspot that caused intense solar storms makes dramatic comeback

    Solar storm could bring extreme auroras, as well as ‘complete collapse’ of electrical grids and blackouts, NOAA warns

  • Two US astronauts stuck in space as Boeing analyzes Starliner problems

    Barry Wilmore and Sunita Williams in spacecraft attached to International Space Station as engineers fix problem

  • Moon, 3 planets to align in weekend sky

    The last weekend of June will feature the best astronomy event of the month as three planets fall in line with the crescent moon. Jupiter, Mars and Saturn will appear in a row about an hour before daybreak Saturday morning in the eastern sky. No telescope is needed to see the planets, although stargazers will have to wake up early to see the event, as late June has some of the earliest sunrises of the entire year. The crescent moon will also align with the planetary trio, glowing between Mars an

  • Katy Perry Went Topless in Nothing But Ripped Tights and an Open Jacket at PFW

    Katy Perry went topless in nothing but ripped tights and an open jacket during Paris Fashion Week.