Ohio Teen Gave 33-Year-Old Boyfriend Ultimatum to Kill His Mom. When He Didn't, She Bludgeoned Woman to Death

Nicole Acosta
·3-min read

Kaitlyn Coones, then 17, reportedly admitted that she killed her adult boyfriend's mother because she felt the mom disapproved of their relationship

<p>Cochise County Sheriff

Cochise County Sheriff's Office (2)

Jonathon Jones; Kaitlyn Coones.

An Ohio teenager accused of murdering her adult boyfriend's mother after giving him an ultimatum to do so has been sentenced, along with her boyfriend, who helped dispose of his mother’s body, authorities said.

On June 4, Kaitlyn Coones, 18, and Jonathon Jones, 34, both pleaded no contest to aggravated murder and abuse of a corpse in the 2023 death of Nicole Jones, Lucas County Prosecutor Julia Bates said in a statement obtained by Fox 8, WTOL, and WTVG. After being convicted, the pair were each sentenced to life in prison with the eligibility for parole after 25 years.

Prior to the plea deal, Coones, who was 17 at the time of the murder, had been charged as an adult, PEOPLE previously reported. As part of the plea agreement, prosecutors dropped multiple additional charges against Coones and Jonathon.

Related: Ohio 17-Year-Old Gave Adult Boyfriend 5 Hours to Kill His Mom, Then Killed Woman Herself: Police

Prosecutors previously said that Coones admitted to killing 53-year-old Nicole on April 19, 2023, by bludgeoning her over the head with a rock in her Toledo, Ohio, home because she felt Nicole disapproved of her relationship with her son, WTVG reported.

On April 11, 2023, Coones went missing from her foster home and went to live with her boyfriend Jonathon, who was living with his mother Nicole at the time. Coones reportedly gave Jonathon five hours to kill his mother, threatening to end their relationship if he didn't. When Jonathan did not kill his mother, Coones took it upon herself to murder her, prosecutors said, per the outlet.

Court documents obtained by WTOL state that Coones and Jonathon then disposed of Nicole’s body in a dumpster at an apartment complex. Authorities said they still have not found Nicole’s body, per the outlet.

“In their recorded interviews both defendants detailed wrapping the body of Nicole Jones and tarps and placing her in the trunk of her own vehicle,” prosecutor Jennifer Liptack-Wilson said, according to WTVG. “The two of them had dinner with the body of Nicole Jones still in the truck of the vehicle.”

The pair then fled to Mexico, where they were arrested in May 2023, weeks after the murder, authorities said, per Fox 8.

Related: What We Know About Case of Teen Accused by Police of Killing Boyfriend's Mom After Giving Him Ultimatum

In a previous statement, the U.S. Marshals Service said Jonathon had been wanted for pandering obscene material and child endangerment in Wood County, and Coones was considered an endangered missing child from Canton, Ohio. He had already been convicted on the charges but had evaded sentencing, WTVG previously reported.

Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? Sign up for PEOPLE's free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases.

Following this week's sentencing, Coones and Jonathon face a wrongful death lawsuit filed in April by the administrator of Nicole’s estate, according to court records obtained by Fox 8. According to the WTOL, the suit seeks $25,000 in damages and other associated costs.

In court, Nicole’s brother, Robert Jones, shared how the loss of his sister affected him.

“The agony of losing Nicki is compounded by the unimaginable betrayal we feel,” Robert Jones said, according to WTVG. “We are denied the closure that comes with laying a loved one to rest, and we are haunted by unanswered questions and horrific imaginings of her final moments.”

For more People news, make sure to sign up for our newsletter!

Read the original article on People.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • A father caught a ride share driver assaulting his daughter. He took matters into his own hands

    Her father tracked her phone to a well-known fishing spot

  • 15-Year-Old Accused of Stabbing Mom in Her Sleep Gave Bizarre Explanation About Why She Did It

    Lexi Jade Brown, 15, has been charged with attempted murder and arson, police say

  • Teenager who murdered boy, 17, on crowded dancefloor at party jailed for life

    Charlie Cosser died in hospital two days after the stabbing, suffering a cardiac arrest

  • Celebrity TV sex therapist who regressed patient into childlike state loses civil rape case

    TV sex therapist Mike Lousada made his patient speak like a child before he carried out sexual acts

  • Moment McDonald’s worker opens fire on drive-thru customer who complained about incorrect order

    Chassidy Gardner, 22, of Lakeland, was arrested after police officers responded to a reported shooting at the McDonald’s drive-thru

  • Woman wins £200k in civil rape case after sex therapist claimed his penis could ‘burn up trauma’

    A woman who won a civil rape case against her sex therapist who claimed his penis could “burn up trauma” has been awarded a record £217,000 in damages.

  • 5 family members of Malaysian man who attacked police station face terrorism charges

    The father of a Malaysian man who attacked a police station and killed two police officers last month was charged Wednesday with inciting terrorism in his family. Radin Imran Radin Mohd Yassin, 62, faces four charges including promoting terrorist acts by allegedly instilling the violent ideology of the Islamic State group in his family, including his 21-year-old son Radin Luqman, who was killed by police in the attack. Radin Luqman stormed the police station in southern Johor state near Singapore in the early hours of May 17 with a machete.

  • Acid attacks soar by 75% with growing numbers of female victims

    Half of all corrosive offences last year were against women, a charity has warned, as figures show attacks are soaring

  • Cops nab ‘person of interest’ in Queens park sex attack against 13 year old girl

    NEW YORK — A migrant from Ecuador has been taken into custody for the horrific sexual assault of a 13-year-old girl in a Queens park, police sources said. The suspect, who entered the U.S. through Eagle Pass, Tex. in June 2021, was taken in for questioning around 1:30 a.m. after a group of good Samaritans recognized him as the one allegedly responsible for the Thursday afternoon attack. ...

  • Man arrested in rape of 13-year-old after residents spot him

    Community members helped identify a man who is accused of raping a 13 year old in Queens, New York.

  • A Florida firefighter had his throat slit ear-to-ear in 1987. Police just ID’ed his killer

    William ‘Billy’ Halpern was found beaten, stabbed and strangled in his home in Miramar on October 21 1986

  • Family of murdered teenager say the ‘life sentence is ours’, as killer jailed

    Charlie Cosser, 17, was stabbed three times in the chest in a marquee at a private party in the grounds of a farmhouse in July 2023.

  • Police Release Justin Timberlake’s Mug Shot After DWI Arrest in the Hamptons

    The “Selfish” singer was arrested by the Sag Harbor Police Department early Tuesday, June 18

  • Diplomats say at least 550 pilgrims died during hajj, mostly Egyptians

    Diplomats on Tuesday said at least 550 pilgrims died during the hajj, underscoring the gruelling nature of the pilgrimage which again unfolded in scorching temperatures this year.At least 323 of those who died were Egyptians, most of them succumbing to heat-related illnesses, two Arab diplomats coordinating their countries' responses told AFP."All of them (the Egyptians) died because of heat" except for one who sustained fatal injuries during a minor crowd crush, one of the diplomats said, adding the total figure came from the hospital morgue in the Al-Muaisem neighbourhood of Mecca.At least 60 Jordanians also died, the diplomats said, up from an official tally of 41 given earlier on Tuesday by Amman.The new deaths bring the total reported so far by multiple countries to 577, according to an AFP tally.The diplomats said the total at the morgue in Al-Muaisem, one of the biggest in Mecca, was 550.The hajj is one of the five pillars of Islam and all Muslims with the means must complete it at least once.The pilgrimage is increasingly affected by climate change, according to a Saudi study published last month that said temperatures in the area where rituals are performed were rising 0.4 degrees Celsius (0.72 degrees Fahrenheit) each decade.Temperatures hit 51.8 degrees Celsius (125 Fahrenheit) at the Grand Mosque in Mecca on Monday, the Saudi national meteorology centre said.- Heat stress -Earlier on Tuesday, Egypt's foreign ministry said Cairo was collaborating with Saudi authorities on search operations for Egyptians who had gone missing during the hajj.While a ministry statement said "a certain number of deaths" had occurred, it did not specify whether Egyptians were among them.Saudi authorities have reported treating more than 2,000 pilgrims suffering from heat stress but have not updated that figure since Sunday and have not provided information on fatalities.At least 240 pilgrims were reported dead by various countries last year, most of them Indonesians.AFP journalists in Mina, outside Mecca, on Monday saw pilgrims pouring bottles of water over their heads as volunteers handed out cold drinks and fast-melting chocolate ice cream to help them keep cool.Saudi officials had advised pilgrims to use umbrellas, drink plenty of water and avoid exposure to the sun during the hottest hours of the day.But many of the hajj rituals, including the prayers on Mount Arafat which took place on Saturday, involve being outdoors for hours in the daytime.Some pilgrims described seeing motionless bodies on the roadside and ambulance services that appeared overwhelmed at times.Around 1.8 million pilgrims took part in the hajj this year, 1.6 million of them from abroad, according to Saudi authorities.- Unregistered pilgrims -Each year tens of thousands of pilgrims attempt to perform the hajj through irregular channels as they cannot afford the often costly procedures for official hajj visas.This places these off-the-books pilgrims at risk as they cannot access air-conditioned facilities provided by Saudi authorities along the hajj route.One of the diplomats who spoke to AFP on Tuesday said that the Egyptian death toll was "absolutely" boosted by a large number of unregistered Egyptian pilgrims."Irregular pilgrims caused great chaos in the Egyptian pilgrims' camps, causing the collapse of services," said an Egyptian official supervising the country's hajj mission."The pilgrims went without food, water, or air conditioning for a long time."They died "from the heat because most people had no place" to take shelter.Earlier this month, Saudi officials said they had cleared hundreds of thousands of unregistered pilgrims from Mecca ahead of the hajj.Other countries to report deaths during the hajj this year include Indonesia, Iran and Senegal.Most countries have not specified how many deaths were heat-related.Saudi Health Minister Fahd bin Abdul Rahman Al-Jalajel said on Tuesday that health plans for the hajj had "been successfully carried out", preventing major outbreaks of disease and other public health threats, the official Saudi Press Agency reported.Health officials "provided virtual consultations to over 5,800 pilgrims, primarily for heat-related illnesses, enabling prompt intervention and mitigating the potential for a surge in cases," SPA said.bur/jsa

  • Jewish girl gang-raped and called ‘dirty Jew’ by child attackers in Paris suburb

    A 12-year-old Jewish girl was gang-raped by child attackers who taunted her with anti-Semitic slurs in a case that has shocked France.

  • Man killed in alleged ‘devastating’ road rage incident in Sydney, police look for ute driver

    A 27-year-old man was allegedly struck down in morning traffic in Blackett after feeling threatened by the vehicle following him

  • Mysterious monolith discovered in desert near Las Vegas

    A mysterious monolith has baffled police officers in Las Vegas after it was spotted glimmering in a remote mountain range near the neon-lit city. Las Vegas police said members of a volunteer search and rescue unit encountered the mirrored object near Gass Peak in the Desert National Wildlife Refuge in Nevada. Officers have no idea where the monolith came from and have said they expect social media users will try to solve the mystery.

  • Drunk Driver Drove to Work with Severed Arm of Pedestrian He Killed in the Passenger Seat, Police Say

    Juan Morgan Munoz, 31, is allegely behind a fatal hit-and-run in Dallas

  • Doctor wishes he had ‘courage’ to report Lucy Letby for attempted murder of baby, court hears

    A doctor has admitted that if he “had more courage” he would have called police immediately after he claimed to have caught Lucy Letby attempting to murder a baby.

  • Child rapist jailed after 15 years of abuse

    Grant Venamore's youngest victim was just four years old when the abuse began.