Popular sunscreens fail safety test - as £2.49 rival passes with flying colours

Sky News
Updated ·2-min read

Some of the UK's most popular sunscreens have failed safety tests - but cheaper alternatives from Aldi and Lidl passed with flying colours.

Which? examined the SPF and UVA protection offered by products on supermarket shelves, and warned three in particular fell short:

• Asda Protect Moisturising Sun Lotion SPF 30 High
• Calypso Press & Protect Sun Lotion SPF 30
• Bondi Sands SPF 50+ Fragrance Free Face Sunscreen Lotion

The consumer watchdog tested face-specific sunscreens for the first time this year, and Asda's lotion failed both rounds of testing.

Calypso's sunscreen - which costs £8 for 200ml - "barely mustered" offering two-thirds of the protection it claims to offer on the bottle.

And the Bondi Sands product, at £7.99 for 75ml, "did not come close" to the claimed SPF, with the research suggesting it also lacked the minimum UVA protection that's required.

By contrast, Lidl's Cien Sun Spray SPF 30 - which costs £3.29 for 200ml - "triumphed" in both tests and did an "all-round excellent job" protecting skin.

Aldi's Lacura SPF 30 Sun Lotion, priced at just £2.49 for 200ml, also passed.

Read more travel news:
Top tips when getting holiday money
World's best restaurant revealed

Which? head of home products Natalie Hitchins said it is "incredibly concerning that some big brands failed our tests" - but it is encouraging to see affordable options on the high street.

"Our results prove there's no need to splash out to keep you and your loved ones safe in the sun this summer and that many of the supermarket own-brand products can do a good job," she added.

Asda said it does not recognise these results - and recent tests by an external provider had confirmed its product had a sun protection factor of 31.5.

"When Which? reviewed this same product in 2022, they awarded it 'Great Value' at that time and it passed their SPF test," a spokesman added.

Calypso Sun said: "All products are carefully and independently tested and have passed EU standards and regulations."

Bondi Sands also questioned the findings, and said its tests had shown its product meets international standards and had an SPF of 61.5 - far beyond the 50+ on the bottle - and also offers UVA protection.

"All of our products undergo rigorous testing processes to ensure they meet and exceed industry standards and requirements. Bondi Sands will work with Which to better understand testing results," a statement added.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • India opposition asks Modi government to question Foxconn hiring practices

    India's opposition Congress urged Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government on Saturday to question Foxconn about its hiring practices after Reuters reported that the Apple supplier rejects married women from iPhone assembly jobs in the country. The government has sought a detailed report from the state of Tamil Nadu, site of a major iPhone factory where Reuters uncovered Foxconn's hiring practices. The story has sparked debates on TV channels, newspaper editorials and calls from women groups, including within Modi's party, to investigate the matter.

  • European Union's competition boss signals fresh AI scrutiny for Microsoft-OpenAI deal and Google

    The European Union is escalating its scrutiny of the artificial intelligence industry, including taking a fresh look into Microsoft's multibillion-dollar partnership with OpenAI, a top EU official said Friday. The European Commission, the bloc's executive arm, started reviewing the deal last year to see whether it broke EU merger rules but dropped it after concluding Microsoft hadn't gained control of OpenAI, Margrethe Vestager, the commission’s executive vice-president for competition policy, said in a speech. “Microsoft has invested $13 billion in OpenAI over the years,” she said “But we have to make sure that partnerships like this do not become a disguise for one partner getting a controlling influence over the other.”

  • Eagles singer Don Henley sues for return of handwritten ‘Hotel California’ lyrics

    Eagles singer Don Henley filed a lawsuit in New York on Friday seeking the return of his handwritten notes and song lyrics from the band’s hit “Hotel California” album. The civil complaint filed in Manhattan federal court comes after prosecutors in March abruptly dropped criminal charges midway through a trial against three collectibles experts accused of scheming to sell the documents. The Eagles co-founder has maintained the pages were stolen and had vowed to pursue a lawsuit when the criminal case was dropped against rare books dealer Glenn Horowitz, former Rock & Roll Hall of Fame curator Craig Inciardi and rock memorabilia seller Edward Kosinski.

  • The 15 biggest chain restaurants in the US, ranked

    Olive Garden, Applebee's, and Texas Roadhouse ranked among the top chain restaurants in the US.

  • Binance must face bulk of US SEC crypto lawsuit, judge rules

    The decision by Judge Amy Berman Jackson of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia deals a blow to Binance, which had asked the court to toss the SEC's lawsuit that alleges Binance and its founder and former CEO Changpeng Zhao broke securities laws. The SEC's suit filed against Binance in June 2023 accused the exchange and Zhao of artificially inflating its trading volumes, diverting customer funds, failing to restrict U.S. customers from its platform and misleading investors about its market surveillance controls.

  • 5 In-Demand AI Jobs That Pay More Than $100,000 — That You Can Do From Home

    As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes more ubiquitous, it will shake up the working world as we know it. According to a World Economic Forum report, an estimated 85 million jobs could be displaced...

  • Visa, Mastercard can likely handle settlement much bigger than $30 billion, judge says

    A federal judge said Visa and Mastercard can likely withstand a "substantially greater" settlement with merchants who said they overpaid on swipe fees than the $30 billion accord she rejected this week. U.S. District Judge Margo Brodie in Brooklyn made her assessment in an 88-page opinion released on Friday, three days after announcing her rejection of the preliminary settlement. The accord covering more than 12 million merchants would have lowered and capped swipe fees, also known as interchange fees, they pay to handle Visa and Mastercard transactions.

  • ‘I can’t get paid.’ Cyberattack affecting car dealerships brings chaos for sellers, buyers and workers

    As the ongoing systems outage at software provider CDK Global stretches into its second week, car dealerships are racking up millions of dollars in losses, according to a new estimate.

  • Is There Really A Difference Between Cheap And Expensive Sunscreen?

    Not sure which brand of sunscreen is best? Experts weigh in on the difference in ingredients, effectiveness and more across different price points.

  • 4 Fast-Food Jobs That Pay $100,000

    Certain roles within major fast-food chains offer surprisingly high earning potential in an industry often associated with low wages and entry-level positions. High-paying fast-food restaurant jobs...

  • These 20 cult-fave beauty products for head-to-toe gorgeousness start at just $5

    From do-it-all products that solve wrinkles and pimples to an all-in-one makeup stick, they're all less than $20.

  • I’m a Self-Made Millionaire: Here’s How I’ll Know When I Can Safely Retire

    Becoming a millionaire and retiring is a dream for many Americans, and many of the self-made ones often achieve this feat thanks to hard work, persistence, patience and discipline, and thanks to...

  • 7-Eleven Is Using Japanese Strategies to Redefine Its Business — Again

    U.S. 7-Elevens have long trailed their Japanese counterparts in prepared foods. Now they’re trying to catch up, and market an expanded menu to customers who associate them with Slurpees and pizza.

  • Jennifer Garner, 52, 'loves' this SPF-infused moisturizer — at $17, it's 40% off

    The celeb says the cream, packed with hyaluronic acid to infuse skin with moisture, makes her feel 'dewy and great.'

  • Here’s what it means when a company like Boeing faces criminal charges

    Criminal charges against a corporation, like the ones the Justice Department is considering bringing against Boeing, would be a serious blow, worsening the company’s already precarious financial situation and further damaging its battered reputation. But it wouldn’t necessarily result in past or current executives facing prison time.

  • Texas wins court block on Biden overtime pay rule

    (Reuters) -A federal judge in Texas on Friday temporarily blocked a Biden administration rule from taking effect that would extend mandatory overtime pay to 4 million salaried U.S. workers. U.S. District Judge Sean Jordan in Sherman, Texas, said the U.S. Department of Labor rule that is set to go into effect on Monday improperly bases eligibility for overtime pay on workers' wages rather than their job duties. Jordan, an appointee of Republican former President Donald Trump, blocked the Labor Department from applying the rule to state workers in Texas pending the outcome of a legal challenge by the Republican-led state.

  • After my husband and I stopped wearing our wedding rings, we tried polyamory. 3 years later, we're happily nonmonogamous.

    My husband and I were monogamous before we got married. When we stopped wearing our wedding rings, we decided to try polyamory.

  • ‘I’m not going to buy electric again – it’s the worst car I’ve ever had’

    Ray Bestwick bought an electric car last May in the hope of hassle-free motoring.

  • Elizabeth Hurley, 59, is a goddess in tiny string bikini

    Elizabeth Hurley showed off her incredible physique in a yellow string bikini as she posed for Instagram – and the Gossip Girl actress, 59, looked better than ever. See photos.

  • Amal Clooney, 46, is glowing in flirty floral dress as she walks hand in hand with George Clooney

    George Clooney and his wife, Amal, were spotted in St Tropez this past week, and Amal made the most of the glorious sunshine with a flirty floral mini dress. See the pictures here...