Russia's thwarting of precision Western weapons in Ukraine shows the value of things like old-fashioned, unguided artillery, European general says

Lloyd Lee
Updated ·2-min read

  • Russia has been jamming precision Western weapons in Ukraine through its electronic countermeasures.

  • A Finnish general told The Wall Street Journal it showed there were still uses for unguided artillery.

  • "They are immune to any type of jamming," he said.

Russia's thwarting of precision weapons provided to Ukraine by the West shows there are still use cases for unguided artillery in technologically advanced warfare, a Finnish general told The Wall Street Journal.

Weapons guided by a GPS system provide precision strikes against enemy targets and have been crucial for some of Ukraine's prior countermeasures against Russia during the war.

The M142 High Mobility Artillery Rocket System, which can hit targets up to 50 miles away, was once seen as a vital lifeline for Ukraine in order to stop Russia's advance in the summer of 2022.

But those same precision weapons, which are being supplied by the West, are being rendered ineffective as Russia adapts on the battlefield and engages in electronic warfare.

The methods involve jamming or spoofing the GPS systems in weapons so they're led off course. These electronic countermeasures are often cheap and can also be used against drones, as Business Insider previously reported. Both Ukraine and Russia have engaged in electronic warfare.

The Journal reported that these measures had also thwarted the Ground-Launched Small Diameter Bomb, a US-Swedish guided bomb that has a range of 94 miles, that Ukraine received in early February.

Lt. Gen. Esa Pulkkinen, the permanent secretary of Finland's defense ministry, told the Journal that electronic warfare had shown there were still uses for less-advanced, unguided artillery shells.

"They are immune to any type of jamming, and they will go to target regardless of what type of electronic-warfare capability there may be," Pulkkinen told The Journal.

The New York Times reported last year that precision-guided weapons had been a large point of focus for the US's broader defense strategy, but in Ukraine, the war was largely being fought with unguided artillery.

As a result, the US and others in the West have ramped up production of unguided artillery shells. Pentagon officials have said the US aims to increase production of 155mm artillery shells, which are shot out of howitzers, to 100,000 a month by 2025.

Read the original article on Business Insider

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Ukraine developed new shields for its US-made Bradleys, which are excelling against Russia

    Ukraine has created new shields for its much-admired US-supplied Bradley infantry fighting vehicles to help protect them from the threat of drones.

  • Ukraine may have just scored its longest-range drone strike yet in Russian territory — a Tu-22M3 supersonic bomber about 1,100 miles away

    The Tu-22M3 is a long-range supersonic bomber designed to take out sea- and ground-based targets using guided missiles and aerial bombs.

  • The US says it has successfully practiced using a low-cost bomb to sink a major surface ship. China is taking note

    A very specialized part of the world’s largest naval drills off the northern Hawaiian island of Kauai is gaining attention on both sides of the Pacific.

  • North Korea mobilises military helicopters for flood rescue

    North Korea deployed military helicopters to bring thousands of people stranded in a flood-hit zone to safety, state media reported Monday.The official Korean Central News Agency (KCNA) reported leader Kim Jong Un last week "personally guided" a military rescue -- including 10 helicopters and navy lifeboats -- shaking the hands of the pilots "one by one".

  • Ukrainian ex-convicts seek second chance in army service

    Former car thief Bohdan Filonenko had a simple response for fellow inmates who criticized his decision to join Ukraine's military. Filonenko, 32, is among thousands of Ukrainian prisoners who signed up under a new law granting them amnesty in exchange for army service. In addition to overhauling the draft, authorities have also courted convicts like Filonenko, who is now training with the 57th Motorised Infantry Brigade, to boost their ranks with motivated men.

  • Ukrainian troops say Russia has driven them out of 2 more eastern Donetsk villages

    Russian forces have overrun two front-line villages in Ukraine’s eastern Donetsk region, a Ukrainian army sergeant said Monday, after relentless assaults that are part of a Kremlin summer push to overwhelm battlefield defenses there. Separately, attacks in Russia's Kursk region by the Security Service of Ukraine, also known as the SBU, struck a number of substations causing power outages, according to a statement from the General Staff of Ukraine.

  • Russia inches toward strategic supply route in Ukraine's east

    KYIV (Reuters) -Russian forces are focusing their heaviest assaults near Ukraine's strategic eastern city of Pokrovsk, Kyiv said on Monday, as Moscow bears down on a key Ukrainian supply route more than 29 months since its full-scale invasion. Fighting on the Pokrovsk front was the fiercest anywhere in the war-scarred east, the General Staff said in a regular battlefield update, adding that Ukraine had fought off 52 Russian assaults there in the last 24 hours. Pokrovsk, a transport hub with a pre-war population of 61,000, lies on a main road that serves as an important supply route to other embattled Ukrainian-held outposts, such as the towns of Chasiv Yar and Kostiantynivka in the Donetsk region.

  • US tests ‘Quicksink’ low-cost bombs which could sink Chinese Navy ships

    The United States has successfully tested a low-cost bomb that can sink ships the size of aircraft carriers, an innovation that could prove a potential game changer in a war with China, experts say.

  • Turkish official accuses Israel of targeting Erdogan after he seemed to threaten to invade over Gaza

    A senior Turkish official on Monday accused the Israeli government of trying to “hide your war crimes” by targeting President Recep Tayyip Erdogan after he seemingly threatened to invade Israel. The post criticized Israel's actions against Palestinians in Gaza. In televised remarks to ruling party officials late Sunday, Erdogan had commented on Israel’s military operations.

  • Russia needs men so badly that its sign-up bonuses are nearly on par with the US military's

    Russia has raised recruitment bonuses to $22,000 to attract more soldiers, placing it on par with the US military's basic bonus of $15,000.

  • Russia takes control of Lozuvatske settlement in eastern Ukraine

    Russia's defence ministry said on Saturday that its forces had taken control of the settlement of Lozuvatske in the Pokrovsk sector of Ukraine's Donetsk region, site of some of the most heated frontline battles in the 29-month-old war. Ukraine's General Staff made no mention of the settlement in its reports, but noted that the area around it was gripped by heavy fighting. Unofficial military bloggers have reported the loss of at least two other localities in the sector.

  • Israel army says 9 soldiers held over suspected abuse of detainee

    The Israeli military said Monday nine soldiers were being held in a case of suspected abuse of a Palestinian detainee at a facility holding Palestinians arrested from Gaza during the war.The military said it has opened an investigation into the "suspected abuse" of a detainee at the Sde Teiman base set up for holding Palestinians arrested in Gaza since the war broke out.

  • Israeli strike on Gaza school killed 30 - health ministry

    More than 100 were injured, the Hamas-run ministry said, adding that most victims were children.

  • Biden administration announces new $1.7 billion lethal aid package for Ukraine

    The Biden administration announced on Monday a new lethal aid package for Ukraine totaling about $1.7 billion and largely consisting of missiles and ammunition for missile, artillery and air defense systems the US has previously provided to Ukraine.

  • US, Japan take a swipe at China and deepen defence ties

    The United States and Japan issued scathing verbal attacks on China and Russia on Sunday after high-level discussions on enhancing already close defence collaboration between Tokyo and Washington in an increasingly unstable region.The discussions between Japan and the United States also covered enhancing Washington's "extended deterrence" commitment to use its military capabilities, including nuclear weapons, to protect Japan.

  • Quad foreign ministers decry dangerous S. China Sea actions

    TOKYO (Reuters) -Foreign ministers from Australia, India, Japan and the United States said on Monday they were seriously concerned about intimidating and dangerous manoeuvres in the South China Sea and pledged to bolster maritime security in the region. The joint statement came after talks between the so-called 'Quad' countries in Tokyo, attended by Australia's Penny Wong, India's Subrahmanyam Jaishankar, Japan's Yoko Kamikawa and Antony Blinken from the U.S..

  • Israeli military detains 9 soldiers over alleged abuse of a detainee at a shadowy military facility

    The Israeli military said Monday it was holding nine soldiers for questioning following allegations of “substantial abuse” of a detainee at a shadowy facility where Israel has held Palestinian prisoners throughout the war in Gaza. The military did not disclose additional details surrounding the alleged abuse, saying only that its top legal official had launched a probe. An investigation by The Associated Press and reports by rights groups have exposed abysmal conditions and abuses at the Sde Teiman facility, the country’s largest detention center.

  • Israel vows to hit 'enemy' after rocket kills 12 in annexed Golan

    Israeli Defence Minister Yoav Gallant on Sunday vowed to "hit the enemy hard" after rocket fire from Lebanon killed 12 young people in the Israeli-annexed Golan Heights and again raised fears that the war in Gaza will spread.Iran warned Israel any new military "adventures" in Lebanon could lead to "unforeseen consequences".Israel's army called it "the deadliest attack on Israeli civilians" since the October 7 attack that began the war in Gaza and triggered regular exchanges of fire across the Lebanese border.Israel blamed Lebanon's Hezbollah movement for the rocket fire but the Iran-backed group -- which has regularly targeted Israeli military positions -- said it had "no connection" to the incident.It came hours after officials in Hamas-run Gaza said an Israeli strike on a school housing thousands of displaced Palestinians killed at least 30 people. Israel said it was targeting "terrorists" operating from the school.- Netanyahu cuts short trip -The rocket fire in Majdal Shams prompted Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to return early from the United States to convene his security cabinet."Israel will not let this murderous attack go unanswered and Hezbollah will pay a heavy price for it, a price it has not paid before," Netanyahu said.The Israeli foreign ministry said Hezbollah had "crossed all red lines".Israel's military said later Sunday it hit Hezbollah targets "both deep inside Lebanese territory and in southern Lebanon".An Israeli drone fired two missiles at the village of Taraiyya in eastern Lebanon, destroying a hanger and a home without causing casualties, a Lebanese security source told AFP.Hezbollah has said its cross-border fire is an act of support for Palestinian Islamists from Hamas who have been fighting Israel' military since October 7 when they attacked southern Israel.That attack resulted in the deaths of 1,197 people in Israel, mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official Israeli figures.Militants also seized 251 hostages, 111 of whom are still held captive in Gaza, including 39 the military says are dead.Israel's retaliatory military campaign in Gaza has killed at least 39,258 people, according to the health ministry in the Hamas-run territory, which does not provide details on civilian and militant deaths.The rocket strike on the Druze town of Majdal Shams hit a football pitch and killed young people aged 10 to 20, Israel's military said.Gallant visited the scene early Sunday, standing with security forces beside the mangled fence and abandoned scooters.- Call for restraint -In the wake of the strike, an AFP photographer saw medics carrying casualties on stretchers at the scene, where dozens of residents had gathered.The United Nations on Sunday urged "maximum restraint", in a joint statement from their special coordinator for Lebanon, Jeanine Hennis-Plasschaert, and UN Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL) chief Aroldo Lazaro.Intensifying exchanges of fire "could ignite a wider conflagration that would engulf the entire region in a catastrophe beyond belief," they said.The United States National Security Council condemned what it described as a "horrific attack" in Majdal Shams.The rocket fire on Majdal Shams came after an Israeli strike killed four Hezbollah fighters in south Lebanon, prompting the militant group to announce a flurry of retaliatory rocket attacks against the Golan and northern Israel.Lebanon's government called for "an immediate cessation of hostilities on all fronts".Rhetoric on both sides escalated once again following the rocket strike."Any ignorant action of the Zionist regime can lead to the broadening of the scope of instability, insecurity and war in the region," said Iran's foreign ministry spokesman Nasser Kanani.Israel's Foreign Ministry called the incident in Majdal Shams a "massacre" that "constitutes the crossing of all red lines by Hezbollah" which the ministry accused of deliberately targeting civilians.Majdal Shams is a Druze town where many residents have not accepted Israeli nationality since Israel seized the Golan Heights from Syria in 1967. Druze traditionally follow an offshoot of Shiite Islam.The violence since October has killed at least 527 people in Lebanon, according to an AFP tally. Most of the dead have been fighters but the toll includes at least 104 civilians.On the Israeli side, 18 soldiers and 24 civilians have been killed, according to Israeli authorities.- 'Madness' -Tens of thousands of residents have been displaced from the border areas in both southern Lebanon and northern Israel.In a speech to the United States Congress on Wednesday, Netanyahu said Israel will do "whatever it must" to secure its northern border.Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah said this month that if a ceasefire is reached in Gaza his movement would stop cross-border attacks.In central Gaza, the school strike on Saturday was at least the eighth on a school since July 6.It prompted European Union foreign affairs chief Josep Borrell to call for a "political solution" to end the "madness" in Gaza, while Irish Prime Minister Simon Harris said: "Targeting an area populated with displaced families is inhumane and despicable."Further south in the Khan Yunis city area, around 170 people have been killed "and hundreds wounded" in an Israeli operation since Monday, Gaza's civil defence agency said.bur-rsc/it

  • Zelensky visits Ukraine front as Moscow claims fresh gains

    Russia said on Monday its forces had captured the village of Vovche in eastern Ukraine, the latest in a string of frontline advances Moscow has claimed in recent weeks.The announcement came as Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky visited special forces in the border region of Kharkiv, where Moscow's forces launched a surprise ground offensive in May but failed to make any major breakthrough.Now grinding through a third year of fighting, neither Kyiv nor Moscow has managed to swing the conflict decisively in their favour, even though Moscow's forces have gained ground in recent months.Moscow's defence ministry said in a daily briefing its units had "liberated" Vovche in the eastern region of Donetsk.The settlement lies about 16 kilometres (10 miles) northwest of Avdiivka, a factory town Russia captured in February.Ukrainian authorities urged remaining residents to evacuate from Vovche last month amid Russian air strikes. Only seven people were left in the village out of a pre-conflict population of around 100.Industrial Donetsk has borne the brunt of fighting between Ukrainian troops and invading Russian forces. It has been partially controlled by Kremlin-supported separatists since 2014.- 'Counting on you' -The Kremlin claimed to have annexed it and three other Ukrainian territories late in 2022 despite not fully controlling them.Ukraine's head of the Donetsk region Vadym Filashkin said Russian forces had killed three people and wounded three more on Monday in the town of Toretsk, which is under Kyiv's control.Russian troops have been closing in on the town that was once home to around 30,000 people in a fresh assault, following a period of relative calm."One person was also killed in Grodivka," Filashkin added -- a village that had a pre-war population of around 2,200 people and lies on the path of Russian forces towards the rail hub of Pokrvosk.The Kharkiv region, which Zelensky visited on Monday, has been under daily shelling by Russian forces since they invaded in February 2022."Kharkiv...  The forward command post of the Special Operations Forces of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, in the area of Vovchansk," Zelensky wrote on social media, announcing the visit.Zelensky described the front in Kharkiv as "one of the most difficult" and told assembled special forces: "The whole country is counting on you."The Ukrainian military said on Monday it had repelled six Russian attacks on the Kharkiv front line over the past day, including at Vovchansk.Russian forces have been trying to capture the small town five kilometres from its border since launching the offensive in the Kharkiv region in May.Moscow made its most significant territorial gains in around 18 months with that offensive, but fell short of its ambition to create a "security zone" to protect Russian border towns from Ukrainian attacks.Russian forces also detained 25 people in parts of Ukraine they control for allegedly supporting and "aiding" Kyiv, Russia's National Guard said.The arrests were made in Ukraine's Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions, large swathes of which Moscow captured after it launched its full-scale assault on the country in February 2022.bur-jbr/jc/gil

  • Israel-Hezbollah all-out war still unlikely - with signs IDF not expecting Lebanon border escalation despite strikes

    What does this attack mean for people in the region - and does it signal a major escalation in the border war that Israel and Hezbollah have been fighting over the Lebanese frontier? Israel was adamant that Iran-backed Hezbollah was responsible for the assault on a football pitch in the community of Majdal Shams. Israel's chief military spokesman Daniel Hagari said the rocket was launched from an area near a village called Chebaa in southern Lebanon.