Senate sinks competing IVF bills: How did they differ?

Joseph Choi
·3-min read

Two Senate bills from different sides of the aisle aimed at protecting access to in vitro fertilization (IVF) were voted down this week amid bipartisan squabbling.

The Right to IVF Act — sponsored by Democratic Sens. Tammy Duckworth (Ill.), Patty Murray (Wash.) and Cory Booker (N.J.) — and the IVF Protection Act — sponsored by Republican Sens. Katie Britt (Ala.) and Ted Cruz (Texas) — were shot down this week along party lines.

Democrats blocked a unanimous request by Republicans on Wednesday, arguing the GOP bill didn’t go far enough in ensuring IVF access. Murray called the legislation “a PR tool, plain and simple.”

“Even though it is an inherent part of the IVF process that families will make more embryos than they need, this bill does absolutely nothing—not a single thing—to ensure families who use IVF can have their clinics dispose of unused embryos without facing legal threats for a standard medical procedure,” Murray said.

“Instead, this bill completely ignores the matter of what happens to frozen embryos, in order to appease Republicans’ extreme anti-abortion allies. This was intentional—and it leaves the door open to a lot of chaos.”

“If Democrats allowed the IVF Protection Act to pass today, they would lose a key scare tactic they believe helps them in November,” Britt said following the vote. “And that is ultimately what this is all about.”

Republicans returned the favor Thursday, blocking the Democrats’ bill from moving forward. GOP senators criticized the vote as an election year stunt and brought up concerns over unfunded mandates, as well as the possible impact on religious freedom.

President Biden lambasted the vote, saying in a statement Thursday, “Once again, Senate Republicans refused to protect access to fertility treatments for women who are desperately trying to get pregnant.”

While these bills were crafted with the same intentions on the surface, there are key differences.

The Republican IVF Protection Act would bar states from receiving Medicaid funding if they implement a ban on IVF. Democrats argue this bill incentivizes far-right Republican policymakers to both defund Medicaid and ban IVF at the same time.

It also explicitly does not guarantee a right to IVF services.

“Nothing in the IVF Protection Act shall be construed to compel any individual or organization to provide in vitro fertilization services,” the legislation reads.

While the bill urges states to not pass IVF bans, it would not stop courts from restricting access to the service. It would also have permitted restrictions on how embryos are stored, implanted and disposed of.

The Democrats’ version is more comprehensive, being a collection of four bills that would establish a national right to IVF services and other assisted reproductive technology.

The bill would establish the right of a patient to receive fertility treatment from a health care provider; to continue or complete an ongoing fertility treatment previously initiated by a health care provider; to make decisions on what happens to reproductive genetic material; and to establish contracts on a provider’s handling, testing, storing, shipping and disposing of the genetic material.

Fertility treatments and counseling would be added to Title 38 of the U.S. Code, which outlines Veterans’ Benefits. State Medicaid plans would also be required to provide assistance for fertility treatments.

This story was updated at 7:08 p.m.

Copyright 2024 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • China's Xi accused the US of trying to trick him into invading Taiwan, but said he won't take the bait, report says

    Xi Jinping told an EU leader that the US was trying to trick China into invading Taiwan, per the Financial Times, amid increasing tensions.

  • China is almost ready for its war with the West

    While Russian forces continued their thrust towards Kharkiv over the weekend, world leaders descended on the Swiss resort of Bürgenstock in attempts to work out what a peace deal should look like. Vladimir Putin, predictably, had no interest in attending, but the absence of another world leader was more significant. Even as the US gears up to pivot its military attention to the Indo-Pacific to confront an increasingly assertive China, Xi Jinping chose not to attend.

  • Disappointing end to Ukraine summit as allies agree to watered-down peace declaration

    Kyiv and its allies agreed on a watered-down declaration at a peace summit in Switzerland that backed Ukraine’s territorial integrity but failed to lay out steps to end the war.

  • ‘This country gave me a lot’: the Vietnamese people staying in Ukraine

    People across Ukraine have united in the face of the Russian threat and its Vietnamese community is no exception

  • Philippine, Chinese ships collide near hotspot reef

    Philippine and Chinese vessels collided near the Second Thomas Shoal in the South China Sea on Monday, with both sides accusing the other of being to blame for the incident.It has in recent months stepped up moves against Philippine vessels in the area around Second Thomas Shoal.

  • US renews warning it's obligated to defend the Philippines after its new clash with China at sea

    The United States renewed a warning Tuesday that it’s obligated to defend its close treaty ally a day after Filipino navy personnel were injured and their supply boats damaged in one of the most serious confrontations between the Philippines and China in a disputed shoal in the South China Sea, officials said. China and the Philippines blamed each other for instigating Monday’s hostilities in the Second Thomas Shoal, which has been occupied by a small Filipino navy contingent aboard a grounded warship that's been closely watched by Chinese coast guard, navy and suspected militia ships in a yearslong territorial standoff. There is fear the disputes, long regarded as an Asian flashpoint, could escalate and pit the United States and China in a larger conflict.

  • Pornography and social media driving rise in labia surgery, Australian report finds

    More than half a million people have had or considered having the procedure due to lack of education and diverse representation, survey shows

  • Putin sacks four deputy defence ministers and appoints relative

    Vladimir Putin has sacked four deputy defence ministers and appointed one of his relatives to the role as he carries out a sweeping purge of officials in charge during the botched invasion of Ukraine.

  • The British Army trains in Kenya. Many women say soldiers raped them and abandoned children they fathered

    Seventeen-year-old Marian Pannalossy cuts a striking figure wherever she goes in Archer’s Post, a small town 200 miles north of Nairobi. She lives alone and is light-skinned in a place where mixed-race people are a rarity and therefore ostracized.

  • Joe Biden appears to freeze again at fundraiser as Barack Obama helps him off stage

    It is the latest in a series of incidents that have sparked concerns about the president’s health

  • Britain shouldn’t wave the nuclear white flag. We could flatten Russia

    As Sir Keir Starmer and his Labour party move ever faster towards No 10, aided by the Conservative party’s penchant to fall on its sword with monotonous regularity, we will soon be forced to confront the nuclear-warhead-sized elephant in the room. Promises to grow the economy are all well and good, but the security of the country is of paramount importance, especially when our Russian enemy has made its hatred for us clear.

  • Spain seeks to avert trade war after China announces pork anti-dumping probe

    SANTANDER/MADRID (Reuters) -Leading EU pork exporter Spain on Monday said it was working with European Union officials to avoid damaging tariffs after Beijing said it would open an anti-dumping inquiry. China's investigation appears mainly targeted at Spain, the Netherlands, France and Denmark, the three biggest EU exporters of pork to China. Its announcement follows one from the European Commission last week that it would impose anti-subsidy duties on imported Chinese cars from July.

  • State Department rejects Xi’s claim that US wants China to invade Taiwan

    State spokesman says ‘One China’ policy unchanged after question from The Independent

  • One-Two Punch From the Skies Is a Massive Blow to Putin

    Ukraine’s military has spent the last two years chronically short of planes. Its prewar stocks were already small in number and mostly dated from the Soviet era. When NATO and other countries sent help, they focused on either sending the same older models or keeping existing aircraft in the air through maintenance and spare parts. Russia, meanwhile, has a larger and often more advanced air force.However, new planes are on the way to help Ukraine. For nearly a year, countries like the Netherlands

  • Pelosi’s split from Jeffries on Netanyahu invite prompts quiet backlash from Democrats

    Former Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) has fanned the flames of the internal Democratic battle over Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coming speech to Congress, questioning the wisdom of the invitation just days after it was endorsed by Democratic leaders in both chambers. Pelosi’s comments — and her decision to air them on national television — have…

  • Britain is already at war, and nobody wants to admit it

    There are fewer than three weeks to go until polling day and, amid all the desperate campaigning and counter-campaigning, there is a dog that hasn’t barked – even though it is perhaps the most vital of all for our long-term survival.

  • Seoul fires warning shots as N. Korean soldiers cross border again

    Dozens of North Korean soldiers briefly crossed the heavily fortified border Tuesday but retreated after warning shots were fired, Seoul said, the second such incident in two weeks as Pyongyang reinforces its frontiers with the South."Dozens of North Korean troops crossed the Military Demarcation Line today... (and) retreated northwards after warning shots" were fired, a JCS official said.

  • China targets Europe's farmers, and not its automakers, in response to EU tariffs on electric cars

    The Chinese government is taking aim at European farmers instead of German automakers by launching an investigation into European Union pork imports, just days after the EU said it plans to impose provisional tariffs on China-made electric vehicles. The Commerce Ministry didn't mention the EV tariffs when it announced Monday that it is opening an anti-dumping investigation into pork from Europe, but the move is widely seen as a response to the EU move on electric cars.

  • US blasts ‘aggressive’ China over South China Sea collision with Philippine ship

    The United States on Monday condemned China over a collision with the Philippines in the disputed South China Sea, the latest in a series of increasingly fraught confrontations that have raised the potential of a flashpoint for global conflict in the vital waterway.

  • Kellyanne Conway Massively Inflates Trump’s Church Crowd

    It appears crowdflation and alternative facts are once again tools in Trumpworld’s arsenal. Kellyanne Conway tried to draw some distinction between Donald Trump and Joe Biden during an appearance on Maria Bartiromo’s Sunday Morning Futures, noting that Trump was making outreaches to Black voters. “You got Donald Trump in Detroit talking to 8,000 people at a Black church,” she told Bartiromo. Read more at The Daily Beast.Get the Daily Beast's biggest scoops and scandals delivered right to your in