Ship canal company wins water firm sewage appeal

Ewan Gawne - BBC News, Manchester
·2-min read
The Lowry footbridge spanning the Manchester Ship Canal at The Quays.
United Utilities has about 100 outfall pipes along the Manchester Ship Canal [BBC]

The owners of the Manchester Ship Canal have won an appeal permitting them to take action against a water company over the dumping of raw sewage into the waterway.

A panel of Supreme Court judges ruled existing laws do not prevent the Manchester Ship Canal Company from making a claim for damages over unauthorised discharges of waste.

It comes after a long-running legal battle between the private company, owned by the Peel Group, and United Utilities, which serves the north west of England.

A canal company spokeswoman said they were pleased with the decision, while the water firm said it was "considering the implications" of the ruling.

View of the Manchester Ship Canal from the Stockton Heath swing bridge in Warrington, Cheshire.
The waterway links the north west of England with the Irish Sea [BBC]

The ship canal, built in 1890s, stretches 36 miles (57km) from the Mersey Estuary to Salford Quays.

There are around United Utilities’ 100 outfalls along the canal, where treated waste is released from the sewerage network.

Raw sewage is also dumped at times when the system is operating over capacity, something the Supreme Court judges said could be avoided if the firm "invested in improved infrastructure and treatment".

They found the canal company was entitled to bring a nuisance or trespass claim for these incidents, even in instances when there had been "no negligence or deliberate misconduct" by United Utilities.

It comes despite rulings to the contrary in both the High Court and the Court of Appeal, which led to the canal company's appeal.

A Peel Ports spokeswoman said the decision gives the watercourse owners "the right to bring legal action against a water company that discharges pollution into its watercourse".

Andrew Ross of law firm Charles Russell Speechlys, said the Supreme Court's decision could lead to "an increase in this type of legal claim".

"Owners of waterways may now consider taking action against sewerage undertakers for polluting water," he added.

United Utilities said it "understood and shared" concerns about the need to improve, and pointed to a £3 billion investment plan aimed at cutting pollution by improving infrastructure.

More on this story

Related internet links

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Rare shark that lives for 500 years could hold secret to increasing human lifespan

    The metabolism of a shark species which can live for 500 years could help scientists treat heart disease and increase people’s lifespan, scientists hope.

  • Indonesia launches first EV battery plant

    Indonesia launched its first electric vehicle battery plant on Wednesday, President Joko Widodo said, as Southeast Asian countries move to gain a foothold in the emerging industry.The plant is part of a $9.8 billion electric vehicle battery deal signed between Indonesia and LG in 2020.

  • Washed-up giant shark removed from beach by forklift

    The body of a giant basking shark which washed up on Scottish beach has been removed by a forklift.

  • Coffee, eggs and white rice linked to higher levels of PFAS in human body

    US study that researchers say highlights chemicals’ ubiquity also shows PFAS association with seafood and red meat

  • Freya the rescued lion cub is safe in South Africa, but many other lions there are bred to be shot

    Freya, a 6-month-old lion cub rescued from the wildlife trade in Lebanon, poked a curious nose out of her transport crate and sniffed the air. Satisfied, she took her first cautious steps in her new forever home in a sanctuary in South Africa. Freya's relocation to the Drakenstein Lion Park is only a partial success story.

  • To save spotted owls, US officials plan to kill hundreds of thousands of another owl species

    To save the imperiled spotted owl from potential extinction, U.S. wildlife officials are embracing a contentious plan to deploy trained shooters into dense West Coast forests to kill almost a half-million barred owls that are crowding out their cousins.

  • What Is the Most Dangerous Animal in the World?

    It's hard to say what is the most dangerous animal in the world; you're not comparing apples to apples. But when it comes dangerous, these four top the list.

  • Philippine town cleans up beach in exchange for rice

    STORY: :: Mabini, PhilippinesPlastic waste litters the shores of this resort town near Manila, the Philippines' sprawling capital.This coastal cleanup crew is trying to hold back the steady flood of waste.But each sack of they gather doesn't go unrewarded. They get a two-pound bag of rice in exchange, enough for a small family's needs.:: This Earth Green campaigners say the exchange can educate the community about why protecting the environment is so critical, all while keeping the shores clean, and as inflation bites, keeping people here, like Janeth Aceveda, afloat. "The exchange is a huge help for us because in a month I need four and a half sacks of rice, but now all I have to buy is two sacks, which is a huge help in saving money. It also helps the environment and it shows when our surroundings are clean." Mabini in Batangas province is a world-class scuba diving destination, known for its vibrant corals and marine biodiversity. But a rising tide of plastic pollution is posing an increasing threat to marine life. Organizer Giulio Endaya has witnessed the harm first hand. :: Giulio Endaya, Exchange organizer"I've seen sea turtles entangled in nets and other types of plastics. They've been known to eat straws and plastic bags, and the fish also eat microplastics that have been, you know, broken down in the shore. And recently we've been finding more and more microplastics even in fish that we eat, so it's also harmful to us." To untangle the problem, Endaya and his group of volunteers spearheaded the ‘Plastic Palit Bigas’– or ‘plastic in exchange for rice’– program. The project is funded by donations from individuals and small companies that advocate for marine conservation. Through the exchange, Mabini volunteers can turn in sacks of litter, regardless of weight, for a kilogram– or 2.2 pounds– of rice. Volunteer Raymond Basit says it’s been a potent incentive. "It helps a lot because people now have an urge, because of poverty and especially during these times, the price of goods is so high. Now during their free time they can clean, and they push themselves to clean because they get something in return, which is a big help for them." An updated 2022 University of Oxford report found that The Philippines accounts for 36% of the total global input of plastic waste into the ocean, more than any other country. The plastic for rice exchange aims to change that. :: 4.7 tonsAccording to Endaya, since clean-up efforts began in October 2022, more than 4.7 U.S. tons of garbage have been collected and exchanged for nearly 3 tons of rice.

  • Reed buntings breed for first time in 27 years

    The National Trust for Jersey is "very excited" about the first confirmed breeding since 1997.

  • Adorable Black Bear Cubs Explore Neighborhood

    Three adorable black bear cubs were spotted roaming around a New Jersey neighborhood in late May.Laura Geer captured this video of the cubs exploring the front lawn of a home before moving on and trotting up the road.“These adorable bear cubs were romping all over the neighborhood searching out mama bear who had walked up the street,” Geer said.New Jersey Fish and Wildlife advise New Jersey residents to take steps to avoid attracting bears, such as securing garbage and not leaving out any food that may encourage bears to linger in residential areas. Credit: Laura Geer via Storyful

  • Not politics, not interest rates: India's surging economy at risk from water

    Water delivered by tankers provides one additional bucket to each of its 1,000 residents for drinking and cooking. In parts of the arid state of Rajasthan, southwest of the Indian capital, tap water is available once every four days for an hour. In rural areas near Mumbai, women and children travel more than a mile to get water.

  • GM will pay $146 million in penalties because 5.9 million older vehicles emit excess carbon dioxide

    General Motors will pay nearly $146 million in penalties to the federal government because 5.9 million of its older vehicles do not comply with emissions and fuel economy standards. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration said in a statement Wednesday that certain GM vehicles from the 2012 through 2018 model years did not comply with federal fuel economy requirements. The penalty comes after the Environmental Protection Agency said its testing showed the GM pickup trucks and SUVs emit over 10% more carbon dioxide on average than GM's initial compliance testing claimed.

  • Newborn white rhino Silverio takes his giant first steps in a Chilean zoo in a boost to his species

    Hannah, a 13-year-old white rhinoceros, has delivered a newborn calf in a rare zoo birth for the almost endangered species. The arrival of the male calf, named Silverio, two weeks ago marked the third time that a white rhino had ever been born in South America. The Buin Zoo in Chile's capital of Santiago unveiled Silverio to the public on Tuesday as he took his first giant-footed steps after 12 days of medical care in confinement.

  • Bylaw blocks B.C. family's bid to move older house onto property

    A young family in British Columbia's Comox Valley thought they found a creative solution to expand their home, but a recent city bylaw change has put a stop to their plans. Paul Myers and Jessica Evans live in a 1940s one-bedroom rancher house in Courtenay. When they welcomed their baby last year, it didn't take long for their home to start feeling cramped. "He's taking up a lot more space than he would seem to if you just look at him," Myers said, laughing. But when the couple looked at moving

  • Nintendo Gave Switch Pirates A Chance To Walk Away But They Apparently Refused

    The Switch may be at the end of its life, but Nintendo is still on the hunt for the platform’s biggest pirates. In a pair of new lawsuits, the console manufacture has taken aim at both mod chip sellers as well as the moderator of the popular r/SwitchPiracy subreddit.

  • Wildlife officials plan to kill hundreds of thousands of barred owls to save spotted owls

    The federal government issued a plan Wednesday that could eliminate 400,000 barred owls, an invasive species, to protect threatened spotted owls in the western U.S. Barred owls, those that will be killed if the plan is finalized, are native to the eastern U.S., but likely migrated west due to man-made changes to the Great Plains…

  • Can the West Afford to Ditch Cheap Chinese Green Tech Imports?

    The U.S. and EU are imposing tariffs on Chinese clean energy products to boost domestic industries, but experts warn this could slow the global green transition and increase consumer costs.

  • The secret plight of seagulls – and why we should learn to love them

    A great annual conflict is underway. Each summer, as hordes of holidaymakers descend on beaches and seaside towns across the country, humans and seagulls come face to face in a chip-based standoff. ‘Giant swarms’ of gulls apparently attack beachgoers, traumatise children – and fill the tabloids. Gulls are even being blamed for postal delays: last month, Royal Mail claimed that aggressive birds had prevented postmen from making deliveries in Liskeard, Cornwall.

  • Diavik's solar plant is running. Officials hope it can be 'deployed elsewhere' when mine closes

    Rio Tinto says its 3.5-megawatt solar plant, which it calls the North's biggest off-grid solar operation, is up and running at Diavik Diamond Mine in the N.W.T. The 6,620 solar panels are expected to generate 4.2 million kilowatt-hours of electricity per year, according to a press release from the company — amounting to 25 per cent of the electricity needed for closure work that's slated to happen between 2026 and 2029. Currently, while the mine is still in production, the plant is generating 2.

  • Seattle plastic surgery provider accused of posting fake positive reviews must pay $5M

    A Seattle-area plastic surgery provider accused of threatening patients over negative reviews and posting fake positive ones must pay $5 million to the state attorney general’s office and thousands of Washington patients, according to a federal consent decree. The consent decree filed Monday resolves a lawsuit brought by Attorney General Bob Ferguson in December 2022, The Seattle Times reported. The complaint accused Allure Esthetic and owner Dr. Javad Sajan of violating state and federal consumer protection laws by posting the false reviews and forcing patients to sign nondisclosure agreements barring them from posting or saying anything negative about Allure.