Starbucks brings out fruity energy drink after Panera stopped selling charged lemonade over deaths

Graig Graziosi
·3-min read
Starbucks brings out fruity energy drink after Panera stopped selling charged lemonade over deaths

Less than two months after Panera Bread announced it would stop selling its Charged Lemonade — a beverage at the center of several wrongful death and injury lawsuits — Starbucks is releasing its own energy drink.

While the drinks are similar, the coffee giant’s Iced Energy drinks have significantly less caffeine than Panera's large-sized Charged Lemonade beverage, according to NBC News.

Starbucks’ Iced Energy offerings range between 180mg of caffeine and 205mg of caffeine depending on the flavor chosen. Panera Bread's large Charged Lemonade, when served in a cup without ice, contained a staggering 390mg of caffeine, just 10g shy of the upper limit for safe consumption by an adult in a single day.

The energy drinks Starbucks is offering will all be served as 24oz beverages, and contain artificial sweeteners, taurine, vitamins, and caffeine.

Panera's now-discontinued Charged Lemonade drink contained sugar, guarana extract, and caffeine.

A promotional image of Starbucks’ Iced Energy drinks. The drinks were announced less than two months after Panera Bread announced it would discontinue its Charged Lemonade energy drink following several wrongful death and injury lawsuits tied to the beverage (Starbucks)
A promotional image of Starbucks’ Iced Energy drinks. The drinks were announced less than two months after Panera Bread announced it would discontinue its Charged Lemonade energy drink following several wrongful death and injury lawsuits tied to the beverage (Starbucks)

In October, the family of Sarah Katz, a 21-year-old University of Pennsylvania student with a heart condition, filed a lawsuit claiming the woman died after consuming Panera’s Charged Lemonade.

Katz's friend, Victoria Rose Conroy, told NBC News that she probably had no idea the lemonade contained nearly an entire day's worth of caffeine when she ordered the drink. She said Katz was "vigilant" about what she consumed because of her heart condition.

“I guarantee if Sarah had known how much caffeine this was, she never would have touched it with a 10-foot pole,” Ms Conroy told the broadcaster.

A second lawsuit was filed in December by the family of Dennis Brown of Florida. He had a chromosomal deficiency disorder and a developmental delay. He also died after drinking a Charged Lemonade, the lawsuit claimed.

Lauren Skerrit, a 28-year-old woman in Rhode Island, has also sued the company over the drink, saying it left her with "permanent cardiac injuries."

While the company has expressed sympathy for the deaths associated with the lawsuits, the company maintains that their "unfortunate passing was not caused by one of the company's products."

A warning label was added to Panera’s “charged lemonade” drinks after a woman died shortly after consuming the high-caffeine beverage (Panera Bread / screengrab)
A warning label was added to Panera’s “charged lemonade” drinks after a woman died shortly after consuming the high-caffeine beverage (Panera Bread / screengrab)

It said it stood by the safety of the drinks. It has not commented on the third lawsuit from Ms Skerrit.

While Panera phases out its drink, Starbucks is just the latest restaurant to introduce a high-energy beverage.

In February, Dunkin' began offering its SPARKD' Energy beverages, with similar ingredients to Starbucks' Iced Energy offering. That beverage has 192mg of caffeine.

Smoothie King also offers "lemonade refreshers" which include up to 125mg of "natural caffeine" from green coffee beans.

While energy drinks have been around for decades, recent entries have ramped up the caffeine content far beyond their predecessors.

Red Bull, one of the most popular of the old-guard brands, has 114mg of caffeine in a 12oz can. Newer brands, like Celsius, have 200mg or more. Bang energy, which can be found at most gas stations and convenience stores, has 300mg of caffeine.

For comparison, a 12oz can of Coke has 34mg of caffeine, while a typical 8oz cup of coffee generally has between 80-100mg of caffeine.

While the US Food and Drug Administration has made recommendations for safe caffeine consumption in adults, the American Academy of Pediatrics has noted that there are no benefits of caffeine for children — besides the jolt of energy it brings — and has advised that children and adolescents avoid the drinks to protect their health.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Panera Introduces 4 New Cold Drinks Just in Time To Beat the Heat

    And replace the Charged Lemonades.

  • She managed to flee Gaza after half her family was killed in an Israeli strike. She blames Israel and Hamas for what happened

    Roba Abu Jibba looked shell-shocked as the doctor delivered his news: She couldn’t have the operation she desperately wanted. She nervously scrunched the fabric of her dress, fighting off the tears that began flooding her one remaining eye.

  • ‘We are really sorry’: man behind Uncle Frog’s Mushroom Gummies apologises after people hospitalised across Australia

    Exclusive: Rohan Bandil says ‘this was not the intention’ after hallucinations and unexpected toxicity leads to health warnings and nationwide recall

  • 16 People Who Thought They Knew Better Than Their Doctors And Suffered Horrible Consequences

    "He got the emergency surgery, and the amount of time he had to spend in the hospital probably doubled."

  • Scientists confirm toxic 'forever chemicals' enter our blood by being absorbed by the skin

    PFAS, known as forever chemicals, can make their way into the bloodstream through skin contact, according to new research.

  • Hay fever medicine that Tiktokers say ‘grows your bottom’ restricted in France

    An over-the-counter hay fever medicine beloved by beauty influencers for its supposed power to make their bottoms bigger has been pulled from pharmacy shelves in France amid widespread misuse.

  • Jamal Abdillah worries about wife's health as she carries fifth child

    The singer says wife Zai Izzati has been getting treatment at the National Heart Institute due to severe allergy

  • Five 60-second high-intensity exercises that won’t hurt your joints – whatever your age

    It’s the fast, efficient workout that’s a brilliant way to get fit if time is tight. Lots of people will have tried high-intensity interval training (HIIT) – a workout made up of short, intense bursts of movement like sprints, burpees and ski jumps, followed by a rest.

  • Skip This Type Of Sushi If You Want To Avoid Food Poisoning

    Here's what you should know to avoid getting a foodborne illness from your favorite takeout meal.

  • Exercising in short bursts could benefit those who cannot work out regularly

    Many people struggle to meet the recommended target for weekly activity, an academic has said.

  • Japan firm probing 76 more deaths in supplement scare

    Japanese health supplement maker Kobayashi Pharmaceutical said Friday it was probing 76 more deaths possibly linked to its tablets containing red yeast rice, meant to lower cholesterol.Kobayashi Pharmaceutical has said it also sold red yeast rice to around 50 other firms in Japan and two in Taiwan.

  • Lee MacDonald: Former Grange Hill star, who played Zammo, reveals skin cancer diagnosis after noticing 'unusual spot on my face'

    Former Grange Hill star Lee MacDonald, who played Zammo McGuire in the iconic children's show, has said he has been diagnosed with skin cancer. The actor, 56, said he went to see a doctor after noticing an "unusual spot on my face", who confirmed it was cancer. Fans took to the comment section to share their well wishes, the Daily Mail said, wishing him "a speedy resolution" and thanking him for highlighting the subject.

  • Justice Department charges nearly 200 people in $2.7 billion health care fraud crackdown

    The Justice Department announced a sweeping series of charges Thursday against nearly 200 people accused of participating in health care fraud schemes with false claims topping $2.7 billion.

  • Mark Hyman: meet the doctor who says he can make us live to 120

    Best-selling author and physician Dr Mark Hyman believes he has the secrets to wellness and longevity. He talks about Big Sugar lobbies and why we need to change how we think about cancer.

  • Hospital doctors in England launch new strike ahead of election

    Junior hospital doctors in England began a five-day strike on Thursday, a week before a general election in which the state of the publicly funded National Health Service is a major issue.It follows nearly a dozen similar protests by doctors below specialist, consultant level over the last 18 months.The NHS is grappling with a massive backlog caused by the Covid-19 pandemic.A recent survey suggested that less than a quarter of Britons were satisfied with the NHS, an unprecedented level.As well as delays to operations and starting cancer treatment, the public also face long waits to see a doctor at their local surgery.The doctors have been asking for 35-percent "pay restoration" as a starting position amid a cost-of-living crisis.They have said they will call off the action if Conservative Prime Minister Rishi Sunak comes to the table with a credible commitment to increase their pay.Shivram Sharma, a junior doctor working in London, told AFP he and his peers were protesting "because we've been in dispute with the government for 20 months... and we're yet to be provided a credible offer".He added: "Doctors are tired. We're frustrated but we're ultimately scared... We've seen the quality of care in this country decline."- Pay restoration -Sharma said patients were being short-changed and having to endure longer waiting times for treatment, particularly in accident and emergency, and doctors were leaving the profession."We need to keep doctors here and stop them from leaving because of the poor conditions and poor pay," he said on a picket line out Saint Thomas' Hospital in central London. "Until we deal with that, the waiting list will continue to go up (and) wards will continue to remain understaffed."Central to the junior doctors' demands is to increase pay from £15 (just under $19) an hour to £20. The deputy chair of the British Medical Association's Junior Doctor Committee, Sumi Manirajan, said wages had not kept up with inflation over the last 15 years and doctors have to pay thousands out of pocket for indemnity fees, courses and exams.Manirajan said the government was already making a number of public spending commitments for the general election on July 4. "Rishi Sunak has made a commitment to spend £2.5 billion on a national (military or civic) service. It would cost £1 billion to pay the doctors," she said.The government had already "wasted three billion pounds fighting us", she added."So the money is there. It's a political choice on where they spend it."The strike runs until Tuesday, two days before a general election which the main opposition Labour party is expected to win.Labour's health spokesman, Wes Streeting, has said any Labour government would not meet the 35-percent demand but that there is "space for a discussion".Decades-high inflation in 2023 saw workers from sectors across the economy, from teachers to train drivers, stage walkouts.The government, quasi-public agencies and private sector firms have resolved many of the other pay disputes. But some remain outstanding, such as with the junior doctors.Sunak's government has said the doctors' demands are unaffordable because of stretched public finances.It has accused the strike organisers of being politically motivated.har-str/phz/gil

  • During debate, Trump and Biden make clear where they stand on abortion

    Trump and Biden went after each other's stance on abortion at Thursday night's debate. But where does each candidate stand?

  • The 12 best shoes for nurses in 2024, according to nurses

    These top picks from Nike, Hoka and Clove are approved by nurses and podiatrists alike for all-day support on the job.

  • Justice Alito says allowing abortions in medical emergencies is ‘bizarre’ as he fights for rights of ‘unborn child’

    The Supreme Court handed abortion rights advocates a narrow win, for now, in case about emergency abortions

  • The days of the week women are most likely to fall pregnant have nothing to do with cycles

    New research has revealed the days couples are more likely to successfully conceive.

  • UK E. coli outbreak: What are the symptoms and how does it spread?

    Stomach bugs are always unpleasant, leading to days of tummy problems that can leave you housebound. While the cause is rarely clear, thousands of cases in the UK every year are a result of eating food that has been contaminated with E. coli.