Tens of thousands of passengers could benefit after Supreme Court rules against British Airways on flight delays

Sky News
Updated ·2-min read

Passengers are entitled to compensation for a flight cancelled due to airline staff illness, the UK's highest court has ruled.

"Tens of thousands" of claims made annually could potentially be affected, the Supreme Court said on Wednesday afternoon.

The case was brought against British Airways (BA) by a couple whose flight was cancelled due to the pilot being sick and the fact no replacement was available.

Money blog: Popular coffee brand issues price warning

Does it matter who is sick or when?

BA had argued this was an "extraordinary circumstance" which was out of their control and could not be avoided - a situation in which airlines do not have to pay compensation.

But the Supreme Court said staff illness was not an "extraordinary circumstance" and so an award was owed, even though the pilot in question fell ill while off work.

"These are all inherent in the carrier's activity and operations and if, for whatever reason, they are unable to attend for work as a result of something going awry during those rest periods, whether it is their fault or not, that failure to attend is not an extraordinary circumstance," the Supreme Court's decision read.

The question of when or who fell ill doesn't matter, the Supreme Court said.

The court said the crew member was an "inherent part of the airline's operation" even when not on duty.

It added: "The same is also true of the need for the captain and other cabin crew to ensure that they are properly rested during stopovers.

"They have numerous obligations both to their employers and to the public during those periods."

Read more business news:
Water bosses summoned for urgent talks
Biggest housebuilder cuts target - just as Labour promises homes

'Succeeded against all odds'

The couple who took the case against BA, Kenneth and Linda Lipton, arrived two and a half hours late on their journey from London to Milan after their original flight was cancelled when the pilot fell ill while off duty.

The UK airline had refused to pay £220 in compensation for the delay.

Two courts had originally upheld BA's position but the Court of Appeal then ruled in the couple's favour, with the airline then taking the case to the Supreme Court.

On Wednesday, five Supreme Court justices unanimously dismissed the company's appeal.

A statement from the couple's law firm, Irwin Mitchell, said: "Their insistence to continue this battle to the highest court in the land has now met with the correct conclusion and our significantly smaller but no less wily team has succeeded against all odds."

A spokesperson for BA said: "We are disappointed with this decision and respect the judgment of the court."

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Kelly emerges as a top contender for Harris’s VP pick

    Sen. Mark Kelly (D-Ariz.) has risen to near the top of the list of possible running mates as Vice President Harris considers whom she wants to run alongside her. Kelly has been sent vetting materials as one of a handful of Democrats under consideration for the role. A veteran and former astronaut, Kelly brings a…

  • Government to pay former FBI officials $2 million in settlements over release of anti-Trump texts

    Ex-FBI officials Peter Strzok and Lisa Page reached settlements with the Justice Department that will see the government paying out a total of $2 million in their lawsuits over the department’s 2018 release of their text messages.

  • Who is leading the race to become Kamala Harris's running mate? New Yahoo News poll shows support for top contenders.

    A Yahoo News guide to the top Democratic vice-presidential contenders

  • UK politics live: Starmer’s government drops objection to Israeli PM Netanyahu’s ICC arrest warrant

    Downing Street confirms it will allow the ICC to issue an arrest warrant for senior Israeli leaders including PM Benjamin Netanyahu

  • Wisconsin Republicans ask voters to take away governor's power to spend federal money

    Wisconsin Republicans are asking voters to take away the governor's power to unilaterally spend federal money, a reaction to the billions of dollars that flowed into the state during the COVID-19 pandemic. Democratic Gov. Tony Evers was free to spend most of that money as he pleased, directing most of it toward small businesses and economic development, angering Republicans who argued the Legislature should have oversight.

  • Mitsubishi Motors to join Honda-Nissan alliance, Nikkei reports

    TOKYO (Reuters) -Japan's Mitsubishi Motors is set to join an alliance between Honda Motor and Nissan Motor, creating a tie-up between automakers with combined sales of more than 8 million vehicles, the Nikkei newspaper said on Sunday. Mitsubishi Motors, which is 34% owned by Nissan, will work with Honda and Nissan to finalise the details of their strategic partnership, Nikkei said, adding the three firms intend to standardise in-vehicle software that controls cars.

  • US defends law forcing sale of TikTok app

    The Justice Department late Friday filed its response to TikTok's civil suit aimed at derailing a law that would force the app to be sold or face a US ban.TikTok's suit in a Washington federal court argues that the law violates First Amendment rights of free speech.

  • US DOJ asks court to reject TikTok challenge to crackdown law

    (Reuters) -The U.S. Department of Justice asked a federal appeals court late on Friday to uphold an April law requiring China-based ByteDance to sell TikTok's U.S. assets by Jan. 19 or face a ban. The DOJ argued in its filing that TikTok under Chinese ownership poses a serious national security threat because of its access to vast personal data of Americans, asserting China can covertly manipulate information that Americans consume via TikTok. "The serious national-security threat posed by TikTok is real," the department said.

  • Fuyao Glass says Ohio unit not target of investigation after Homeland Security raids

    Chinese automotive glass maker Fuyao Glass Industry Group said the United States government agencies searched its subsidiary on July 26 in Ohio as part of an ongoing investigation into a third-party labour services company. Fuyao Glass America Inc was not the target of the investigation, Fuyao quoted the U.S. authority as saying, in a filing to the Shanghai Stock Exchange. Local media earlier quoted a U.S. Homeland Security Investigations spokesperson as saying that their special agents are serving search warrants at Fuyao Glass's unit and 27 other locations as part of an investigation into "allegations of financial crimes and labour exploitation."

  • The US economy Kamala Harris inherits and how she may run on it

    Kamala Harris will have President Joe Biden’s mostly strong economy to run on. Still, one of her biggest challenges is lifting the negative feelings many Americans have about the economy, stemming from sharply higher prices for everything from groceries to rent over the past four years.

  • Civil servants must be allowed to work from home, say unions

    Labour must let civil servants work from home by scrapping “arbitrary targets” which force staff to be in the office for a fixed number of days a week, union chiefs have said.

  • Dutch Bros. is gunning for Starbucks' top coffee spot

    Inflation has significantly impacted the restaurant industry across the board, as budget-conscious consumers increasingly seek out value options. Yahoo Finance reporter Brooke DiPalma analyzes the top three strategies restaurants are employing to attract customers in this challenging economic environment with a focus on Dutch Bros (BROS) as the coffee chain strives to establish itself as the next major player in the coffee industry, seeking to rival even Starbucks (SBUX). Dutch Bros. is set to report earnings on Wednesday, August 7. For more expert insight and the latest market action, click here to watch this full episode of Asking For A Trend. This post was written by Angel Smith

  • Six banks settle European bond price fixing litigation in New York

    Six banks including Bank of America and Citigroup agreed to pay $80 million to settle antitrust litigation in New York accusing them of conspiring to rig prices of European government bonds. A preliminary settlement with Bank of America, Citigroup, Jefferies, NatWest, Nomura and UBS was filed late Friday in Manhattan federal court, and requires a judge's approval. Investors led by three public pension funds accused the banks of having colluded, including in online chatrooms, to bid high prices at bond auctions to ensure a dominant market share, and then to sell the bonds at inflated prices to mutual funds, pension funds, insurers and other investors.

  • As California seeks to curb groundwater declines, farmers in one county fight back in court

    Farmers in one California county are challenging state officials' effort to crack down on groundwater overpumping. A judge gives growers a temporary reprieve.

  • Why now is a good time to buy an EV: Auto expert explains

    With incentives from the government and more automakers releasing new EV models, it may be time for consumers to consider buying an EV. Autoblog Editor-in-Chief Greg Migliore joins Wealth! to break down some car-buying tips for those in the market looking to get a great deal. Greg starts off by saying: "I think now actually is a pretty good time as a consumer to be in the market for an EV. The selection has never been better. So whether it's Chevy (GM), whether it's Volkswagen (VWAGY), Mercedes (MBG.DE), Cadillac, Ford, (F) Tesla, (TSLA), you name it, basically everybody has their take on electric vehicles. With the $7,500 tax credit that's available on some vehicles and for people of certain incomes, they can still be pretty reasonably priced." He continues by stressing the power the consumer has: "I think dealers are always willing to negotiate. That's sort of the, like the secret power, if you will, of the consumer, because, right now you can arm yourself with all sorts of knowledge. You can figure out what the invoice price is, you can get all the available incentives, and know what you should be paying going into the dealership, so it's different than it was even 15 years ago when you kind of had to sort of ask the dealer for the price, ask nicely, and then kind of negotiate from there." For more expert insight and the latest market action, click here to watch this full episode of Wealth! This post was written by Nicholas Jacobino

  • Spray-on marathon shoe launches in the shadow of Paris Games

    STORY: This robotic arm is putting the finishing touches on a new high-tech marathon shoe... After three minutes spraying material onto a mold, it's complete. It's the latest effort by running brand On, founded in 2010. It's been trying to muscle its way onto the high-tech shoe leaderboard, traditionally dominated by the likes of Nike and Adidas.Built to be lightweight and bouncy so runners can maintain a fast pace over 26 miles, marathon shoes have become big business for sportswear brands.At $330, On's shoe is at the upper end of the market, though a less eye-watering price tag than Adidas' $500 model launched last September.The "LightSpray" production method requires fewer parts per pair and challenges the usual footwear manufacturing production model... which relies on shipping finished shoes to consumers from factories in South-East Asia. While most running shoe innovations focus on the midsole, On argues the LightSpray shoe's thin, seamless, one-piece upper makes it light and aerodynamic.Co-founder Caspar Copetti is hopeful about the technology’s future.“In terms of scaling it, it's actually quite simple basically, we just need more robots, right.”The launch comes as supply chain disruptions, geopolitical risks, and government incentives are driving interest in "nearshoring" – manufacturing or bringing production closer to the end customer.The midsole, foam, and plate of the LightSpray shoes are currently produced in Asia, but On executives say the aim is to eventually manufacture those elements in Switzerland as well. Co-founder Olivier Bernhard:“But I think really that this is a start of something so new, so good for the planet that, you know, we can do so much more.”

  • Lammy urged to drop ‘ludicrous’ financial aid to Cuba over concerns troops are fighting for Russia in Ukraine

    Britain needs to rethink financial support, a leading US congressman has told The Independent

  • Deputy who killed Sonya Massey was removed from the Army, had DUIs and needed ‘high stress decision’ classes, records show

    Before he killed a mother in her home, former sheriff’s deputy Sean Grayson had a history of problems in the Army and another sheriff’s agency, records show.

  • Can Kamala’s knitting-obsessed, topless-modelling stepdaughter help her to the presidency?

    When Kamala Harris’s stepdaughter described what her parents thought of her tattoos and quirky hair, she said: “I think they’re all in the realm of, like: ‘I don’t understand it, but I want you to be who you want to be.’”

  • Nikki Haley Says 'Democrats Are Very Smart To Put In A Younger Candidate' Against Trump But Kamala Harris Is The 'Weakest Candidate'

    Nikki Haley, the former Governor of South Carolina, has recently voiced her steadfast support for Donald Trump over Kamala Harris in the upcoming November election. What Happened: As per a CNN report on Thursday, Haley justified her decision to back Trump, despite their previous disagreements during the Republican primary fight. She also shared her thoughts on President Joe Biden’s decision to step down from the race, stating it was expected. Don’t Miss: IRS Finalizes 10-Year Rule For Retirement