Toxic burn after Ohio derailment unneeded, officials say

Kayla Epstein - Senior Journalist
·4-min read
Smoke billows from a derailed Norfolk Southern train in East Palestine on 3 February 2023.
Smoke billows from a derailed Norfolk Southern train in East Palestine on 3 February 2023. [Getty Images]

The burning of toxic chemicals after a rail disaster in East Palestine, Ohio - which sent hazardous smoke billowing into the air - may have been unnecessary, an investigation into the February 2023 train derailment found.

On Tuesday, the National Transportation Safety Board discussed a draft of a report about an incident that caused thousands of Ohioans to evacuate their homes last year and sparked fears of poisoned air and water.

Faulty equipment, flawed containers, and a lack of adequate training for emergency responders may have contributed to the accident, investigators said.

“To the people of East Palestine and the surrounding communities, we extend our deepest sympathies,” NTSB member Michael Graham said.

Federal transportation authorities have been investigating the derailment and its handling by Norfolk Southern, which drew national outrage, for more than a year.

The evening of 3 February 2023, a Norfolk Southern train derailed in East Palestine, Ohio. It was carrying goods like malt liquors and frozen vegetables - as well as about 11 cars worth of potentially toxic chemicals.

Several of the train cars caught fire, leading to immediate concerns about potentially volatile chemicals escaping.

A few days later, railroad officials decided to burn off one of the chemicals, vinyl chloride, due to fears it could explode. A photographer captured an image of a column of inky smoke rising over the town, which quickly became a symbol of the disaster and locked the nation’s attention on East Palestine.

Both President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump visited East Palestine during the ongoing recovery effort last year.

Following the burn, officials told residents that the air was safe, but it only inflamed concerns among the local community that their town had been poisoned.

On Tuesday, officials said that burn may not have been necessary.

Norfolk Southern officials had believed the vinyl chloride could explode due to fears it had undergone a process called polymerization, the investigators said.

But the investigation found that Norfolk Southern had misinterpreted pressure data on the cars carrying the vinyl chloride, and that temperatures in those containers had declined.

“Vent and burn action was not necessary to prevent polymerization induced tank ruptures,” read a presentation of the panel’s findings.

The team recommended that the safety guidelines for vinyl chloride be modified, and for federal guidance on what circumstances would warrant use of such vent and burn procedures.

In a statement sent to the BBC, Norfolk Southern said that the "only motivation" in recommending the vent and burn "was the health and safety of the community and first responders".

The statement added that the company's specialist contractors believed it was "the only option" and that they "could not wait and see what happened" under the circumstances.

"The vent and burn effectively avoided a potential uncontrolled explosion," the statement added. "There was no loss of life, injuries, or damage to property, and contractors took steps to manage environmental impact."

In May, Norfolk Southern agreed to pay $310m (£243m) in a settlement with the government, and it reached a $600m settlement with East Palestine residents in April.

Last week, Norfolk Southern announced it would convene a "vent and burn workgroup" as part of its settlement with the US government.

Investigators also pinpointed other failures and weaknesses that contributed to the derailment itself.

They found that local firefighters and emergency responders did not have enough training to safely and properly combat the fire, and recommended enhanced training and resources.

The panel also found that Norfolk Southern did not notify first responders fast enough after the accident about the hazardous materials onboard, leading them to stay at the site longer than they should have immediately after the derailment.

Track and other infrastructure issues, train crew performance, and the marking of loading of train cars were among factors that did not contribute to the accident, investigators found.

In a lengthy response to the NTSB, Norfolk Southern said it "appreciates" the investigation and said that had already taken steps to address many of the safety concerns it identifies.

“We resolved not to wait for the NTSB’s final report before taking decisive action” said John Fleps, the firm's chief safety officer.

The company added that it will now compare the NTSB's recommendations to its own protocols to determine what further steps can be implemented.

The NTSB is now expected to release an executive summary of the report, with the final report to follow in the coming weeks.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Delhi airport roof collapse kills one, injures others after heavy rains

    A man was crushed to death in his car and eight others were injured on Friday after a section of roof at New Delhi’s airport collapsed following heavy rain, the latest high profile infrastructure disaster to dent India’s image.

  • No tsunami threat after magnitude 7.2 earthquake strikes Peru coast

    At least three quakes hit near the coast of central Peru over a period of 10 minutes around 12.36am local time

  • New Delhi airport roof collapses after heavy rain

    STORY: :: Water pours through the roof of New Delhi's main airport before the roof collapses and kills one person:: June 28, 2024:: New Delhi, India :: Deepika Narayan BhardwajA portion of the canopy at the departure area of Delhi airport's Terminal 1 collapsed early in the morning and flight operations were shut down until 2 p.m. (0830 GMT), India's aviation minister told reporters.Video from the Delhi Fire Services showed cars crushed under collapsed columns. Footage shot by an eyewitness showed the roof leaking water during heavy rain before the collapse. Reuters was able to confirm the location of the video from exteriors of the airport which matched government reports and aftermath of the incident. Reuters was able to confirm the date of the videos from the original file metadata.The entire terminal, one of three at the country's busiest airport, was evacuated. Eight injured people were taken to hospital and the rescue operation had been completed, said Atul Garg, the director of Delhi Fire Service.

  • Climber Rappels Next to 'Raging Waterfall' That Developed During Flash Flood

    A “raging waterfall” cascading down the Morning Glory Arch was not enough to deter an experienced outdoorsman on June 21, with jaw-dropping visuals showing him rappelling down after a flash flood hit the area.Video by 16-year-old Spencer Grover shows Tyler Erickson rappelling from a sandstone cliff outside Moab, Utah, within touching distance of a muddy waterfall that “spontaneously developed”, Spencer’s father, Michael Grover, told Storyful.Speaking to Storyful, Erickson said that although the canyoneering adventure “unexpectedly turned into a test of resilience and preparedness,” at no point were he and his group in serious danger.“We were well prepared, equipped with headlamps, sufficient food, and water,” Erickson said.“Despite the situation, the temperature remained a comfortable 70 degrees, and no one was at risk of hypothermia. The storm was described by search and rescue as a once-in-150-years event, catching even experienced guides off guard.”Erickson said that the unexpected flash flood brought close to four inches of rain in just 20 minutes. He highlighted “the importance of preparedness and staying calm in unexpected situations”, but said the experience, while challenging, was also “an unforgettable and humbling adventure”.“It was a testament to the resilience and teamwork of our group, and a reminder that nature can be unpredictable,” he said.Separately, a group of 20 people had to be rescued during the same extreme conditions, local media said Credit: Spencer Grover via Storyful

  • Part of a Minnesota home has plunged into the Blue Earth River as deadly Midwest flooding threatens the nearby Rapidan Dam

    Part of a house perched on the edge of the Blue Earth River in Minnesota collapsed into raging waters as deadly flooding that hit the Midwest threatened the nearby Rapidan Dam, which was built in the early 1900s.

  • Another heatwave to follow after storms hit Italy and Switzerland

    High temperatures are forecast to start returning to Italy on Thursday after heavy rain whipped the north and centre of the country this week.

  • How record heat is pushing Delhi's firefighters to the brink

    STORY: :: Delhi, IndiaA team of firefighters race down the streets of Delhi on this sweltering day in June.They are responding to a major blaze at a worn-down building that houses textile shops in the old quarter of the Indian capital.:: June 13, 2024It took some 250 firefighters to douse the flames.Summer is a particularly busy time for the Delhi Fire Services.But firefighter Indervir Singh can't recall responding to as many fires as this year. :: Indervir Singh, Delhi Fire Services firefighter“In my 32-year-long career, this has been the hottest year and Delhi Fire Services have gotten the most fire calls this year. We get at least 200-250 calls daily."Temperatures in Delhi have hit record highs this year, with the mercury hitting nearly 120 degrees Fahrenheit (50 degrees Celsius) on several occasions.Scientists say the heat is being worsened by human-driven climate change.Fire services data show there were more than 9,000 fire calls between April and June.That’s more than double from a year ago.And deaths more than tripled in that period, from 10 a year ago.Reuters spoke to more than a dozen firefighters and officers.Many describe working in "doubly" strenuous conditions of extreme heat and surging fires.Their shifts are 24 hours long, followed by a day of rest. Director of Delhi Fire Services Atul Garg says his men are stretched thin.:: Atul Garg, Delhi Fire Services Director"They are not able to sleep, they are not able to take rest, because our job is a physical job. This cannot be done by a robot or something. Man has to go inside and inhale the smoke and the heat and then you know, you get tired out. So the fire department is really stretched at this time.” Fire officers say electrical failures are responsible for nearly three-quarters of the blazes this summer.As Delhi sweats through one of its longest heat waves on record, demand for air cooling has surged.Round-the-clock use of power-intensive appliances like air conditioning puts severe strain on the city's old wiring.Fire officers say improper maintenance of cables and equipment can also lead to short circuits and start fires.Assistant Divisional Officer of Delhi Fire Services Somvir Singh.:: Somvir Singh, Assistant Divisional Officer, Delhi Fire Services“More than 70% of causes of fire are electrical origins only and in the electrical origins, we can say overloading, two is short-circuiting and third one is the overheating.”The fire service has proposed making it mandatory for commercial buildings to submit an annual fire audit.Officers say that will ensure businesses check if the wiring in their premises can cope with the higher loads.350 aspiring firefighters are undergoing training and will bolster all-male force by August. The service is also obtaining smaller vehicles to weave through congested roads, and buying technology for hard-to-access areas.

  • Seven killed in Slovakia train and bus collision

    Seven people were killed and at least five more injured when an international train and a bus collided in southwestern Slovakia on Thursday afternoon, the country’s emergency services said.

  • Victoria Beckham first slept with David ‘hours after meeting Prince Charles’

    ‘Thereafter, she said, Beckham was ‘a total animal’ in bed,’ the biography claims

  • ‘This wasn’t a debate, it was a medical emergency’: Our writers give their verdicts

    Follow the latest reaction in our live blog

  • Boy, 14, was held down and hacked to death at Wyoming mall while he tried to protect his girlfriend

    Dominique Antonio Richard Harris and Jarreth Plunkett, both 15, are accused of murdering 14-year-old Bobby Maher during fatal attack

  • Indonesia detains 103 Taiwanese in a raid in Bali involving suspected cybercrime

    Indonesian immigration authorities have detained 103 Taiwanese people after a raid at a villa on the resort island of Bali, officials said Friday. Godam said Indonesian authorities cannot charged them with conducting cybercrime.

  • As ice melts, Everest's 'death zone' gives up its ghosts

    On Everest's sacred slopes, climate change is thinning snow and ice, increasingly exposing the bodies of hundreds of mountaineers who died chasing their dream to summit the world's highest mountain.Sherpa said that bringing one body down from close to Lhotse's 8,516 metre peak -- the world's fourth-highest mountain -- had been among the hardest challenges so far.

  • Three bodies found inside crater at summit of Mount Fuji

    Three bodies were found at the summit of Mount Fuji, Japan’s most famous mountain. One of the bodies had been brought down from the slopes but efforts to bring back the two other bodies were set to continue Friday or later, according to officials after a search was called off for Thursday because of forecasts for heavy rainfall.

  • South Korea is running out of children – and this country could be next

    Every spring, when warm rays of sunshine herald the start of South Korea’s baking summer, fountains across Seoul’s central Gwanghwamun plaza suddenly burst into life, sending cooling jets of water into the air.

  • 4 hours to heaven: 10 short trips to take from Singapore

    The post 4 hours to heaven: 10 short trips to take from Singapore appeared first on SETHLUI.com.

  • China expels two former defense ministers from Communist Party as military purge deepens

    China on Thursday expelled its former Defense Minister Li Shangfu from the ruling Communist Party over corruption allegations, state broadcaster CCTV reported, eight months after he was dramatically removed from the post.

  • China says it picked up a submarine detector dropped by a US Navy aircraft in the South China Sea

    A video shared by Chinese state media shows a US Navy plane dropping something into the sea. China called it a submarine detector.

  • ‘I really don’t know what he said – and I don’t think he does either’: Trump pulls no punches as Biden struggles in debate

    The first debate began with Biden spluttering and tripping over his own words, while Trump rambled

  • Russia is losing 1,000 soldiers a day in its relentless 'meat grinder' tactics against Ukraine: report

    Russian troops are being used in head-on assaults on Ukrainian positions.