Trump ordered Pentagon to let convicted Navy SEAL keep elite status

By Phil Stewart

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - President Donald Trump ordered the Pentagon to let a Navy SEAL convicted of battlefield misconduct keep his Trident pin designating him as a member of the elite force, instead of holding a review board, his defense secretary said on Monday.

The disclosure by Mark Esper illustrates how Trump intervened repeatedly in the case of Special Operations Chief Edward Gallagher, who was acquitted by a military jury of murdering a captured Islamic State fighter in Iraq, but convicted of posing with the detainee's corpse.

After restoring Gallagher's rank on Nov. 15, Trump on Sunday gave a formal order to halt the military's plans to hold a review board, Esper said.

"I spoke with the President on Sunday. He gave me the order that Eddie Gallagher will retain his Trident pin," Esper told reporters at the Pentagon, referring to Special Operations Chief Edward Gallagher.

Esper said he had been in favor of following the regular processes but stressed that, as president, Trump had "every right, authority and privilege to do what he wants to do."

Gallagher's case had been championed by conservative commentators, who argued he had been treated unfairly. Trump restored his rank earlier this month, when he also pardoned two Army officers accused of war crimes in Afghanistan.

Critics, including Democrats in Congress, have said such actions would undermine military justice and send a message that battlefield atrocities will be tolerated.

"It signals to people that they can operate outside the rule of law and the Geneva Convention," said Senator Jack Reed, the top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee.

Esper's comments to a gathering of Pentagon reporters were his first since he fired Navy Secretary Richard Spencer on Sunday over his handling of Gallagher case.

Spencer told CBS News on Monday that Trump's decision sent the message "that you can get away with things."

"We have to have good order and discipline. It's the backbone of what we do," he said.

Trump defended himself on Monday, saying he was sticking up for "warriors" and defending the military.


Esper gave new details on Monday about why he fired Spencer, saying the Navy chief had sought to cut a side deal with the White House that was "contrary to what we had agreed to and contrary to Secretary Spencer's public position," in which he appeared to favor allowing the military justice process to go ahead.

"We learned that several days prior, Secretary Spencer had proposed a deal whereby if the President allowed the Navy to handle the case, he would guarantee that Eddie Gallagher would be restored to rank, allowed to retain his Trident and permitted to retire," Esper said.

Esper said he and Army General Mark Milley, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, had been completely caught off guard by the news. The Navy secretary, Esper said, had undermined everything Pentagon leadership had been collectively discussing with Trump.

Esper called Spencer and said he "was completely forthright in admitting what had been going on." Esper asked for Spencer's resignation letter on Sunday.

Esper's remarks contradicted what had appeared to be a principled stand laid out in Spencer's resignation letter, seen by Reuters, that suggested a split with Trump over the need to uphold the rule of law.

U.S. Senator Tim Kaine, another Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee, suggested he still had questions about what happened to Spencer, who he called "a good man, a patriotic American and an effective leader."

"The Senate Armed Services Committee must fully investigate what happened to ensure accountability," Kaine said.

Milley said on Monday that as far as he was concerned the Gallagher case was now closed, however.

"As far as I'm concerned, it is case closed now and it is time to move on and address the national security of the United States," Milley, the top U.S. military officer, told a small group of reporters during a trip to the Middle East.

(Reporting by Phil Stewart; additional reporting by Idrees Ali in Manama, Patricia Zengerle, Daphne Psaledakis and Lisa Lambert in Washington; Editing by Alistair Bell and Sonya Hepinstall)