Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SMRT says sorry for 'income opportunity' alert

    SMRT has apologised for sending out a message alert that asked its own affiliate taxis to take advantage of the massive MRT breakdown on Thursday evening.

    The message sent out at 7:58pm on Thursday read, "Income opportunity. Dear partners, there is a breakdown in our MRT train services from Bishan MRT to Marina Bay MRT stretch of stations."

    An SMRT spokesperson confirmed the legitimacy of the picture and the message that was sent out on Thursday night, telling Yahoo! Singapore that it was a wrongly-worded message that was sent out by its taxi staff.

    “We are sorry for the oversight. Our staff used a template and we have since corrected it,” she said, adding that the transport operator has since spoken with their taxi staff responsible for broadcasting these messages to change it.

    Thousands of commuters were left stranded from the massive disruption on the North-South line in what's believed to be the worst disruption in SMRT's 24-year operating history.

     34-year-old Loh Boon Teo was riding in an SMRT taxi on his way home to Malaysia when he happened to come across the message and snapped a picture of it.

    The video editor for omy.sg told Yahoo! Singapore that he was quite incensed at the sight of the message, as he was already spending a week’s worth of MRT train fares on a single taxi ride to the Woodlands checkpoint.

    “It just really made me feel like all they cared about was making money out of this,” he said. “They really don’t seem to care about us passengers at all.”

    His colleague, Kenneth Kong, then posted it on Facebook, and it soon spread like wildfire — as did the controversy that followed.

    Many Yahoo! Singapore readers were outraged at the message, with some saying it was wrongly-worded and others taking great offence, angered that Singaporeans seem to have been taken as a source of “income”.

    Commenting on a post of the picture, user Lucilla Teoh wrote, “Totally unethical to call it an ‘income opportunity’. A simple announcement to say that taxis will be needed will suffice.”

    Another user Aaron Ang added, “This is seriously going over the line. What are they taking Singaporeans for? Are we just dollar bills? … Income opportunity, really?”

    Several others, however, said that it was good that taxi drivers were being alerted to the immediate need for cabs in affected areas around the island.

    User Jen Jen Lee wrote, “(It’s) just the language problem, I think — otherwise, it’s fine. Without this message, those waiting for cabs can’t get to where they want to go.”

    Reader Veronica Tang said, “I really didn’t think there’s anything wrong. First, it’s Carpe Diem in its brightest display. Second, people still need transport to get home. No problem. Everyone benefits.”

    ePeng Tan pointed out, “This is the power of teamwork and information-sharing. Economically, it is the best distribution of resources.”

    The controversy comes just days after SMRT Taxis announced plans to increase flagdown fares, meter fares and waiting time charges next Tuesday. The move is in line with similar fare changes announced by Comfort Delgro's own taxi fleet.

    How do you feel about this article?

     
     
    Top Locations Hong Kong Singapore

    905 comments

    • Polar  •  5 months ago
      C'MON! Said it before & will say it AGAIN. The CEO MUST GO!
      • Gelly 5 months ago
        https://www.facebook.com/pages/Saw-Phaik-Hwa-should-Resign-for-SMRT-Delays/272066569507680
      • Hectorlah 5 months ago
        four shore.
      • Mok 5 months ago
        Right. The CEO MUST GO! Fiasco + fiasco + fiasco... The entire 20+ years' corporate image of SMRT was ruined overnight.
    • Broy Lim  •  5 months ago
      "Income opportunity" "template"?!

      Does that mean that SMRT has been looking at Singaporeans as cash cows ALL THESE WHILE?!
      • The other Hard Truth 5 months ago
        The "template" excuse merely opened up the can of worms -- so we now have got proof that SMRT is abusing its stranglehold position to hatch wicked plots against the defenceless populace.

        You are right, we have all been used as cash cows, the SMRT, the government are in cahoots to milk us all dry.....and then afterwards send us to the slaughter house.
      • Emeritus S. Angry Bird 5 months ago
        Ya, "template" mean that it's not the operator's fault. It's the company's directive to get the taxi fleet to 趁火打劫.

        SMRT better sack the spokesperson before she 越描越黑. Anyway, I agreed with "The Other Hard Truth" that we are seen as cashcow and they are all out to squeeze us dry.
      • TIM 5 months ago
        Fellow Singaporean taxi driver also want higher income and better life. You and I are also see our companies as cash cow.....if not we will not work for them. Dont think you are so high and mighty.
    • Jimmy Lee  •  5 months ago
      this smrt message to their cabbies to come and make money out of a miserable situation faced by commuters tell a story. they are not fit to run the mrt system. a ,money faced organisation who care for money and not principles.
      • bL4CkW00d 5 months ago
        "a ,money faced organisation who care for money and not principles."

        You're talking about the PAP?
      • E 5 months ago
        the CEO very very very worried about getting less bonus ?
      • Eug 5 months ago
        CEO worried about getting $1.5 million bonus, $100,000 less than last year...
    • Jimmy Lee  •  5 months ago
      our staff used the wrong template and we are sorry for the oversight. well where is your public relations dept, come on this message was sent with prior approval. stop telling story we are not born yesterday. if you are right no need to say sorry. as i said you are not fit to run the mrt system, no proper contingency plans for the safety of commuters not in a hundred but by the tens and tens ofthousand last night. just quit and that is the solution.
      • Basel 5 months ago
        Whats that template is for......is it to mislead commuters.......
      • We r not united as one! 5 months ago
        lol!!! unintentionally or intentionally? evidence is in the photo. but of cos, good stuff must give own people mah.
      • We r not united as one! 5 months ago
        or u rather let outsiders have the candies?
    • four30talk  •  5 months ago
      c'm SHE is from the retail sector all the while, one of the rightful strike is income opportunity .... that explains the listing and the fare increase.
    • LoneWolf  •  5 months ago
      Lets see... few days ago pricing for taxis went up... and then the MRT shuts down, forcing people to rely on those taxis.... accident? o.O
      • PAP's Lucid 5 months ago
        Nope. How can it be accident? how many taxi does SMRT have? SMRT only earn the rental from those taxi. If you compare the lose of revenue during the disruption to the rental revenue earned, I tink you know the answer.

        And do you mean that smrt purposely shuts down the mrt so that commuters can all take taxi? How many tens of thousands of taxi will be needed to pick up "all" passensers? And if smrt want to force people to take taxi, why bother to activate free buses?

        Lone wolf, are you retarded or what? I was really shock to see such a shallow comment like yours here.
      • june 5 months ago
        thats what i was thinking too...and i am sure many other people too. Made worse by the message sent out by SMRT alerting their business partners that there was a breakdown.....business for their taxis. Its too bad in spore people cant sue...Otherwise....! all these people trapped in the trains without air or light ...can sue! if the plane crash victims can sue why not this ???????????? And this morning again !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      • MIW Haters 5 months ago
        @Lucid I'am a SMRT taxi driver now let me tell you before the incident occur we the taxi driver already known a week before so.Thats this is going to be happen.You idiot Temasek bootlicker what you know.
    • Jackson  •  5 months ago
      train fares perhaps 2 dollars , train break down you have to pay much more than 2 dollars by taking taxi , because taxi after price increase business drops 50% , so this is to make tre trains breakdown and you are forced to take taxi so taxi can make more money mah .

      simple logic .
    • songanddance  •  4 months ago
      The kachang puteh man at Lavender Station just commented to me......"I wish I saw the message......will have moved my stall over to Dhoby Ghuat for the income opportunity."
      What can I say?
    • JackL  •  4 months ago
      SMRT says it's a "wrongly-worded message". They never said it's a wrong message - just a "wrongly-worded" one.
    • Tera  •  5 months ago
      "template". 'Nuff said.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  4 months ago
      THAT"S RIGHT, THE CEO MUST GO!!! IF THE CEO STILL WANT TO STAY WITH THE BIG FAT PROFIT DO THIS:
      1) Appear on TV LIVE to announce immediately law to mandatory all kind of taxi and buses to go and pick commuters WITH NO FEES AT ALL whenever MRT DOWN !!! Who pay? Pay from the big fat profit account !!!!
      2) Appear LIVE on TV and annnounce what are the few back-ups system in the case of MRT breakdown. Where to get finance for the extra back-up systems? From the big fat profit account again !!! If not enough, fork out CEO salary !!!! Like an airplane which deal with human life, it has at least 3 back-up power systems on airplane if not two systems. BUT SMRT are very quick to deal human life as money object. Such a heartless world !!!
      3) No SORRY as so many Singaporean affected. So, to say SORRY, CEO pls appear on TV LIVE and announce fare reduction !!!!!!!
    • Lucilla  •  4 months ago
      Any fine should be compensated to the mrt users instead of into the pocket of the government.
    • Oh Tham Eng  •  5 months ago
      SENSELESS SMRT STAFF!

      Lack of a sense of public spiritedness. Are taxi-drivers so stupid as not to understand this already? Do those senseless SMRT staff need to blare it out like that? Really stupid! 5:23 am 17/12/2011
    • cc  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  4 months ago
      all the fake publicity to appease the public but in reality, they dont care.
    • A Yahoo! User  •  4 months ago
      SAY SORRY ??? I think no mercy here nor forgiveness because it is not from a human heart ( not a human heart at all). If they want to help the commuters, at first place should have a heart to initiate a command to all SMRT buses, taxis and drivers to all affected MRT station to carry the affected commuters NO FEES CHARGE !! Why this simple action/idea/respond can't even appear? Because at first place, all commuters are coins. When vending machine down, coins will pour out and alert give out to collect them-why not to help them by all means transport them with NO FEES? Because commuters are coins !
    • mocacheng  •  4 months ago
      template!!! u called it a template!!! Are ur words also template?
    • CS  •  4 months ago
      IMO, SMRT should do the honorable thing in the light of what has happened, and consider delaying the taxi fare hikes until after the MRT rails are fully back and proven reliable....

      they owe it to the commuters...
    • Lai Fong  •  4 months ago
      The truth is money and moral are often of conflicting interests. If you want money, you have to forgo your moral. If you want moral, you have to forgo the money. You cannot have both. How you will balance the both of them will depends on what you think is more important to you.
    • TheGardener  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  4 months ago
      What's the need for the apology?
      Glad to see your true colors.
      Bloody Mercenaries!!!
    • ngk  •  5 months ago
      Bus: lost, Mrt: spoil, Taxi: money face... And they wonder why we don't want to take public transport and rather go through the trouble and money to get a car...

    Featured Blog Posts