Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

 

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SingaporeScene

    Electrical fault behind train delay: SMRT

    Over 17,000 commuters were affected by the major delay on the MRT. (Yahoo! photo)Over 17,000 commuters were affected by the major delay on the MRT. (Yahoo! photo)UPDATED

    SMRT says an electrical fault caused the major train delay that left 17,500 passengers stranded along the East-West line during peak hour traffic on Thursday morning.

    In a statement to Yahoo! Singapore, SMRT said the electrical fault caused an eastbound train to stall between Tiong Bahru and Outram Park MRT stations at 8.59 am.


    According to standard operating procedures, another train was then used to gently push the stalled train to the next station for passengers to alight. The stalled train was then directed back to the depot.

    But as the stalled train was crowded due to peak hour traffic, the train officer took a longer time moving from cabin to cabin to release the cabin brakes. The train doors also remained closed when it arrived at Outram Park station and had to be manually opened.

    This led to the process, which usually takes 20-30 minutes, taking over an hour to complete.

    To maintain train service, SMRT said some westbound trains were turned around at Queenstown MRT station while eastbound trains were turned around at Outram Park MRT station.

    Normal train service resumed at 9:50am.

    Hundreds of commuters delayed at Outram Park MRT station. (Yahoo! photo)Hundreds of commuters delayed at Outram Park MRT station. (Yahoo! photo)

    During the delay, two passengers near Tiong Bahru station felt unwell and had to be sent to Singapore General Hospital.

    According to a SCDF spokesperson, a man in his 50s felt giddy and a woman in her 30s experienced breathlessness and chest discomfort.

    Analyst Kelvin Chow, 30, said he was stuck in the tunnel between Redhill and Tiong Bahru for 20 minutes when the driver announced that a passenger was having chest pains.

    The driver could not move to the next station as the train in front was still stationary.The driver then asked for medical personnel onboard to help the passenger.

    "Finally after another 20 minutes, we moved to Tiong Bahru (where an ambulance was waiting) and managed to get the passenger off," he said.

    Public relations executive Felicia Goh, 24, told Yahoo Singapore she was stuck on the train for over an hour during rush hour traffic.

    "I was initially stuck at Clementi before moving two stops and stalling again at Buona Vista," she said.

    Train commuters stuck at Commonwealth MRT. (Yahoo! photo)Train commuters stuck at Commonwealth MRT. (Yahoo! photo)

    Undergraduate Jacqueline Wong, 22, was at Buona Vista station and after waiting for 15 minutes on the train and finding out about the long delay on micro-blogging platform Twitter, got off and took a bus instead.

    Her mother was not so lucky. She took one hour and 20 minutes to get from Buona Vista station to Outram Park, reaching work two hours late, said Wong.

    Jeremy Foo, 32, an engineer stuck at Outram Park station, added, "I heard trains have been delayed all morning. I've been waiting here for the last 25 minutes and still no train. This is bad."

    Another commuter stuck at the Outram MRT station, sales manager Germaine Chia, said what made it worse was that mobile phone reception was poor.

    "People have been complaining since I got here. The trains are not running and there' s no reception so we can't call in at work. Thankfully, this seldom happens," said the 27-year-old.

    Frustrated commuters also took to Twitter to complain about the crawling train service and warned others to skip the train ride this morning.

    @redha tweeted, "I think the delay affected a lot of places. Lots of grumpy people at Bugis MRT station when i got down just now."

    The SMRT has apologised for the inconvenience caused.

    It added that passengers who were unable to complete their journeys due to the disruption can file a claim for a refund at any of the MRT station counters within the next three working days.

    On Sunday, a train was delayed at the Ang Mo Kio station after a Thai teenage girl fell onto the tracks and was hit by a train.

    Follow Yahoo! News on Twitter and become a fan on Facebook.

     

    595 comments

    • winter  •  1 year 1 month ago
      The authorities better show that they can handle such situations before expanding the population to 6.5 million!
      • Brian 1 year 1 month ago
        I so agree with Winter!
      • Tomcat 1 year 1 month ago
        Yes. Whoever was the smart alec who decided Singapore needs 6 million people better rethink again. I'm pretty sure when we reach 6 million, he will say we can increase to 7.5 million. We are only a small island and have to know our geographical constraint. SMRT should be fined heavily for this incident. There has been too many lapses by them, remember the vandalism incident?
      • John 1 year 1 month ago
        well said. thumbs up!
    • Kenneth  •  1 year 1 month ago
      I was caught and missed by 930 am daily meeting but just wanted to provide a balance overview.

      Standing iether on the platform or even worse in the crowded cabin was bad especially if it's more than 30 mins.

      Good Points:
      1. Train driver was trying his best to keep passengers posted the last 30 mins when it became evidant we had to stop from between Redhill to Tiong Baru
      2. We contacted him on a pax fainting and he did his best to divert any medical personnel to Cabin 1006
      3. Most pof apx stayed calm for at least the first 30 mins
      4. Driver also explained that there was a stalled train in from for which SMRT was trying to omve and hence he could not release trap door to allow pax to walk on tracks due ot electricity not being shut off
      5. At TB station, the response team was ready for action - kudos

      Bad Points:
      1. Given the cramped conditions, once a delay is suspected to be more than 15 mins, SOP should be stricter to immediately release pax at the nearest SMRT station asap and not continue
      2. No first aid kits available in cabin
      3. At Quenstown/ Redhill station, more passengers joined. I was with a wheel chair bound person but there was to advice from the station controller to actually ask before to off load since the delay was going to be another 15-30mins especially for kids, pregnant mothers and invalids
      4. For the general public, this is a small inconevenience if we compare it to the Tsunami. So if SG was to be in a state of calamity, what will the reaction of SG be? It would be quite scarry I think.

      Yes I think SMRT will need to improve but also yes I think this incident showed me how much is SG prepared in the face should a greater calamity strike us....

      For now, I am still thankful to God that I got to office late rather than never. also found out from buy=bodying i could collect a letter advising my employees for ny lateness (another area SMRT need to improve).

      My hope is that the lady got proper treatment and recover.

      One thing I sure do know, the media will scruintinize SMRT and I know at least a dozen more new SOPs will be put in place as "COUNTER-MEASURE".

      As for me, since being young, apart from learning to stay calm and interact with the cain driver,
      I finally got to press the red dot in the cabin that says "SG5000 fine" if mis-used.

      Unbiased reports from an affected commuter...
      • Hu 1 year 1 month ago
        It is true. I was also in the same cabin. Suggest the SMRT provide reserved cabin for kids, pregnant women and old people, etc. not only reserved seats, in case such case will occur again.
      • John Lim 1 year 1 month ago
        I strongly suggest all seat to be taken off.

        We got enough old people, pregnant women, kids. We are over-populated. Face it.
      • gonggong 1 year 1 month ago
        Thank you for sharing your experience. I was lucky and i wasnt on board that carriage.
    • Baby Coddle  •  1 year 1 month ago
      SMRT is doing a very bad job at managing expectation of the commuters. I boarded the train from Jurong East and along the way, the public announcement just mentioned that due to the track fault ahead, the train would be delayed. It went on for the next 15 minutes and then they finally announced that the train would be delayed for another 15 minutes. After that they repeated the same message. Shouldn’t they just announced that the train will be delayed by at least 30 min to an hour and this would allow the commuters to take the decision to take other form of transportation. I can accept that accident or track fault does happen from time to time but the way they have managed the whole situation totally pissed me off. I wasted 45 mins on the train when I could have got off and take a bus instead.
      • Keen 1 year 1 month ago
        absolutely, bad call with the misleading announcement. After years of operation, still so amatuerish!
      • lol 1 year 1 month ago
        not amatuerish. is heck care. they have immunity from competitors thus they dont have the need to improve themselves.
      • i m t 1 year 1 month ago
        unexpected fault and situation.Main and prirority task at that time was to move the train. Fault may be unknown.If rush, take others transport.Add unexpected delay time to what they announce next time.just like you smart boss,always give you amber time to finish your unexpected error.Take train ? Enjoy the ride when it sent you to your destination on time.If only once delay,NVM is the word have to use.
    • reveal  •  1 year 1 month ago
      It seems that the usage for MRT has a sharp climb in usage. Even on an ordinary peak hour, the MRT is next to impossible to use. It is packed to the brim.

      Shouldnt SMRT and the governmnet resolve this issue by having more reliable trains? This is something SMRT and the government should be proactive at.

      The government appears to have a huge surplus in collecting taxes and should not pass this cost to commuters.

      Alternatively, have more buses and remove the erp's, reduce parking fees so that folks and drive to work.
      • Nameless 1 year 1 month ago
        they shld had at least longer stations to plan for the increased population. larger stations would allow more flexibility. longer trains could then be added as demand requires.
      • sgER 1 year 1 month ago
        "It seems that the usage for MRT has a sharp climb in usage. Even on an ordinary peak hour, the MRT is next to impossible to use. It is packed to the brim."

        Reason being, they still want people to maximize the passenger volume even at non-peak. Solution?? Bring in more FT lor.. the more the merrier.
      • Baldie 1 year 1 month ago
        naw, they cannot make trains longer, the mrt stations cannot support longer trains.
    • T  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Apart from imposing a fine on MRT, the train company should be barred from increasing its fares for the next 5 years.
      • Lucymum 1 year 1 month ago
        U cant possibly retain its fares for the next 5 years. Otherwise, how are our elected officials going to pay themselves millions of dollars in taxpayers money?

        Remember: the higher the revenue received by SMRT, the more taxes they ahve to pay.

        But it doesnt matter because SMRT is belonged to the Lees.

        Long Live PAP!!
      • sillyporean 1 year 1 month ago
        Why fine SMRT?....it just like $ going out from right pocket and into the left.....and the colour of the pants is white.....so does the shirt....
      • DC 1 year 1 month ago
        In addition, the fares should be reduced back to early days. This is coz the services never get improved from the moment they increased the fares.
    • Singaporean  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Train break down again mean ticket price will go up ( to pay the fine),
      and inflation go up (transportation is one of the index basket).

      So will the accountability and transparency go up or go down ?

      World Class Transport
    • Mr L  •  1 year 1 month ago
      I was in the cabin where the passenger fainted complained of chest pains.

      It was a horrible experience. The train was fully packed. It was sardine-packed.

      The foreigners are not the problem for they delay. But look at situations like this whereby the transport system is overly stretched and this kind of situations happened.

      It was a chaotic situation inside the train. Babies crying, someone fainted, no medical help, no medical aid. Air was getting thin, everybody was grasping for air. If you think this is nothing, please think again. Can you just think about this for a second, what would have happened to the two fainted passengers without medical aid should the train was further delay by another 30 mins to 2 hrs?

      Nobody is complaing. But since when are we satisfied with just not being the WORST?! Just because our transportation system is better than India and Pakistan, so we should just close our eyes on our failings?!?!

      I kind of got a feeling Singapore is becoming a country consistently giving excuses for its inadequacies and diverting attention away from its flaws just by simply comparing ourselves with other “you-so-called-it-lousier-countries”.

      If you are stuck underground, in a sardine-packed cabin, for more than an hr, not knowing when you will be out, air getting thinner by the minute. People starting fainting before you. Another 45 mins to 1 hr. Im sure more casualty or even fatalities is going to happen. Small issue? Nothing? I Hope the one fainted is you.
    • Harry  •  1 year 1 month ago
      If this were to happen in japan, the CEO of the organisation will come out to the media, bow down 90 degree to apologise to the public for the inconvenience.

      So wheres SMRT CEO?
    • CitiZen  •  1 year 1 month ago
      I have nothing against them but if you are going to take in 2.5 million foreigners, please make sure you increase the MRT capacity by 2.5million people, increase 2.5million jobs, set aside land for 2.5million HDB and buildings instead of increasing MRT fares and selling the land away to the rich and powerful foreigners in sentosa cove and all the most beautiful places in Singapore. You think launching 1-2k of HDB flats is enough to meet the demand?? I will not vote you.
    • RuSure  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Frankly, we have one of the best transport systems with our MRT comparing it with countries like India, Australia, Malaysia etc. Fast and efficient.
      Plea to Singaporeans: Please dont hate the foreigners. Its the government who created this situation chasing after GDP at all costs. Either they have to reduce the foreigner flow or increase the resources like housing, transport etc. However I really dont think that our small city can really take in this much of population at all.

      And a plea to foreigners: Please stop saying that there is no Singapore without yourall. Cos you are only increasing resentment against foreigners and i see that hurting you more in the long run than the singaporeans. Trust me, this mrt was here long ago, just as efficient as it is now. I took the mrt when i was in secondary school everyday from tampines to redhill and I am in my 30s now. There hasnt been much changes except for the additional stations.
      Most of us who are over 20s know how wonderful Singapore was from the late 80s to early 2000. Honestly, things starting going way downhill ever since LHL took over. The quality of life here has really deteriorated and sorry that you guys are the easy target for the hatred. See it this way, if someone you welcome to your nation ends up leaving you with a debt which will take an additional 20 yrs to settle, where our housing is concerned, will you be happy?
      I am impartial to Foreigners but it gets on my nerves when you attribute to Singapore's growth to yourselves. Singapore's growth of 15% this yr made our govt's happier but made the citizens life sadder. Its only a growth in financial terms but definitely not on the qualities of our lifes.
    • Freden  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Own a car is next to impossible, taking public transport have no control over timing. What's next? Resort to Kite Flying?
    • Pang  •  1 year 1 month ago
      SMRT has to compensate on this matter. We know LTA can easily slaps a fine for the economic loss to the nation.

      What about the losses to the employers? Lesser manhour to the companies, delaying projects and appointments. loss of business..the list can go on.

      And what about losses to employees and communters??? Having to pay extra for a taxi ride and bus ride, work piling up, students missing lectures and lessons, loss of commissions due to loss of sales, physical and emotion sufferings for trapping in the trains for over an hour and where you cant even move around....

      SMRT should compensate with free rides for affected individuals.
    • Kriston  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Car - Traffic Jam
      Bus - Traffic Jam
      MRT - Human Jam + MRT tio Jam

      No horse run for all of us. Lets walk and lead a healthy lifestyle! lol
    • clemence chang  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Face it. Singapore is getting overpopulated
    • Dave  •  1 year 1 month ago
      That's the reason why I never like to take MRT trains. When you are in one of them and the whole train system stalls, you'll be stuck like forever. If a bus breaks down anywhere along the road, all you have to do is alight the bus and take another bus or a taxi.
    • peer  •  1 year 1 month ago
      SMRT knows how to increase fare . Do the relevant authority ever think of getting a fast solution when incident as such happen ? With such unexpected delay , SMRT has to make fast solution for the following people .

      1) People going to work - some employers will not buy such as MRT delay. Late means late and will be recorded.

      2) Children going to school - Will the whole school wait for the student to come before lesson is started ?

      3) With MRT now extended till Airport , imagine a person who needs to catch a flight. Would SMRT compensate the passenger the air fare , accomodation if needed.

      We seen many exercise by SAF , SPF and SCDF for emergency. SMRT also need to have such especially when some MRT Staff ( Like in Redhill Stn) are not courteous alot.

      SMRT has to wake up and have all the necessary exercise done to avoid such.
    • DingDong  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Train is delayed... train is delayed.... train is delayedddddddddddddddddddddddddd....... Please start complaining............! Love your ride...... Ding Dong.......
    • Juronggrc Voices  •  1 year 1 month ago
      Housing Pricing (60% increase within 2 years)
      When it faces congested public transportation system
      the authorities decided to increase the trip count to 2 mins per train during congested hours...
      It solve the problem by abit... but
      Our trains faces overpressure requires to move very very fast to meet the 2mins count time
      under conditions of very very heavy passenger weight loading...
      So many foreign within past 3 years... so many...
      People please exercise your vote wisely..
    • have  •  1 year 1 month ago
      The pap will tell you this is not a big problem bcos this happens only once in 10 yrs , I am sure pap dont take feeder service change to another bus then takes a train once in 10 yrs so they can never understand the trouble , problem , inconvinence and strees the pessengers went through everyday ,

      The pap will tell you that even with this problem our transport system are still world class .

      Give up
    • T  •  1 year 1 month ago
      SMRT should not be allowed to raise fares for the next 5 years.

    Featured Blog Posts

    Blog Authors / Profiles