Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

 

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    SingaporeScene

    ‘Minister Teo should explain handling of Suntec City assault case’

    Two involved in a brawl at Suntec City have reportedly jumped bail. (AFP file photo)Two involved in a brawl at Suntec City have reportedly jumped bail. (AFP file photo)

    By Andrew Loh

    The Singapore Police Force (SPF) keeps Singapore safe. That is its job. But what happens if Singaporeans themselves start losing faith and trust in the force? In recent times, several cases have dented Singaporeans' confidence in the men in blue.

    The most famous case was of terrorist suspect Mas Selamat Kastari who escaped from the Whitley Road Detention Centre in 2007. More recently, Romanian diplomat Silviu Ionescu was allowed to leave Singapore even as his case was being investigated by the police.

    Ionescu, the highest-ranking diplomat at the Romanian embassy in Singapore at the time of the incident, was reported to have hit three men with his car in the early hours of December 2009. The incident resulted in the death of Malaysian Tong Kok Wai.

    Ionescu has since been charged in Romania for the incident. The case is still ongoing.
    Closer to home, the police's apparent lackadaisical attitude towards some cases have also raised questions about its competence.

    The Suntec City assault incident involving three foreign men is now making the rounds on the Internet after The New Paper reported the assault in 2011, followed by online portals later on.

    What frustrates and disappoints the public, particularly, are two things:

    1.    The police's silence, even to the victims of the assault, in providing updates on the case.

    2.    The police's seeming disinterest in pursuing the case so that justice is meted out swiftly, and the victims can have closure to the matter. It took more than a year before the assailants were charged in court, and it has been 22 months since the night of the assault.
    The Suntec City attack was a vicious one carried out by three foreigners — New Zealander Robert Stephen Dahlberg, Australian Nathan Robert Miller and Briton Robert James Springall — in the evening of April 2010.

    So far, only Miller has been brought to justice, with a three weeks sentence in jail. Dahlberg, rather inexplicably, was allowed to leave Singapore in July last year, just about a month after he was charged in court.

    Springall too was apparently allowed to leave Singapore in September last year.

    Both men have since absconded, leaving the victims of the attack finding the whole process incredulous.

    Disbelief and anger

    Online reactions too express disbelief and anger at how the two expats could be allowed to leave Singapore so easily.

    This is not a case of pickpocketing or littering or something more innocuous. This is a case of a viciously violent assault on three do-gooders whose only intent that night was to come to the aid of a cab driver who was being punched, threatened and harassed by the reportedly drunk men close to midnight.

    The three good Samaritans, which were really what they were, put their lives on the line, as it turned out, to help a 57-year old cabby who pleaded with them to help. A passerby who chipped in to assist that night was also threatened by the assailants that he would be killed if he did not get out of their way while they were escaping from the scene. It was a threat which had already been effectively carried out on one of those they had attacked just minutes earlier that night.

    To members of the public, it is clear-cut case of assault and causing grievous hurt. One of the do-gooders had his head slammed by one of the assailants into the sharp edge of one of the pillars at the building at Suntec. Blood poured from the wound on his head. He fell to the floor — only to have the assailant then repeatedly and mercilessly kick him on the head, rendering him unconscious.

    It is more than fortunate that he was not killed.

    Yet, speaking to the two victims, the police seemed disinterested in lending any urgency to pursuing the matter, even though the victims had provided the police with all information to help in the case, and offered themselves in assistance.

    It took more than a year before the case finally went to the courts.

    And even after this, two of the three men have been allowed to escape.

    The authorities cannot fault the public, and especially the victims themselves, if the charge of incompetency is levelled at the police. One might even say the police officers involved in the case are inept, lazy and a disgrace to the rest of their colleagues in the force who are doing good work.

    This is a case which should evoke a personal response from the Minister for Home Affairs. This is a matter of public interest. The victims have been trying to obtain information from the police but have been met with a wall of silence.

    The Minister for Home Affairs should now take a personal interest in this case and account to the public the behaviour, the performance (or lack thereof), and the apparent disinterest and incompetence of those under his charge.

    He should also explain to the public and the victims what his ministry now plans to do with regards to the two assailants who have fled our country.

    (Read an account of what the victims have to say about the case here.)

    Andrew helms publichouse.sg as Editor-in-Chief. His writings have been reproduced in other publications, including the Australian Housing Journal in 2010. He was nominated by Yahoo! Singapore as one of Singapore's most influential media persons in 2011.

     
    • 1521  •  3 months ago
      A garang guni man (with mental illness) was jailed 6 mths for threatening an MP.
      A foreign talent (with sound mind) was jailed 3 weeks for actual assault on taxi driver.
      One set of law for locals, one set of law for FT. Enough Said.
      • L 3 months ago
        UNEQUAL JUSTICE. The balancing scales is tilted in favour of the WHITE trash
    • William  •  Sydney, Australia  •  3 months ago
      I think those 3 foreign devils should be brought back to Singapore and be given a proper "Singapore style" caning.
      • Jack 3 months ago
        agree
      • Steve 3 months ago
        Thot we have good relationship with Interpol?? Can't we bring them back thru Interpol???
      • Tel 3 months ago
        i agree but interpol not like Singapore rulings
    • Henry  •  London, United Kingdom  •  3 months ago
      Would the outcome be different if one of the victims is a PAP MP????
      • Warthog Warrior 3 months ago
        Freak man! There would be an immediate clearance of all court cases, just so to charge the person in court, to make an example on how not to mess with that PAP MP idiot.
      • terry 3 months ago
        The assailant should be out of jail by now after serving a 2 yrs sentence.
    • Henry  •  London, United Kingdom  •  3 months ago
      Let me guess....Minister Teo Chee Hean going to blame the 3 good samaritans for provoking the 3 angmoh???

      Another one of those non-seizable offense....so victims must spend money to file a magistrate complaint??? No wonder S'pore has a "low" crime rate...because many crimes are NOT classified as crimes!!
      • Abdul Muqsit 3 months ago
        Sorry bro, rules change, no more non-seizable offence, now it's called non-arrestable offence..
      • L 3 months ago
        Shit Times will tell u later that these 2 white trash are on Interpol list. What they will NOT TELL U is : Interpol's priority is to arrest criminals with terrorist backgrounds, not some assailants committing assault in a country not well regarded even at UN
    • Raptor  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      Silence from SPF and Law Ministry is deafening. Singaporeans are calling for justice. Why is the government keeping quiet?
      • Parody 3 months ago
        We want accountability and transparency for this case..
      • Abdul Muqsit 3 months ago
        Wrong site, stomp would be more appropriate
    • SurelyYouJest  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      spf, if you cannot bring this dahlberg bugger back, go bring his father, bill dahlberg, here to face this violent crime committed by his son....
      we are paying you, the spf, with our sweat and blood and yet not doing your duty to the singaporean...
      it makes me feel so sad being a singaporean...
    • Celdawen  •  3 months ago
      Please explain to us what's going on.
      Once laws are meted out, we should stand by them regardless of the situations.
      We just want justice for the victims and an explanation for everything.
      Are we asking for too much? Are we still safe here like before?
    • Glenn  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      As I said it before with all who agrees...
      The S'pore government wants to protect ang moh more than the locals...
      The court, the police, the immigrations, the government department...
      All given ways to the so call ang moh...
      Just because they are fairer then the Asian...
      What a shame to the society with all the recents incidents...!!!
      Those leaders Should slap their own face only to find that their beloved son or daughter is the victims themselves...
    • Darren  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      I am throughly disgusted by this...absolute brush off from the people we thought would at least have a stand for justice. How do you expect us to rally in times of trouble when the opposite has just been shown to us? How do you expect ur sons to come back from overseas? How is this even our home anymore?

      An old demented man was sent to prison within a few weeks for pouring gasoline on an MP. You sent a whole team of riot police for 3 people carrying place cards in a peaceful demonstration. And here, our fellow men was brazenly hurt and humiliated, not to mention a total disregard for the peace that we 'must not" take it granted, you let them get away? Leaders of Singapore, you tell me, how shall we make of this? You have let us down. U have just disrespected the older generation, the current generation and showed our younger generation what kind of a government they are living with. It's alright if you are that stupid, I cant forgive 60% of our Singaporeans for being retards.
    • spike  •  3 months ago
      sometimes in a volatile situation u just have to fight. Singaporeans are so afraid that they go down without throwing a punch. seem to have lost their killer instinct. this is not the 1st time such things have happened; i think angmohs in the country must already got the impression that we are 东亚病夫. not every problem can be solved by complaining to the government. the other taxi drivers could have gather more colleagues give those thugs a thrashing, or other singaporeans there could have join in and lynched them. there's a total lack of national integrity and camaraderie here.
    • future singaporeans  •  3 months ago
      Is Justice Unfair or Dead?
    • rangerboi  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      Who is the one responsible for the passport impounding? Tell that sod to come clean on why the angmohs can jump bail. If he dare to do so, then let's see how DPM will react. Won't be too late to crucify the guilty ones after all. But if keep diam diam, then...

      对人民不仁,休怪人民不义。
    • lee  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      a good reminder. government service is getting worst?
    • SING  •  3 months ago
      This is the rot within the Ministry of Home Affairs that was under Wong Kan Seng before Teo Chee Hean took over. New broom sweeps better. Worms pouring out everywhere from the opened can now.
    • Rrunner  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      "So far, only Miller has been brought to justice, with a three weeks sentence in jail" Wow!! Is this a joke? Just 3 weeks for viciously violent assault?
    • Noel  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      Oh dear, would it be quicker if the victims are some White Horses? Hmmm....
    • Truly Saint  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      Foreigners thinks coming to Singapore to work is easy...... For them to leave Singapore, will be much easier but all thanks to PAP. They love foreign talents that they forgot about us Singaporeans.
    • The Pariah  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      K Shanmugam was Minister for Home Affairs when above assault happened in Apr 2010. Shanmugam should take accountability instead of keeping mum. With this quality of job performance, how can PM Lee HL reward Shanmugam with the plump job of Foreign Minister after George Yeo lost GE in May 2011? What does it say of PM Lee's judgement? Or did PM Lee know?
    • Jack  •  Singapore, Central Singapore  •  3 months ago
      what signals is sent to outside world? (with these jump-bail issues occurred)
    • future singaporeans  •  3 months ago
      See How the MPs Talked Big and Acted Big,
      When its come across such Injustices Scenario,
      All Quietly Behaved likes Scary Mice Searching for Hide-Outs.

    Featured Blog Posts

    Blog Authors / Profiles