Biden’s Israel-Hamas cease-fire plan running out of time

Laura Kelly
·8-min read

President Biden is running out of time to complete his goal of ending Israel’s war against Hamas and implement a megadeal to reshape the Middle East toward a position of peace.

The administration is focusing all its efforts to first get Hamas to agree to a three-phase, cease-fire deal that would establish, immediately, at least a six-week pause in fighting in the Gaza Strip.

But counter-proposals by Hamas have contributed to weeks of back and forth and are testing the hope and patience of mediators — and raising questions of what is Plan B.

“I’m not sure how many more days I have of saying, ‘Well, I’m still hoping’ — within this framework,” Sen. Mark Warner (D-Va.), chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, said during a roundtable with reporters Tuesday hosted by the Christian Science Monitor.

Biden has sought to bring international pressure to bear against Hamas, securing the support of the Israeli government; approval by the United Nations Security Council, and an endorsement by the Group of 7 nations and Arab and Gulf states on a proposal he laid out May 31.

The first phase of the proposal includes a temporary cease-fire where Hamas would release in batches the 120 Israelis it kidnapped from Israel on Oct. 7, while Israel is expected to commit to release Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails. Supporters of the cease-fire deal say it is imperative to surge humanitarian support to Palestinians and ease suffering marked by displacement, starvation, and critically needed medical care.

A group of Israeli families of hostages held by Hamas have put their support behind Biden’s cease-fire proposal. Andrey Kozlov, one of four Israelis rescued from Hamas captivity in early June in a daring and deadly operation, called for a cease-fire to secure the release of remaining hostages.

“For the hostages still in Gaza, there is one decision, only one, it is the deal between Israel and Hamas,” he said in a video message published last week.

Warner put the blame on Hamas’s leader hiding in Gaza, Yahya Sinwar, describing him as holding a reputation as a cold, calculating leader and who reportedly views the tens of thousands of Palestinian casualties in the war as “necessary sacrifices.”

“This is the kind of leader who’s for the notion of the Palestinian people but doesn’t give a hoot about how many Palestinians die in this conflict,” Warner said.

Biden’s priority plan is to use the initial weeks of a cease-fire between Israel and Hamas to negotiate a permanent end to the war, establish new governance in Gaza and lay out a pathway to a Palestinian state. Those commitments would then allow Saudi Arabia to establish ties with Israel as a broader security grouping against Iran.

Warner said that efforts to normalize relations between Israel and Saudi Arabia “absolutely” depends on first getting to a cease-fire.

Barbara Leaf, the assistant secretary of state for Near Eastern Affairs, described Sinwar as a “psychopath” and “messianic,” but said mediators are in “intensive discussions” to bridge gaps between Hamas’s proposed changes to the cease-fire proposal.

“We do believe ultimately, this proposal is the best roadway to get an end to the conflict now that would enable a multitude of things and that would ultimately be offered the prospect for an end to the conflict altogether,” she told a Senate Foreign Relations subcommittee hearing on the Middle East on Tuesday.

‘Reality has a way of intruding’

Sinwar’s obstinance is only one challenge to the Biden administration’s grand plan.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, blamed by some Democrats in Congress as responsible for the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, lashed out in a video at the Biden administration for what he said was an “inconceivable” decision to hold back delivery of U.S. weapons and munitions.

Biden officials rejected Netanyahu’s characterization — the president has paused one shipment of heavy bombs to Israel — but the episode underscored the fraught tensions the U.S. is having with the Israeli leader over the course of the war.

Netanyahu’s critics have accused him of prioritizing the military operation against Hamas over diplomacy, and U.S. and Israeli officials have also criticized the prime minister as failing to talk about what authority can rule Gaza instead of Israeli military control.

“We are potentially weeks, maybe a month or two away from the formal military operations coming to a close and it is extraordinary that we have no viable plan from the Israeli government as to what comes next,” said Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.), chair of a Senate Foreign Relations subcommittee that oversees the Middle East, pressing Leaf on the administration’s engagement with Israel.

“There is still insufficient planning, to say the least, on the part of the Israeli government,” Leaf responded.

Netanyahu has shot down any talk of the West Bank-based Palestinian Authority reasserting rule in Gaza, generally rejecting the idea of an independent Palestinian state that would link both territories.

Still, Netanyahu has, at times, signaled openness to some sort of civil governing authority for Palestinians in Gaza. He has spoken about Israel maintaining freedom of military movement to address security threats, but he floated ideas about Arab countries taking responsibility for some security aspects of the territory.

Leaf, responding to criticisms that Arab and Gulf countries are unlikely to step up responsibilities to help stabilize the situation with the Palestinians, said “there’s no magical thinking” on the part of the administration.

“These get to the heart of politics for every one of these governments and for the Palestinians, and the Israelis as well. But I think reality has a way of pushing even those who can’t imagine a concept such as the [Palestinian Authority] returning to Gaza, reality has a way of intruding,” she said.

Leaf said she is likely headed to the Middle East this weekend to continue discussions with Israeli, Arab and Gulf partners on a day-after scenario.

“There will have to be a political alternative and that’s what we’re in the process of putting together these concepts,” she said.

Sen. Ben Cardin (D-Md.), chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, said he is also engaged in discussions bringing regional partners onboard for a “day-after” scenario.

“I’ve had individual discussions as well as collective discussions with the Saudis, with the Emirates, with the Jordanians, with the Egyptians, with the Qataris, all of them have been showing signs of an interest in participating … including the governance issues, including the economic issues and those types of issues,” he told a roundtable of reporters last week.

“There’s a lot of fill in the blanks that haven’t been quite filled in, a lot of volunteers that are willing to step forward, provided that the conditions are met, that there’s a real peace in the region and there’s a commitment to move forward to two states,” he said.

Saudi Arabia key ally in path to peace

Biden has cultivated Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman as a key ally in pushing forward any prospect of a lasting peace between Israel and the Palestinians — given a cease-fire can be implemented to start.

The president has long-since abandoned his campaign promise of making Saudi Arabia a “pariah” state, recognizing along with Democrat and Republican lawmakers that closer ties with Riyadh are part of a bigger effort to counter Iran and weaken China and Russia’s influence in the region.

Regional military cooperation to counter an Iranian missile attack on Israel in April served as a real-life demonstration of the defensive power linking together the U.S., Israel, and Saudi Arabia, along with other partners.

The Saudi crown prince is laser focused on securing a mutual defense treaty with the U.S. and assistance in building a civil, nuclear program. That deal is contingent on Saudi Arabia establishing ties with Israel, which Prince Mohammed said can only happen if there’s an Israeli commitment towards agreeing to recognizing a Palestinian state.

“In meetings with MBS [Prince Mohammed], I saw someone that I think was prepared to make the decision — if we could get this defense alliance with the United States — would stop trying to play both sides against the middle, and I think that is in America’s best interest,” Warner said.

All or nothing

Biden officials and their allies in Congress say that all parts of this megadeal must move together or not move at all — cease-fire, the day-after plan, a pathway to a Palestinian state, and normalization between Israel and Saudi Arabia.

Hamas has not made public its changes to the cease-fire proposal Biden laid out May 31, but the disagreement appears to be related to Hamas’s demand for an Israeli commitment for a full end to the war and withdrawal of Israeli troops. Netanyahu has said a full end to the war can only happen through negotiation, the so-called Phase 2 of Biden’s three-phase deal.

Warner, while raising doubt about Sinwar’s commitment to negotiate, projected some optimism that a cease-fire can be reached based on experiences over the course of the war. But he also cautioned about how quickly talks can fall apart.

He described a moment in early May where Hamas and Israel appeared poised to come to an agreement, but a Hamas rocket attack killing three Israeli soldiers triggered a collapse of talks.

“We’ve gotten close so many times, but that moment when, this was only a blip in the news, it was probably the time we were closest when Israel’s leaning, I think Hamas was ready, and there happened to be a random attack that killed three [Israeli military] soldiers,” he said.

“As of these last few weeks, the blame lies with Hamas’s leadership, Sinwar in particular,” the chair said.

Copyright 2024 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • Taiwan warns against travel to China after execution threat

    TAIPEI (Reuters) -Taiwan's government raised its travel warning for China on Thursday, telling its citizens not to go unless absolutely necessary, following a threat from Beijing last week to execute those deemed "diehard" Taiwan independence supporters. Liang Wen-chieh, spokesperson for Taiwan's Mainland Affairs Council, told reporters the raised travel warning also applied to the Chinese-run cities of Hong Kong and Macau. China, which views democratically governed Taiwan as its own territory, has made no secret of its dislike of President Lai Ching-te, whom it views as a "separatist", and staged two days of war games after he took office last month.

  • Israel says it can send Lebanon 'back to Stone Age' as UN warns against war

    Israel said it does not want war in Lebanon but could send its neighbour "back to the Stone Age", as the UN's humanitarian chief warned such a conflict would be "potentially apocalyptic".It's potentially apocalyptic," warned Griffiths, whose term ends this week.

  • Iran is preparing to open a new front in its war against Israel

    If, as the polls indicate, Labour will form our new government next week, it is likely that one of its first challenges will be how to respond to the eruption of full-scale hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah in Lebanon.

  • South Korea is running out of children – and this country could be next

    Every spring, when warm rays of sunshine herald the start of South Korea’s baking summer, fountains across Seoul’s central Gwanghwamun plaza suddenly burst into life, sending cooling jets of water into the air.

  • The Latest | Gaza families bid a tearful goodbye to critically ill kids leaving for treatment abroad

    Families bid a tearful goodbye to nearly two dozen critically ill children who left Gaza for treatment abroad on Thursday. It’s the first medical evacuation since the territory’s sole travel crossing shut down in early May after Israeli forces captured it, Palestinian officials say. The kids and their adult escorts left Nasser Hospital in the southern Gaza town of Khan Younis bound for the Kerem Shalom cargo crossing with Israel.

  • Social Media Predicts Outcome Of Trump-Biden Debate — And It's Hilarious

    Pundits and politicians aren’t the only ones offering their hot takes on how Thursday’s CNN event will go.

  • Modi's govt calls on Indian state to look into Reuters report on Foxconn hiring

    Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government on Wednesday said it has asked the Tamil Nadu state to submit a "detailed report" after a Reuters story revealed that Apple supplier Foxconn rejected married women from iPhone assembly jobs in the country. In a statement calling for the probe, the federal government's Ministry of Labour and Employment cited the Equal Remuneration Act of 1976, saying the law "clearly stipulates that no discrimination (is) to be made while recruiting men and women workers." The ministry said it has requested a detailed report from the Labour Department of Tamil Nadu, site of a major iPhone factory where Reuters uncovered Foxconn’s practice of shunning married women from jobs.

  • Ex-Kuwaiti Hornets to join RMAF fleet, Su-30MKMs to be upgraded to ‘Super Flankers’ under bold, ambitious plan

    Game changer – The RMAF’s capabilities will undergo a massive transformation under a bold and ambitious new roadmap that will see the introduction of a fifth-generation stealth fighter, upgraded Su-30MKM Flankers, and additional F/A-18 Hornet strike fighters from ex-Kuwaiti stocks. The post Ex-Kuwaiti Hornets to join RMAF fleet, Su-30MKMs to be upgraded to ‘Super Flankers’ under bold, ambitious plan appeared first on Twentytwo13.

  • ‘This party should fall’: MAGA candidate who didn’t win Boebert’s old seat calls Republican Party ‘irredeemable’

    Volunteers and supporters of grassroots Colorado Republican Ron Hanks, who’d hoped to fill the congressional seat vacated by fellow MAGA diehard Lauren Boebert, gathered Tuesday night at a Grand Junction brewery for a watch party. Hanks lamented the results — and the state of the Republican Party. Sheila Flynn reports from the third congressional district

  • Newsmax Slaps Very Awkward Note On Screen During Donald Trump Interview

    Critics on social media suggested the chyron meant one thing.

  • Beijing backtracks on a law punishing clothing that hurts ‘the feelings of the Chinese people’ after a public outcry

    People were concerned about the law's vagueness, after reported incidents where officials targeted people wearing traditional Japanese clothing.

  • Biden administration moves toward allowing American military contractors to deploy to Ukraine

    The Biden administration is moving towards lifting a de facto ban on American military contractors deploying to Ukraine, four US officials familiar with the matter told CNN, to help the country’s military maintain and repair US-provided weapons systems.

  • Sandy Hook victim's brother is 'shocked' that a letter Trump once sent him turned up in a Mar-a-Lago evidence photo

    Trump sent JT Lewis a condolence letter in 2018. A draft of the letter was among keepsakes prosecutors say Trump kept mingled with national secrets.

  • ‘It’s a very big secret’: the ultra-orthodox Jews shunning their families to fight in Gaza

    When he leaves the army barracks to return to his ultra-orthodox Kiryat Menchem neighbourhood in west Jerusalem, Jacov Barchaim immediately swaps his khaki uniform for a traditional black suit to avoid causing offence.

  • Chris Wallace's Stunning Claim On Trump Strategy For Debate Cracks Up CNN Pundit

    Wallace's claim about the former president's planned approach was too much for Jamie Gangel, who repeatedly laughed.

  • Critics Clown Marjorie Taylor Greene Over Wild Election 'Self-Own': 'NO Self Awareness'

    Social media users spotted the far-right Republican's hypocrisy as she argued to reduce a top official's salary to $1 over DEI directives.

  • South Korea's military fires on border islands for the first time in 7 years as a North Korean missile fails and the balloon war rages on

    It's been a noticeably tense time on the Korean peninsula lately with spats, deals, and muscle flexing.

  • Indonesia detains 103 foreigners in a raid in Bali involving suspected cybercrime

    Indonesian immigration authorities have detained 103 foreign nationals after a raid at a villa on the resort island of Bali, officials said Thursday. Immigration authorities said they conducted the raid on Wednesday at a villa in Kukuh village in Tabanan district and detained 91 men and 12 women.

  • Bolivian army chief arrested after coup attempt

    Bolivia's army chief was arrested Wednesday after sending soldiers and tanks to take up position in front of government buildings in what President Luis Arce called an attempted "coup d'etat".The troops and tanks entered Plaza Murillo, a historic square where the presidency and Congress are situated, in the afternoon, prompting global condemnation of an attack on democracy.One of the tanks tried to break down a metal door of the presidential palace.Surrounded by soldiers and eight tanks, the now-dismissed army chief General Juan Jose Zuniga said the "armed forces intend to restructure democracy, to make it a true democracy and not one run by the same few people for 30, 40 years."Shortly thereafter, AFP reporters saw soldiers and tanks pulling back from the square.Later Wednesday, Zuniga was captured and forced into a police car as he addressed reporters outside a military barracks, footage on state television showed. "General, you are under arrest," Deputy Interior Minister Jhonny Aguilera told Zuniga."No one can take away the democracy we have won," Arce said from a balcony of the government palace in front of hundreds of supporters.Earlier he had urged "the Bolivian people to organize and mobilize against the coup d'etat in favor of democracy," in a televised message to the country alongside his ministers inside the presidential palace. He also swore in new military leaders, firing Zuniga.Former president Evo Morales wrote on X that "a coup d'etat is brewing" and also urged a "national mobilization to defend democracy."- Zuniga's anti-democratic remarks -Bolivia is deeply polarized after years of political instability and the ruling Movement Towards Socialism (MAS) is riven by internal conflict between supporters of Arce and his former mentor Morales.Morales, who was Bolivia's first Indigenous president, was extremely popular until he tried to bypass the constitution and seek a fourth term in office in 2019. The leftist and former coca union leader won that vote but was forced to resign amid deadly protests over alleged election fraud, and fled the country. He returned after Arce won the presidency in October 2020.Since then a power struggle has grown between the two men, and Morales has increasingly criticized the government and accused it of corruption, tolerating drug trafficking, and sidelining him politically.Six months ago, the Constitutional Court disqualified Morales from the 2025 elections, however he is still seeking nomination as the MAS candidate.Arce has not said whether he will seek re-election.Zuniga appeared on television on Monday and said he would arrest Morales if he insisted on running for office again in 2025."Legally he is disqualified, that man cannot be president of this country again," he said.Since that interview, rumors have swirled that Zuniga was on the verge of being dismissed.- Calls for calm -The US administration of Joe Biden said it was keeping a close eye on events in Bolivia and "calls for calm," according to a spokesperson for the National Security Council.Condemnations of the troop movements also poured in from across Latin America, with leaders of Chile, Ecuador, Peru, Mexico, Colombia and Venezuela calling for democracy to be respected. Brazil's President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva wrote on X: "I am a lover of democracy and I want it to prevail throughout Latin America. We condemn any form of coup d'etat in Bolivia."Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez on Wednesday called for "respect for democracy and the rule of law," in a message on X.The Organization of American States (OAS) said the international community would "not tolerate any form of breach of the legitimate constitutional order in Bolivia."bur-fb/md

  • Israel threatens to ‘take Lebanon back to the Stone Age’

    A large-scale conflict between Israel and Hezbollah could break out in a matter of weeks if Gaza truce talks fail to produce a ceasefire, US intelligence suggests.