Education council rejects minister's latest bid for documents

CBC
·4-min read

The Anglophone East district education council is rejecting a new attempt by Education Minister Bill Hogan to get his hands on financial records and documents about its hiring of lawyers to fight changes to Policy 713.

In a letter Monday, the council argued that the information is protected by solicitor-client privilege.

"All of the documents … are confidential communications between a client and its solicitor for the purpose of getting legal advice or representation," one of the council's lawyers, Darren Blois, wrote.

"I am asserting [solicitor-client privilege] over all of the documents enumerated in your letter of June 17, 2024, and refusing to produce the requested documents to you."

v
Education Minister Bill Hogan has threatened to dissolve the Anglophone East district education council over its spending of tax dollars on the dispute over Policy 713, but he has yet to file the required court application. (Jacques Poitras / CBC)

That letter from Hogan told the DEC he was appointing Christopher Neal, a Saint John chartered accountant, to "investigate and inquire into the financial condition connected with the management, administration and operation" of the district.

The appointment gives Neal the powers of a commissioner under the provincial Inquiries Act, including the power to summon witnesses to answer questions under oath and to order them to turn over documents.

Hogan has threatened to dissolve the council over its spending of tax dollars on the dispute over Policy 713, but he has yet to file the required court application.

The government updated Policy 713 last year to require school staff to get parents' consent when a student younger than 16 wants to adopt a new name or pronoun at school that reflects their gender identity.

Anglophone East argued this violates the rights of 2SLGBTQ+ students under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Education Act and the provincial Human Rights Act.

In a written statement, Hogan did not respond to a question from CBC News about whether he appointed Neal to gather information for a possible court application to dissolve the council.

Darren Blois, a lawyer in Moncton, has filed a small claims action against Parking Solutions and its two listed directors after his vehicle was booted in November. He was charged $180 to have the device removed. No company is currently permitted to boot in the city and a bylaw caps the removal fee at $45.
'All of the documents … are confidential communications between a client and its solicitor for the purpose of getting legal advice or representation,' one of the Anglophone East district education council's lawyers, Darren Blois, wrote in a letter. (Shane Magee/CBC)

"The DEC for Anglophone School District-East is spending hundreds of thousands of dollars meant for educational purpose on lawyers from outside the province," the statement said.

"Under the Education Act, the Department has the authority to look into the finances of a school district to ensure that it is spending the money responsibly as budgeted and as required under the Act."

Anglophone East spokesperson Stephanie Patterson said no one from the council would do an interview.

"At this time, we are unable to provide comment," she said in an email.

Hogan wants invoices, retainer agreements, witness fees and any documents about the district seeking bids for the legal work.

The two firms representing the council are Ottawa-based Power Law and Murphy Collette Murphy in Moncton.

The Moncton courthouse on Assumption Boulevard on May 10, 2024.
Last week, Court of King’s Bench Chief Justice Tracey DeWare heard arguments on whether the council has standing to seek an injunction blocking the changes to Policy 713. (Shane Magee/CBC)

In April, the Anglophone East council refused a similar request from Hogan for information about its hiring of the law firms, citing the same solicitor-client privilege.

The new request carries greater potential consequences if it's refused.

Under the Inquiries Act, someone who refuses to answer a commissioner's questions or turn over requested documents can be jailed for up to 30 days.

After Hogan's changes to Policy 713 last year, the Anglophone East council adopted its own policy on implementing them.

It says school staff "shall respect the direction of the student in regard to the name and pronouns they wish to be called in daily interactions with school personnel and other students."

Hogan says this doesn't comply with the provincial policy and has told the district he was repealing it.

The district education council applied for an injunction to block the implementation of the provincial changes, arguing a council can't be put in a position of violating students' rights.

Hogan argues the council can spend money from its budget "for educational purposes only" and must stop spending on the lawsuit or face dissolution.

Last week Court of King's Bench Chief Justice Tracey DeWare heard arguments on whether the council has standing to seek an injunction blocking the changes.

If she rules it does, she'll hear arguments in July about which expert witnesses and evidence can be admitted in the case.

The main hearing would then take place in September.

  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next
  • Up next

Latest stories

  • ‘This wasn’t a debate, it was a medical emergency’: Our writers give their verdicts

    Follow the latest reaction in our live blog

  • ‘Panic mode’ Democrats begin calling for Biden to step aside after ‘horrible’ debate performance against Trump

    ‘Need to have Harris take over. Cleanest option,’ one Democrat strategist told The Independent

  • Taiwan warns against travel to China after execution threat

    TAIPEI (Reuters) -Taiwan's government raised its travel warning for China on Thursday, telling its citizens not to go unless absolutely necessary, following a threat from Beijing last week to execute those deemed "diehard" Taiwan independence supporters. Liang Wen-chieh, spokesperson for Taiwan's Mainland Affairs Council, told reporters the raised travel warning also applied to the Chinese-run cities of Hong Kong and Macau. China, which views democratically governed Taiwan as its own territory, has made no secret of its dislike of President Lai Ching-te, whom it views as a "separatist", and staged two days of war games after he took office last month.

  • Breaking ranks: Justice Amy Coney Barrett defies Supreme Court conservatives to back environmental protections

    Justice Barrett, a Trump appointee, split from her conservative colleagues in recent decisions

  • ‘I really don’t know what he said – and I don’t think he does either’: Trump pulls no punches as Biden struggles in debate

    The first debate began with Biden spluttering and tripping over his own words, while Trump rambled

  • Indonesia detains 103 Taiwanese in a raid in Bali involving suspected cybercrime

    Indonesian immigration authorities have detained 103 Taiwanese people after a raid at a villa on the resort island of Bali, officials said Friday. Godam said Indonesian authorities cannot charged them with conducting cybercrime.

  • China says it picked up a submarine detector dropped by a US Navy aircraft in the South China Sea

    A video shared by Chinese state media shows a US Navy plane dropping something into the sea. China called it a submarine detector.

  • Beijing backtracks on a law punishing clothing that hurts ‘the feelings of the Chinese people’ after a public outcry

    People were concerned about the law's vagueness, after reported incidents where officials targeted people wearing traditional Japanese clothing.

  • Russia is losing 1,000 soldiers a day in its relentless 'meat grinder' tactics against Ukraine: report

    Russian troops are being used in head-on assaults on Ukrainian positions.

  • Social Media Predicts Outcome Of Trump-Biden Debate — And It's Hilarious

    Pundits and politicians aren’t the only ones offering their hot takes on how Thursday’s CNN event will go.

  • Watch: A shaky and mumbling Biden freezes in first debate

    Follow the latest reaction to Trump vs Biden in our live blog

  • Iran is preparing to open a new front in its war against Israel

    If, as the polls indicate, Labour will form our new government next week, it is likely that one of its first challenges will be how to respond to the eruption of full-scale hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah in Lebanon.

  • Who could replace Joe Biden? Here are six possibilities

    With Biden not yet officially endorsed as Democratic presidential candidate, it is in theory open to the party to choose another candidate

  • Army must be ‘twice as lethal’, says new chief

    The Army must become twice as lethal in the next three years, its new chief has said.

  • The first debate was a complete disaster for Joe Biden

    Biden seemed out of breath, hastily reciting facts while slurring and omitting words. At times, the president uttered nonsensical phrases.

  • She managed to flee Gaza after half her family was killed in an Israeli strike. She blames Israel and Hamas for what happened

    Roba Abu Jibba looked shell-shocked as the doctor delivered his news: She couldn’t have the operation she desperately wanted. She nervously scrunched the fabric of her dress, fighting off the tears that began flooding her one remaining eye.

  • Bolivian army chief arrested after coup attempt

    Bolivia's army chief was arrested Wednesday after sending soldiers and tanks to take up position in front of government buildings in what President Luis Arce called an attempted "coup d'etat".The troops and tanks entered Plaza Murillo, a historic square where the presidency and Congress are situated, in the afternoon, prompting global condemnation of an attack on democracy.One of the tanks tried to break down a metal door of the presidential palace.Surrounded by soldiers and eight tanks, the now-dismissed army chief General Juan Jose Zuniga said the "armed forces intend to restructure democracy, to make it a true democracy and not one run by the same few people for 30, 40 years."Shortly thereafter, AFP reporters saw soldiers and tanks pulling back from the square.Later Wednesday, Zuniga was captured and forced into a police car as he addressed reporters outside a military barracks, footage on state television showed. "General, you are under arrest," Deputy Interior Minister Jhonny Aguilera told Zuniga."No one can take away the democracy we have won," Arce said from a balcony of the government palace in front of hundreds of supporters.Earlier he had urged "the Bolivian people to organize and mobilize against the coup d'etat in favor of democracy," in a televised message to the country alongside his ministers inside the presidential palace. He also swore in new military leaders, firing Zuniga.Former president Evo Morales wrote on X that "a coup d'etat is brewing" and also urged a "national mobilization to defend democracy."- Zuniga's anti-democratic remarks -Bolivia is deeply polarized after years of political instability and the ruling Movement Towards Socialism (MAS) is riven by internal conflict between supporters of Arce and his former mentor Morales.Morales, who was Bolivia's first Indigenous president, was extremely popular until he tried to bypass the constitution and seek a fourth term in office in 2019. The leftist and former coca union leader won that vote but was forced to resign amid deadly protests over alleged election fraud, and fled the country. He returned after Arce won the presidency in October 2020.Since then a power struggle has grown between the two men, and Morales has increasingly criticized the government and accused it of corruption, tolerating drug trafficking, and sidelining him politically.Six months ago, the Constitutional Court disqualified Morales from the 2025 elections, however he is still seeking nomination as the MAS candidate.Arce has not said whether he will seek re-election.Zuniga appeared on television on Monday and said he would arrest Morales if he insisted on running for office again in 2025."Legally he is disqualified, that man cannot be president of this country again," he said.Since that interview, rumors have swirled that Zuniga was on the verge of being dismissed.- Calls for calm -The US administration of Joe Biden said it was keeping a close eye on events in Bolivia and "calls for calm," according to a spokesperson for the National Security Council.Condemnations of the troop movements also poured in from across Latin America, with leaders of Chile, Ecuador, Peru, Mexico, Colombia and Venezuela calling for democracy to be respected. Brazil's President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva wrote on X: "I am a lover of democracy and I want it to prevail throughout Latin America. We condemn any form of coup d'etat in Bolivia."Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez on Wednesday called for "respect for democracy and the rule of law," in a message on X.The Organization of American States (OAS) said the international community would "not tolerate any form of breach of the legitimate constitutional order in Bolivia."bur-fb/md

  • How ‘mentally unfit’ Biden can survive a 90-minute TV battle with Trump

    Follow The Telegraph’s live coverage of the Trump vs Biden debate

  • Who could replace Joe Biden? Debate performance has Democrats in crisis talks

    The president just gave his party a reality check. Where can Democrats go from here?

  • Germany demands new citizens accept Israel’s right to exist

    People applying for naturalization in Germany will now be required to affirm Israel’s right to exist, under changes to the country’s citizenship law.