Reporting by Nicholas Yong, Hannah Teoh and Wan Ting Koh
Emeritus Senior Minister Goh Chok Tong said that while he understands the “dilemma” Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong faces amid the Oxley Road saga, he maintained that ministers should pursue legal action if baseless accusations are made against them.
“My view remains that when a Minister thinks an allegation made against him is without basis, he should sue,” he said in Parliament on Tuesday (4 July).
Goh made his speech during the second day of a Parliament session centred on PM Lee’s response to accusations made by his younger siblings – sister Lee Wei Ling and brother Lee Hsien Yang – of abuse of power in dealing with their late father’s Oxley Road home. In his ministerial statement delivered on Monday, PM Lee stated that he would prefer not to sue his siblings as it would only “drag out the process for years” and “further besmirch” their parents’ names.
In a 1999 interview with Asiaweek, Goh – who was then prime minister – said, “We (the government) have an understanding that if a minister is defamed and he does not sue, he must leave Cabinet. By defamation, I mean if somebody says the minister is on the take or is less than honest.”
Responding to PM Lee’s stance, Goh said that he understood the prime minister’s dilemma. “Indeed, I have urged him (PM Lee) as well as Lee Hsien Yang to sort out their differences, misunderstanding and reconcile,” said Goh. “It is surely not worth the feud being passed on to the next generation.”
ESM Goh said his main concern amid the saga was not the fate of the Oxley Road house or the Lee family feud, but the “wilful attack on the integrity of our leaders and the insidious erosion of public faith in our institutions” that has been sparked by Hsien Yang and Wei Ling’s accusations.
On this note, he questioned the agenda of PM Lee’s accusers and wondered if they were “whistle blowing in a noble effort to save Singapore, or waging a personal vendetta without any care for the damage done” to the nation.
“I have kept my ears open. From what Lee Hsien Yang and his wife (Lee Suet Fern) are freely telling many others, it is clear that their goal is to bring Lee Hsien Loong down as PM, regardless of the huge collateral damage suffered by the Government and Singaporeans,” said Goh.
Noting that the saga is “now no more a cynical parlour game”, he called for a “clear conclusion at the end of this debate”. “Either we clear PM over the allegation on his abuse of power or we censure him,” said Goh.
Challenge to Workers’ Party MPs, NMPs
Elsewhere in his speech, Goh said he was satisfied with PM Lee’s and Deputy Prime Minister Teo Chee Hean’s accounts of the matter and defended their integrity as politicians.
Goh also took aim at Workers’ Party chief Low Thia Khiang’s speech in Parliament on Monday, in which the latter called the Oxley Road saga a “sorry state of affairs” and asked the government to take action to “end this saga now”. Low had also noted how the Lee siblings had made “vague allegations” in the public domain based on “scattered evidence”.
Responding to Low’s words, Goh said Low should “follow up with a clear statement” on how the latter had “come to the conclusion that the allegations are baseless”.
Goh also challenged Low, the other Workers’ Party MPs and Nominated Members of Parliament (NMPs) to state their position clearly on PM Lee’s and the government’s integrity.
– additional reporting by Dhany Osman
- Lee family feud: MPs call for independent inquiry on abuse of power allegations
- Deed of Gift for Lee Kuan Yew’s items handled ‘correctly and above board’: Lawrence Wong
- Teo Chee Hean: Rarely need to reveal formation of Committees like one on 38 Oxley Road
- Lee family feud is a serious matter, not a ‘Korean drama show’: Low Thia Khiang
- Suing my siblings would ‘further besmirch my parents’ names’: PM Lee
- PM Lee recounts father’s changing views on 38 Oxley Road
- PM Lee in Parliament: Allegations of abuse of power by my siblings are ‘entirely baseless’
- I am just trying to honour my father’s final wish: Lee Hsien Yang
- PM Lee’s siblings need to show more proof of allegations, say 4 in 10 Singaporeans: survey
- Lee Hsien Loong ‘rejected’ offer of Oxley Road memorial garden: Lee Hsien Yang
- An ‘insult’ to suggest Lee Kuan Yew did not understand his own will: Hsien Yang
- Ho Ching had ‘no business’ acting on PMO’s behalf in collection of LKY’s papers: Hsien Yang
- Ho Ching refutes Lee Hsien Yang’s claim that she ‘helped herself’ to Lee Kuan Yew’s papers
- PM Lee Hsien Loong obtained deed of gift for Oxley House items in official capacity: Lawrence Wong
- PAP took Lee Kuan Yew’s note to Cabinet ‘out of context’: Lee Wei Ling
- Ministerial Committee ‘refused to identify’ full membership for almost a year: Lee Wei Ling
- NHB error on collection date for LKY’s items ‘even more troubling’: Hsien Yang
- Lee Hsien Loong told Lee Kuan Yew he wanted Oxley house to be heritage site: Hsien Yang
- Workers’ Party to ask about abuse of power allegations arising from Lee family feud
- Lee Wei Ling raps Shanmugam for view on conflict of interest
- COMMENT: House of Lee feud takes on national significance
- PM Lee using Parliament session to ‘cover-up and whitewash’ himself: Hsien Yang